Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
'= Ni^:P:(C) 10314/2016: . , :
BHARAT ENTERPWSES ^ ^ ^ . ......Petitioner . : Ttoough; ]^. Ravi Chandbk aMMr. Rahul Gupta^^^^
/_ '' =•'" "• V ;Advs.'-' •" • ,/• ' versus.. •. ' '
..•..Respondent .
' Through: Mr. Satyakani, Ady. ; - , •: .
.+ W.P.(C) 10572/2016, GM A^^ ".. . \ M/S,STELCO OVERSEAS iPVT LTD . , , !.,.. Petitioner
' ; '-• - Through: Mr. F'uneet Rai, Adv. • ; , versus.
/ COMMISSIONERpFTRApE&TA^S.& ANR, .,.., Respondent
.. ; / ; ^ fhrough: Mr. Gautam Narayanj ASC and
Tyer,Advs. •
' W.P:(G)lp6l^^ : ; . \ :
; M/S PA^S INDUSTRIES^; . ' y^ jPetitioner : , :/ ' / ; Through: Mr; PuheetRai,Adv. . , .
' • V-.versus/,, ^ \ A ' - .
, GOMMISSIONER OF TRADE &-TAXES, & ANR....:. Respondent
• :. . : ;/ /Through: Mr; GautamNarayan, A
^ "•...••/ . TyeryAdys.. ^
'= Ni^:P:(C) 10314/2016: . , :
BHARAT ENTERPWSES ^ ^ ^ . ......Petitioner . : Ttoough; ]^. Ravi Chandbk aMMr. Rahul Gupta^^^^
/_ '' =•'" "• V ;Advs.'-' •" • ,/• ' versus.. •. ' '
..•..Respondent .
' Through: Mr. Satyakani, Ady. ; - , •: .
.+ W.P.(C) 10572/2016, GM A^^ ".. . \ M/S,STELCO OVERSEAS iPVT LTD . , , !.,.. Petitioner
' ; '-• - Through: Mr. F'uneet Rai, Adv. • ; , versus.
/ COMMISSIONERpFTRApE&TA^S.& ANR, .,.., Respondent
.. ; / ; ^ fhrough: Mr. Gautam Narayanj ASC and
Tyer,Advs. •
' W.P:(G)lp6l^^ : ; . \ :
; M/S PA^S INDUSTRIES^; . ' y^ jPetitioner : , :/ ' / ; Through: Mr; PuheetRai,Adv. . , .
' • V-.versus/,, ^ \ A ' - .
, GOMMISSIONER OF TRADE &-TAXES, & ANR....:. Respondent
• :. . : ;/ /Through: Mr; GautamNarayan, A
^ "•...••/ . TyeryAdys.. ^
WR(G) 11358/2016,CM APPL.4^^^ \ , ; ,AMANENTERPRISES ,, . / : V V , ; V Petitioner
' . ; Through: Mr/ Raj K. Batra, Mr._Rajesh.Jain and
" Mr. Kapil Ghaudharyi.Adys. ^^.
•; ^ yersus : - • . \ •. .' ..... Respondent
. Through: Mr/^ugAggarwal, ASC, GNCTD with' / Ms. Deboslh*eeMukherjee, Ady. ' , ;WR.(C)9520/201/6 / ; . - y ;
/ .heritage I/NpiA EXPORTS PVT. LTD. ' Petitioner
^ :Advs; '
' . ; Through: Mr/ Raj K. Batra, Mr._Rajesh.Jain and
" Mr. Kapil Ghaudharyi.Adys. ^^.
•; ^ yersus : - • . \ •. .' ..... Respondent
. Through: Mr/^ugAggarwal, ASC, GNCTD with' / Ms. Deboslh*eeMukherjee, Ady. ' , ;WR.(C)9520/201/6 / ; . - y ;
/ .heritage I/NpiA EXPORTS PVT. LTD. ' Petitioner
^ :Advs; '
VERSUS
• ; Z'/ ^ '
GOMMISSiONER OF VALUE ADDED TAX / Respondent
/ • .. "' Through: Mr. Gautam Narayan, ASG-and
2016:DHC:9311-DB. 1 . y . ^ :.'-Iyer, Advs. • .. ' . • . 'l-', •'
.+ 'C :W:P.(Q r05t5/2016,-CM - "; ' - SUf^TENTEI^RISES'Pm^^ ; Petitioner , ; ' . Through:: Mr. Raj K,Batra, Mr/Rajesh^J^^^^
• , y ! ; Mr.KapilChaudhary,Advs. . , ' ' • .-'versus
: GONMISSIONEROp TROT fe AI^. ..... Respondent .
.' ' : , . Through: Mr Anug Aggarwal, ASC, GNCTD.with
V .Ms. Deboshree hiukherjee, Adv. " .
. ^ .• T •-
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S. RAVINDRA BHAT , ••'HGN'RLE MR.'JUStlGE.NAJM WAZIRI;,-;.-"
-V;'. 6 RD E R
: : • It. is stkted that refund order's have been made and amounts;
; received in some ,cases. . A\%ere,ver the amounts have not been
, received, the State/respondent shall ensure that the amounts,are, in fact
• > remitted to the petitioners,' account within ,a/week; Disputes' with . .
• ;respect'to the correctness of.the amounts or. interek, ifany, shall be : subjepT,'to applications for ,clarification- in .that fegkd. The
. apphcations,.4f;any, shall be'disposed off withili 30 days;of their
' ••receipt."-,^:- '!
. '; ; iThe.writ petitionkare dispo^d.offinterfiis ofthese directions. - , ]'
A A" V; J:,,;. A; S.RAVINDitA,BHATiJ
•-"A;;.,- najmiIaAziri,J
DECEMBER 17,2016/acm
\ •
2016:DHC:9311-DB
GOMMISSiONER OF VALUE ADDED TAX / Respondent
/ • .. "' Through: Mr. Gautam Narayan, ASG-and
2016:DHC:9311-DB. 1 . y . ^ :.'-Iyer, Advs. • .. ' . • . 'l-', •'
.+ 'C :W:P.(Q r05t5/2016,-CM - "; ' - SUf^TENTEI^RISES'Pm^^ ; Petitioner , ; ' . Through:: Mr. Raj K,Batra, Mr/Rajesh^J^^^^
• , y ! ; Mr.KapilChaudhary,Advs. . , ' ' • .-'versus
: GONMISSIONEROp TROT fe AI^. ..... Respondent .
.' ' : , . Through: Mr Anug Aggarwal, ASC, GNCTD.with
V .Ms. Deboshree hiukherjee, Adv. " .
. ^ .• T •-
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S. RAVINDRA BHAT , ••'HGN'RLE MR.'JUStlGE.NAJM WAZIRI;,-;.-"
-V;'. 6 RD E R
: : • It. is stkted that refund order's have been made and amounts;
; received in some ,cases. . A\%ere,ver the amounts have not been
, received, the State/respondent shall ensure that the amounts,are, in fact
• > remitted to the petitioners,' account within ,a/week; Disputes' with . .
• ;respect'to the correctness of.the amounts or. interek, ifany, shall be : subjepT,'to applications for ,clarification- in .that fegkd. The
. apphcations,.4f;any, shall be'disposed off withili 30 days;of their
' ••receipt."-,^:- '!
. '; ; iThe.writ petitionkare dispo^d.offinterfiis ofthese directions. - , ]'
A A" V; J:,,;. A; S.RAVINDitA,BHATiJ
•-"A;;.,- najmiIaAziri,J
DECEMBER 17,2016/acm
\ •
2016:DHC:9311-DB
JUDGMENT