Supreme Court of India

16,793 judgments

Year:

K.K. Dixit v. Rajasthan Housing Board

05 Sep 2014 · Fakkir Mohamed Ibrahim Kalifulla; Shiva Kirti Singh

Diploma holders acquiring AMIE qualification must complete the full required experience after qualification to be eligible for promotion in the degree holders' quota; prior diploma-holder service cannot be counted.

service_law appeal_allowed Significant promotion eligibility degree holders diploma holders AMIE qualification

Harsha Constructions v. Union of India

05 Sep 2014 · Anil R. Dave; Vikramajit Sen

The Supreme Court held that disputes expressly excepted from arbitration under a contract cannot be decided by an Arbitrator and set aside the arbitral award on such non-arbitrable issues while upholding the rest.

civil appeal_partly_allowed Significant arbitration excepted matters Clause 39 extra work rates

Pargan Singh v. State of Punjab & Anr.

05 Sep 2014 · J. Chelameswar; A.K. Sikri

The Supreme Court upheld convictions for murder and robbery, affirming that eyewitness identification after long lapse is credible when supported by injured witness testimony and corroborated extra-judicial confession.

criminal appeal_dismissed Significant eyewitness identification injured witness extra-judicial confession memory theory

U.P. Hindi Sahitya Sammelan v. State of U.P.

04 Sep 2014 · R.M. Lodha; Dipak Misra; Madan B. Lokur; Kurian Joseph; S.A....

The Supreme Court upheld the constitutional validity of Uttar Pradesh's law declaring Urdu as the second official language alongside Hindi, affirming the State Legislature's power under Article 345 to adopt multiple official languages absent conflicting Presidential directions under Article 347.

constitutional appeal_dismissed Significant Article 345 Article 347 official language State Legislature

M/s Anand Brothers P. Ltd. TR. M.D. v. Union of India & Ors.

04 Sep 2014 · T.S. Thakur; C. Nagappan; Adarsh Kumar Goel
Cites 1 · Cited by 0

The Supreme Court held that under Clause 70 of the contract, an arbitral award must include reasons supporting the arbitrator's findings, and a non-speaking award without such reasons can be set aside.

civil appeal_dismissed Significant arbitral award non-speaking award Clause 70 General Conditions of Contract findings

H.A. Martin v. Moses Thambi Pillai

04 Sep 2014 · Chelameswar; A.K. Sikri

The Supreme Court held that the Tamil Evangelical Lutheran Church, a religious society registered under the 1860 Act, is exempt from the Tamil Nadu Societies Registration Act, 1975, rendering the Act inapplicable to it.

civil appeal_allowed Significant Tamil Evangelical Lutheran Church Tamil Nadu Societies Registration Act, 1975 Societies Registration Act, 1860 exemption

STATE OF NCT OF DELHI v. SANJAY

04 Sep 2014 · M.Y. Eqbal; Pinaki Chandra Ghose

The Supreme Court held that the MMDR Act does not bar prosecution under the IPC for illegal mining offences, police can register FIRs and investigate without authorized complaints, but Magistrates can take cognizance under the MMDR Act only on complaints by authorized officers.

criminal appeal_allowed Significant Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957 Section 21 MMDR Act Section 22 MMDR Act Illegal mining

Narinder Singh v. New India Assurance Company Ltd

04 Sep 2014 · M.Y. Eqbal; Pinaki Chandra Ghose

The Supreme Court held that driving a vehicle without valid registration at the time of accident constitutes a fundamental breach of the insurance policy, justifying repudiation of the claim.

civil appeal_dismissed Significant Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 vehicle registration insurance claim repudiation temporary registration

Hindustan Coca Cola Beverage (P) Ltd. v. Union of India

04 Sep 2014 · Dipak Misra; Abhay Manohar Sapre

The Supreme Court held that recovery under Section 153(4) of the Finance Act, 2003 can proceed without prior notice but factual disputes must be resolved in statutory appeals, directing deposit of disputed amounts as a condition precedent to appeal.

tax appeal_allowed Significant Finance Act 2003 Section 153 Central Excise Recovery order

Oil & Natural Gas Corporation Ltd. v. Western Geco International Ltd.

04 Sep 2014 · T.S. Thakur; C. Nagappan; Adarsh Kumar Goel

The Supreme Court partially modified an arbitral award on delay attribution and upheld key contractual and tax findings, clarifying the scope of public policy in setting aside arbitral awards.

civil appeal_allowed Significant arbitral award force majeure liquidated damages excess engagement charges

Tanua Rabidas v. State of Assam

04 Sep 2014 · M. Y. Eqbal; Pinaki Chandra Ghose

The Supreme Court upheld the conviction under section 302 IPC based on reliable dying declarations recorded before medical witnesses despite absence of physical evidence like kerosene smell.

criminal appeal_dismissed Significant dying declaration section 302 IPC kerosene oil burn life imprisonment

Commissioner of Income Tax, Rajkot v. Govindbhai Mamaiya

04 Sep 2014 · A.K. Sikri; J. Chelameswar
Cites 1 · Cited by 0

The Supreme Court held that heirs are assessed individually, not as an Association of Persons, and interest on enhanced land acquisition compensation is taxable in the year of receipt under Section 45(5) of the Income Tax Act.

tax appeal_allowed Significant Association of Persons Inheritance Enhanced Compensation Interest under Section 28

V.K. Vasantha Kumari v. R. Sudhakar

04 Sep 2014 · J. Chelameswar; A.K. Sikri

The Supreme Court enhanced the permanent alimony awarded to a divorced wife to ensure stable monthly maintenance despite fluctuating interest rates on the lump sum amount.

family appeal_allowed Significant permanent alimony Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 maintenance interest rate fluctuation

Prempal v. State of Haryana

03 Sep 2014 · T. S. Thakur; R. Banumathi
Cites 1 · Cited by 0

The Supreme Court upheld the conviction based solely on a reliable dying declaration despite the victim's severe burn injuries, dismissing the defence's suicide theory and challenges to the statement's validity.

criminal appeal_dismissed Significant dying declaration Section 302 IPC burn injuries fit state of mind

Raghubir Singh v. General Manager, Haryana Roadways, Hissar

03 Sep 2014 · Sudhansu Jyoti Mukhopadhaya; V. Gopala Gowda

The Supreme Court held that termination without enquiry under Article 311(2)(b) was unlawful, delay in raising industrial dispute does not bar relief, and ordered reinstatement with back wages, setting aside the Labour Court and High Court orders.

labor appeal_allowed Significant Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 Article 311(2)(b) Constitution natural justice doctrine of proportionality

Mohd. Arif @ Ashfaq v. The Registrar, Supreme Court of India & Others

02 Sep 2014 · R.M. Lodha; Jagdish Singh Khehar; A.K. Sikri; Rohinton Fali...

The Supreme Court held that review petitions in death penalty cases must be heard in open court with oral arguments, overruling the practice of deciding such petitions by circulation without oral hearing to uphold constitutional fairness under Article 21.

criminal appeal_allowed Significant death penalty review petition oral hearing Supreme Court Rules 1966

Abhay Kumar Singh v. State of Bihar

02 Sep 2014 · T. S. Thakur; Adarsh Kumar Goel; R. Banumathi

The Supreme Court held that while minimum height is a valid eligibility criterion for police constable selection, height alone cannot be the sole basis for selection, and directed fresh appointment of candidates dismissed for height manipulation without continuity of past service.

administrative appeal_allowed Significant height criterion police constable selection Article 14 arbitrariness

Narendra v. State of Rajasthan

02 Sep 2014 · T. S. Thakur; R. Banumathi

The Supreme Court modified a murder conviction to culpable homicide not amounting to murder under Exception 5 of Section 300 IPC, recognizing a suicide pact with consent of the deceased.

criminal appeal_allowed Significant Exception 5 of Section 300 IPC suicide pact culpable homicide not amounting to murder consent to death

Vireshwar Singh v. Municipal Corporation of Delhi

02 Sep 2014 · Ranjan Gogoi; M. Y. Eqbal

The Supreme Court upheld that ad hoc medical officers appointed without UPSC selection are entitled to regularization only from the date of UPSC recommendation, not from their initial appointment dates.

service_law appeal_dismissed Significant ad hoc appointment regularization Union Public Service Commission Delhi Municipal Corporation

Kusha Laxman Waghmare v. State of Maharashtra

02 Sep 2014 · M. Y. Eqbal; Pinaki Chandra Ghose

The Supreme Court altered the appellant's conviction from murder under Section 302 IPC to culpable homicide not amounting to murder under Section 304 Part-II IPC due to lack of evidence of intent to cause death.

criminal appeal_allowed Significant extra-judicial confession Section 302 IPC Section 304 Part-II IPC intention to cause death