Full Text
Translation output
- ~ '" ..
. . ~ H.C.D.O.A.-2 HIGH COURT OF DELHI INDEX SHEET
CAUSE ITLE.................A:ah,:..e?"\'.':\~.;..J.\.1.l6........................c... · ............ :C......:.:..OF 200
NAME CF THE ' . . c, ~ ~~. .
PARTIE~................J)~h1...$..h.ts.~~J... '~"~"""""'~~""""""""""""""""
. . ~ H.C.D.O.A.-2 HIGH COURT OF DELHI INDEX SHEET
CAUSE ITLE.................A:ah,:..e?"\'.':\~.;..J.\.1.l6........................c... · ............ :C......:.:..OF 200
NAME CF THE ' . . c, ~ ~~. .
PARTIE~................J)~h1...$..h.ts.~~J... '~"~"""""'~~""""""""""""""""
VERSUS
...............................................\.)..Q~.....~....~.".........................................................:.............
. PARTA&B'
SI .• AMOUNT
DESCRIPTION OF DOCUMENTS No. OF PAGE..
COURT FEE
PAID
~f)-o r '1/\ Ot Ll , ~ \ .
.. (' awi1 \'" ~ dJr- <;2;1 II r~ r1 ~ { I 1~r-'1
I 1 I 'C,'s'lh \~;;: rb I..
"'.-.
'G..
~;, ~. ,p,' .
~,,'l . '!.o " !(. ~~1J . 0 .t>,.,,'t,s,:,o.ff!.<$1e<::i ~"ti
ItP cP<::i~"'"'''otCP''' ~~ \;~....u&. ~~,,~ ': ~
. lr\\\j .~."..
\~ ...~,1':0 " d\ ~~v" ~Q)
~ ~k~A\.~ '--.o..\\V' ~ ! '. '" , . . '. ~. .., ,. ", ' " , ..
" ~ f~&1n S"'ll>j 2016:DHC:8333 -" HIGH COURT OF DELHI
Su jectl :22012 - • 1 ARB. PETITION U/S 11 Of THE ARBITRATIO~ AND CONCILIATIONfS)
AC 1996 . . . , ~ , Su jeel2 :0 - • • NOT ENTERED . (~ II
. PARTA&B'
SI .• AMOUNT
DESCRIPTION OF DOCUMENTS No. OF PAGE..
COURT FEE
PAID
~f)-o r '1/\ Ot Ll , ~ \ .
.. (' awi1 \'" ~ dJr- <;2;1 II r~ r1 ~ { I 1~r-'1
I 1 I 'C,'s'lh \~;;: rb I..
"'.-.
'G..
~;, ~. ,p,' .
~,,'l . '!.o " !(. ~~1J . 0 .t>,.,,'t,s,:,o.ff!.<$1e<::i ~"ti
ItP cP<::i~"'"'''otCP''' ~~ \;~....u&. ~~,,~ ': ~
. lr\\\j .~."..
\~ ...~,1':0 " d\ ~~v" ~Q)
~ ~k~A\.~ '--.o..\\V' ~ ! '. '" , . . '. ~. .., ,. ", ' " , ..
" ~ f~&1n S"'ll>j 2016:DHC:8333 -" HIGH COURT OF DELHI
Su jectl :22012 - • 1 ARB. PETITION U/S 11 Of THE ARBITRATIO~ AND CONCILIATIONfS)
AC 1996 . . . , ~ , Su jeel2 :0 - • • NOT ENTERED . (~ II
IARY 674043/2015 CA5E ARB.P. \\ IFilin~05/01/16c-
NO : TYPE: . iDate .15.13.49 I I ! DELHI STATE CONSUMERS COOPERATIVE FEDE~TION LTD
Vs. ' UNION OF INDIA & ANR.
(' Th case has been passed for date: 08-JAN-16
Th petition/appeal being in order/may be registered.
SC U ASSISTANT: SH.5UNTL DUTT s~ Dealing Assistant
AJ/~ r I I....:., , ! I I , .J' 05-01-2016 http:// 0.25. J96. J59/html/prashant/efile_defect.php?dno=674043&dyr-:-:20J 5
2016:DHC:8333 .,.' 'III r HIGH COURT OF DELHI
ARB.P.9/2016
DELHI STATE CONSUMER COOPERATIVE FEDERATION LTD ..... Petitioner
Through: Ms. Anju Bhattacharya, Mr. Elgin Matt John, Advs.
NO : TYPE: . iDate .15.13.49 I I ! DELHI STATE CONSUMERS COOPERATIVE FEDE~TION LTD
Vs. ' UNION OF INDIA & ANR.
(' Th case has been passed for date: 08-JAN-16
Th petition/appeal being in order/may be registered.
SC U ASSISTANT: SH.5UNTL DUTT s~ Dealing Assistant
AJ/~ r I I....:., , ! I I , .J' 05-01-2016 http:// 0.25. J96. J59/html/prashant/efile_defect.php?dno=674043&dyr-:-:20J 5
2016:DHC:8333 .,.' 'III r HIGH COURT OF DELHI
ARB.P.9/2016
DELHI STATE CONSUMER COOPERATIVE FEDERATION LTD ..... Petitioner
Through: Ms. Anju Bhattacharya, Mr. Elgin Matt John, Advs.
VERSUS
UNION OF INDIA & ANR. ..... Respondents
Through: Mr. Anil Panwar, Mr. Gaurav Rohilla, Advs. for R-l and R-2
Through: Mr. Anil Panwar, Mr. Gaurav Rohilla, Advs. for R-l and R-2
ARB.P. 10/2016
DELHI STATE CONSUMER COOPERATIVE FEDERATION LTD ..... Petitioner
Through: Ms. Anju Bhattacharya, Mr. Elgin Matt John, Advs.
DELHI STATE CONSUMER COOPERATIVE FEDERATION LTD ..... Petitioner
Through: Ms. Anju Bhattacharya, Mr. Elgin Matt John, Advs.
VERSUS
UNION OF INDIA & ANR. ..... Respondents
Through: Mr. Anil Panwar, Mr. Gaurav Rohilla, Advs. for R",l and R-2 i~
I
16 . I
Through: Mr. Anil Panwar, Mr. Gaurav Rohilla, Advs. for R",l and R-2 i~
I
16 . I
ARB.P. 11/2016
.
DELHI STATE CONSUMER COOPERATIVE FEDERATION LTD ..... Petitioner
Through: Ms. Anju Bhattacharya, Mr. Elgin Matt John, Advs.
.
DELHI STATE CONSUMER COOPERATIVE FEDERATION LTD ..... Petitioner
Through: Ms. Anju Bhattacharya, Mr. Elgin Matt John, Advs.
VERSUS
UNION OF INDIA & ANR. ..... Respqndents
Through: Mr. Anil Panwar, Mr. Gaurav Rohilla, Advs. for R-1 and R-2
2016:DHC:8333 l' , ARB.P. 12/2016 DELHI STATE CONSUMER COOPERATIVE
FEDERATION LTD ..... Petitioner
Through: Ms. AnjuBhattacharya, Mr. Elgin Matt John, Advs.
Through: Mr. Anil Panwar, Mr. Gaurav Rohilla, Advs. for R-1 and R-2
2016:DHC:8333 l' , ARB.P. 12/2016 DELHI STATE CONSUMER COOPERATIVE
FEDERATION LTD ..... Petitioner
Through: Ms. AnjuBhattacharya, Mr. Elgin Matt John, Advs.
VERSUS
UNION OF INDIA & ANR. ..... Respondents
Through: Mr. Ani! Panwar, Mr. Gaurav Rohilla, Advs. for R-l and R-2
Through: Mr. Ani! Panwar, Mr. Gaurav Rohilla, Advs. for R-l and R-2
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE J.R. MIDHA
0/0 08.01.2016
0/0 08.01.2016
IA 299/2016 in Arb.P.9/2016, IA 300/2016 in Arb.P.I0/2016, IA 30112016 in Arb.P.1112016 and
IA 302/2016 in Arb.P.12/2016
Allowed subject to just exceptions.
Arb.P.9/2016, Arb.P.I0/2016, Arb.P.1112016 and Arb.P.12/2016
Issue notice. Learned counsel for the respondents accepts notice and seeks time to file reply. Let the same be filed within three weeks.
Rejoinder, ifany, be filed within two weeks thereafter.
List on 16th March, 2016.
J.R. MIDHA, J.
JANUARY 08, 2016 -u //J 1/ t?6 /tiL IW dk 2016:DHC:8333
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
ARB.P.9/2016
DELHI STATE CONSUMER COOPERATIVE FEDERATION LTD..... Petitioner
Through Ms.Anju Bhattacharya, Adv.
Allowed subject to just exceptions.
Arb.P.9/2016, Arb.P.I0/2016, Arb.P.1112016 and Arb.P.12/2016
Issue notice. Learned counsel for the respondents accepts notice and seeks time to file reply. Let the same be filed within three weeks.
Rejoinder, ifany, be filed within two weeks thereafter.
List on 16th March, 2016.
J.R. MIDHA, J.
JANUARY 08, 2016 -u //J 1/ t?6 /tiL IW dk 2016:DHC:8333
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
ARB.P.9/2016
DELHI STATE CONSUMER COOPERATIVE FEDERATION LTD..... Petitioner
Through Ms.Anju Bhattacharya, Adv.
VERSUS
UNION OF INDIA & ANR
Through ..... Respondents Mr.Anil Panwar, CGSC with
Mr.Gaurav Rohilla, Adv.
Through ..... Respondents Mr.Anil Panwar, CGSC with
Mr.Gaurav Rohilla, Adv.
ARB.P. 10/2016
DELHI STATE CONSUMER COOPERATIVE FEDERATION LTD..... Petitioner
Through Ms.Anju Bhattacharya, Ad".
DELHI STATE CONSUMER COOPERATIVE FEDERATION LTD..... Petitioner
Through Ms.Anju Bhattacharya, Ad".
VERSUS
UNION OF INDIA & ANR
Through ..... Respondents Mr.Anil Panwar, CGse with
Mr.Gaurav Rohilla, Adv.
Through ..... Respondents Mr.Anil Panwar, CGse with
Mr.Gaurav Rohilla, Adv.
ARB.P.11/2016
DELHI STATE CONSUMER COOPERATIVE FEDERATION LTD..... Petitioner
Through Ms.Anju Bhattacharya, Adv.
DELHI STATE CONSUMER COOPERATIVE FEDERATION LTD..... Petitioner
Through Ms.Anju Bhattacharya, Adv.
VERSUS
UNION OF INDIA & ANR
Through ..... Respondents Mr.Anil Panwar, CGse with
Mr.Gaurav Rohilla, Adv. .i ,I I I 2016:DHC:8333
Through ..... Respondents Mr.Anil Panwar, CGse with
Mr.Gaurav Rohilla, Adv. .i ,I I I 2016:DHC:8333
ARB.P.12/2016
DELHI STATE CONSUMER COOPERATIVE FEDERATION LTD..... Petitioner
Through Ms.Anju Bhattacharya; Adv.
DELHI STATE CONSUMER COOPERATIVE FEDERATION LTD..... Petitioner
Through Ms.Anju Bhattacharya; Adv.
VERSUS
UNION OF INDIA & ANR ..... Respondents
Through Mr.Anil Panwar, CGSC with Mr.Gaurav Rohilla, Adv.
Through Mr.Anil Panwar, CGSC with Mr.Gaurav Rohilla, Adv.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANMOHAN SINGH
0/0 16.03.2016 Replies have not been filed. One final opportunity is granted to the respondents to file the same within three weeks. Rejoinders, if any, be filed within two weeks thereafter.
List on 18th May, 2016 for disposal.
~A~~ MARCH 16, 2016/ka - U /p II tJd Ai t Ad-.
-IV,! /lr/Did"" <>u>f f'/J _~ul-e.rJ IviA ~~ /0 ,b 13.
.. a 2016:DHC:8333 S $-10 to 13 )
IN THE HIGH COURT OF .DELHI AT NEW DELHI
ARB.P. 9/2016
DELHI STATE CONSUMER COOPERATIVE FEDERATION LTD..... Petitioner
Through Mr.Elgin Matt John, Adv. with Ms.Anju Bhattacharya" Adv.
0/0 16.03.2016 Replies have not been filed. One final opportunity is granted to the respondents to file the same within three weeks. Rejoinders, if any, be filed within two weeks thereafter.
List on 18th May, 2016 for disposal.
~A~~ MARCH 16, 2016/ka - U /p II tJd Ai t Ad-.
-IV,! /lr/Did"" <>u>f f'/J _~ul-e.rJ IviA ~~ /0 ,b 13.
.. a 2016:DHC:8333 S $-10 to 13 )
IN THE HIGH COURT OF .DELHI AT NEW DELHI
ARB.P. 9/2016
DELHI STATE CONSUMER COOPERATIVE FEDERATION LTD..... Petitioner
Through Mr.Elgin Matt John, Adv. with Ms.Anju Bhattacharya" Adv.
VERSUS
UNION OF INDIA & ANR ..... Respondents
Through Mr.Anil Panwar, CGSC with Mr.Gaurav Rohilla, Govt Pleader.
Through Mr.Anil Panwar, CGSC with Mr.Gaurav Rohilla, Govt Pleader.
ARB.P.I0/2016
DELHI STATE CONSUMER COOPERATIVE FEDERATION LTD..... Petitioner
Through Mr.Elgin Matt John,. Adv. with Ms.Anju Bhattacharya, Adv.
DELHI STATE CONSUMER COOPERATIVE FEDERATION LTD..... Petitioner
Through Mr.Elgin Matt John,. Adv. with Ms.Anju Bhattacharya, Adv.
VERSUS
UNION OF INDIA & ANR ..... Respondents
Through Mr.Anil Panwar, CGSC with Mr.Gaurav Rohilla, Govt Pleader.
Through Mr.Anil Panwar, CGSC with Mr.Gaurav Rohilla, Govt Pleader.
ARB.P. 11/2016
DELHI STATE CONSUMER COOPERATIVE FEDERATION LTD..... Petitioner
Through Mr.Elgin Matt John, Adv. with Ms.Anju Bhattacharya, Adv.
DELHI STATE CONSUMER COOPERATIVE FEDERATION LTD..... Petitioner
Through Mr.Elgin Matt John, Adv. with Ms.Anju Bhattacharya, Adv.
VERSUS
2016:DHC:8333 ., UNION OF INDIA &ANR ..... Respondents
\ Through Mr.Anil Panwar, CGSC with Mr.Gaurav Rohilla, Govt Pleader.
\ Through Mr.Anil Panwar, CGSC with Mr.Gaurav Rohilla, Govt Pleader.
ARB.P. 12/2016
DELHI STATE CONSUMER COOPERATIVE FEDERATION LTD..... Petitioner
Through Mr.Elgin. Matt John, Adv. with Ms.Anju Bhattacharya, Adv.
DELHI STATE CONSUMER COOPERATIVE FEDERATION LTD..... Petitioner
Through Mr.Elgin. Matt John, Adv. with Ms.Anju Bhattacharya, Adv.
VERSUS
UNION OF INDIA & ANR ..... Respondents
Through Mr.Anil Panwar, CGSC with Mr.Gaurav Rohilla, Govt Pleader.
Through Mr.Anil Panwar, CGSC with Mr.Gaurav Rohilla, Govt Pleader.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANMOHAN SINGH
0/0 18.05.2016 Learned counsel appearing on behalf of respondents submits that his client is ready to appoint the sole Arbitrator within the period of six weeks from today to adjudicate the disputes between the parties. Learned counsel for the petitioner has informed that his client has no objection if the
.", arbitrator is appointed within the period ofsix weeks.
Under these circumstances, as agreed, respondents to appoint the sole arbitrator within the period of six weeks from today. As desired, the liberty c is also granted to the respondents to raise the plea of limitation before the
Arbitral Tribunal.
The petitions are disposed of.
2016:DHC:8333 Copy ofthe order be given dasti to both the parties.·
MAY 18, 2016 2016:DHC:8333
0/0 18.05.2016 Learned counsel appearing on behalf of respondents submits that his client is ready to appoint the sole Arbitrator within the period of six weeks from today to adjudicate the disputes between the parties. Learned counsel for the petitioner has informed that his client has no objection if the
.", arbitrator is appointed within the period ofsix weeks.
Under these circumstances, as agreed, respondents to appoint the sole arbitrator within the period of six weeks from today. As desired, the liberty c is also granted to the respondents to raise the plea of limitation before the
Arbitral Tribunal.
The petitions are disposed of.
2016:DHC:8333 Copy ofthe order be given dasti to both the parties.·
MAY 18, 2016 2016:DHC:8333
JUDGMENT