Supreme Court of India

18,587 judgments

Year:

Narendra v. State of Uttar Pradesh

06 Jan 2016 · T.S. Thakur; R. Banumathi

The Supreme Court modified murder convictions to culpable homicide not amounting to murder where the victim died after a prolonged interval due to complications, emphasizing the necessity of medical evidence on causation and affirming common intention liability.

criminal appeal_allowed Significant Section 302 IPC Section 304 Part I IPC common intention septicaemia

Shivanagowda Shankargouda Desai v. M. Channaveerappa Modi & Ors.

06 Jan 2016 · Anil R. Dave; Adarsh Kumar Goel

The Supreme Court set aside a High Court judgment decided without the appellant's presence and remanded the Second Appeal for fresh hearing and decision.

civil appeal_allowed Second Appeal admission stage opportunity to be heard incorrect facts

State of A.P. v. Patchimala Vigneswarudu

06 Jan 2016 · Dipak Misra; Prafulla C. Pant

The Supreme Court restored the murder conviction under Section 302 IPC by holding that the circumstantial evidence formed a complete chain proving the accused's guilt beyond reasonable doubt, overturning the High Court's acquittal.

criminal appeal_allowed Significant Section 302 IPC murder circumstantial evidence chain of circumstances

Malati Sardar v. National Insurance Company Limited

05 Jan 2016 · Anil R. Dave; Adarsh Kumar Goel

The Supreme Court held that a Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal has territorial jurisdiction if the insurance company carries on business within its limits, and appellate courts cannot set aside awards on technical jurisdictional grounds absent failure of justice.

civil appeal_allowed Significant Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 Section 166 territorial jurisdiction Claims Tribunal

Vanka Neeraja v. Veerina Sai @ Sairam

05 Jan 2016 · Anil R. Dave; Adarsh Kumar Goel

The Supreme Court allowed the appeal and directed transfer of a matrimonial case to the Family Court, Hyderabad, holding that Family Courts are the proper forum for such disputes.

family appeal_allowed matrimonial dispute family court transfer of case jurisdiction

Sri Aurobindo Ashram Trust v. R. Ramanathan

05 Jan 2016 · Madan B. Lokur; S. A. Bobde

The Supreme Court held that mere failure of trustees to ban a controversial book or expel its author does not amount to breach of trust warranting removal under Section 92 CPC and allowed revocation of leave to sue.

civil appeal_allowed Significant Section 92 CPC public charitable trust removal of trustees breach of trust

Jagdish Prasad Verma v. State of M.P.

05 Jan 2016 · Anil R. Dave; Adarsh Kumar Goel

The Supreme Court enhanced the compensation for land acquisition to Rs. 40 per square foot, aligning it with prevailing circle rates and directing payment of statutory benefits to landowners.

property appeal_allowed Significant land acquisition compensation circle rate statutory benefits

Kuldeep Kumar Pathak v. State of U.P.

05 Jan 2016 · A.K. Sikri; Rohinton Fali Nariman

The Supreme Court set aside the cancellation of the appellant's Intermediate Examination results and certificate confiscation for lack of any valid Regulation and violation of natural justice principles.

civil appeal_allowed Significant natural justice cancellation of examination results opportunity of hearing simultaneous examination

Damodar Lal v. Sohan Devi and Others

05 Jan 2016 · T. S. Thakur; Kurian Joseph

The Supreme Court held that the High Court erred in upsetting concurrent findings of fact on unauthorized structural alterations by tenants without establishing perversity, restoring the eviction decree in favor of the landlord.

civil appeal_allowed Significant concurrent findings of fact perversity second appeal Section 100 CPC

State of Uttarakhand & Ors. v. Suman Pal

04 Jan 2016 · Anil R. Dave; Adarsh Kumar Goel

The Supreme Court held that reinstatement with backwages is not just for a daily wager relieved years ago and awarded a lump-sum compensation instead.

labor appeal_partly_allowed Significant daily wager reinstatement backwages monetary compensation

Sameera Paikara v. Amit Ajit Jogi & Ors.

04 Jan 2016 · Anil R. Dave; Adarsh Kumar Goel

The Supreme Court allowed the appeal and added the issue of whether an American citizen by birth is eligible to contest State Assembly elections in India for adjudication.

constitutional appeal_allowed Procedural Assembly election eligibility citizenship American citizen by birth State Assembly

Mohdinsa Nabisa Gurikar v. Imamsa Chandas Gurikar

04 Jan 2016 · Anil R. Dave; Adarsh Kumar Goel

The Supreme Court set aside the High Court order and remanded the land dispute case for fresh consideration due to absence of clear findings on key factual questions.

civil appeal_allowed Procedural land dispute partition re-grant of land finding of fact

RAMAKANT DWIVEDI v. RAFIQ AHMAD & ORS.

04 Jan 2016 · ANIL R. DAVE; ADARSH KUMAR GOEL
Cites 1 · Cited by 0

The Supreme Court upheld the validity of the Government Order mandating e-tendering for mining leases, rejecting claims of vested rights from pending applications and dismissing leases granted in violation of this policy.

administrative appeal_dismissed Significant mining lease minor minerals Uttar Pradesh Minor Minerals (Concession) Rules, 1963 Government Order 31 May 2012

The Management of Narendra & Company Private Limited v. The Workmen of Narendra & Company

04 Jan 2016 · Kurian Joseph; Rohinton Fali Nariman

The Supreme Court held that back wages to workmen cannot be extended beyond the date the industry ceased functioning, affirming that appellate courts should not disturb factual findings without perversity.

labor appeal_partly_allowed Significant back wages retrenchment compensation industry closure appellate interference

Pramod v. State of Maharashtra & Ors.

29 Dec 2015 · VikramaJit Sen; Shiva Kirti Singh
Cites 0 · Cited by 1

The Supreme Court held that a senior-most lecturer in a private aided polytechnic is entitled to promotion as Principal under statutory MEPS Rules, overruling the applicability of Government Rules 2012 and directing reinstatement with consequential benefits.

labor appeal_allowed Significant promotion principal appointment private polytechnic MEPS Rules

S.K.L. Co. v. Chief Commercial Officer

29 Dec 2015 · VikramaJit Sen; Shivakirti Singh

The Supreme Court upheld the legality of leasing railway parcel space through competitive tenders while affirming the Railways' duty to fix and enforce upper tariff limits to prevent undue preference and protect public interest.

administrative appeal_dismissed Significant Indian Railways Act 1989 leasing parcel space Section 70 undue preference tariff fixation

Pegasus Assets Reconstruction P. Ltd. v. M/s. Haryana Concast Limited

29 Dec 2015 · VikramaJit Sen; Shiva Kirti Singh

The Supreme Court held that secured creditors can enforce security interests under the SARFAESI Act without Company Court intervention during winding up, disallowing supervisory fetters imposed under the Companies Act.

civil appeal_allowed Significant SARFAESI Act Companies Act Section 13 SARFAESI Section 529A Companies Act

LIC OF INDIA v. INSURE POLICY PLUS SERVICES PVT. LTD.

29 Dec 2015 · Virkamajit Sen; Shivakirti Singh

The Supreme Court held that life insurance policies were freely assignable under Section 38 of the Insurance Act, 1938 prior to its 2015 amendment, and insurer's refusal to register assignments was illegal and void.

civil appeal_dismissed Significant life insurance policy assignment transfer Section 38 Insurance Act 1938

The Kerala Bar Hotels Association v. State of Kerala

29 Dec 2015 · Vikramajit Sen; Shivakirti Singh
Cites 1 · Cited by 0

The Supreme Court upheld Kerala's policy restricting liquor licenses to Five Star hotels as a reasonable classification under Articles 14 and 19, affirming the State's power to regulate liquor trade to reduce public consumption.

administrative appeal_allowed Significant Abkari Act FL-3 license Article 14 Article 19(1)(g)

Central Bank of India v. Virudhunagar Steel Rolling Mills Ltd. & Ors.

29 Dec 2015 · VikramaJit Sen; Shivakirti Singh

The Supreme Court held that personal guarantees executed on a specific date do not cover liabilities incurred prior to that date unless expressly stated, dismissing the bank's appeal to hold directors liable for earlier debts.

civil appeal_dismissed Significant continuing guarantee surety liability prior debts contra proferentem rule