Full Text
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
W.P.(Cl 10126/2016 & CM No.40114/2016 ANANT AGENCY ..... Petitioner
DIVYA ENTERPRISES ..... Petitioner Venus I COMMISSIONER OF VAT & ANR. .....Resptndents
I
ENVIRO INFRA ENGINEERS PVT LTD. ..... P11t10ner
JIANNA ENTERPRISES ..... P{11:itioner
W.P.(Cl 10157/2016 & CM No.40194/2016 ANANT AGENCY ..... Petitioner
W.P.(ClI0164/2016 SANMITI CABLES PVT. LTD. ..... P~titioner
I
W.P.(Cl 10195/2016 & CM No.40290/2016 ~I DAYAL POULTRY APPLIANCES ..... P titioner
COMMISSIONER OF TRADE & TAXES & ANR...... Respqndents
I
I
! 2016:DHC:8856-DB i IY I :
I
W.P.{C1I0252/2016 & CM No.4046112016 I I I ASCO ENTERPRISES ..... Petitioner
I
W.P.{C1I0253/2016 BHARAT ENTERPRISES ..... Pe,itioner
I
:
W.P.(C1I0254/2016 & CM No.40462/2016 ! COMBINED TRADERS ..... Pe~itioner
W.P.(C1I0255/2016 & CM No.40463/2016 J RAKESH KUMAR RAJESH KUMAR ..... Pe tioner
W.P.(C1I0257/2016 & CM No.40465/2016 I KHERA OIL TRADERS ..... Pethioner
W.P.{C) 10259/2016 BHARAT ENTERPRISES ..... Petitioner e
, ! W.P.(C1I0262/2016 & CM No.40469/2016 SlYA ENTERPRISES ..... Pet*ioner
W.P.{C} 10263/2016 & CM No.40470/2016 .
MUKUND BATH PLAZA .......Petitioner I
:0
SAMVARDHAN MARKETING PVT LTD. ..... Petitioner
DIYA APPAREL ..... Pe~itioner
S.S.PACKAGING INDUSTRIES ..... Petitioner
I
SKYLINE LIGHTING PVT. LTD. ..... Pet~ioner
COMMISSIONER OF TRADE & TAXES ..... Respondent
I i
A.N. PACKAGING PVT. LTD. ..... Petitioner
A.P. POLYPLAST PVT. LTD. ..... Peti~ioner
I
L.R.SHARMA & CO. ..... Petitipner
MODERN ENGINEERING WORKS ..... Petitipner
PUNJAB FOOD MACHINERY ..... Petitioner
I
W.p.(el 10324/2016 & eM No.40605/2016 PUNJAB FOOD MACHINERY ..... Petitioner
W.p.(ell0325/2016 SPACE TELELINK LTD. ..... Petitioner
COMMISSIONER OF TRADE & TAXES ..... Res~ondent
I w.p.(e) 10332/2016 & eM No.40630/2016 1 RAJDHANI CABLE HOUSE ..... Plitioner
! W.p.(el 10333/2016 & eM No.40631/2016 i NITIN SHARMA ..... P~titioner
GANPATI PACKAGING ..... P~titioner
COMMISSIONER OF TRADE & TAXES & ANR. ..... Resp~ndents
I
Through: Mr. Vasudev Lalwani, Mr. Rohit Oautam and Mr. Sunil Aggarwal, Advocdtes for
Petitioners in Item Nos. 14 and 15. I Mr.Vineet Bhatia and Mr. Chanderl Kant
Singh, Advocates for Petitioners in Item Nos. 24, 51, 54 and 65.
Mr. Raj K. Batra and Mr. Kapil Cho~dhary, Advocates for Petitioners in Item Nps. 26, 33,39,41 and 42. :
Mr. Rajesh Jain and Mr. Virag triwari, Advocates for Petitioners in Item Nos.30
JUDGMENT
31. i Mr. Nitin Gulati, Advocate for Petitipner in I Item No. 48. Mr. Gautam Narayan, ASC in Item l'fos. 28, 31,48&49,65 and 67.: Mr. Anuj Aggarwal, ASC and I Ms. Deboshree Mukherjee, Advocate for Respondent GNCTD in Item Nos. 24, 63 and 64. I Mr. P. Roychaudhuri, ASC and I Mr. Aamir Aziz, Advocate for Res~ondent GNCTD in Item Nos. 12, 14, 16,21,129,35, 59,68 and 69. Mr. Satyakam, ASC for Restondent GNCTD in Item Nos. 26, 30, 33, 38'139, 42, 51,54 and 93. Mr. Ravi Chandhok, Mr. Prakash Aggarwal, Mr. Ranjeet Singh and Mr. Rahul! Gupta, Advocates for Bharat Enterprises in Item Nos. 29 and 35. I CORAM: HON'BLE MR.
JUSTICE S. RAVINDRA BHAT HON'BLE MR.
JUSTICE NAJMI WAZIRI ORDER % 15.11.2016 CM Nos.40114, 40161, 40167, 40194, 40290, 40461-63, 40465, 40469-72, 40479,40587,40598,40605 & 40630-31 of 2016 (for exemptions) Allowed, subject to all just exceptions. The applications are disposed off. I i • I I w.p.(e) Nos. 10126, 10136, 10138, 10143, 10157, 10164, 10195, ~0252- 55, 10257, 10259, 10262-63, 10265-66, 10272, 10298, 10300, \10310, 10316-17,10323-25,10332-34 & 10155 of2016 Pursuant to the orders of this Court, standing counsel for the Government of NCT submits that refund orders have been made.:In the ! circumstances, it is hereby directed that the amounts together with ipterest shall be remitted to the petitioners' accounts within one week. In d1ase of any discrepancy, it is open to the petitioners to move an application in that regard. The same shall be decided within one month of its receipt by the concerned VATO. The writ petitions are allowed in the above terms.
NAJMI WAZIRI, J. NOVEMBER 15,2016 sb