Full Text
Translation output
s HIGH COURT OF DELHI
Reservedon 22"'' May.2018 ' Date ofdecision:\4"' Ausust.2018
.. W.P.(C)No. 12088/2016.& CM'Nos.9316, 10386,,,1467,8/2017 ; W.P.(C)
2658/2017 & CM No.l1560/2017; W.P.(C) 3360/2017 & CM No.14703/2017;
Reservedon 22"'' May.2018 ' Date ofdecision:\4"' Ausust.2018
.. W.P.(C)No. 12088/2016.& CM'Nos.9316, 10386,,,1467,8/2017 ; W.P.(C)
2658/2017 & CM No.l1560/2017; W.P.(C) 3360/2017 & CM No.14703/2017;
W.P.(C) 3385/2017 & CM No.l4800/2017;: W.P.(C) •3684/2617 •& CM
No.16236/2017; W.P.(C>3792/2017 & CM No.16681/2017; W.P.(C)3987/2017 &
CMNo.l7543/2017;.W.P.(C).4007/2017& CIVl No.17632/2017; W.P.(C)4080/2017
& CM -Nos.17912, 20168/2017; W.P.(C).4102/2017 & CM No.1,7996 /2017;
No.16236/2017; W.P.(C>3792/2017 & CM No.16681/2017; W.P.(C)3987/2017 &
CMNo.l7543/2017;.W.P.(C).4007/2017& CIVl No.17632/2017; W.P.(C)4080/2017
& CM -Nos.17912, 20168/2017; W.P.(C).4102/2017 & CM No.1,7996 /2017;
W.P.(C) 4103/2017 & CM' No.17998/201.7; W.P.(C)- 4106/2017 & CM
No.18004/2017; W.P.(C)4446/2017 & CM No.19413/2017; W:P.(C)4493/2017 &
CM No.19640/2017; W.P.(C)'4867/20ll&''CM No.210.93/2017; W.P.(C)4934/2017
& CM No.21336/2017; W;P;(C):>'^4998/2017 -& CM No.21608/20.17;;W.P.(C)
5013/2017 & CM-.140.21650/2017; ^ W.P.(e^''5026/2017 & CM No.21663/2017;
No.18004/2017; W.P.(C)4446/2017 & CM No.19413/2017; W:P.(C)4493/2017 &
CM No.19640/2017; W.P.(C)'4867/20ll&''CM No.210.93/2017; W.P.(C)4934/2017
& CM No.21336/2017; W;P;(C):>'^4998/2017 -& CM No.21608/20.17;;W.P.(C)
5013/2017 & CM-.140.21650/2017; ^ W.P.(e^''5026/2017 & CM No.21663/2017;
W.P.(C) 5199/2017 & CM .:N'o.22r37/20"l7^^ 5200/2017' & CM
No.22139/2017;,W.P.(C).5214/26;i7.:&,.CM:;Nq W.P.(C)5217/2017 &
CM No.22172/2017; WT.(C>521'8Ml7...(gvMMo;m73/20l7;W.P.(C),5753/2017
& CM No.23956/2617; ■\^S;(C)''-;5.7#2bl7;r^ 5933/2017 & CM
No.24668/2017;. W.P.(C) 6078/2m7;#.CM.^'K^^^ W.P;(C) 6155/2017 &
CMNo.25609/2017; W.P.(C).6794/2o'lf. &;CM;No.28326/2017; W;P:(C) 6815/2017
& .CM; No.28372/2017; W-.P.(C).3;6S3iy26l7:^7CM W.P.(C)
6990/2017 & CM No.28997/201.7; ,W.P.,(G) ,7012^^ & CM No;29106/2017;
No.22139/2017;,W.P.(C).5214/26;i7.:&,.CM:;Nq W.P.(C)5217/2017 &
CM No.22172/2017; WT.(C>521'8Ml7...(gvMMo;m73/20l7;W.P.(C),5753/2017
& CM No.23956/2617; ■\^S;(C)''-;5.7#2bl7;r^ 5933/2017 & CM
No.24668/2017;. W.P.(C) 6078/2m7;#.CM.^'K^^^ W.P;(C) 6155/2017 &
CMNo.25609/2017; W.P.(C).6794/2o'lf. &;CM;No.28326/2017; W;P:(C) 6815/2017
& .CM; No.28372/2017; W-.P.(C).3;6S3iy26l7:^7CM W.P.(C)
6990/2017 & CM No.28997/201.7; ,W.P.,(G) ,7012^^ & CM No;29106/2017;
W.P.(C) 7141/2017;,W.P.(C) 7495/2017 CM<Nop0926/2017; W.P.(C) 7760/2017
& CM No.32053/2017; .W.P.(C)i.8229/20iS:i^V:CM No.33833/2017; " W.P.(C)
8622/2017 & CM Nd.35424/20l7;V#P(d)l4-(5;^^^ &. CM.No:37207/2017;
W.P.(C)No.9187/2017 & Ciyf"N6;37^6/26|7t •|W:.P.(^^ & CM
No.37681/2017 & W.P.(C)No.9446/20lSfcl#teM^^^
For the petitioners :7 . 7V J' Mr. S.K. Duhey and Mr. Rajmdngal Kumar, Advs. for the petitioner in W.P (C) nos.12088/2016, 4493/2017,:499m017, ; .;>q
Mr. Bhuvnesh Sehgal and Mr. Ariubhdv -Bhasin/iALdvs£m W.P (C) nos.2658/2017, 4446/2017 ' "
Mr. Dhruv Mehta, Sr. Adv. with Mr. Vipin Singhania, Adv. forpetitioner in W.P (C) no.3360/2017
Mr. Vaibhav Arora, Adv.for thepetitioners in W.P (C) no.4607/2017
Mr. Sandeep Vishnu and Mr. Anil Kr. Gupta, Advs. for petitioners in W.P ( C) no.4080/2017.
Mr. Ankit Jain, Adv. with Mr. Sarvesh Rai, Adv. for the.petitioner in W.P (C) nos.4102/2017, 4103/2017, 4106/2017
Mr. Dhruv Mehta,. Sr. Adv. with Mr. Vikas Dutta, Mr. Siddharth Silwal and Ms
PriyankaNayyar, Advs.for thepetitioner in W.P (C) no.4867/2017
Mr. Puneet Saini andMr. KapilHans, Advs.forpetitioner in:W.P.(C)No. 4934/2017,.
Mr. Harvinder Singh, Mr. K.K. Mukhija, Mr. Sandeep Sharma, Mr. S.C. Dhingra, Ms. Reeta Yagnik and Ms. Deepti Singh Sodhi, Advs. for petitioners in
& CM No.32053/2017; .W.P.(C)i.8229/20iS:i^V:CM No.33833/2017; " W.P.(C)
8622/2017 & CM Nd.35424/20l7;V#P(d)l4-(5;^^^ &. CM.No:37207/2017;
W.P.(C)No.9187/2017 & Ciyf"N6;37^6/26|7t •|W:.P.(^^ & CM
No.37681/2017 & W.P.(C)No.9446/20lSfcl#teM^^^
For the petitioners :7 . 7V J' Mr. S.K. Duhey and Mr. Rajmdngal Kumar, Advs. for the petitioner in W.P (C) nos.12088/2016, 4493/2017,:499m017, ; .;>q
Mr. Bhuvnesh Sehgal and Mr. Ariubhdv -Bhasin/iALdvs£m W.P (C) nos.2658/2017, 4446/2017 ' "
Mr. Dhruv Mehta, Sr. Adv. with Mr. Vipin Singhania, Adv. forpetitioner in W.P (C) no.3360/2017
Mr. Vaibhav Arora, Adv.for thepetitioners in W.P (C) no.4607/2017
Mr. Sandeep Vishnu and Mr. Anil Kr. Gupta, Advs. for petitioners in W.P ( C) no.4080/2017.
Mr. Ankit Jain, Adv. with Mr. Sarvesh Rai, Adv. for the.petitioner in W.P (C) nos.4102/2017, 4103/2017, 4106/2017
Mr. Dhruv Mehta,. Sr. Adv. with Mr. Vikas Dutta, Mr. Siddharth Silwal and Ms
PriyankaNayyar, Advs.for thepetitioner in W.P (C) no.4867/2017
Mr. Puneet Saini andMr. KapilHans, Advs.forpetitioner in:W.P.(C)No. 4934/2017,.
Mr. Harvinder Singh, Mr. K.K. Mukhija, Mr. Sandeep Sharma, Mr. S.C. Dhingra, Ms. Reeta Yagnik and Ms. Deepti Singh Sodhi, Advs. for petitioners in
WP(C) 5217/2017& connectedmatters Page1of2
2018:DHC:8547-DB W.P.(C)Nos.5013/2017, 5026/2017, 5199/2017, 5200/2017, 5214/2017, 5217/2017, 5218/2017and5253/2017.
Mr. Neeraj Malhotra Sr. Adv. with Mr. Arijit Mazumdar, Adv. in
W.P.(C)Nos.5217/2017,5218/2017,5753/2017,5779/2017and25247/2017.
Mr.AshokAgarwalandMs.SlomitaRai,Advs.forpetitionerin W.P.(C)5779/2017.
Mr.RishiAgrawalaandMs.Niyati.Kohli,Advs.forpetitioner in W.P.(C)6155/2017.
Mr. VivekKishore,Adv.forthepetitioner in W.P.(C)6794/2017.
Ms.FarehaAhmadKhan,Adv.forpetitioner in W.P.fC)6815/2017
Mr.AmitSeth,Adv.forpetitioner in W.P.fC)6990/2017
Mr.AlokBhasin andMs.Poonam Das,Advs.forpetitioner in W.P.
(C)Nos.6841/2017 and 7012/2017 Mr. Vikram Dhokalia and Mr. Sahil Bakshi, Advs. for petitioner in W.P.fC)
7141/2017.
Mr.ManuBera,Adv.forpetitioner in W^P.fC)7495/2017.
For the Respondents Mr. Ramesh Singh, ^Standing Comsek withfMr. Sandeepan Pathdk, Adv. for respondentsin W.PffC)6155/2:017)^^f [ff//f
Mr.Sanjay Ghose ASCfor GNCTif.;with/MEyRishahh^^M^^ and MsrUrviMohan, Advs. inW.PfC)nos.I2088/2m6V^658/20^^M/2dl7,-3684/201774080/2017, 4102/2017, 4934/2017, 4998/20i^xf0imojMi51^017, 5200/2017, 5214/2017, 5217/2017, 5218/2017,5779/2Ol7f25^^2^r0^/2O17,6815/2017, 6841/2017, 6990/2017,7012/2017,7141/2O17^05/2m000bl7.
Mr.Santosh Kumar Tripathi,ASCfbr'^NCTB in'^iP.fC)Nos.4446/2017,4867/2017 and5753/2017 ' j/.§Wfi'^ '
Mr. Devesh Singh, ASC fCivil)(GNCfD fpyith^Ms. Neelam Kholiya, Adv. for respondentno.1 in W.P.fC)5026^017/7/!%
Mr.SiddharthDutta,Adv.forreipoifd&fitflhW^^ 7
2018:DHC:8547-DB W.P.(C)Nos.5013/2017, 5026/2017, 5199/2017, 5200/2017, 5214/2017, 5217/2017, 5218/2017and5253/2017.
Mr. Neeraj Malhotra Sr. Adv. with Mr. Arijit Mazumdar, Adv. in
W.P.(C)Nos.5217/2017,5218/2017,5753/2017,5779/2017and25247/2017.
Mr.AshokAgarwalandMs.SlomitaRai,Advs.forpetitionerin W.P.(C)5779/2017.
Mr.RishiAgrawalaandMs.Niyati.Kohli,Advs.forpetitioner in W.P.(C)6155/2017.
Mr. VivekKishore,Adv.forthepetitioner in W.P.(C)6794/2017.
Ms.FarehaAhmadKhan,Adv.forpetitioner in W.P.fC)6815/2017
Mr.AmitSeth,Adv.forpetitioner in W.P.fC)6990/2017
Mr.AlokBhasin andMs.Poonam Das,Advs.forpetitioner in W.P.
(C)Nos.6841/2017 and 7012/2017 Mr. Vikram Dhokalia and Mr. Sahil Bakshi, Advs. for petitioner in W.P.fC)
7141/2017.
Mr.ManuBera,Adv.forpetitioner in W^P.fC)7495/2017.
For the Respondents Mr. Ramesh Singh, ^Standing Comsek withfMr. Sandeepan Pathdk, Adv. for respondentsin W.PffC)6155/2:017)^^f [ff//f
Mr.Sanjay Ghose ASCfor GNCTif.;with/MEyRishahh^^M^^ and MsrUrviMohan, Advs. inW.PfC)nos.I2088/2m6V^658/20^^M/2dl7,-3684/201774080/2017, 4102/2017, 4934/2017, 4998/20i^xf0imojMi51^017, 5200/2017, 5214/2017, 5217/2017, 5218/2017,5779/2Ol7f25^^2^r0^/2O17,6815/2017, 6841/2017, 6990/2017,7012/2017,7141/2O17^05/2m000bl7.
Mr.Santosh Kumar Tripathi,ASCfbr'^NCTB in'^iP.fC)Nos.4446/2017,4867/2017 and5753/2017 ' j/.§Wfi'^ '
Mr. Devesh Singh, ASC fCivil)(GNCfD fpyith^Ms. Neelam Kholiya, Adv. for respondentno.1 in W.P.fC)5026^017/7/!%
Mr.SiddharthDutta,Adv.forreipoifd&fitflhW^^ 7
CORAM:, HON'BLE THE Acxmce|i|EF5ES^icrE
HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE C.HARISHaSjKAR....
JUDGMENT
.
GITA MITTAL.ACTING ChAfIiUSTICE "" Forjudgment,see W.P.(C)No.8125/2016.
ACT G chbefuustiSe C.nARIS AUGUST 04,2018/aj WPfC)5217/2017& connected matters Page2of2
2018:DHC:8547-DB
GITA MITTAL.ACTING ChAfIiUSTICE "" Forjudgment,see W.P.(C)No.8125/2016.
ACT G chbefuustiSe C.nARIS AUGUST 04,2018/aj WPfC)5217/2017& connected matters Page2of2
2018:DHC:8547-DB