Search Judgments

Search by legal issue, facts, citation, statute, or case name

M/s Haryana Mining Company v. State of Haryana & Ors.

Supreme Court of India · 09 May 2022

The Supreme Court set aside the termination of a mining lease due to lack of evidence implicating the lessee in illegal mining, emphasizing the need for cogent proof before such adverse administrative action.

administrative appeal_allowed

MIHAN INDIA LTD. v. GMR AIRPORTS LTD. & ORS.

Supreme Court of India · 09 May 2022 · 2022 INSC 534

The Supreme Court held that a duly issued and accepted Letter of Award under a public bidding process constitutes a binding contract, and annulment of the bidding process thereafter without just cause is arbitrary and violative of Article 14.

administrative appeal_dismissed

MIHAN INDIA LTD. v. GMR AIRPORTS LTD. & ORS.

Supreme Court of India · 09 May 2022

The Supreme Court held that a duly issued and acknowledged Letter of Award under a public bidding process constitutes a binding contract, and annulment of the bidding process thereafter without valid reasons is arbitrary and violative of Article 14.

administrative appeal_allowed

NIMS University v. Union of India

Supreme Court of India · 09 May 2022 · 2022 INSC 537

The Supreme Court upheld the Central Government's decision to maintain the 50 percentile cut-off for Super Specialty medical admissions, refusing to lower it but directing a mop-up counselling round to fill vacant seats.

constitutional appeal_dismissed

NIMS University v. Union of India

Supreme Court of India · 09 May 2022

The Supreme Court upheld the decision to maintain the 50th percentile eligibility cut-off for Super Specialty medical courses, refusing to lower it despite vacant seats, but directed a mop-up counselling round to fill vacancies.

constitutional petition_dismissed

V. Prakash @ G.N.V. Prakash v. M/s. P.S. Govindaswamy Naidu & Sons’ Charities

Supreme Court of India · 09 May 2022

The Supreme Court held that the appellant, despite holding a US Green Card, qualifies as a founder trustee under the trust’s Scheme of Administration by virtue of his residence and animus to reside within the Madras Presidency, restoring the Trial Court’s judgment and setting aside the High Court’s contrary decision.

civil appeal_allowed

Haryana Staff Selection Commission v. Priyanka and Others

Supreme Court of India · 09 May 2022

The Supreme Court held that candidates with provisional B.Ed. results declared before the cut-off date are eligible for appointment, directed merit-based selection respecting seniority, and clarified compliance with its prior order amid contempt proceedings.

administrative appeal_allowed

Haryana Staff Selection Commission v. Priyanka and Others

Supreme Court of India · 09 May 2022

The Supreme Court held that candidates with provisional university results declared before the cut-off date are eligible for appointment, directed merit-based selection respecting court orders, and clarified compliance and merit principles in recruitment litigation.

administrative appeal_allowed

Pooja Bhuneshwar Prasad Sharma v. Ashish Vinaybhai Mishra

Supreme Court of India · 09 May 2022 · 2022 INSC 540

The Supreme Court allowed the dissolution of marriage by mutual consent under Section 13-B of the Hindu Marriage Act, dispensing with the six-month waiting period and rendering transfer petitions infructuous based on a mediated settlement.

family appeal_allowed

Pooja Bhuneshwar Prasad Sharma v. Ashish Vinaybhai Mishra

Supreme Court of India · 09 May 2022

The Supreme Court allowed mutual consent divorce by accepting a mediated settlement, dispensing with the six months' waiting period, and disposed of connected transfer petitions as infructuous.

family petition_allowed

T.N. Godavarman Thirumulpad v. Union of India

Supreme Court of India · 09 May 2022

The Supreme Court revoked NBWL clearance for doubling a railway line through the Western Ghats, emphasizing mandatory environmental clearances, sustainable development, and precautionary principle.

environmental appeal_allowed

Bhola Kumhar v. State of Chhattisgarh

Supreme Court of India · 09 May 2022 · 2022 INSC 535

The Supreme Court held that detention beyond the sentence period fixed by the High Court, including remission, is illegal and awarded compensation to the appellant for violation of fundamental rights.

criminal appeal_allowed

Bhola Kumhar v. State of Chhattisgarh

Supreme Court of India · 09 May 2022

The Supreme Court held that detention beyond the lawful sentence period violates fundamental rights and awarded compensation to a convict illegally detained beyond his sentence.

criminal appeal_allowed

Dilip Hariramani v. Bank of Baroda

Supreme Court of India · 09 May 2022

The Supreme Court held that a partner cannot be criminally convicted under Section 138 read with Section 141 of the Negotiable Instruments Act without the firm being prosecuted and without proof that the partner was in charge of and responsible for the firm's business or consented to the offence.

criminal appeal_allowed

Dilip Hariramani v. Bank of Baroda

Supreme Court of India · 09 May 2022

The Supreme Court held that a partner cannot be criminally convicted under Section 138 read with Section 141 of the Negotiable Instruments Act without the firm being prosecuted as the principal offender and without proof that the partner was in charge of and responsible for the firm's business.

criminal appeal_allowed

Raj Kumari Taneja v. Rajinder Kumar & Ors.

Delhi High Court · 09 May 2022 · 2024:DHC:6366

The Delhi High Court appointed an arbitrator under Section 11(5) of the Arbitration Act to resolve partnership disputes, holding that questions of settlement are for the arbitrator to decide.

civil appeal_allowed

Raj Kumari Taneja v. Rajinder Kumar & Anr.

Delhi High Court · 09 May 2022 · 2024:DHC:6365

The Delhi High Court held that under Section 11(5) of the Arbitration Act, the Court must appoint an arbitrator if an arbitration agreement exists and the petition is timely, leaving factual disputes such as settlement to the arbitrator.

civil appeal_allowed

Omkar Mahadeo Supekar v. Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai

High Court of Bombay · 06 May 2022

The Bombay High Court held that MCGM's construction of a cycling and jogging track inside Powai Lake violates Development Control Regulations and is illegal, ordering removal of all construction and restoration of the lake.

environmental petition_allowed

Adani Electricity Mumbai Ltd. v. The Chief Conciliator and Ors.

High Court of Bombay · 06 May 2022

The Bombay High Court held that the Maharashtra Industrial Relations Act, 1946 applies to a company engaged in both generation and supply of electricity in Mumbai, dismissing the writ petition challenging the Industrial Court's jurisdiction.

labor appeal_dismissed

Sea Sagar Construction Co. v. Mr. V.A. Nair & Ors.

High Court of Bombay · 06 May 2022

The Bombay High Court held that reassessment notices issued beyond the six-year limitation without a binding appellate finding or direction are invalid, upholding the completed contract method of accounting and quashing the reopening of assessments.

tax petition_allowed