Full Text
Translation output
$-6 & 7 HIGH COURT OF DELHI
FAO(OS) 241/2015 & CM 7969/2015
BHARAT SANCHAR NIGAM LTD
Through: Mr Chandan Kurnar Appellant
FAO(OS) 241/2015 & CM 7969/2015
BHARAT SANCHAR NIGAM LTD
Through: Mr Chandan Kurnar Appellant
VERSUS
.
CANARA BANK & ANR
CANARA BANK & ANR
FAO(OS) 366/2015
Respondents
Through: Mr Pradeep Dewan, Sr Advocate with Ms Anupam Dhingra for R- 1.
Mr Sunil Sabharwal with Mr Parvesh Khanna, Mr Anish K. Gupta, Ms Poorva Khandekar, Abhishek Khanna, Mr Chirag Babbar and
Mr Rahul Sabharwal for R-2 RENEWABLE ENERGY SYSTEMS LIMITED Appellant
Through: Mr Sunil Sabharwal with Mr Parvesh Khanna, Mr Anish K. Gupta, Ms Poorva Khandekar, Abhishek Khanna, Mr Chirag Babbar and
Mr Rahul Sabharwal
Respondents
Through: Mr Pradeep Dewan, Sr Advocate with Ms Anupam Dhingra for R- 1.
Mr Sunil Sabharwal with Mr Parvesh Khanna, Mr Anish K. Gupta, Ms Poorva Khandekar, Abhishek Khanna, Mr Chirag Babbar and
Mr Rahul Sabharwal for R-2 RENEWABLE ENERGY SYSTEMS LIMITED Appellant
Through: Mr Sunil Sabharwal with Mr Parvesh Khanna, Mr Anish K. Gupta, Ms Poorva Khandekar, Abhishek Khanna, Mr Chirag Babbar and
Mr Rahul Sabharwal
VERSUS
BHARAT SANCHAR NIGAM LTD & ANR Respondents
Through: Mr Chandan Kumar for R-1IBSNL.
Mr Pradeep Dewan, Sr Advocate with Ms Anupam Dhingra for R-2/Canara Bank
Through: Mr Chandan Kumar for R-1IBSNL.
Mr Pradeep Dewan, Sr Advocate with Ms Anupam Dhingra for R-2/Canara Bank
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE BADAR DURREZ AHMED
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV SACHDEVA
08.12.2015 When FAO(OS) 241/2015 came up for hearing before this Bench, for the first time, on 01.05.2015, after hearing the learned counsel for BSNL, we issued notice, restricted to the contents of paragraph 51 of the impugned
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV SACHDEVA
08.12.2015 When FAO(OS) 241/2015 came up for hearing before this Bench, for the first time, on 01.05.2015, after hearing the learned counsel for BSNL, we issued notice, restricted to the contents of paragraph 51 of the impugned
ORDER
, wherein an arbitrator had been directed to be appointed other than in terms of the arbitration clause.
2015:DHC:11936-DB ft )
We had made it clear that in all other respects, the impugned order did not warrant any interference.
In the course of hearing, it transpired that, by the agreement of parties, an independent arbitrator, preferably a former judge of this Court, could be appointed as the sole arbitrator to adjudicate the disputes between the parties in terms of the directions given by the learned Single Judge in paragraph 51. The learned counsel for BSNL has indicated that a decision has been taken by BSNL on 30.11.2015, a copy of which has been handed over to us and the same is taken on record, that the competent authority has conveyed an approval to appoint Justice Manju Goel, a former judge of this Court
(residing at R-128, Greater Kailash-I, First Floor, New Delhi-110048) as the sole arbitrator to adjudicate the disputes between the parties. The learned counsel appearing for Canara Bank as well as Renewable Energy Systems Limited have also taken instructions and they concur on the appointment of Justice Manju Goel, a former judge of this Court, as the sole arbitrator.
Consequently, with this modification in the impugned judgment, the appeals are disposed of It is also made clear that the consequential compensation claimed by
Renewable Energy Systems Limited would also be examined by the learned Arbitrator.
But, the said issues would be decided, as directed by the learned Single Judge, on the basis of the existing material. The other directions of the learned Single Judge, as contained in paragraph 51, are reiterated. Another modification in the impugned order is to the effect that the learned Arbitrator shall fix her own fees.
The appeals stand disposed of 11EZ AHMED, J DECEMBER 08, 2015 SANJEEV SACHDEVA, J
SR
C
I
2015:DHC:11936-DB
2015:DHC:11936-DB ft )
We had made it clear that in all other respects, the impugned order did not warrant any interference.
In the course of hearing, it transpired that, by the agreement of parties, an independent arbitrator, preferably a former judge of this Court, could be appointed as the sole arbitrator to adjudicate the disputes between the parties in terms of the directions given by the learned Single Judge in paragraph 51. The learned counsel for BSNL has indicated that a decision has been taken by BSNL on 30.11.2015, a copy of which has been handed over to us and the same is taken on record, that the competent authority has conveyed an approval to appoint Justice Manju Goel, a former judge of this Court
(residing at R-128, Greater Kailash-I, First Floor, New Delhi-110048) as the sole arbitrator to adjudicate the disputes between the parties. The learned counsel appearing for Canara Bank as well as Renewable Energy Systems Limited have also taken instructions and they concur on the appointment of Justice Manju Goel, a former judge of this Court, as the sole arbitrator.
Consequently, with this modification in the impugned judgment, the appeals are disposed of It is also made clear that the consequential compensation claimed by
Renewable Energy Systems Limited would also be examined by the learned Arbitrator.
But, the said issues would be decided, as directed by the learned Single Judge, on the basis of the existing material. The other directions of the learned Single Judge, as contained in paragraph 51, are reiterated. Another modification in the impugned order is to the effect that the learned Arbitrator shall fix her own fees.
The appeals stand disposed of 11EZ AHMED, J DECEMBER 08, 2015 SANJEEV SACHDEVA, J
SR
C
I
2015:DHC:11936-DB