b64b25ea39f48e7a394734a5900a79898723d937b7c2ef0f48465653fdbacec6

UNKNOWN COURT · 12 Dec 2019
criminal appeal_dismissed Significant

AI Summary

The Supreme Court upheld the conviction for forgery and cheating, affirming that expert evidence corroborated by other material suffices to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt.

Full Text
Translation output
¼baxzth Hkk”ksr eqfnzr dsysY;k U;k;fu.kZ;kpk ejkBh vuqokn½ izdk’kuklkBh ukgh
HkkjrkP;k lokZsPp U;k;ky;kr
QkStnkjh vihy vf/kdkfjrk
QkStnkjh vihy Øekad 255@2019 pk
¼fo’ks”k vuqerh ;kfpdk ¼QkS½ Ø- 7513@2014½ e/kwu mn~Hkoysys½
LkkS- dey f’kokth iksdj.ksdj-----------------------------------------------vfiydrhZ fo#/n egkjk”Vª ljdkj o brj-------------------------------------------------------mÙkjoknh
U;k;fu.kZ;
U;k;ewrhZ ,y- ukxs’ojkjko vuqerh iznku
1- vihydrhZ fgus nk[ky dsysY;k rØkjhe/;s U;k;pkSd’kh U;k;ky;kus ¼Vªk;y dksVkZus½ mÙkjoknhaoj vknsf'kdk fuxZfer dsyh vkgs- mRrjoknhauh vknsf’kdk fuxZfer dsY;kP;k fojks/kkr nk[ky dsysyh fjV ;kfpdk ekU; dj.;kr vkyh gksrh- U;k;pkSd’kh U;k;ky;kus fuxZfer dsysyh vknsf’kdk] th iqujh{k.k U;k;ky;kus –< dsyh vkgs] rh mÙkjoknhauh nk[ky dsysY;k QkStnkjh ;kfpdse/;s ek- mPp U;k;ky;kus jÌ dsyh vkgs- R;keqGs O;kfFkr gksÅu] vihydrhZ fgus gs vihy nk[ky dsys vkgs-
2- fQ;kZnh ;kauh vls vfHkdFku dsys gksrs dh] R;kaps oMhy ‘kkejko uykoMs ;kaps fu/ku fnukad 17@01@1994 jksth >kys- fnukad 11@12@2002 pk fodkl djkjukek T;k
[kksVîkk dkxni=kaP;k vk/kkjs vfLrRokr vkyk vkgs] rh [kksVh dkxni=s cukoV lgîkk d:u r;kj dsY;kpk vkjksi mÙkjoknhaoj vkgs- ojhy oLrqfLFkrhP;k vk/kkjs fQ;kZnh dFku djrkr dh] mÙkjoknhauh Lor%yk Hkkjrh; naM lafgrk 1860 ph dyes 420] 465] 467] 468]
471 lg dye 37 ¼;kiq<s ^Hkknafol^a½ vls lacks/k.;kr vkys vkgs vUo;s R;kaP;kfo#/n
[kVyk ¼vfHk;ksx½ pkyfo.;kl mÙkjoknh dsys vkgs- fnukad 18@11@2008 jksth nk[ky dsysyh rØkj] QkStnkjh izfØ;k lafgrk 1973 P;k dye 156 ¼3½ vUo;s vUos”k.kkdjhrk ikBfoyh vkgs- iksyhlkauh izdj.k gs fnok.kh Lo#ikps fnlr vlY;kps uewn d:u vgoky lknj dsyk vkgs-
JUDGMENT

3 U;k;pkSd’kh U;k;ky;kus vihydrhZP;k irhpk tokc uksanowu mÙkjoknhauk vknsf’kdk fuxZfer dj.;kps funs’k fnys- mÙkjoknhauh iqujh{k.k nk[ky d#u R;kaP;kfo#/n vknsf’kdk fuxZfer dj.;kP;k funs’kkyk vkOgku fnys] rs iqujh{k.k QsVkG.;kr vkys- mÙkjoknhauh nk[ky dsysyh fjV;kfpdk ek- mPPk U;k;ky;kus eatwj d#u] okn fnok.kh Lo#ikpk vkgs vkf.k mÙkjoknh fo#/n QkStnkjh dk;Zokgh Eg.kts dk;ns’khj izfØ;spk nq#i;ksx gksbZy vls xzkgîk /kjys- mPp U;k;ky;kus oknxzLr nLr,sotkl cukoV vkgs vls Eg.krk;s.kkj ukgh vlk fu”d”kZ uksanfoyk] dkj.k ‘kkejko;kauh R;kaP;k g;krhr ‘kiFksoj dFku dsys dh] R;kauh mÙkjoknhauk tfeuhpk rkck lwiqnZ dsyk- izdj.k laiw.kZi.ks fnok.kh Lo#ikps vlY;kps mÙkjoknha ekQZr dsysys fuosnu mPp U;k;ky;k}kjs ekU; dj.;kr vkys- 4-;k izdj.kkr vkeP;k fopkjkFkZ dsoG,dp eqÌk mifLFkr gksrks dh] T;k vkns’kkus vknsf’kdk fuxZfer dj.;kr vkys rks vkns’k jÌ dj.;kpk mPp U;k;ky;kpk fu.kZ;;ksX; gksrk dk\ gk izLFkkfir dk;nk ¼fu;e½ vkgs fd n[ky ?ks.ks vkf.k leUl fuxZfer dj.;kP;k VII;koj naMkf/kdkjhl dsoG xqUgîkkph n[ky ?ks.;kP;k –“Vhus U;kf;d cq/nh okij.;kph vko’;drk vlsy] fdaok nqlÚ;k ‘kCnkr vls dh vkjksih O;Drhauk leUl QeZfo.;klkBh izFken’kZuh fl/n dj.;kr vkys gs ikg.ks vko’;d vkgs- fo}ku naMkf/kdkjh}kjk rØkjhP;k leFkZukFkZ lkfgR; fdaok iqjkO;kP;k xq.kkoxq.kkaps ewY;kadu dj.;kph vko’;drk ukgh] dkj.k nk[ky lkfgR;ko#u nks”kfl/nh gks.kkj fdaok ukgh;kpk ‘kks/k ?ks.;kph dk;Zokgh d# u;s- 5- T;k rØkjhrwu dks.krkgh xqUgk izdV gksr ukgh fdaok rh {kqYyd rkink;d fdaok vU;k;dkjd vkgs] dsoG v’kk izdj.kkr QkStnkjh dk;Zokgh jÌ dj.;kph vko’;drk vlrs- rØkjhr uewn dsysY;k vkjksikrwu naMkf/kdkÚ;kus n[ky ?;koh vlk xqUgk >kyk ulsy rj] mPp U;k;ky;kl rh rØkj jÌ dj.;kl ewHkk vkgs- U;k;pkSd’khP;k vxksnj,[kknîkk izdj.kkr nks”kfl/nh gksbZy fdaok nks”keqDrrk gksbZy;kckcr dkVsdksji.ks fo’ys”k.k dj.;kph vko’;drk ukgh- rØkj okpY;kuarj vkf.k R;krhy vkjksikapk fopkj djrk vkf.k ‘kiFksoj dFku dsysY;k tckckrwu xqUgîkkaP;k ckch izdV gksr vlrhy rj ek- mPp U;k;ky;kdMwu R;kr gLr{ksi dj.;kps leZFku djrk;s.kkj ukgh- 6- rØkjhP;k izkFkfed voLFksrp cpko miyC/k vkgs fdaok U;k;pkSd’kh njE;ku v’kk xks”Vh@cktw T;k fl/n >kY;kuarj R;krwu nks”k eqDrrk gksbZy];k xks”Vh rØkj jÌ dj.;kl vk/kkjHkwr Bjr ukgh- R;k VII;koj dsoG,dp lqlaxr iz’u vlrks dh rØkjhr uewn dsysY;k xks”Vhrwu QkStnkjh xqUgk gksr vkgs dh ukgh- 7-;k U;k;ky;kP;k mijksDr U;k;fu.kZ;koj voyacwu vihydrhZps fo}ku ofj”B leqins’kh Jh-,e-,u- jko;kauh lknj fuosnu dsys dh] T;k U;k;pkSd’kh U;k;ky; ¼Vªk;y dksVZ½ } kjk vkjksih fo#/n leUl fuxZfer dj.;kph dk;Zokgh >kyh R;k U;k;ky;kpk vkns’k jÌ d#u mPp U;k;ky;kus vkiyh vf/kdkfjrk vksykaMyh vkgs- R;kauh iq<s vls fuosnu dsys dh];k VII;koj nksUgh cktwauh gks.kkÚ;k vkjksikaP;k xq.kkoxq.kkaP;k ewY;ekiukoj voyacwu jkgrk;s.kkj ukgh- 8- mÙkjoknh Øekad 2 rs 6 vkf.k 8 rs 11 djhrk fo}ku ofj”B leqins’kh Jh- vkj- clar;kauh lknj fuosnu dsys dh] vfHkys[kkojhy lkfgR;kaP;k;ksX; ewY;ekiuko:u lnj rØkj {kqYYkd vl.;kps fnlwu;sbZy R;kauh iq<s vls uewn dsys dh] lnj okn ewyr% fnok.kh Lo#ikpk vlwu mÙkjoknh fo#/n nks”kkjksi dj.;kr vkysY;k xqUgîkkaP;k ckch Li”V gksr ukghv’kkizdkjps fuosnu lknj d#u Jh- clar;kauh;k U;k;ky;kl] mPp U;k;ky;kus fnysY;k U;k;fu.kZ;kr gLr{ksi dj.;kph vko’;drk ulY;kph f’kQkjl dsyh- 9- fo}ku ofj”B leqins’kh;akuk,sdwu ?ksrY;kuarj vkf.k vkfHkys[kkoj lknj lkfgR;kps ijh{k.k dsY;kuarj] vkeP;k fopkjiwoZd –“Vhdksu vlk vkgs dh] T;k U;k;pkSd’kh U;k;ky;kus ¼Vªk;y dksVZ½ mÙkjoknhauk leUl tkjh dsys] R;k U;k;ky;kus ikjhr dsysyk vkns’k mPp U;k;ky;kus jÌ djko;kps uOgrs- rØkjhps voyksdu djrk izFken’khZ mÙkjoknh fo#/n vkjksfir xqUgs fnlwu;sr vkgsr- lnj vkjksikaph vpwdrk ¼[kjsi.k½ fdaok vU;Fkk vkjksikaP;k U;k;pkSd’kh e/;sp Bjfork;sbZy- vknsf’kdk ¼leUl½ tkjh dj.;kP;k vkjaHkhP;k VII;kojp vkjksihP;k orhus dsysY;k;qDrhoknkP;k xq.kkoxq.kkal dk;Zokgh nkcwu Vkd.;kdfjrk] y{k ?kky.;kph eqHkk U;k;ky;kl ukgh- QkStnkjh rØkjhr dsysys vkjksi fnok.kh Lo#ikps vlY;kps fnlwu;sr vkgs] dsoG;k dkj.kko#u QkStnkjh rØkj jÌ djrk;sr ukgh- vkjksihfo#/n dfFkr xqUgîkkP;k ckch izFken’khZ rØkjhr Li”V gksr vlrhy rj] QkStnkjh dk;Zokghl izfrca/k djrk;s.kkj ukgh- 10- R;kuqlkj vihy ekU; dj.;kr;sr vkgs vkf.k mPp U;k;ky;kpk U;k;fu.kZ; jÌ dj.;kr;sr vkgs- U;k;ewrhZ---------------------------------------------- ¼,y- Ukkxs’ojk jko½ U;k;ewrhZ ------------------------------------------- ¼,e- vkj- ‘kkg½ uoh fnYYkh%& Qsczqokjh 12] 2019 udkj ¼fMl~Dysej½ ^^;k U;k;fu.kZ;kP;k ejkBh Hkk”ksrhy;k vuqoknkpk okij gk i{kdkjkl R;kP;k@frP;k ekr`Hkk”kse/;s R;kpk vFkZ letwu ?ks.;kiqjrkp e;kZfnr jkghy vkf.k R;kpk brj dks.kR;kgh dkj.kkdfjrk okij djrk;s.kkj ukgh- rlsp] baxzth Hkk”ksrhy U;k;fu.kZ; gkp loZ O;kogkfjd vkf.k dk;kZy;hu okijkdfjrk fo’oluh; vlsy vkf.k rksp R;krhy vknks’kkP;k fu”iknu vkf.k vaeyctko.kh dfjrk oS/k ekuyk tkbZy-**