Full Text
Translation output
■} >
* IN THE HIGH GOURT DELHI At NEW DELHI
:Wj»,(G);m5/2oi7 .
•'-+ . .;w.p.(e)1742/26.17 • ^:; .. , , .
■ W.P.(C) 1244/201.7
:■ .MOHANXAL .
ARUN-'SiN.GH: ^
'^XHOTTEBLAL.-;
-^.'....Petitioner petitioner .....petitioner. thfoUgii:.Mr;' Dharmender Sharma, Advocate for, petitioners:;L - > : , X . ■ 1
-
* IN THE HIGH GOURT DELHI At NEW DELHI
:Wj»,(G);m5/2oi7 .
•'-+ . .;w.p.(e)1742/26.17 • ^:; .. , , .
■ W.P.(C) 1244/201.7
:■ .MOHANXAL .
ARUN-'SiN.GH: ^
'^XHOTTEBLAL.-;
-^.'....Petitioner petitioner .....petitioner. thfoUgii:.Mr;' Dharmender Sharma, Advocate for, petitioners:;L - > : , X . ■ 1
-
VERSUS
> /«f-
'1-
• J
'-..... Respondent ' -
' ,v , ■ 2 :Through:.1^ jMananjay Mishra, Advocate^ and;
: X \ Ms..:Vidhi. Jain,.'Advocate for Mr; ' Sri .Harsha
. .. ■ ' ■ Pedcfe^ - " .
?:/^"2"-''GbRAM:- - .X' y',: /p;., ■''■■;X-; ' ;.x;,- - ; -X'-,^
: HON'BLEMR.JUSTiGlE G.S.^^
HON'BLEMR.Jt^TICE \HN^ X : X x: ORDER 1/';" . ■ ' "X ' X- ,. • ' .' '.. ^^xX v/' -V, ' x x'. x"/ " ";:X
GM^PI^ 7762-7763/2012(Exekptjonl X / .. 1X
GM.APPL 7782-7783/2017 (Exemptibny x X ^ '
GM.APPL 7785r7786/2017 (jExembtionJ ^ x 2
"V." .
N • The'dppiieatiqn stands disposed'of,'.-\
; W.P.(G) 1742/2017 & GMNo. 7784/2017 (stay)
1.- MohanXal. Ill front of.Shop No. E-18,-Wintage-Shop, Inner
■Gifcle, GOnnaughf Plade^ hew Del^^ :
2017:DHC:9023-DB
A
- • r. •
'Arun Singh .Near -Shop No. 10, F-Block,' Inrier, Circle, -ConnaughtPlace,"new-Delhi. .
3."- .
■ ... ), 1 ' '• '
ChptteLal
I f
■ Opp. of Shop No.:1B, Marshal Holise, Behind
Regal' Bhilding,, Near Ajlahabad. Bank;
ConnaughtPlace,new Dplhi. , f .
'-V ' on the ground that the sites in-question'are'No Hawking/No Vending Zones'.,The petitioners
/pray'that till d final decision is'taken4h the;matter by the Town Vending
-Comnlittee as an interirn measurethey should be relocated so thattherets no
, .loss oflivelihood. ■ :
."-;
'Learned .counsel for- the NDIvlC, without admitting the averments made-in the writ petitioris, subniits;that the vendors-were renidyed as the
■ . sites;ih question hre'No.Hawjtiilg/No"Vendihg-rZxmes',The;ND.MC^is'nqt
,;:ail6wing any hawkerto ve at the;''No Hawking/No Vending Zohek'
■ ■ except those vendors who hpldviicehces are allowed to vend;,'Counsel
.subrhitsThat no,supporting documents^in the cas,e ofsome ofthe vendors
V ofwith thefollowing agreed directions
(i)^ The cases
.A'-
(ii) :'Metel^ because the petitionefS'afe not'fourid Vending when the^ i /' surveyis conducted^ Wduld ndtbe a groMd aloneto reje^their
;, case, m-case iii)' As an"interim measure; the^ petitioners -would: be"granted. alternate"sites'within six weeks from the date ofreceipt ofthis:, , ■ )■•
I order subject to the petitioners filing supporting-documents in ^ their favour..
We make it clear that we have not expressed any opinion on the merits-ofthe matters. ^ , All petitions are disposed of. .
OrdQn dasti.
G.S.SISTANI,J
VINODGOEL,J
FEBRUARY 27,2017 .
"sk"
C%J
'1-
• J
'-..... Respondent ' -
' ,v , ■ 2 :Through:.1^ jMananjay Mishra, Advocate^ and;
: X \ Ms..:Vidhi. Jain,.'Advocate for Mr; ' Sri .Harsha
. .. ■ ' ■ Pedcfe^ - " .
?:/^"2"-''GbRAM:- - .X' y',: /p;., ■''■■;X-; ' ;.x;,- - ; -X'-,^
: HON'BLEMR.JUSTiGlE G.S.^^
HON'BLEMR.Jt^TICE \HN^ X : X x: ORDER 1/';" . ■ ' "X ' X- ,. • ' .' '.. ^^xX v/' -V, ' x x'. x"/ " ";:X
GM^PI^ 7762-7763/2012(Exekptjonl X / .. 1X
GM.APPL 7782-7783/2017 (Exemptibny x X ^ '
GM.APPL 7785r7786/2017 (jExembtionJ ^ x 2
"V." .
N • The'dppiieatiqn stands disposed'of,'.-\
; W.P.(G) 1742/2017 & GMNo. 7784/2017 (stay)
1.- MohanXal. Ill front of.Shop No. E-18,-Wintage-Shop, Inner
■Gifcle, GOnnaughf Plade^ hew Del^^ :
2017:DHC:9023-DB
A
- • r. •
'Arun Singh .Near -Shop No. 10, F-Block,' Inrier, Circle, -ConnaughtPlace,"new-Delhi. .
3."- .
■ ... ), 1 ' '• '
ChptteLal
I f
■ Opp. of Shop No.:1B, Marshal Holise, Behind
Regal' Bhilding,, Near Ajlahabad. Bank;
ConnaughtPlace,new Dplhi. , f .
'-V ' on the ground that the sites in-question'are'No Hawking/No Vending Zones'.,The petitioners
/pray'that till d final decision is'taken4h the;matter by the Town Vending
-Comnlittee as an interirn measurethey should be relocated so thattherets no
, .loss oflivelihood. ■ :
."-;
'Learned .counsel for- the NDIvlC, without admitting the averments made-in the writ petitioris, subniits;that the vendors-were renidyed as the
■ . sites;ih question hre'No.Hawjtiilg/No"Vendihg-rZxmes',The;ND.MC^is'nqt
,;:ail6wing any hawkerto ve at the;''No Hawking/No Vending Zohek'
■ ■ except those vendors who hpldviicehces are allowed to vend;,'Counsel
.subrhitsThat no,supporting documents^in the cas,e ofsome ofthe vendors
V ofwith thefollowing agreed directions
(i)^ The cases
.A'-
(ii) :'Metel^ because the petitionefS'afe not'fourid Vending when the^ i /' surveyis conducted^ Wduld ndtbe a groMd aloneto reje^their
;, case, m-case iii)' As an"interim measure; the^ petitioners -would: be"granted. alternate"sites'within six weeks from the date ofreceipt ofthis:, , ■ )■•
I order subject to the petitioners filing supporting-documents in ^ their favour..
We make it clear that we have not expressed any opinion on the merits-ofthe matters. ^ , All petitions are disposed of. .
OrdQn dasti.
G.S.SISTANI,J
VINODGOEL,J
FEBRUARY 27,2017 .
"sk"
C%J
JUDGMENT