BHARAT ENTERPWSES v. COMMISSIONER OF TRADE & TAXES

Delhi High Court · 17 Dec 2016 · 2016:DHC:9311-DB
S. Ravindra Bhat; Najmi Waziri
W.P.(C) 10314/2016
2016:DHC:9311-DB
tax petition_allowed

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court directed the State to promptly remit tax refund amounts to petitioners and mandated expeditious disposal of disputes regarding refund correctness through applications for clarification.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
'= Ni^:P:(C) 10314/2016: . , :
BHARAT ENTERPWSES ^ ^ ^ . ......Petitioner . : Ttoough; ]^. Ravi Chandbk aMMr. Rahul Gupta^^^^
/_ '' =•'" "• V ;Advs.'-' •" • ,/• ' versus.. •. ' '
..•..Respondent .
' Through: Mr. Satyakani, Ady. ; - , •: .
.+ W.P.(C) 10572/2016, GM A^^ ".. . \ M/S,STELCO OVERSEAS iPVT LTD . , , !.,.. Petitioner
' ; '-• - Through: Mr. F'uneet Rai, Adv. • ; , versus.
/ COMMISSIONERpFTRApE&TA^S.& ANR, .,.., Respondent
.. ; / ; ^ fhrough: Mr. Gautam Narayanj ASC and
Tyer,Advs. •
' W.P:(G)lp6l^^ : ; . \ :
; M/S PA^S INDUSTRIES^; . ' y^ jPetitioner : , :/ ' / ; Through: Mr; PuheetRai,Adv. . , .
' • V-.versus/,, ^ \ A ' - .
, GOMMISSIONER OF TRADE &-TAXES, & ANR....:. Respondent
• :. . : ;/ /Through: Mr; GautamNarayan, A
^ "•...••/ . TyeryAdys.. ^
WR(G) 11358/2016,CM APPL.4^^^ \ , ; ,AMANENTERPRISES ,, . / : V V , ; V Petitioner
' . ; Through: Mr/ Raj K. Batra, Mr._Rajesh.Jain and
" Mr. Kapil Ghaudharyi.Adys. ^^.
•; ^ yersus : - • . \ •. .' ..... Respondent
. Through: Mr/^ugAggarwal, ASC, GNCTD with' / Ms. Deboslh*eeMukherjee, Ady. ' , ;WR.(C)9520/201/6 / ; . - y ;
/ .heritage I/NpiA EXPORTS PVT. LTD. ' Petitioner
^ :Advs; '
VERSUS
• ; Z'/ ^ '
GOMMISSiONER OF VALUE ADDED TAX / Respondent
/ • .. "' Through: Mr. Gautam Narayan, ASG-and
2016:DHC:9311-DB. 1 . y . ^ :.'-Iyer, Advs. • .. ' . • . 'l-', •'
.+ 'C :W:P.(Q r05t5/2016,-CM - "; ' - SUf^TENTEI^RISES'Pm^^ ; Petitioner , ; ' . Through:: Mr. Raj K,Batra, Mr/Rajesh^J^^^^
• , y ! ; Mr.KapilChaudhary,Advs. . , ' ' • .-'versus
: GONMISSIONEROp TROT fe AI^. ..... Respondent .
.' ' : , . Through: Mr Anug Aggarwal, ASC, GNCTD.with
V .Ms. Deboshree hiukherjee, Adv. " .
. ^ .• T •-
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S. RAVINDRA BHAT , ••'HGN'RLE MR.'JUStlGE.NAJM WAZIRI;,-;.-"
-V;'. 6 RD E R
: : • It. is stkted that refund order's have been made and amounts;
; received in some ,cases. . A\%ere,ver the amounts have not been
, received, the State/respondent shall ensure that the amounts,are, in fact
• > remitted to the petitioners,' account within ,a/week; Disputes' with . .
• ;respect'to the correctness of.the amounts or. interek, ifany, shall be : subjepT,'to applications for ,clarification- in .that fegkd. The
. apphcations,.4f;any, shall be'disposed off withili 30 days;of their
' ••receipt."-,^:- '!
. '; ; iThe.writ petitionkare dispo^d.offinterfiis ofthese directions. - , ]'
A A" V; J:,,;. A; S.RAVINDitA,BHATiJ
•-"A;;.,- najmiIaAziri,J
DECEMBER 17,2016/acm
\ •
2016:DHC:9311-DB
JUDGMENT