Full Text
Fw;wtpay; nky;KiwaPl;L rl;ltuk;g[
Fw;wtpay; nky;KiwaPL vz;fs; 445?446-2019
(rpwg;g[ mDkjp kD (Fw;w/) vz;fs; 5675?5676-2017?,d; K:yk; vGfpd;wd) khepy muR gpujpepjpj;Jtk;.
Jiz fz;fhzpg;ghsh;.
CHy; jLg;g[ kw;Wk; fz;fhzpg;g[j; Jiw. jkpH;ehL/ ///nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;(fs;)
?vjph;? b$/ Jiurhkp ,d;Dk; gpwh; ///vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;(fs;) jPh;g;g[iu khz;g[kpF ePjpaurh; jpU/ mga; kndhfh; rhg;nu:
1/ mDkjp tH';fg;gl;lJ/
2/ brd;id cah; ePjpkd;wj;jpdhy; Fw;wtpay; rPuha;t[ tHf;F vz;fs;
825 kw;Wk; 826-2015?,y; tH';fg;gl;l. 14/07/2016?Mk; njjpaplg;gl;l ,Wjp jPh;g;g[iu kw;Wk; cj;jutpw;bfjpuhf ,k;nky;KiwaPLfs; jhf;fy; bra;ag;gl;Ls;sd. mj;jPh;g;g[iuapy;. ,';Fs;s vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsUf;bfjpuhf. (,jd; gpd;dh; @C/j/ rl;lk;@ vd Rl;lg;gLk;) CHy; jLg;g[r; rl;lk;. 1988?,d; fPH;. jpUtz;zhkiy. rpwg;g[ ePjpgjp-jiyik ePjpj;Jiw Fw;wtpay; eLth; mth;fs; Kd;ghf rpwg;g[ tHf;F vz; 4-2014?,d; fPH; (,jd; gpd;dh; @F/tp/K/r/@ vd Rl;lg;gLk;) 1973?Mk;
Mz;ila Fw;wtpay; tprhuizKiwr; rl;lj;jpd; fPH; vLf;fg;gl;l eltof;iffspdpd;W mth; F/tp/K/r/. gphpt[ 227?,d; fPH; ,';Fs;s vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;fis tpLtpj;J gpwg;gpj;j cj;juthdJ cWjpbra;ag;gl;L. nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;-khepy murpd; nky;KiwaPlhdJ js;Sgo bra;ag;gl;lJ/
3/ ,k;nky;KiwaPLfs; fPnH Fwpg;gplg;gl;Ls;s bghUz;ikfspypUe;J bjspthFk; RUf;fkhd tptu';fSld; rk;ge;jg;gl;ljhFk;/
4/ vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;fshd (F/rh/1 kw;Wk; F/rh/2) Mfpnahh; jkpH;ehL muR fhty; gzpapy; Kiwna Ma;thsuhft[k; kw;Wk; cjtp Ma;thsuhft[k;
(<)?,d; fPH; jz;of;fj;jf;f Fw;wj;jpw;fhf. Fw;w tHf;bfz; 3-2008 kw;Wk; rpwg;g[ tHf;bfz; 4-2014?,d; fPH; jpUtz;zhkiy. jiyik ePjpj;Jiw Fw;wtpay; eLth;-rpwg;g[ ePjpgjpapd; Kd;ghf tHf;F bjhLf;fg;gl;ldh;/
5/ rl;lj;jpy; njitg;gLk; mDkjpiag; bgw;wgpd;dh;. muR Kfikahy; jhf;fy; bra;ag;gl;l ,Wjp mwpf;ifapd; mog;gilapy; mth;fs; ,UtUk; mth;fis Fw;w tHf;fpypUe;J tpLtpf;ff;nfhhp. jpUtz;zhkiy jiyik ePjpj;Jiw Fw;wtpay; eLth; Kd;ghf. F/tp/K/r/. gphpt[ 227?,d; fPH; (F/g/k/ vz;fs; 648-2014 kw;Wk; 113-2015) Mfpatw;iw jhf;fy; bra;jdh;/ rhuj;jpy;.
@v';fSf;bfjpuhf C/j/ rl;lj;jpd; fPGk; kw;Wk; ,Wjp mwpf;ifapYk; ve;j
Kfhe;jpuKk; epU:gpf;fg;gltpy;iy@ vd;Wk;. vdnt Fw;w";rhl;lg;gl;l ,UtUk;
Fw;wj;jpdpd;W tpLtpf;fg;gl mUfija[ilath;fs; vd;Wk; thjpl;ldh;/
6/ jiyik ePjpj;Jiw Fw;wtpay; eLth; 29/06/2015?Mk; njjpaplg;gl;l jd;Dila cj;jutpd;K:yk; mth;fSila tpz;zg;g';fis mDkjpj;J. tHf;fpdpd;W mth;fis tpLtpj;jhh;/ muRj;jug;ghdJ jiyik ePjpj;Jiw
Fw;wtpay; eLtuhy; gpwg;gpf;fg;gl;l 29/06/2015?Mk; njjpaplg;gl;l cj;jutpdhy; ghjpg;gile;jjhf czh;e;J. cah; ePjpkd;wj;jpy; ,U rPuha;t[fis jhf;fy; bra;jJ/ cah; ePjpkd;wkhdJ vjph;g;gpw;Fs;shd jd;Dila cj;jutpd;K:yk; rPuha;t[fis js;Sgo bra;J. jiyik ePjpj;Jiw Fw;wtpay; eLthpd; cj;juit cWjpbra;jJ/ muRj;jug;ghdJ ,e;ePjpkd;wj;jpy; rpwg;g[ mDkjp
K:yk; ,k;nky;KiwaPLfis jhf;fy; bra;a itj;jJ/
7/ vdnt. ,k;nky;KiwaPLfspy; ghprPyidf;bfGk; RUf;fkhd tpdh ahbjdpy;. vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;fshy; F/tp/K/r/. gphpt[ 227?,d; fPH; jhf;fy; bra;ag;gl;l tpz;zg;g';fis mDkjpj;jjpy; ,U fPHik ePjpkd;w';fSk; epahag;gLj;jg;gLfpd;wdth> vd;gjhFk;/
8/ nky;KiwaPl;lhsUf;fhf Kd;dpiyahd fw;wwpe;j tHf;Fiu"h; jpU/ ghh;j;jrhujp kw;Wk; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;fSf;fhf Kd;dpiyahd fw;wwpe;j
K:j;j tHf;Fiu"h; jpU/ ePuh$; b$apd; kw;Wk; fw;wwpe;j tHf;Fiu"h; jpU/ v!;/ jd";brad; Mfpnahh;fspd; thj';fs; nfl;fg;gl;ld/
/3/
9/ ,U jug;gpdh;fSf;fhd fw;wwpe;j tHf;Fiu"h;fspd; thj';fisf; nfl;Lk;. vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;fshy; rkh;g;gpf;fg;gl;l vGj;Jtot thj';fs; cl;gl tHf;fpd; nfhg;gpYs;s Mtz';fisg; goj;Jk; eh';fs; nky;KiwaPLfis mDkjpf;f tpUk;g[fpnwhk;/ vjph;g;gpw;Fs;shd cj;juit ePf;fwt[ bra;ifapy;.
F/tp/K/r/. gphpt[ 227?,d; fPH; jhf;fy; bra;ag;gl;l tpz;zg;g';fisj; js;Sgo bra;fpd;nwhk;/ tHf;if jFjpapd; mog;gilapy; rl;lj;jpw;Fl;gl;L tprhhpf;f rpwg;g[ ePjpgjp-jiyik ePjpj;Jiw Fw;wtpay; eLtUf;F jpUg;g[fpnwhk;/
10/ muRj;jug;gpdhy; jhf;fy; bra;ag;gl;l Mtz';fs; kw;Wk; mj;Jldhd
,Wjp mwpf;if Mfpatw;wpdog;gilapy; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;fSf;bfjpuhf
Kfhe;jpuk; VJk; cs;sjh> vd;gJ bjhlh;ghf mwpa[k; nehf;fpy; vjph;g;gpw;Fs;shd cj;jut[ cl;gl eh';fs; Mtz';fisg; goj;njhk;/
11/ Mtz';fs;. ,Wjp mwpf;ifapd; cs;slf;f';fs; kw;Wk; vjph;g;gpw;Fs;shd cj;jut[ Mfpatw;iwg; goj;jjpy;. cah; ePjpkd;wkhdJ ,e;ePjpkd;wj;jpdhy; nahnfc&; vd;fpw rr;rpd; $f;jPc&; n$hc&p ?vjph;? kfhuhc&;ou khepy muR. [(2008)
JUDGMENT
(10) v!;/rp/rp/ 394) vd;w tHf;fpd; jPh;g;g[iuapy; tFf;fg;gl;l tpjpia Rl;oabghGjpYk;. mjpy; tFf;fg;gl;l bfhs;iffis rhpahfg; bghUj;jhikahy; jtwpiHj;J. vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;fs; jk;ik tpLtpf;ff;nfhhp. F/tp/K/r/. gphpt[ 227?,d; fPH; jhf;fy; bra;j tpz;zg;g';fis mDkjpj;J gpiH bra;Jtpl;lJ vd eh';fs; fUJfpnwhk;/ 12/ cah; ePjpkd;wkhdJ. rPuha;t[ ePjpkd;wkhf bray;glhky;. rpwg;g[ ePjpkd;wj;jpd;,Wjp cj;jutpd;kPjhd nky;KiwaPl;il nfl;Fk; nky;KiwaPl;L ePjpkd;wj;ijg; nghd;W bray;gl;Ls;sJ vd eh';fs; mwpfpd;nwhk;/ 13/ mJ cah; ePjpkd;wj;jpd; KothdJk; kw;Wk;,jd; fPnH fhzg;gLtJkhd 14?Mk; gj;jp cl;gl xl;Lbkhj;j cj;juita[k; goj;jjpypUe;J bjspthfpwJ/ gj;jp 14 gpd;tUkhW: @14/ mJ mt;thwpUf;f. xnukhjphpahd Fw;wr;rhl;Lfs;. JiwhPjpapyhd eltof;iffspy; epUtg;glKoahjbghGJ. mnj bghUz;ikfSf;fhf Fw;wtpay; eltof;iffspy; Fw;wr;rhl;il /4/ tidtjhy;. jz;og;gjw;fhd tha;g;g[ kpft[k; bjhiythFk;/ mnjneuj;jpy;. JiwhPjpapyhd eltof;iffspypUe;J tpLtpj;jbyhd;nw tpLjiy kDit mDkjpg;gjw;F mog;gil fhuzkhf bfhs;sKoahJ vd;Dk; rl;l epiyg;ghl;il,e;ePjpkd;wk; ed;fwpe;Js;sJ/ vdnt. xU Fw;w";rhl;lg;? gl;ltUf;bfjpuhf Fw;w';fs; Rkj;Jtjw;F muRj;jug;gpdhy; VnjDk; Kfhe;jpuk; epUtg;gl;Ls;sjh> vd;gJ bjhlh;ghf ftdpf;fntz;oaJ njitahfpwJ/,t;tHf;fpy; muRj;jug;gpd; tHf;fhdJ. rhl;rp-KiwaPl;lhsuhd Re;juuh$d; kw;Wk; mtUila ikj;Jdh; nrfh; Mfpnahhpd; Tw;iwna Kjd;ikahf rhh;e;Js;sJ/ tprhuiz ePjpkd;wj;jpdhy; fUj;J bjhptpf;fg;gl;lJ nghd;W. muRj;jug;g[ rhl;rpfspd; Tw;WfSf;fpilna Kuz;ghLfs; cs;sd/ nkYk;. tprhuiz ePjpkd;wj;jpdhy; fUj;J bjhptpf;fg;gl;lJ nghd;W (mUzhr;ryk; j';Fk; tpLjp-tpUe;jpdufk;) miw vz; 4?,y; F/rh/1 kw;Wk; F/rh/2 Mfpnahh;,Ue;jjw;fhd rhd;bwija[k;. Fiwe;jgl;r Mtzk; vija[k; muRj;jug;g[ rkh;g;gpf;ftpy;iy/ nkw;go j';Fk; tpLjpapd; miw vz; 4?,y; U:/5,yl;rk; jug;gl;lJ vd;gJ muRj;jug;gpd; tHf;fhdbghGjpYk;. brd;id. CHy; jLg;g[ rpwg;g[ FGtpd; fhty;Jiw TLjy; fz;fhzpg;ghsuhd Rg;igah Kd;dpiyapy; 14/09/2010 md;W F/tp/K/r/. gphpt[ 161?,d; fPH; gjpag;gl;l nrfhpd; thf;FK:yj;jpy;. mth; gzk; jug;gl;l njjpahf 15/01/2004 vd Rl;oa[s;shh;/ Mdhy;. ntY}h;. Fw;wg; gphpt[ TLjy; khtl;l fz;fhzpg;ghsh; $%a;yd; Kd;dpiyapy;. 09/07/2004 md;W jug;gl;l thf;FK:yj;jpy;. 15/02/2004 md;iwf;F Kd;g[ XhpU ehl;fspy; gzk; jug;gl;ljhf Twpa[s;shh;/ vdnt. F/rh/1 kw;Wk; F/rh/2?f;F nkw;go gzk; U:/5,yl;rk; jug;gl;ljhd njjpapy; mog;gil Kuz;ghL cs;sJ/ nkw;go nrfhpd; thjKiw rhuh Tw;iwj; jtpu. F/rh/1 kw;Wk; F/rh/2 Mfpnahuhy; gzk; /5/ nfhug;gl;lij epU:gpf;f,e;ePjpkd;wj;jpd; Kd;ghf MtznkJkpy;iy/ 14/ v';fSila fUj;jpy;. vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;fspd; (Fw;w";rhl;lg;? gl;lth;fspd;) tpLjiy tpz;zg;g';fis jPh;khdpf;ifapy;. cah; ePjpkd;wj;jpd; mj;jifa mQqFKiwahdJ rl;lg;go rhpahdjy;y/ vdnt. mJ cWjpbra;ag;gl KoahJ/ 15/ v';fSila fUj;jpy;. tpLjiy nehf;fpy; Mtz';fisg; ghprPypj;jy; xUtpjk;. nky;KiwaPl;L ePjpkd;wj;jpdhy; nky;KiwaPlhdJ jPh;khdpf;fg;gLifapy; Mtz';fs; ghprPypf;fg;gLtJ ntWtpjkhFk;/ 16/,Wjpawpf;if jhf;fy; bra;ag;gl;l gpd;dh;. cldoahf tpLjiy nfhUk; tHf;ifg; ghprPypf;ifapy;. ePjpkd;wkhdJ nky;KiwaPl;L ePjpkd;wkhfp. cah; ePjpkd;wj;jpdhy; vjph;g;gpw;Fs;shd 19 gf;f';fs; cs;s cj;jutpy; bra;ag;gl;lJnghd;W. rhl;rpfspd; thf;FK:y';fspYs;s Kuz;ghLfis mwptjd;K:yk; rhd;Wfis Ma Jt';fptpl KoahJ/ mJ rl;lg;go mDkjpf;fj;jf;fjy;y/ 17/ eh';fs; bghUz;ikfisnah my;yJ tprhuiz ePjpkd;wj;jpy; mspf;fg;gl;L tphpthf Ma;t[bra;ag;glt[s;s rhd;iwnah tpthpf;ftpy;iy kw;Wk; tHf;fpd; jFjpfspd; mog;gilapy;. ahbjhU mwpe;jikiaa[k; (Koita[k;) gjptJ jug;gpdh;fs; jkJ tHf;if ciuf;ifapy;. mth;fSila chpikfis ghjpf;Fk; vd;gjhy;. mt;thW gjptjpdpd;Wk; eh';fshfnt jtph;j;Jf;bfhz;nlhk;/ 18/,k;nky;KiwaPLfis mDkjpf;ifapy;. eh';fs; TWk; midj;Jk; ahbjdpy;.,e;j tprhuiz fl;lj;jpy;. vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;fis tpLtpf;f Kfhe;jpuk; VJkpy;iy vd;gjhFk;/ vdnt Mtz';fs; kw;Wk; ePjpkd;wj;jpd; cj;juitaLj;J jhf;fy; bra;ag;gl;l,Wjp mwpf;ifapd; cs;slf;f';fs; Mfpatw;wpd; jFjpfspd; mog;gilapy; mth;fs; tprhuizia vjph;bfhs;sntz;oa[s;sJ/ muRj;jug;ghdJ jd;Dila Fw;wr;rhl;Lfis epUgpf;f,Wjp mwpf;iff;F Mjuthf rhd;Wfis rkh;g;gpf;f rpwg;g[ ePjpkd;wkhdJ (jiyik ePjpj;Jiw Fw;wtpay; eLth;) muRj;jug;ig mDkjpj;jpUf;fntz;Lk;/ /6/ 19/ nkw;go tpthjj;jpd; mog;gilapy;. nky;KiwaPLfs; btw;wpbgWfpd;wd/ mjw;fpz';f mit mDkjpf;fg;gLfpd;wd/ vjph;g;g[f;Fs;shd cj;jut[ ePf;fwt[ bra;ag;gLfpwJ/ mjd; tpisthf vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;fshy; F/tp/K/r/. gphpt[ 227?,d; fPH; jhf;fy; bra;ag;gl;l tpz;zg;g';fs; js;Sgo bra;ag;gLfpd;wd/ 20/ rpwg;g[ ePjpgjp (jiyik ePjpj;Jiw Fw;wtpay; eLth;) rl;lj;jpw;Fl;gl;L tprhuizia bjhlh;e;J 6 khj';fSf;Fs;shf Kof;FkhW gzpf;fg;gLfpwhh;/ 21/ rpwg;g[ ePjpgjpahdth;,t;tHf;Ffspy; cah; ePjpkd;wj;jpdhYk; kw;Wk;,t;tHf;F eltof;ifapy;,e;ePjpkd;wj;jpdhYk; bjhptpf;fg;gl;l fUj;Jfshy; bry;thf;F brYj;jg;glhky;. rpwg;g[ ePjpkd;wkhdJ tprhuizapy; jug;gpdh;fshy; rkh;g;gpf;fg;gLk; rhd;Wfspd; mog;gilapy; tHf;if fz;og;ghf rl;lj;jpw;Fl;gl;L Kof;fntz;Lk;/ khz;g[kpF ePjpaurh; jpU/ mga; kndhfh; rhg;nu khz;g[kpF ePjpaurh; jpU/ jpndc&; knfc&;thp g[J jpy;yp. 07/03/2019/............................................................................................................................................................... epge;jid @tl;lhu bkhHpapy; bkhHpahf;fk; bra;ag;gl;l,j;jPh;g;g[iuahdJ. tHf;fho. jd;Dila bkhHpapy; g[hpe;Jf;bfhs;tjw;fhd tiuaWf;fg;gl;l gad;ghl;ow;nfad;wp. ntW ve;j nehf;fj;jpw;Fk; gad;gLj;jg;glKoahJ/ epiwntw;Wjy; kw;Wk; eilKiwg;gLj;Jjy; nghd;w midj;J eilKiwrhh; kw;Wk; mjpfhug;g{h;trhh; nehf;f';fSf;Fk;. jPh;g;g[iuapd; M';fpyg; gjpg;ng mjpfhug;g{h;tkhdjhFk;/@