Supreme Court of India

18,257 judgments

Year:

Ashok Kumar Aggarwal v. Sumit Bose & Another

28 Feb 2014 · B. S. Chauhan; J. Chelameswar

The Supreme Court held that a government servant whose suspension is quashed by a judicial authority is entitled to back wages from the date of quashing, but claims for promotion must be pursued separately.

administrative petition_allowed Significant suspension back wages Fundamental Rule 54B contempt petition

Sikander Mahto v. Tunna

27 Feb 2014 · P. SATHASIVAM; RANJAN GOGOI

The Supreme Court held that authentic school records disproved the accused's juvenility claim, allowing the appeal and restoring the trial court's order treating him as an adult for offences under IPC.

criminal appeal_allowed Significant juvenility claim age determination forged certificate school admission records

Basappa v. State of Karnataka

27 Feb 2014 · Sudhansu Jyoti Mukhopadhaya; Kurian Joseph

The Supreme Court held that an appellate court should not reverse a trial court's acquittal unless the judgment is perverse or unsupported by evidence, and restored the appellant's acquittal in a motor vehicle accident case.

criminal appeal_allowed Significant appeal against acquittal Section 378 CrPC perverse judgment reappreciation of evidence

Bharti v. State of Haryana & Anr.

27 Feb 2014 · Ranjana Prakash Desai; Madan B. Lokur

The Supreme Court allowed the appeal and permitted compounding of offences under Sections 451 and 354 IPC committed in 2000 based on a genuine compromise, setting aside the conviction and acquitting the appellant.

criminal appeal_allowed Significant compounding of offences Section 451 IPC Section 354 IPC Code of Criminal Procedure Amendment 2008

State of M.P. & Anr. v. Suresh Narayan Vijayvargiya & Ors.

27 Feb 2014 · B. S. Chauhan; K. S. Radhakrishnan; S. A. Bobde

The Supreme Court held that private medical colleges willfully violated binding interim orders on seat sharing with the State, imposed a Rs. 50 lakh fine, and directed prompt adjustment of excess admissions.

administrative petition_allowed Significant contempt of court interim orders seat sharing private medical colleges

Mahesh Dhanaji Shinde v. State of Maharashtra

27 Feb 2014 · P. Sathasivam; Ranjan Gogoi; Shiva Kirti Singh

The Supreme Court upheld the murder convictions based on circumstantial evidence but commuted the death sentences to life imprisonment, emphasizing the balance of mitigating factors and the 'rarest of rare' doctrine.

criminal sentence_modified Significant circumstantial evidence death penalty rarest of rare life imprisonment

Daljit Singh Gujral v. Jagjit Singh Arora

27 Feb 2014 · K. S. Radhakrishnan; Vikramajit Sen

The Supreme Court set aside a High Court judgment summoning hospital administrators for medical negligence based on an erroneous premise of patient's death and held that correction of judgment altering fundamental issues without notice is impermissible.

criminal appeal_allowed Significant medical negligence summoning order quashing petition correction of judgment

BALDEV SINGH v. STATE OF PUNJAB

26 Feb 2014 · K.S. Radhakrishnan; Vikramajit Sen

The Supreme Court upheld the conviction of a retired public servant for bribery under Section 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988, modifying the sentence considering his age and retirement.

criminal appeal_dismissed Significant Prevention of Corruption Act Section 13(2) bribery demand and acceptance

Defence Research & Development Organization v. Anjanappa

26 Feb 2014 · Dr. B.S. Chauhan; J. Chelameswar

The Supreme Court upheld the High Court's enhancement of compensation for land acquired by DRDO, affirming that compensation must reflect true market value with reasonable annual increments.

property appeal_dismissed Significant Land Acquisition Act, 1894 compensation enhancement market value Section 4 notification

Union of India v. M/s Tata Chemicals Ltd.

26 Feb 2014 · H.L. Dattu; S.A. Bobde
Cites 1 · Cited by 0

The Supreme Court held that interest under Section 244A of the Income Tax Act is payable on refunds of tax deducted at source made to resident deductors, even without a notice of demand under Section 156.

tax appeal_dismissed Significant Section 244A Income Tax Act interest on tax refund tax deducted at source Section 195(2) refund

Ex. Armymen’s Protection Services P. Ltd. v. Union of India

26 Feb 2014 · Sudhansu Jyoti Mukhopadhaya; Kurian Joseph

The Supreme Court held that natural justice principles may be excluded in national security matters where the Executive demonstrates justifiable facts, limiting judicial review and upholding withdrawal of security clearance without pre-decisional hearing.

administrative appeal_dismissed Significant natural justice national security security clearance administrative law

Nanak Ram v. State of Rajasthan

26 Feb 2014 · T. S. Thakur; C. Nagappan

The Supreme Court reclassified the appellants' conviction from murder to culpable homicide not amounting to murder under Section 304 Part I IPC, sentencing them to seven years imprisonment, affirming that death caused in a sudden fight without premeditation falls under this provision.

criminal appeal_allowed Significant culpable homicide not amounting to murder murder Section 302 IPC Section 304 IPC

Pal Singh & Anr. v. State of Punjab

25 Feb 2014 · Dr. B.S. Chauhan; A.K. Sikri

The Supreme Court upheld life convictions under Section 302 IPC despite defective charge framing, holding no prejudice to accused and affirming that omission to frame specific charge is not fatal if accused had fair trial.

criminal appeal_dismissed Significant Section 302 IPC charge framing common intention Section 149 IPC

Dinubhai Boghabhai Solanki v. State of Gujarat & Ors

25 Feb 2014 · Surinder Singh Nijjar; A.K. Sikri

The Supreme Court upheld the transfer of investigation to the CBI without hearing the accused, affirming that principles of natural justice do not apply at the investigation stage and dismissed the appellant's challenge to the transfer and arrest.

criminal appeal_dismissed Significant transfer of investigation right to be heard principles of natural justice Section 173(8) CrPC

Justice Ripusudan Dayal (Retd.) v. State of M.P.

25 Feb 2014 · P. Sathasivam; Ranjan Gogoi; Shiva Kirti Singh

The Supreme Court held that legislative privileges do not exempt officials from criminal investigations and upheld the maintainability of a writ petition challenging breach of privilege notices violating fundamental rights.

constitutional appeal_allowed Significant Legislative privilege Lokayukt Act Special Police Establishment Breach of privilege

INTERNATIONAL CONVEYORS LTD. v. COMMNR. OF CENTRAL EXCISE & CUSTOMS

25 Feb 2014 · Anil R. Dave; Shiva Kirti Singh

The Supreme Court allowed the appeal of International Conveyors Ltd. holding that refund of duty cannot be recovered when duty incidence was not passed on and no unjust enrichment occurred, setting aside the appellate tribunal's order demanding repayment.

tax appeal_allowed Significant refund claim customs duty unjust enrichment passing on of duty incidence

M/s Band Box Private Limited v. Estate Officer, Punjab & Sind Bank and Anr.

25 Feb 2014 · H. L. Gokhale; Kurian Joseph

The Supreme Court held that the Public Premises Act does not apply retrospectively to premises occupied before 1958, allowing the appellant to continue possession subject to enhanced rent and setting aside eviction orders.

property appeal_allowed Significant Public Premises Act retrospectivity eviction rent control

Rajkumar v. State of M.P.

25 Feb 2014 · Dr. B.S. Chauhan; M.Y. Eqbal
Cites 1 · Cited by 0

The Supreme Court upheld the appellant's conviction for rape and murder but commuted the death sentence to life imprisonment with a minimum 35-year term, emphasizing careful evaluation of child witness evidence and the exceptional nature of capital punishment.

criminal sentence_modified Significant child witness DNA evidence rape and murder death sentence

Aayush Buildwell Pvt. Ltd. v. Haryana Urban Development Authority

25 Feb 2014 · Surinder Singh Nijjar; Pinaki Chandra Ghose

The Supreme Court held that an unsuccessful applicant in a public allotment process has no inherent right to allotment and must comply with prescribed criteria, dismissing the appellant's claim for allotment despite procedural irregularities in the original allotment.

civil appeal_dismissed Significant allotment of plots arbitrariness Article 14 res judicata

Gohil Jesangbhai Raysangbhai & Ors. v. State of Gujarat & Anr.

25 Feb 2014 · Surinder Singh Nijjar; H.L. Gokhale

The Supreme Court upheld the validity of Section 43 of the Gujarat Tenancy Act and the Government Resolution fixing premium rates based on Jantri valuation for land transfer, ruling that the premium is a legitimate consideration and applications must be decided within reasonable time.

property appeal_dismissed Significant Section 43 Bombay Tenancy Act land transfer restrictions premium for land transfer Jantri rates