Full Text
Gkos dh ;[gohw e'oN ftZu eohwhBb$|"idkoh nghb nfXeko y/so
(CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION) eohwhBb$|"idkoh nghb (CRIMINAL APPEAL) Bzpo 1090$2019
(n?;Hn?bHghH(eohwhBb$c"idkoh Bzpo 8293$2018 ftZu'A T[sgzB j'Jh)
(Arising out of SLP(Crl.) No. 8293 of 2018) wBihs f;zx nghb eosk(tK) pBkw gzikp oki ns/ j'o
T[Zsotkdh(nK) fBoDK
(
(
(
(
JUDGMENT
2H fJj nghb gzikp ns/ jfonkDk jkJh e'oN uzvhrV d[nkok ;kb 2003 dh eohwhBb$|"idkoh nghb Bzpo^ n?;H^1964^n?;HphH^2003 (Criminal Appeal No. S-1964-
SB of 2003) ftZu 02$05$2017 B{z fdZs/ rJ/ fBoD/ ns/ j[ew s'A g?dk j'Jh j? fi; d[nkok jkJh e'oN B/ d'Ph oDihs f;zx B{z PZe dk bkG d/ e/ poh ehsk ;h, go nghb eosk wBihs f;zx
B{z NokfJb e'oN d[nkok fdZsh rJh ;Ik dh g[PNh ehsh rJh ns/ T[;B{z e?d dh ;Ik ;[DkJh rJh. jkJh e'oN B/ I[owkB/ dh oew B{z 1000$^ o[gJ/ s'A tXk e/ 50,000$^ o[gJ/ eo fdZsk ns/ Bkb jh fJj oew fPekfJs eosk^jodhg f;zx B{z w[nktI/ ti'A d/D d/ j[ew fdZs/.
3H fJ;srk;/ dk e/; fJj j? fe 04$06$2001 B{z Pkw 5L30 ti/ id'A fPekfJs eosk^jodhg f;zx (ghHvpb:{^1) nkgD/ ;e{No s'A pZ; nZv/ s'A nkgD/ fgzv prhnkoh tkg;
4H fPekfJs eosk$Iywh ftnesh ns/ d{i/ rtkjK d/ fpnkBK B{z ftukod/ j'J/, NokfJb e'oN B/ d'Ph^wBihs f;zx ns/ T[;d/ Gok^oDihs f;zx B{z Gkosh dzv ;zxsk dh Xkok 307 sfjs d'Ph gkfJnk ns/ jo/e B{z gzi ;kb dh ;ys e?d ns/ 1000$^ o[gJ/ I[owkB/ dh ;Ik
;[DkJh. Gkosh dzv ;zxsk dh Xkok 324 d/ sfjs ;Ik :'r ngokX bJh T[BQK B{z d' ;kb dh
;yas ;ik ;[DkJh rJh. NokfJb e'oN B/ d'Ph^dftzdo f;zx B{z PZe dk bkG fdzfdnK poh eo fdZsk. nghb ftZu jkJh e'oN B/ nghb eosk B{z d'Ph mfjokT[D ns/ d'Ph^wBihs f;zx B{z fdZsh rJh ;ik dh g[PNh ehsh. jkbKfe, jkJh e'oN B/ d'Ph oDihs f;zx B{z fJj efj e/ poh eo fdZsk fe T[;d/ fybkc brkJ/ rJ/ d'P tkip PZe s'A go/ ;kps BjhA j[zd/. fBokP j' e/ d'Ph^wBihs f;zx B/ fJ; nghb B{z soihj fdZsh.
5H nghb dh ;w{bhns d"okB, fJj fejk frnk j? fe fXoK B/ ;wM"sk eo fbnk j?. nghb eosk^d'Ph d/ wkD:'r tehb ns/ fPekfJs eosk^jodhg f;zx B/ nkgD/ tehb PqhwkB r'gkb f;zx tehb okjhA 15 i[bkJh, 2019 B{z fJZe jb|Bkwk dkfJo ehsk j?, fi; ftZu fJj fejk frnk j? fe fXoK B/ wkwb/ ftZu ;wM"sk eo fbnk j?. nghb eosk^d'Ph B/ 29 wJh,
2019 B{z fXoK ftueko j'J/ ;wM"s/ Bkw/ B{z th dkfJo ehsk j?. 6H Gkosh dzv ;zxsk dh Xkok 307 fJZe r?o okIhBkw/ ekpb ngokX nXhB nkT[Adh j?. fXoK d/ ftueko j'J/ ;wM"s/ B{z doI eoB dh fJikIs BjhA fdZsh ik ;edh. JhPto f;zx pBkw wZX gqd/P oki, (2008) 15 n?;H;hH;hH 667 e/; ftZu, Gkos dh wkD:'r ;[gohw e'oN B/ fejk ;h fe fJZe r?o^okIhBkw/ ekpb ngokX ftZu j'fJnk ;wM"sk n;b ftZu ;zpzXs jkbks j?, fi; B{z e'oN d[nkok ;Ik dh fwedko ftukoB bJh fXnkB ftZu oZfynk ik ;edk j?. JhPto f;zx(;[gok) e/; ftZu fdZs/ rJ/ fBoD/ d/ g?oQk Bzpo (13) ns/ (14) ftZu fJ; e'oN B/ j/m nB[;ko fejk j?L^
“ 13H i/mk okw pBkw oki;EkB oki, (2006)9 n?;H;hH;hH 255, w[o{r/;B pBkw rDgsh t/bo, (2001), 10 n?;H;hH;hH 504 ns/ JhPto bkb pBkw wZX gqd/P oki, (2008) 15 n?;H;hH;hH 671 e/; ftZu fJ; e'oN B/ fXoK ftueko j'J/ ;wM"s/ B{z fXnkB ftZu oZyfdnK j'fJnK, nghb eosk^d'Ph B{z fdZsh rJh ;ik dh fwedko xNk fdZsh rJh i' fe d'Ph eZN u[Zfenk ;h, jkbKfe ngokX okIhBkw/ ekpb BjhA ;B, go wj/P uzd pBkw oki;EkB oki (Mahesh Chand Vs. State of Rajasthan, 1990 Supp. SCC 681 ) ftZu th fejk frnk ;h fe nfij/ ngokXK B{z okIhBkw/ ekpb eoB dk j[ew fdZsk frnk ;h. 14H ;kv/ ftuko ftZu, ;zxsk d/ nXhB ekBz{Bh ftt;EktK B{z BIo^nzdki ns/ fJZe gk;/ oZyfdnK j'fJnK, fJZe r?o^okIhBkw/ ekpb ngokX B{z okIhBkw/ ekpb ngokX dh Pq/Dh ftZu eoB dk j[ew eoBk mhe BjhA j't/rk. ;kv/ fBoD/ ftZu, fco th, nghb eosk d/ wkD:'r tehb d[nkok oZyh rJh ;hws g/PeP ftuko eoB :'r j? fe tk;sfte ;Ik fdzd/ j'J/, fXoK d/ ftueko j'J/ ;wM's/ dk sZE, n;b ftZu ;zpzXs jkbks j?, fi;B{z e'oN fXnkB ftZu oZy ;edk j?.@ 7H fit/A fe gfjbK dZf;nk frnk j?, w"i{dk e/; ftZu, nghbeosk^wBihs f;zx B{z gzi ;kb dh ;yas ;ik fdZsh rJh j?. fJj fejk frnk j? fe nghb eosk B/ ;skoK wjhB/ dh e?d eZNh j?. fXoK d/ ftueko j'J/ ;wM"s/ B{z fXnkB ftZu oZyd/, fXoK d/ ;zpzXK ns/ e/; d/ sZEK ns/ jkbksK B{z ftukod/ j'J/ ns/ nghb eosk^d'Ph d[nkok eZNh ;Ik B{z th fXnkB ftZu oZyd/ j'J/, d'Ph B{z Gkosh dzv ;zxsk dh Xkok 307 ns/ 324 sfjs fdZsh rJh ;Ik B{z gzi ;kbK$d' ;kbK s'A T[; d[nkok gfjbK jh eZNh ik u[eh ;Ik sZe xNkfJnk iKdk j?. nghb eosk B{z fJ; Pos s/ s[ozs svZD d/ j[ew fdZs/ iKd/ jB fe T[;dh jkIoh fe;/ e/; ftZu b'VhAdh Bk j't/. fXoK ftueko j'J/ ;wM"s/ B{z d/yd/ j'J/, nghb eosk T[Zs/ brkJ/ rJ/ 50000$^ o[gJ/ d/ I[owkB/ B{z ykoi ehsk iKdk j?. i/eo T[es I[owkBk gfjbK jh ndk eo fdZsk frnk j? sK T[j nghb eosk^wBihs f;zx B{z tkg; eo fdZsk ikt/rk. 8H nghb nzfPe s"o s/ wBI{o ehsh iKdh j?. HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHiZi nkoHpB{wkEh HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHJ (R.BANUMATHI) HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHiZi J/Hn?;Hp'gzBk .........................J (A.S.BOPANNA) BthA fdZbh, 22 i[bkJh, 2019
fv;eb/wo:-;EkBe GkPk ftZu nB[tkd ehsk frnk fBnK fBoDK e/tb w[eZdw/pkIk bJh T[jBK dh nkgDh GkPk ftu ;wMD sZe jh ;hws j? ns/ fJ;dk fe;/ j'o T[d/P bJh fJ;s/wkb BjhA ehsk ik ;edk. ;ko/ ftjkoe ns/ nfXekos wzstk bJh, fBnK fBoD/ dk nzro/Ih ;z;eoD gqwkfDe j't/rk ns/ nwb bkr{ eoB bJh fJ; B{z soihj fdZsh ikt/rh. Translated by Ms. Sangeeta, Translator. Typed by Sh. Ajay Abbot.