5234e5e245c9e87c7af4d97b67da0730476a8cc3565bba26f6aeb29d6c82a0be

1. n?;Hn?bHghH(;h) HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHvhHBzH6472$2018 ftZu d/oh dh w[nkch.

2. wBI{oh fdZsh rJh.

3. w"i{dk e/;K ftZu, gzikp;oeko B/ gzikp NkT[B fJzgo{tw?AN n?eN, 1922 dh Xkok 36 sfjs fwsh 18H6H1993, 25H6H1993 ns/ 2H7H1993 B{z 24 J/eV 6 eBkb ns/ 11 wob/ B{z wkgD bJh fszB nfX;{uBktK ikoh ehshnK. (fJ; s'A pknd “dk n?eN@ dk fIeo ehsk frnk j?) fJ; s'A pknd nfX;{uBk fwsh 28H4H1994 nB[;ko, n?eN d/;?ePB 42 nXhB fJZe;ehw fi; B{z NqK;g'oN Bro;ehw, o{gBro ti'A ikfDnk iKdk j?, B{z wBi{oh fdZsh rJh;h. fJj ntkov fwsh 18H4H1996 B{z x'fPs ehsk frnk ns/ e[b?eNo, o{gBro B/ tZy^tZy torK dh IwhBK bJh j/mb/ do s/ w[nktik fdZsk:- “ ukjh IwhB: o[gJ/ 2,01,984$- gqsh J/eV pokBh IwhB: o[gJ/ 1,00,992$- gqsh J/eV r?o w[zwfeB IwhB: o[gJ/ 1,39,200$- gqsh J/eV@ 4H IwhBh jZedkoK d[nkok jtkbk d/D s/ fIbQk iZi, o{gBro B/ tZyo/ yofunK s'A fJbktk ntkov fwsh 9H11H2001 d[nkok o[gJ/ 6,93,000$- (S/ bZy soKBt/ jIko o[gJ/) gqsh J/eV w[nktIk fdZsk. - 3 nkovo j/m fby/ nB[;ko j?: “12HHHHHHHHHfoekov d/;p{s s'A fJj;ZgPN j? fe gqkgs ehsh IwhB uzvhrVQ^o'gV^Bzrb e"wh oki wkor ns/ nkoHNhHghH eb'Bh fi; ftZu 700$800 xo jB T[j f;oc fJZe gk;/ s/ fbze o'v s/ j? ns/ d{i/ gk;/, g[fb; bkJhBI j?, fi; ftZu brGr 100 e[nkoNoI Pkfgzr ezgb?e; jB, fiZE/ p?Ae,;e{b, nkoHNhHn?cH ekb'Bh ftZu jB. o'gV s'A nkT[D tkbh;Ve s'A b? e/ gqkgs ehsh IwhB sZe;Ve d/ d'tK gkf;nK s/ th d[ekBK jB. fgzv e'Nbk fBjzr dh IwhB g[fb; bkJhBK d/ fgZS/;fEZs j?. ghHn?;HJhHph dh 132 e/HthH ekb'Bh th gqkgs ehsh IwhB d/ B/V/;fEs j?.@ ns/ 13H T[; t/b/ d/ fibQk iZi o{gBro B/ gfjbK jh p/bk o'v Gkr^II;ehw bJh gqkgs ehsh IwhB dh wkoehN ehws dk w[bKeD ekgh nkc ntkov d[nkok o[gJ/ 5,25,000$- gqsh J/eV ehsk j?. T[; e/; ftZu Pkwb IwhB pj[s Bht/A fJbke/ ftZu;h feT[Afe o{gBro e;p/ d/ po;ksh ns/ j'o;kok gkDh T[; IwhB d/ tZb iKdk j?, T[go'es uouk d/ nB[;ko w"i{dk wkwb/ ftZu gqkgs ehsh IwhB fpjso;fEsh ftZu j? ns/ p/bk o'v, Gkr-II ftek;;ehw bJh gkgs ehsh IwhB d/ w[ekpb/ pj[s uzrh w[Zb tkbh j?. T[; e/; ftZu IwhB fwsh 12H4H1989 dh nfX;{uBk d[nkok gqkgs ehsh rJh;h, idfe w"i{dk wkwb/ ftZu gqkgs ehsh IwhB dh wkoehN ehws fBoXkos eoB dh (material) fwsh 18H6H1993 j?. fJ; soQK d' nfX;{uBktK d/ ftueko uko - 4 -;kb dk nzso j?, jkbKfe 1994(4) ghHn?bHnkoH 243(;[gok) d' sohyK dh nfX;{uBk ftueko ehws tkX/ B{z 12% gqsh;kb dh do Bkb wBI{oh fdZsh rJh;h, go w"i{dk wkwb/ ftZu gqkgs ehsh IwhB dk uzrk w[Zb ns/ B/Vsk d/ wZd/BIo d' sohyK dh nfX;{uBktK ftueko ehws tkX/ B{z 8% gqsh;kb dh do s/ nkfrnk fdZsh iKdh j?. fJ; bJh w/ok wzBDk j? fe dknt/dko gqkgs ehsh IwhB d/ w[nktI/ B{z b?D dk jZedko j?, i' fe o[gJ/ 6,93,000$^ gqsh J/eV j? feT[Afe fJj o{gBro dh fwTA{;hgb jZd nzdo;fEs j? ns/ fJ; B{z y/shpkVh IwhB ti'A BjhA fbnk ik;edk.@ 5H fJj wkwbk IwhB d/ jZedkoK d[nkok gzikp ns/ jfonkDk jkJhe'oN ftZu f;tb foZN gNh;aB Bzpo 2718$2002 dkyb eoe/ nZr/ tXkfJnk frnk;h.;[Xko e/Ado B/ fibQk iZi d[nkok fdZs/ rJ/ w[nkti/ dh do s'A go/PkB j' e/ foN gNh;aBK dkfJo ehshnK. jkJh e'oN B/ nkgD/ nkd/P ns/ c?;b/ fwsh 26H11H2011 d[nkok, fJ; nkXko s/ g[o;eko(ntkov) fwsh 9H11H2001 B{z oZd eo fdZsk fe fJ; wkwb/ dk c?;bk fibQk iZi dh nZrtkJh j/m fNqfpT{Bb d[nkok ehsk ikDk;h BK fe f;o| fibQk iZi d[nkok. fJBQK wkwfbnK B{z w[V ftuko bJh, G"A gqkgsh fNqfpT{Bb, o{gBro ftZy/ G/i fdZsk frnk. 6H g';N ohwKv, fibQk iZi B/ nkgD/ nkd/;a fwsh 01H02H2014 d[nkok j/m fbyhnK doK s/ w[nktik fdZsk:- “ ukjh G{wh @: 2,69,312$- o[gJ/ gqsh J/eV - 5 pokBh G{wh @: 1,34,656$- o[gJ/ gqsh J/eV r?o w[zwfeB G{wh @: 1,85,600$- o[gJ/ gqsh J/eV@ 7H IwhB d/ wkbeK ns/ jkJhe'oN d/ c?;b/ fwsh 9H2H2017 ns/ j[ewK d[nkok u[D"shnK d/ IohJ/ wkwb/ d[pkok jkJhe'oN ftZu bZr/, T[jBK B/ G"A gqkgsh fNqfpT{Bb d/ c?;b/ B{z;'fXnk ns/ IwhBK dhnK fe;wK;hws Bk oZyd/ j'J/ w[nktik 2,69,312$^ (d' bZy T[BZso jIko fszB;"' pkoK) o[gJ/ gqsh J/eV w[bKeD ehsk. fJ; soQK jkJhe'oN d[nkok cb?N o/N s/ w[nktIk fdZsk frnk;h. fJ; c?;b/ B{z j[D u[D"sh j?. 8H;hBhno;bkjeko Pqh Bhoi e[wko i?B B/ w[Zy s"o s/ fJ; sZE s/ Go';k ehsk fe Bkb bZrd/ fgzv s'A e[M IwhB dh gqkgsh d/ wkwb/ ftZu fiZE/;zB 1989 ftZu gqkgsh dh P[o{nks ehsh rJh, w[nktIk @ 5,25,000$^ (gzi bZy gZuh jIko) o[gJ/ gqsh J/eV fdZsk frnk. G"A gqkgsh d/ nZr/ fJ; gfjb{ B{z T[ikro ehsk frnk;h ns/ gq;s{sh th ntkov fwsh 1H2H2014 ftZu do;kfJnk frnk;h, i' fe fJ; gqeko j?:- “13H fpB?ekoK d/ tehb B/ jkJh e'oN d[nkok R.F.A. No. 291 of 1989 ftZu gk; ehs/ rJ/ g[o;eko s/ Go';k ehsk j?, fJ; dh ekgh Ex P-1 j?, fi; nB[;ko e'Nbk fBjzr dh IwhB nfX;{uBk fwsh 20H3H1985 okjhA jk;b ehsh rJh;h ns/ wkB:'r jkJh e'oN nghbeosktK B{z @ 4,84,000$^ o[gJ/ gqsh J/eV dh do Bkb w[nktIk d/D bJh y[P;h. fpB?ekoK B/ fJZemh G{wh;zdoG bhv e/; BzH 141 nkc 24H9H1993 fi;dk c?;bk 25H4H1998 B{z wkB:'r iZi Pqh n?;Hn?;Hro/tkb, fibQk iZi, o{gBro d[nkok ehsk frnk (Ex P-2 ns/ Ex P- 3), ftZu gk; ehs/ rJ/ ntkov dh foekov dh ekgh th oZyh j?. fi; okjhA - 6 fpB?ekoK B{z fgzv jt/bh y[od dh IwhB pko/ nfX;{uBk fwsh 12H4H1989 d/ fj;kp Bkb tXh j'Jh w[nktI/ dh okPh fdZsh rJh;h ns/ fJ; e/; ftZu fpB?ekoK B{z w[nktI/ d/ o{g ftZu o[gJ/ 5,25,000$^ gqsh J/eV dh do Bkb gqkgs IwhB bJh w[nktIk fdZsk frnk. 9H fJ; bJh e'Nbk fBjzr dh IwhBK ftZu d/yD ftZu nkfJnk j?, i' nfX;{uBk fwsh 20H3H1985 okjhA jk;b ehsh rJh;h s/ w[nktIk 4,84,000$^(uko bZy u"ok;h jIko) o[gJ/ fdZsk frnk;h. fgzv jt/bh y[od dh IwhBK i' nfX;{uBk fwsh 12H4H1989 okjhA jk;b ehsh rJh;h dk w[nktIk 5,25,000$^ (gzi bZy gZuh jIko) o[gJ/, gqsh J/eV fdZsk frnk;h. Pqh i?B B/ g/go p[Ze gzBk 178 d/ bZr/;kJhN w?g(BePk) s/ Go';k eofdnK fejk fe fJj d' fgzv, fgzv d/ Bkb bZrd/ jB fi; Bkb n;hA toswkB;w/A ftZu;zpzX oZyd/ jK. 10H Pqh n?;H;hHgm/bk, gqshfBXh^;[Xko e/Ado tb'A g/P j'J/ tehb B/ fejk fe BePk fi; s/ fBoGosk oZyh rJh;h, B{z j/mb/ ndkbsK;kjwD/ ed/ BjhA fdykfJnk frnk ns/ fit/A fe wB'i e[wko pBkw jfonkDk oki ns/ j'o, (2018) 13 SCC 96, ftZu i' do fgSbh gqkgshnK ftZu fdZsk frnk j? s/ nk;kBh Bkb fJ; s/ fBoGo j'Dk ukjhdk. n;h fJ; ndkbs d/ wB'i e[wko(;[gok) dk c?;bk tkfunk j?.;kv/ fynkb ftZu, fJ; e/; ftub/ fBohyD wkwb/ ftbZyD sZE d/;zdoG ftZu pDkJ/ rJ/;B. 11H fJj sZE fe T[go'es d' fgzvK ftZu gqkgsh fJ; rZb s/ fBoGo;h fe G"A gqkgsh fNqfpT{Bb i' fe T[go'es uouktK s'A fpbe[b;gPN j?, gqkgs ehsh IwhB dh;fEsh - 7 ns/;zGkth ns/ e'Nbk fBjzr ns/ jt/bh y[od dh IwhBK Bkb B/Vsk d/ nkXko s/ ntkov fwsh 9H11H2001 dh rDBk;h, i' fe seBheh nkXko s/ fpbe[Zb nbZr oZfynk frnk. fJjBK gqkgshnK d/;zpzX ftZu fdZs/ rJ/ ntkov @ 4,85,000$^ (uko bZy guZk;h jiako) o[gJ/ gqsh J/eV ns/ @ 5,25,000$^ (gzi bZy gZuh jiako) o[gJ/ gqsh J/eV;h. fJj gqkgshnK;kb 1985 ns/ 1989 dh;h. n;hA fJ; t/b/ fJjBK gqkgshnK Bkb;zpzXs jK, i';kb 1993 ftZu ikoh nfX;{uBktK Bkb;zpzXs;B. 12H;kv/ fynkb ftZu, fJjBK d'tK fgzvk d/;zpzX ftZu fdZsk frnk w[nktIk fJZe;ze/se j?, fi; B{z nDd/fynk BjhA ehsk ik;edk. w"i{dk wkwfbnK ftZu Pkwb IwhB dh jZd 25 J/eV IwhB j?, fi; dh tos'A Pfjoh Io{os bJh NqK;g'oN Bro fBrw;ehw bJh ehsh iKDh;h. fJ; bJh n;hA @ 5,25,000$^ (gzi bZy gZuh jIko) o[gJ/ gqsh J/eV dh do s/ fBoGo eod/ jK, fit/A fe;kb 1989 ftZu ntkov ehs/ i' 1993 ftZu gqkgsh bJh T[fus w[nkti/ s/ gj[zuD bJh w[ZYb/ o/N ti'A do;kfJnk frnk;h Gkt uko;kb pknd. fJ; jkbks ftZu;kv/ ftuko Bkb, nghbeosk w[ZYb/ o/N 5,25,000$^(gzi bZy gZuh jIko) o[gJ/ gqsh J/eV s'A 6 %;zfus tkX/ d/ jZedko jB Gkt/A IwhB e'Jh th Pq/Dh dh j't/ IwhB d/ jedkoK B{z fdZs/ iKd/ jB. 13H nfij/ w[ZYb/ do d/ nkXko s/ w[nktI/ dk ekoi j/m fby/ nB[;ko j?:fgqz;hgb ftnki e[Zb oew gfjbk;kb 5,25,000$^ o[gJ/ + 31,500 = 5,56,500/d{ik;kb 5,56,500$^ o[gJ/ + 33,390 =5,89,890/- - 8 shik;kb 5,89,890$^ o[gJ/ + 35,393 = 6,25,283/u"Ek;kb 6,25,283$^ o[gJ/ + 37,517 = 6,62,800/-

14. n;h fJjBK nghbK dh fJikIs fdzd/ jK ns/ x'PDk eod/ jK fe nghbeosk w"i{dk gqkgshnK ftZu IwhBK d/;zpzX ftZu w[nkti/ d/ jZedko jB, fiBQK dh ehws 6,62,800$^ (S/ bZy pkjm jIko nZm;") o[gJ/ gqsh J/eV ns/ ftXkBe bkG fJ; do d/ nkXko s/ e'Jh bkrs BjhA. HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHiZi (T[d/ T[w/;a bfbs) HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHiZi (fJzd{ wbj'sok) BthA fdZbh, 24 ngq??b, 2019H - 9 wZd Bz: 2 e'oN Bz: 8 Gkr IV-ph Gkos dk;[gohw e'oN ekotkJhnK dk foekov;g?;ab bht gNhPB bJh nghb(;h) Bz(;)H 31767-31776/2017 i' fe fJjBK ftu' T[sgzB j'Jh iZiw?AN ns/ nkovo fwsh 09^02^2017 in CWP Nos. 722/2015, 5869/2014, 6070/2014, 6069/2014 ns/ 6074$2014 ns/ fwsh 02^06^2017 in RA-CW No. 284/2017(O&M) in CWP No. 722/2015, RA-CW No. 290/2017(O&M) in CWP No. 5869/2014, RA-CW NO. 295/2017(O&M) in CWP No. 6070/2014, RA-CW No. 296/2017 (O&M) in CWP NO. 6069/2014 ns/ RA-CW No. 294/2017 (O&M) in CWP No. 6074/2014 jkJh e'oN gzikp ns/ jfonkDk uzvhrVQ d[nkok gk; ehs/ rJ/.;odkok f;zx ns/ j'o nkfd HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHtkdh(;) pBkw G"A gqkgsh e[b?eNo,;[Xko e/Ado, o{gBro ns/ j'o HHHHHHHHHHHHT[Zsotkdh(;) Bkb n?;Hn?bHghH(;h) Bz: HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH@ vkfJoh Bz(;)H 6472$2018(IV-ph) (Bkb n?;Hn?bHghH dkyb eoB ftZu doyk;s ftZu d/oh) fwsh: 24.04.2019 fJj gNhPBK nZi;[DtkJh bJh;h. - 10 e'ow wkB:'r iZi Pqh T[d/ T[w/P bfbs wkB:'r iZi Pqhwsh fJzd{ wbj'sok nghbeosk(;) bJh Pqh Bhoi e[wko i?B,;hBhno tehb Pqh nfBe/s i?B, tehb Pqh f;XkoE i?B, tehb Pqh T[wzr Pzeo, n?vt'e/N nkB foekov Pqh fdB/P towk, tehb Pqh ois Powk, tehb Pqh;[GnkPhP G'fwZe, tehb, Pqh n?;Hn?bHnB/ik, n?vt'e/N nkB foekov bJh T[sotkdh(;) bJh Pqh n?;H;hHgm/bk, tehb Pqh:Pgkb YhArok, n?vt'e/N nkB foekov bJh ndkbs B/ tehb B{z;[DB s'A pknd j/m fby/ nkovo ehs/:n?;Hn?bHgh(;h)HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHvh BzH 6472$2018 ftZu d/oh dh w[nkch. wBi{oh fdZsh rJh. j;skyo ehs/ Bk^fog'oN:'r c?;fbnK(iZiw?AN) d/ o{g ftZu nghbK B{z fpBK yofunK d/ wBI{oh fdZsh iKdh j?. (okfizdo e"o) (;ohsk g[o'fjs) poKu nc;o AR-cum-PS (j;skyo Bk fog'oN:'r iZiw?AN ckfJb ftZu oZyh iKdh j?) - 11 fv;eb/wo:-;EkBe GkPk ftZu nB[tkd ehsk frnk fBnK fBoDK e/tb w[eZdw/pkIk bJh T[jBK dh nkgDh GkPk ftu;wMD sZe jh;hws j? ns/ fJ;dk fe;/ j'o T[d/P bJh fJ;s/wkb BjhA ehsk ik;edk.;ko/ ftjkoe ns/ nfXekos wzstk bJh, fBnK fBoD/ dk nzro/Ih;z;eoD gqwkfDe j't/rk ns/ nwb bkr{ eoB bJh fJ; B{z soihj fdZsh ikt/rh. Translated by Ms. Kusum Lata, Translator. Typed by Sh. Ajay Abbot.