Full Text
Translation output
mm" $-25 & 26 HIGH COURT OF DELHI
W.P.(C)2982/2016& C.M.No.12543/2016
PRIYANSHI& ORS Petitioners
Through Mr.Ajay Kumar Singh with Mr.Medhanshu Tripathi,Advocates.
W.P.(C)2982/2016& C.M.No.12543/2016
PRIYANSHI& ORS Petitioners
Through Mr.Ajay Kumar Singh with Mr.Medhanshu Tripathi,Advocates.
VERSUS
THE HERITAGE SCHOOL& ORS Respondents
Through Mr.K.P.Sundar Rao,Advocate for R- 1.
Mr.Peeyosh Kalra,ASC with Ms.Sona Babbar,Advocate for
Through Mr.K.P.Sundar Rao,Advocate for R- 1.
Mr.Peeyosh Kalra,ASC with Ms.Sona Babbar,Advocate for
GNCTD. W.P.(C)3016/2016& C.M.No.12684/2016
UTSAW KUMAR AND ORS Petitioners
Through Mr.Ajay Kumar Singh with Mr.Medhanshu Tripathi,Advocates.
UTSAW KUMAR AND ORS Petitioners
Through Mr.Ajay Kumar Singh with Mr.Medhanshu Tripathi,Advocates.
VERSUS
THE POORNA PRAJNA PUBLIC SCHOOL AND ORS Respondents
Through Mr.Kaustubh Sinha,Advocate for R- 1 &2.
Mr.Gautam Narayan,ASC with Mr.Shatrajit Banerji and Mr.Pankaj
Yadav,Advocates for GNCTD.
Through Mr.Kaustubh Sinha,Advocate for R- 1 &2.
Mr.Gautam Narayan,ASC with Mr.Shatrajit Banerji and Mr.Pankaj
Yadav,Advocates for GNCTD.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE MANMOHAN
08.04.2016 Present writ petitions have been filed challenging the expulsion letters whereby the admissions of the minor petitioners have been
2016:DHC:9219 cancelled on the ground that the income certificates forwarded by their parents were not genuine.
Learned counsel for petitioners state that the fathers of the
N petitioners were cheated by touts in the office of Deputy
H Commissioner, South District. They further state that the fresh
1 income certificates ofthe parents ofthe minor petitioners still disclose their actual income as less than Rs.1lakh.
A Learned counsel for the petitioners also rely upon the orders dated January,2016 and 26^^ February,2016 passed by this Court in W.P.(C) 557/2016, wherein this Court directed the school authorities not to cancel the admissions ofthe minors on the ground of the misdeeds ofthe fathers.
Learned counsel for the Heritage School states that the seats in
EWS category are still available with it and the minor petitioners can be accommodated in the school.
Learned counsel for the Pooma Prajna Public School also confirms that seats under EWS category are still available with it and the minor petitioners can be accommodated in this school. He, however, states that income certificates of 10 of the petitioners in
08.04.2016 Present writ petitions have been filed challenging the expulsion letters whereby the admissions of the minor petitioners have been
2016:DHC:9219 cancelled on the ground that the income certificates forwarded by their parents were not genuine.
Learned counsel for petitioners state that the fathers of the
N petitioners were cheated by touts in the office of Deputy
H Commissioner, South District. They further state that the fresh
1 income certificates ofthe parents ofthe minor petitioners still disclose their actual income as less than Rs.1lakh.
A Learned counsel for the petitioners also rely upon the orders dated January,2016 and 26^^ February,2016 passed by this Court in W.P.(C) 557/2016, wherein this Court directed the school authorities not to cancel the admissions ofthe minors on the ground of the misdeeds ofthe fathers.
Learned counsel for the Heritage School states that the seats in
EWS category are still available with it and the minor petitioners can be accommodated in the school.
Learned counsel for the Pooma Prajna Public School also confirms that seats under EWS category are still available with it and the minor petitioners can be accommodated in this school. He, however, states that income certificates of 10 of the petitioners in
WP(C)3016/2016 have expired.
Learned counsel for the petitioners states that fresh income certificates in lieu of expired certificates shall be furnished to the respondents within a period oftwo weeks.
Learned senior standing counsel for GNCTD states that recently the GNCTD vide circulars dated 6^^ November,2015 and 27^^
January,2016 has simplified the procedure ofissuance ofan income
'l certificate. He also confirms that the new valid income certificates that have been produced,have been found to be genuine.
Keeping in view the aforesaid,this Court directs that the minor petitioners who have forwarded fresh income certificates shall continue with their studies in the respondents/schools under EWS category.
In lieu of expired income certificates, the fathers of minor petitioners are directed to furnish fresh income certificates within a period oftwo weeks. The respondents/schools are directed to verify the said certificates and if they find them to be genuine, they shall allow the minor petitioners to continue with their studies under EWS category.
Needless to say that the minor petitioners shall be entitled to all the benefits/entitlements underthe said group.
Since fathers ofthe minor petitioners had admittedly produced the wrong income certificates, they are directed to pay costs of
Rs.5,000/- each to the Lok Nayak Jai Prakash Hospital,Delhi, within a period oftwo weeks.
With the aforesaid directions, present writ petitions and applications stand disposed of.
Order dasti under the signature ofCourt Master.
MANMOHAN,J APRIL 08,2016 KA
Learned counsel for the petitioners states that fresh income certificates in lieu of expired certificates shall be furnished to the respondents within a period oftwo weeks.
Learned senior standing counsel for GNCTD states that recently the GNCTD vide circulars dated 6^^ November,2015 and 27^^
January,2016 has simplified the procedure ofissuance ofan income
'l certificate. He also confirms that the new valid income certificates that have been produced,have been found to be genuine.
Keeping in view the aforesaid,this Court directs that the minor petitioners who have forwarded fresh income certificates shall continue with their studies in the respondents/schools under EWS category.
In lieu of expired income certificates, the fathers of minor petitioners are directed to furnish fresh income certificates within a period oftwo weeks. The respondents/schools are directed to verify the said certificates and if they find them to be genuine, they shall allow the minor petitioners to continue with their studies under EWS category.
Needless to say that the minor petitioners shall be entitled to all the benefits/entitlements underthe said group.
Since fathers ofthe minor petitioners had admittedly produced the wrong income certificates, they are directed to pay costs of
Rs.5,000/- each to the Lok Nayak Jai Prakash Hospital,Delhi, within a period oftwo weeks.
With the aforesaid directions, present writ petitions and applications stand disposed of.
Order dasti under the signature ofCourt Master.
MANMOHAN,J APRIL 08,2016 KA
JUDGMENT