16638f39b43e3f6cba03e6b3ba7b804f78846bdbf214ac05b459b50a57aa2bd6

UNKNOWN COURT · 07 Jul 2019
fnok.kh vihy Ø- 4665@2019
criminal appeal_dismissed Significant

AI Summary

The Supreme Court upheld the conviction of accused persons, affirming that the prosecution proved guilt beyond reasonable doubt through credible evidence including medical and forensic reports.

Full Text
Translation output
¼baaxzthe/;s Vadfyf[kr U;k;fu.kZ;kps ejkBhe/;s Hkk”kkarj½ izdk'kuklkBh ukgh
Hkkjrkps loksZPp U;k;ky; fnok.kh vfiyh; vf/kdkfjrk fnok.kh vihy Ø- 4665@2019
¼fo'ks”k vuqerh ;kfpdk ¼fnok.kh½ Ø- 16421@2017 e/khy
U;k;fu.kZ;krwu mn~Hkoysys½ lapkyd] ifjogu foHkkx] nknjk o uxj gosyh g;k dsanz'kkflr izns'kkaps iz'kklu] flYoklk vkf.k brj -------vihydrsZ fo:/n
Jh vfHkuo fnidHkkbZ iVsy --------mRrjoknh
U;k;fu.kZ;
,y- ukxs'oj jko] U;k;ewrhZ vuqerh eatwj
1½ mPp U;k;ky;kP;k U;k;fu.kZ;k}kjs mRrjoknh ;kaph fjV
;kfpdk eatwj d:u R;kaph lgk¸;d eksVkj okgu fufj{kd Eg.kwu fu;qfDr
dj.;kckcrps fnysys funZs'k] gk ;k vihyke/;s oknkpk fo”k; vkgs- mRrjoknh gs] xqtjkr jkT; rlsp nknjk o uxj gosyh g;k dsanz'kkflr izns'kkae/khy] vuqlwfpr tekrh g;k izoxkZrhy ekU;rk izkIr ^/kksfM;k* g;k vuqlwfpr tekrhps vkgsr o xqtjkr jkT;krhy lacaf/kr l{ke izkf/kdkÚ;kauh tkjh dsysys tkr izek.ki= R;kaP;kdMs vkgs- R;kauh R;kaps fuoklLFkku xqtjkre/kwu nknjk o uxj gosyh g;k dsanz'kkflr izns'kke/;s LFkykarjhr dsys vkgs- R;kaps dsanz'kkflr izns'kke/;s ekydh gDdkps jfgoklh fuoklLFkku vlwu rs nknjk o uxj gosyh ;sFkhy jfgoklh gksrs gs n'kZfo.;kdfjrk R;kaP;kdMs ernkj vksG[ki= ns[khy vkgs-
2½ fnukad 25-10-2014 jksth] lgk¸;d eksVkj okgu fufj{kdkph nksu ins] T;kiSdh ,d in vuqlqfpr tekr g;k izoxkZdfjrk vkjf{kr gksrs]
Hkj.;kdfjrk tkfgjkr izfl/n dj.;kr vkyh gksrh- lnj tkfgjkrhe/;s vls
Li”Vi.ks uewn dj.;kr vkys gksrs dh] loZ Hkkjrh; ukxfjd lnj inkoj fu;qfDr gks.;kdfjrk vtZ d: 'kdrkr] ijarq T;k O;fDr nknjk o uxj gosyhP;k ^vf/koklh* vkgsr] R;kauk fo'ks”k loyr ¼izk/kkU;½ ns.;kr ;sbZy- ts mesnokj vuqlqfpr tekrhps lHkkln vlY;kpk nkok djrhy] R;kauh l{ke izkf/kdkjh ;kaP;kdMwu tkjh dj.;kr vkysY;k tkr izek.ki=kph lka{kkfdr izr lknj dj.;kcjkscjp rks@rh mesnokj vuqlqfpr tekr lektke/kwu vkyk vlY;kps fo/kku dj.ks vko';d gksrs- mRrjoknh ;kauh lnj lgk¸;d eksVkj okgu fufj{kd ;k inkoj fu;qfDr izkIr dj.;klkBh vtZ dsyk vkf.k izkIr >kysY;k ,dw.k 114 vtkZaph Nkuuh >kY;koj] vls vk<Gwu vkys dh] ^loZlk/kkj.k* izoxkZrhy rhu mesnokj vkf.k
vuqlqfpr tekrh* g;k izoxkZrhy nksu mesnokj ik= Bjys gksrs- mRrjoknh gs fnukad 01@07@2015 jksth ?ks.;kr vkysY;k ys[kh ijh{ksl mifLFkr jkfgys gksrs- fnukad 11-07-2015 jksth] ys[kh ijh{kspk] vukjf{kr inklkBh fudky tkghj dj.;kr vkyk] ijarq vuqlwfpr tekrhdfjrk vlysY;k fjDr inklkBhpk fudky tkghj dj.;kr vkyk Ukkgh vkf.k ;k xks”Vhps mRrjoknh ;kauk vk'p;Z okVys- R;kaP;k lgk¸;d eksVkj okgu fufj{kd g;k inkoj u >kysY;k fuoMhckcr R;kauh dsysY;k vfHkosnukauk dks.krkgh izfrlkn izkIr u >kY;keqGs R;kauh Hkkjr ljdkjP;k] vuqlwfpr tekrhadfjrkP;k jk”Vªh; vk;ksxkPks nkj BksBkoys- R;koj] mRrjoknh gs nknjk o uxj gosyh g;k dsanz'kkflr izns'kkrhy jfgoklh vkgsr vkf.k rs vuqlwfpr tekr g;k izoxkZrhy vkgsr ;kph [kk=h iVY;koj] jk”Vªh; vk;ksxkus nknjk o uxj gosyhP;k izfrfu/khyk] Hkkjr ljdkjP;k x`gea=ky;kdMwu ;kckcrhr Li”Vhdj.k ekxowu ?;kos o rn~uarj mRrjoknh ;kaph ¼lnj inkoj½ fu;qfDr djkoh] vls funsZ'k fnys- Hkkjr ljdkjP;k x`gea=ky;kus vls Li”Vhdj.k fnys dh] mRrjoknh gs fu;qDrhdjhrk ik= gksrs vkf.k iq<s vlk lYyk fnyk dh vuqlwfpr tekrhlkBhP;k jk”Vªh; vk;ksxkus tkjh dsysY;k funs'kkizek.ks lacaf/kr izkf/kdkÚ;kauh ;ksX; rh dk;Zokgh djkoh- R;kuarj] Hkkjr ljdkj] nknjk o uxj gosyh dsanz'kkflr izns'k vkf.k jk”Vªh; vk;ksx ;kaP;ke/;s cÚ;kp eksB;k izek.kkr i=O;ogkj >kY;kuarj] fnukad 25@07@2016 jksth] jk”Vªh; vk;ksxkus vkns'k ikfjr d:u vihydrsZ ;kauk mRrjoknh ;kaP;k ukos fu;qfDri= tkjh dj.;kps funs'k fnys- ijarq] mRrjoknh ;kaP;k
fu;qfDrckcr dks.krhgh dk;Zokgh u >kY;keqGs R;akuk mPp U;k;ky;] eqacbZ
;sFks fjV ;kfpdk nk[ky dj.ks Hkkx iMys-
3½ vihydrsZ ;kaP;korhus] mPp U;k;ky;kleksj vls fuosnu lknj dj.;kr vkys dh] fnukad 01@09@2006 jksth nknjk o uxj gosyh g;k dsanz'kkflr izns'kkus ,d /kksj.k vk[kys vkgs] T;k}kjs vlk fu.kZ;
?ks.;kr vkyk vkgs dh] [kqY;k izoxkZrhy LFkkfud mesnokjkauh ^vf/kokl* izek.ki= lknj dj.ks xjtsps vkgs- tksoj vkjf{kr izoxkZapk laca/k vkgs]
QDr LFkkfud mesnokjkapk fopkj dj.;kr ;sbZy- lnj /kksj.kke/;s fnukad
26-12-2013 jksth] [kqY;k izoxkZrhy mesnokjkaP;k ckcrhr QDr
^vf/kokl* lacaf/kr lq/kkj.kk dj.;kr vkyh- vihydrsZ ;kaP;k orhus vlsgh dFku dj.;kr vkys dh] vuqlwfpr tekrhP;k] ,dk jkT;ke/kwu nwlÚ;k jkT;ke/;s vkf.k ,dk jkT;ke/kwu ,[kkn;k dsanz'kkflr izns'kke/;s
LFkykarj dj.kkÚ;k O;fDrackcrhr dks.krkgh HksnHkko gksÅ 'kdr ukgh- nknjk o uxj gosyhe/khy vuqlwfpr tekrh vf/klwfpr dj.;klkBh ek- jk”Vªirh ;kauh Lora= vkns'k tkjh dsysys vlY;keqGs] LFkykarjhr O;fDr dsanz'kkflr izns'kke/;s vkj{k.kklkBh nkok d: 'kdr ukghr- LFkkfud mesnokjkauk ns.;kr vkysY;k izk/kkU;kpk lanHkZ nsÅu] vihydrsZ ;kauh vls
Eg.k.ks lknj dsys vkgs dh] fuoM izfdz;se/;s LFkkfud mesnokjkauk ts 20 xq.k ns.;kr vkysys vkgsr rs [kqY;k izoxkZrhy vkf.k vkjf{kr izoxkZrhy mesnokjkauk lekursus ykxw gksrkr- ijarq] vihydrsZ Bkei.ks vls lkaxr jkghys dh vuqlwfpr tekr g;k izoxkZlkBh Bso.;kr vkysY;k vkj{k.kkpk ykHk gk LFkykarjhr mesnokjkalkBh ukgh rj dsoG LFkkfud mesnokjkaiqjrkp
e;kZfnr Bso.;kr vkysyk vkgs-
4½ vihydrsZ ;kaP;k] dsanz'kkflr izns'kkckgsjhy vuqlwfpr tekr g;k izoxkZrhy lHkklnkauk ¼mesnokjkauk½ ¼lnj½ dsanz'kkflr izns'kkrhy vkjf{kr izoxkZe/;s eksM.kkÚ;k lkoZtfud ¼ljdkjh½ inkaoj fu;qfDrlkBh
R;kaP;k ukoakpk fopkj gks.;kiklwu oxG.;kr vkysys vkgs] g;k fuosnukpk mPp U;k;ky;koj dks.krkgh izHkko iMyk ukgh- mPp U;k;ky;kP;k ers]
LFkkfud mesnokjkauk fuoM izfdz;se/;s ns.;kr vkysY;k xq.kkaP;k izk/kkU;o:u vls fnlwu ;srs dh] ckgsjhy ¼LFkykarjhr½ mesnokjkauk R;kaP;k ukokapk fu;qfDrckcr fopkj gks.;kiklwu oxG.;kr vkys uOgrs- mRrjoknh gs nknjk o uxj gosyh g;k dsanz'kkflr izns'kkrhy jfgoklh vlY;kps vk<Gwu vkys vkgs vkf.k tjh rs xqtjkr jkT;ke/kwu LFkykarjhr >kysys vlys] rjh ns[khy fu;qfDrdfjrk vkjf{kr izoxkZrhy mesnokj Eg.kwu
R;kaP;k ukokpk fopkj gks.;kl ik= gksrs- lnj fu”d”kkZP;k vk/kkjsp] mPp
U;k;ky;kus vihydrkZ ;kauk vls funs'k fnys dh] R;kauh mRrjoknh ;kauk] lnj fuoMizfdz;se/kwu fu;qDr >kysY;k brj mesnokjkaP;k fu;qfDr fnukadkiklwup] lgk¸;d eksVkj okgu fufj{kd g;k inkoj fu;qDr djkos-
5½ vihydrkZ ;kaP;korhus cktw ekaM.kkÚ;k fo}ku odhykauh fofo/k ifji=dkapk lanHkZ fnyk] T;krwu dsanz'kkflr izns'kkps vls /kksj.k fun'kZukl ;srs dh vkj{k.k gs LFkykarj d:u vkysY;k O;fDrauk ukgh rj
QDr LFkkfud O;fDraukp ykxw vkgs- R;kauh vlk ;qfDrokn dsyk dh] dsoG dsanz'kkflr izns'kke/;s vf/kokl vl.kkÚ;k O;fDrp vkj{k.kkpk ykHk feG.;klkBh nkok d: 'kdrkr- R;kaP;k erkuqlkj] ,[kk|k O;fDrps
uko vuqlwfpr tekrhe/kwu ,[kk|k lkoZtfud inkoj fu;qfDrlkBh fopkjkr ?ks.;kdjhrk lnj O;fDr dsanz'kkflr izns'kke/;s fdeku 10 ¼ngk½ o”kZs okLrO;kl vlyh ikfgts- dsanz'kkflr izns'kkdMwu mRrjoknhP;k fu;qfDrl udkj ns.;kP;k d`rhps leFkZu dj.;kdfjrk R;akuh] izLrqr
U;k;ky;kus] egkjk”Vª jkT;krhy vuqlwfpr tkrh vkf.k vuqlwfpr tekrh ;kauk tkr izek.ki= tkjh dj.;klanHkkZrhy d`rh lferh o brj fo:/n Hkkjrkps la?kjkT; vkf.k brj] ,l~- iq”ik vkf.k brj fo:/n f'kokpu~eqxkosyw vkf.k brj iqMwpsjh 'ksM;wYM dkLV ihiy osy~Qsvj vlksfl,'ku fo:/n 'kklukps eq[; lfpo] ik¡Mspjh dsanz'kkflr izns'k vkf.k brj] o chj flax fo:/n fnYyh ty eaMG vkf.k brj g;k nkO;kae/;s fnysY;k U;k;fu.kZ;kaoj vkiyh fHkLr Bsoyh vkgs-
6½ mRrjoknh ;kaP;korhus cktw ekaM.kkÚ;k fo}ku ofj”B odhykauh] dsanz'kkflr izns'kkus tkjh dsysY;k dk;kZy;hu Kkiukpk lanHkZ nsÅu vlk
;qfDrokn dsyk dh] lnj Kkiuke/kwu vls Li”Vi.ks fun'kZukl ;srs dh] brj jkT;akrhy vuqlwfpr tekrhe/khy mesnokjkauk jk[kho izoxkZrhy lkoZtfud inkaoj fu;qfDrlkBh fopkj dj.;kiklwu oxG.;kr vkysys ukgh- LFkkfud mesnokjkauk izk/kkU;kpk tks ykHk ns.;kr vkysyk gksrk rksp ykHk vuqlwfpr tekrhrhy mesnokjkauk lq/nk ykxw gksrks- pkj mesnokjkaiSdh ts mesnokj ik+= vlY;kps vk<Gwu vkys vkf.k ts mesnokj ys[kh ijh{kse/;s lgHkkxh >kys gksrs] R;kiSdh mRrjoknh ;kauh lokZr tkLr xq.k izkIr dsys gksrs vkf.k rs g;k U;k;ky;kus fu/kkZfjr d:u fnysY;k dk;|kuqlkj vukjf{kr inkoj fu;qfDrhlkBh ik= Bjys gksrs- fnukad
¼1½
¼2½
¼3½ ¼4½
26-12-2013 jksthP;k dk;kZy;hu Kkiukuqlkj lq/nk] tks xV ^d* e/khy inkaoj ljGlsok Hkjrh'kh lacaf/kr vkgs] vuqlwfpr tekrhe/khy mesnokj]
T;kaph fuoM R;kaP;k Lor%P;k xq.koRrsoj dks.kR;kgh ekudkP;k f'kfFkyrsf'kok; >kysyh gksrh] R;kaph [kqY;k izoxkZlkBh osxG;k] jk[kwu
BsoysY;k inkoj fu;qDr dj.;kr ;sbZy- fo}ku ofj”B odhykauh vlk
;qfDrokn dsyk dh] vlk LFkkfir dk;nk vkgs dh] dsanz'kkflr izns'kkrhy jfgoklh gk vkjf{kr izoxkZrhy mesnokj Eg.kwu lkoZtfud inkoj fu;qDrhlkBh fopkj gks.;kl gDdnkj vkgs- rks LFkykarj d:u vkysyk vkgs g;k ,deso dkj.kklkBh R;kyk vkjf{kr izoxkZrhy mesnokj gk ntkZ feG.;kiklwu oafpr Bsork ;s.kkj ukgh- vls lknj fuosnu dj.;kr vkys dh] tkfgjkrhP;k fnukadkP;k lgk o”ksZ vxksnj iklwu mRrjoknh gs dsanz'kkflr izns'kke/;s jgkr gksrs ;kckcrhr dks.krkgh la'k; ukgh- R;kauh]
^iq”ik* ¼lqizk½ g;k izdj.kke/;s ikjhr dsysY;k dk;n;kP;k pkSdVhl dks.krkgh /kDd ykxysyk ukgh gk ;qDrhokn iVowu ns.;klkBh g;kp
U;k;ky;kus fcj flax ¼lqizk½ g;k izdj.kke/;s ikjhr dsysY;k U;k;fu.kZ;kpk nk[kyk fnyk vkgs-
7½ jkT;?kVuk ¼nknjk o uxj gosyh½ vuqlwfpr tekrh vkns'k]
1962 vUo;s ek- jk”Vªirhuh] nknjk o uxj gosyh g;k dsanz'kkflr izns'kkP;k ckcrhr] R;k dsanz'kkflr izns'kke/;s okLrO;kl vl.kkÚ;k jfgok'kkaP;k laca/kkr ^/kksfM;k* gh tkr vuqlwfpr tekr vlY;kps ?kksf”kr dsys vkgs- fnukad 10-07-1995 jksth vihydrkZ ;kauh ,d ifji=d tkjh d:u R;k}kjs fnukad 01-01-1990 iwohZ fu;qDr >kysY;k O;fDraP;k
ckcrhr] ljdkjh dk;kZy;kae/;s vuqlwfpr tkrh@vuqlwfpr tekrhaP;k mesnokjkauk vkj{k.kkpk ykHk feG.ks rlsp pkyw jkghy o Hkfo”;ke/;s gks.kkÚ;k fu;qD;kaP;k ckcrhr Lora=i.ks fu.kZ; ?ks.;kr ;sbZy] vls
?kksf”kr dsys- fnukad 01-09-2006 jksthP;k dk;kZy;hu Kkiukuqlkj] nknjk o uxj gosyh g;k dsanz'kkflr izns'kkP;k iz'kkluke/;s vf/kokl vl.kkÚ;k vuqlwfpr tkrh@vuqlwfpr tekrhaPkk jk[kho izoxkZrhy lkoZtfud inkaoj fu;qfDrdfjrk fopkj dj.;kr ;sbZy vls uewn dj.;kr vkys gksrs- lnjph vf/klwpuk gh xV ^d* o xV ^M* e/khy inkaoj ljGlsosus HkjrhP;k lanHkkZr gksrh- lkoZtfud {ks=krhy inkaoj fu;qD;kalkBh vl.kkjk vkj{k.kkpk ykHk gk] dsanz'kkflr izns'kklkBh ykxw vl.kkÚ;k vf/klwpuse/;s varZHkwr dsysY;k tkrh@tekrhadfjrkp e;kZfnr vlsy ;kpk iqu:Ppkj djrkauk] fnukad 13-01-2013 jksth x`gea=ky;kyk fyfgysY;k i=k}kjs vls dGfo.;kr vkys vkgs dh] LFkkfudkauk vxzde@izk/kkU; ns.;kr ;sbZy-
;ke/;s dks.krsgh nqer ukgh dh lnjpk vxzdze gk [kqY;k rlsp vkjf{kr izoxkZrhy mesnokjkaP;k ckcrhr ykxw vlsy- Hkkjr ljdkjus] ^c*] ^d*] vkf.k ^M* xVkae/khy inkaoj ljGlsok Hkjrhe/;s LFkkfud O;fDrauk fo'ks”k loyr@izk/kkU; ns.;kckcrP;k izLrkokyk eatwjh fnysyh vkgs- Hkkjr ljdkjps vls er gksrs dh] laiw.kZ vkj{k.k gs LFkkfud O;fDrukap ns.ks gs vlkafo/kkfud gksbZy- R;kaurj nknjk o uxj gosyh g;k dsanz'kkflr izns'kkus vlk fu.kZ; ?ksryk dh] lnj dsanz'kkflr izns'kke/;s] [kqY;k vkf.k vkjf{kr v'kk nksUgh izoxkZae/kwu izoxZ ¼xV½ ^d* e/khy inkaoj ljGlsosus Hkjrh gksrkuk LFkkfud ukxfjdkauk 20 vfrfjDr xq.kkaph fo'ks”k loyr ns.;kr
;sbZy- tkfgjkrhe/;s uewn dsY;kuqlkj] vkjf{kr izoxkZe/kwu vtZ dj.kkÚ;k mesnokjkus l{ke izkf/kdkÚ;kadMwu tkjh dj.;kr vkysys izek.ki= lknj dj.ks vko';d gksrs- rlsp loZ Hkkjrh; ukxfjd lgk¸;d eksVkj okgu fufj{kd ;k inkoj fuoM gks.;klkBh vtZ dj.;klkBh ik= gksrs vkf.k
LFkkfudkauk ns.;kr ;s.kkÚ;k fo'ks”k loyrhckcr mesnokjkauk dGfo.;kr vkys gksrs-
8- ekjh panz'ks[kj jko fo:/n vf/k”Bkrk] lsB th- ,l- oS|dh; egkfo|ky; vkf.k brj ;k izdj.kke/khy ;kfpdkdrkZ gk gs vka/kzizns'kkrhy
^xkSMk* g;k tkrhrhy gksrs] thyk lnj jkT;kdjhrk] jk”Vªirha}kjs tkjh dsysY;k vkns'kke/;s] vuqlwfpr tekr Eg.kwu ekU;rk ns.;kr vkysyh vkgs- R;kus egkjk”Vª jkT;krhy oS|dh; egkfo|ky;kr izos'k feG.kslkBh vtZ dsyk gksrk vkf.k vkj{k.kkps ykHk feG.kslkBh ekx.kh dsyh gksrh- ek- jk”VªirhaP;k egkjk”Vª jkT;kdjhrk tkjh dsysY;k vkns'kke/;s ^^xkSMk** gh tkr vuqlwfpr tekr Eg.kwu ekU;rk izkIr uOgrh vkf.k ;kp dkj.kkP;k vk/kkjs R;kyk vkj{k.kkps ykHk ukdkj.;kr vkys- ;k U;k;ky;kus vlk fu.kZ; fnyk dh] ek jk”Vªirha}kjs egkjk”Vª jkT;kdfjrk tkjh dsysY;k vkns'kke/;s R;kP;k lektkpk vuqlwfpr tekrhe/;s lekos'k dsysyk ulY;keqGs R;kyk egkjk”Vª jkT;ke/;s vkj{k.kkpk ykHk feG.;klkBh nkok dj.;klkBh dks.krkgh dk;ns'khj vf/kdkj izkIr gksr ukgh-
9- fuoM Js.kh f'k{kd ;kaph f'k{k.k lapyuky;] ikaW¡Mspsjh
'kklu ;kauh dsysyh fu;qfDr gk] g;k U;k;ky;kus] ,l- iq”ik ¼lqizk½ g;k izdj.kkr fnysY;k U;k;fu.kZ;kpk okn fo”k; gksrk- loZlk/kkj.k dsanzh; lsok]
¼5½
xV ^d* e/;s fuoM Js.kh f'k{kdkaph 350 ins Hkjrh dj.ks ckcrph tkfgjkr ns.ksr vkyh gksrh- R;kiSdh 56 ins gh vuqlwfpr tkrhP;k mesnokjkalkBh vkjf{kr Bso.;kr vkyh gksrh- ik¡Mspsjh g;k dsanz 'kkflr izns'kkrhy ;sue vkf.k ekgs g;k izkarkae/;s vuqlwfpr tkrhps mesnokj iqjs';k la[;sr miyC/k ulY;keqGs( rkfeGukMw] vka/kz izns'k vkf.k dsjG ;k jkT;karhy toGP;k lsok;kstu dk;kZy;kar uksan.kh dsysY;k mesnokjkauk ns[khy iqjLd`r dj.skr vkys gksrs- R;ke/;s] brj jkT;krwu LFkykarjhr
>kysYkk vuqlwfpr tkrhrhy mesnokj gk ik¡Mspsjh ;k dsanz'kkflr izns'kkrhy vuqlwfpr tkrhrhy mesnokjklkBh vkjf{kr BsoysY;k inkoj fu;qDr dj.;klkBh ik= vkgs dk vlk iz'u fopkjkFkZ iq<s vkyk gksrk- ;k ckcrhr] dsanzh; iz'kkldh; U;k;kf/kdj.kkps vls er gksrs dh] ik¡Mspsjh
'kklukP;k lsosrhy lsok;kstusP;k izdj.kkr LFkykarjhr gksÅu vkysys mesnokj vkj{k.kkP;k ykHkkph ekx.kh dj.ksdjhrk gDdnkj vl.kkj ukghr- ijarq] g;k U;k;ky;kus] ik¡Mspsjh g;k dsanz'kkflr izns'kkrhy vuqlwphr tkrhlkBh vkjf{kr BsoysY;k tkxkaoj LFkykarjhr gksÅu vkysY;k vuqlwphr tkrhP;k mesnokjkaph fuoM o fu;qDrh djrkauk Hkkjrh; jkT;?kVusrhy dks.kR;kgh rjrwnhps mYya?ku >kysys ukgh vls vHkh{k.k ukasnowu dsanzh; iz'kkldh; U;k;f/kdj.kkus fnysyk U;k;fu.kZ; fQjfoyk-
10- ik¡Mspsjh 'kklukP;k orhus tkjh dsysY;k 'kkldh; vkns'kke/;s egkfo|ky;kae/;s izos'kklaca/kkr ns.;kr vkysy;k vkj{k.kkpk ykHk gk dsoG dsanz 'kkflr izns'kke/;s eqyr% jkgkr vl.kkÚ;k vuwlwfpr tkrhrhy mesnokjkalkBh ns.;kr vkyk gksrk- Hkkjrh; jkT;?kVusP;k vuqPNsn
341¼1½ vkf.k 342 ¼2½ vUo;s tkjh dj.;kr vkysY;k vf/klwpusPkk lanHkZ nsrkauk] g;k U;k;ky;kus] iqMwpsjh ¼ik¡Mspsjh½ vuqlwfpr tkr tudY;k.k la?k ¼lqizk½ ;k izdj.kkr vlk fu.kZ; fnyk vkgs dh] dk;Zdkjh
'kfDaruk ¼vf/kdkÚ;kauk½ jk”Vªirha}kjs tkjh vkns'kke/;s nq:Lrh] Qsjcny]
QsjQkj vkf.k Qjd dj.;kl ijokuxh ukgh- lnj U;k;fu.kZ;ke/;s g;k
U;k;ky;kus vlk fu.kZ; fnyk vkgs dh] dk;Zdkjh vkns'kkus] jk”VªirhaP;k vkns'kkrhy jfgok'kh ;k 'kCnk,soth ^ewG* vlk 'kCn nk[ky dj.ks gs d`R; ns[khy jk”VªirhaP;k vkns'kkr cny dj.;klkj[ksp vkgs vkf.k v'kk d`R;kl ijokuxh nsrk ;s.kkj ukgh-
11- ,[kk|k fof'k”V jkT;krhy vuqlwfpr tkrhP;k mesnokjkauk nqlÚ;k jkT;ke/;s ykHk o loyrh ns.;klanHkZkr vlysyh erfHkUurk fopkjkr ?ksÅu] lnjps izdj.k ?kVukihBkdMs fopkjkFkZ ikBfo.;kr vkys gksrs- fcjk flax ¼lqizk½ g;k izdj.kke/;s] g;k U;k;ky;kps vls er gksrs dh] ,l~- iq”ik ¼lqizk½ ;k izdj.kkr O;Dr dj.ksr vkysY;k n`f”Vdks.kkoj iquZfopkj dj.ksph vko';drk ukgh- ?kVukihBkus ;kpkgh Bkei.ks iqu:Ppkj dsyk dh] ¼jkT;?kVusP;k½ vuqPNsn 341 vkf.k 342 vUo;s tkjh dj.ksr vkysY;k jk”VªirhaP;k vf/klwpuse/;s Qsjcny fdaok QsjQkj dk;Zdkjh
¼vf/kdkjh½ d: 'kdr ukghr- ojhy ppsZpk ifj.kke vlk dh ,[kknh vuqlwfpr tkr vFkok vuqlwfpr tekr] th ek- jk”VªirhadMwu ,[kkn;k dsanz'kklhr izns'kklkBh vf/klwfpr dsyh tkrs] R;k tkrh vFkok tekrhe/khy O;Drh frpk vkjf{kr mesnokj Eg.kwu fopkj dj.ksl gDdnkj vkgs] ek= v'kh O;fDr lnj dsanz'kkflr izns'kkrhy jfgok'kh vlkoh-
12½ g;k izdj.kke/;s dks.krsgh nqer ukgh dh] mRrjoknh gs tkfgjkrhP;k rkj[ksP;k lgk o”kZs vxksnjiklwu nknjk vkf.k uxjgosyh g;k dsanz'kkflr izns'kkrhy jfgok'kh gksrs- R;kauh ;kfpdse/;s vls dFku dsys vkgs dh] R;kaph Lor%P;k ekydhPkh lnfudk vlwu rs R;k lnfudse/;s jgkr vkgsr] vkf.k R;kauh R;kp dsanz'kkflr izns'kkrhy ^^/kksMh;k** tekrh e/khy efgys'kh fookg dsyk vkgs- R;kauh iq<s vls dFku dsys vkgs dh] lnj dsanz 'kkflr izns'kklkBhP;k ernkj ;knhe/;s R;kaps uko uewn vkgs- vihydrsZ ;kauh gh oLrwfLFkrh ukdkjysyh ukgh- vfiydrsZ ;kauh ek- mPp
U;k;ky;kleksj mifLFkr dsysyk eq[; eq|k vlk gksrk dh] mesnokj gk dsanz'kkflr izns'kkrhy LFkkfud O;Drh vlyk ikfgts ;kpkp vFkZ vlk dh] LFkykarjhr vuqlwfpr tekrhauk vkj{k.kkpk ykHk nsrk ;sÅ 'kd.kkj ukgh- nknjk vkf.k uxj gosyh g;k dsanz'kkflr izns'kkalkBh tkjh dsysyh ek- jk”Vªirhaph vf/klwpuk vkj{k.kkpk ykHk gk R;ke/;s uewn vuqlwfpr tekrhauk R;kaps ewG g;k vk/kkjs nsr ulwu jfgoklkP;k vk/kkjs nsrs- nknjk vkf.k uxj gosyh g;k dsanz'kkflr izns'kkrhy vuqlwfpr tekrhlkBh vlysys vkj{k.k gs LFkykarjhr vuqlwfpr tekrhalkBh miyC/k ukgh] g;k vfiydrsZ ;kaP;k fon~oku odhy ;kauh ekaMYksY;k eqn~n;ke/;s vkEgkyk dks.krkgh izHkko vk<Gyk ukgh- vkj{k.kkP;k ykHkklkBh nkok dj.kkÚ;k
O;Drhpk 10 o”ksZ jfgokl vl.ks vko';d vkgs vls vfiydrsZ ;kaP;k orhus cktw ekaM.kkÚ;k ofdykauh lkax.;kpk nqcGk iz;Ru dsyk- lnj
;qDrhoknkP;k iq”VFkZ ek- mPp U;k;ky;kP;k vfHkys[kkoj dks.krkgh iqjkok lknj dj.ksr vkyk ukgh vkf.k r'kk izdkjps n`< fo/kku ;kfpdsr nk[ky
dj.;kr vkysY;k izfr 'kiFki=ke/;s nk[ky dj.;kr vkysys ukgh- gk eqn~nk ek- mPp U;k;ky;kleksj mifLFkr dj.;kr vkysyk ukgh- vkf.k rls dkj.k fo'ks”k vuqerh ;kfpdsr ns.ksr vkysys ukgh] T;keqGs lnj dFkukP;k xq.kkoxq.kkpk fopkj djrk ;s.kkj ukgh- vkEgh ikfjr dj.kslkBh izLrkfor dsysY;k vkns'kkpk fopkj djrk mRrjoknh ;kaps fon~oku ofj”B odhy
;kauh ;qfDroknke/;s lknj dsysY;k brj eq|kadMs funsZ'k dj.;kph xjt ukgh- HkkjrkP;k la?kjkT;kus lYyk fnysyk vlrkuk vkf.k vuqlwphr tekrhlkBhP;k jk”Vªh; vk;ksxkus funsZ'k tkjh dsysys vlrkauk nsf[ky] mRRkjoknh ;kaph fu;qDrh u dj.;kph d`rh d:u vfiydrsZ ;kauh mRrjoknhaoj ?kksj vU;k; dsyk vkgs- mRrjoknh ;kaph lgk¸;d eksVkj okgu fufj{kd Eg.kwu use.kwd gks.;kr ;kiq<s dks.krhgh fnjaxkbZ lgu dsyh tk.kkj ukgh-
13- mPp U;k;ky;kP;k U;k;fu.kZ;ke/;s gLr{ksi dj.;klkBh vkeP;kdMs dks.krsgh dkj.k ukgh vkf.k R;keqGs vfiy QsVkG.ksr ;sr vkgs-
--------U;k;k/kh'k
¼,y- ukxs'ojk jko½ uoh fnYyh --------U;k;k/kh'k es 07] 2019 ¼,e- vkj- 'kgk½ udkj (fMl~Dysej)
“;k U;k;fu.kZ;kP;k ejkBh Hkk”ksrhy ;k vuqoknkpk okij gk i{kdkjkl R;kP;k@ frP;k ekr`Hkk”kse/;s R;kpk vFkZ letwu ?ks.;kiqjrkp
e;kZfnr jkghy vkf.k R;kpk brj dks.kR;kgh dkj.kkdfjrk okij djrk
;s.kkj ukgh- rlsp] baxzth Hkk”ksrhy U;k;kfu.kZ; gkp loZ O;kogkfjd vkf.k dk;kZy;hu okijkdfjrk fo'oluh; vlsy vkf.k rksp R;krhy vkns'kkP;k fu”iknu vkf.k vaeyctko.khdfjrk oS/k ekuyk tkbZy-”
DISCLAIMER
“The Translated
JUDGMENT
in vernacular language is meant for the restricted use of the litigant to understand it in his/her language and may not be used for any other purpose. For all practical and official purposes, the English version of the judgment shall be authentic and shall hold the field for the purpose of execution and implementation”.
XXXXXX