M.V. Enterprises v. National Insurance Co. Ltd.

Delhi High Court · 24 Jul 2018 · 2018:DHC:9279

Rajiv Shakdher

OMP(ENF.)(COMM.)111/2018

2018:DHC:9279

civil appeal_allowed

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court allowed withdrawal of a Section 34 petition challenging an arbitral award, granting liberty to recover money if CBI investigations lead to conviction or adverse findings, and ordered release of deposited funds to the awardee.

Full Text

p $-29& 33 HIGH COURT OF DELHI OMP(ENF.)
(COMM.)111/2018 M.V.ENTERPRISES Petitioner
Through: Mr. Sameer Nandwani with Mr. Junaidullah and Ms. Smritee Relhan, Advs.

VERSUS

NATIONALINSURANCE CO.LTD Respondent
Through: Mr.Madan Gera,Adv. / O.M.P.(COMM)330/2017&I.A.No.10138/2017,7254/2018
NATIONAL INSURANCE CO LTD Petitioner
Through: Mr.Madan Gera,Adv.

VERSUS

M V ENTERPRISES Respondent
Through: Mr. Sameer Nandwani with Mr. Junaidullah and Ms. Smritee Relhan, Advs.

CORAM:

HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE RAJIV SHAKDHER
24.07.2018

ORDER

1.. Mr. Gera, who, appears for the petitioner in OMP (COMM) No.330/2017 i.e.. National Insurance Co. Ltd., says that he has received instructions to withdraw the said petition filed under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996(hereafter referred to as'1996 Act'), albeit, with a caveat. The caveat being that since,the Central Bureau of OMP(ENF.)(COMM.)111/2018& O.M.P.(COMM)330/2017 Pg.l of[3] 2018:DHC:9279 c Investigation (CBI), is presently carrying on investigations qua M.V. Enterprises, and those investigations may culminate in a conviction or adverse findings then, in such an eventuality National Insurance Co. Ltd. should have liberty to recover the money paid to M.V.Enterprises under the award in a manner known to law.

2. Mr.Nandwani,who,appears for M.V.Enterprises,says that he has no instructions as to whether or not any investigations are being carried on visa-vis his client. 2.[1] Furthermore, Mr. Nandwani says that if any action is instituted by National Insurance Co.Ltd.to seek recovery ofmoney that may be released in favour of M.V. Enterprises pursuant to the award dated 5.4.2017, M.V. Enterprises should have the liberty to defend the same in accordance with law.

3. Given the submissions advanced before me,in these circurnstances,as prayed for by Mr. Gera,OMP(COMM)No.330/2017 shall stand dismissed as withdrawn,subjectto NationalInsurance Co.Ltd.having liberty to file an action to recover the amount paid to M.V.Enterprises,ifinvestigations said to be carried on by the CBI lead to the conviction ofthe accused or return of adverse findings by a competent court. The liberty given will be subject to the right ofM.V.Enterprises to set up every defence that may be available to it in law.

4. Consequently, the money deposited by National Insurance Co. Ltd., pursuant to the order dated 8.5.2018, passed in OMP (ENF.)(COMM.) No.111/2018, will be released by the Registry along with accrued interest, within a period ofone week from today. OMP(ENF.)(COMM.)111/2018& O.M.P.(COMM)330/2017 Pg.2of[3]

5. The captioned matters are disposed ofin terms ofthe aforementioned directions.

6. Pending applications shall stand closed.

7. Dasti. C N RAJIV SHAKDHER,J JULY 24,2018/pmc OMP(ENF.)(COMM.)111/2018& O.M.P.(COMM)330/2017. Pg.3of[3]

M.V. Enterprises v. National Insurance Co. Ltd.

AI Summary

Full Text

ORDER

Contact Us for a Free Consultation