M/S SPECTRUM CONCRETE (P) LTD. v. DELHI STATE INDUSTRIAL & INFRASTRUCTURE CORPORATION LTD.

Delhi High Court · 06 May 2016 · 2016:DHC:8883-DB
Badar Durrez Ahmed; Sanjeev Sachdeva
W.P.(C)9002/2014
2016:DHC:8883-DB
administrative petition_dismissed

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court dismissed writ petitions challenging certain tender clauses as infructuous due to contract completion, while preserving petitioners' rights to challenge similar clauses in future tenders.

Full Text
Translation output
r $-17to 22 HIGH COURT OF DELHI
W.P.(C)8978/2014&CMNo.20527/2014
M/SRAJREADYCONCRETEWORKS&ANR Petitioners
Through MrA.K.Singla,SrAdvocatewith MrA.S.
Khatri,Advocates.
VERSUS
LMTED industrial&INFRASTRUCTURECORPORATION ^ Through ^RenukaArorawithMrR.S.ChaXli^x
Engg.,CD-21,DSIIDC.
W.P.(C)9002/2014&CM No.20560/2014
M/S.SPECTRUMCONCRETE(P)LTD.ANDANR. Petitioners
Through MrA.K.Singla,SrAdvocate with MrA.S.
VERSUS
DELHISTATEINDUSTRIAL&INFRASTRUCTURECORPORATIONLTD.
Respondent
Through MsRenuka Arora with MrR.S.Chauhan,Ex
W.P.(C)9220/2014&CM No.20950/2014
M/S.RAJ READY CONCRETE WORKSAND ANR Petitioners
Through MrA.K.Singla,Sr Advoeate with MrA.S.
VERSUS
GOVT.OF NOTOFDELHI
Through MrPeeyoosh Kalra,Advocatefor GNCT with
MrR.M.Goyal,Asstt.Engineer,Irrigation& Flood Control Deptt.,GNCTD. W.P.(C)9251/2014&CM No.20990/2014
RAMREADYMIXCONCRETEPVT.LTD. Petitioner 2016:DHC:8883-DB
Through MrKuljeetRawal,Advocate,
VERSUS
GOVT.OFNCTOFDELHI&ANR
Through mSatyAan,.AdvocateforTespontoCl En^gg"rDSirc."^
W.P.(C)9292/2014&CMNo.21054/2014
M/S.SPECTRUMCONCRETE(P)LTD.&ANR. pe,;,jokers
Through ^a.K.Singia,SrAdvocatewithMrAS ^ Khatri,Advocates.
VERSUS
GOVT.OF NCT OFDELHI
Through MsRenukaArorawithMrR.S.ChLhan Ex Mr Santosh Kumar Tripathi,Advocate for
GNCTD with MrR.M.Goel,Asstt.Engg.,Flood Control Deptt,GNCTD.
W.P.(C)2424/2015& CMNo.4367/2015
M/S ANTARCTICA CONSTRUCTION CO. Petitioner
Through MsPriyaKumar with Mr Adhish Srivastava and MsTanya Tiwari,Advocates.
VERSUS
DELHISTATEINDUSTRIAL&INFRASTRUCTUREDEVELOPMENT
CORPORATIONLTD. Respondent
Through MsSangeeta Chandra,AdvocateforDSIIDC with MrR.S.Chauhan,E.E.,CD-21
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR.JUSTICEBADARDURREZAHMED
HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE SANJEEV SACHDEVA
"/« 06.05.2016 The learned eounsel appearing on behalfofGovt.ofNCT ofDelhi as also thelearned counselappearingonbehalfofDSIIDCstate,oninstructionsfrom(a) r r
Mr R.M.Goel,Asstt. Engg.,Flood Control Department,GNCTD and(b)Mr R.S.
Chauhan,Ex.Engg.,CD-21,DSIIDC respectively,that the subject contracts have been completed and,therefore,these petitions have become infructuous.
The writ petitions are disposed of as such. Their disposal is without prejudice to the rights of the petitioners to challenge future tenders in which clauses similar to clauses 19 to 27 are retained.
The writ petitions stand disposed ofaccordingly.
BADAR DURREZ AHMED,J f —
SANJEEV SACHDEVA,J MAY 06,2016 st
JUDGMENT