339ffeb708f1f279a6e2ca9d1e04b22a14dd80abd142271ecacd0ac3e012e2d2

UNKNOWN COURT · 31 Oct 2019
A.S. Bopana
Criminal Appeal No 556 of 2009
2019 INSC 843
criminal appeal_dismissed

AI Summary

The court upheld the conviction and sentence of the appellant for murder under Section 302 IPC based on credible eyewitness and medical evidence.

Full Text
Translation output
fv;eb/wo:-;EkBe GkPk ftZu nB[tkd ehsk frnk fBnK fBoDK e/tb w[eZdw/pkIk bJh T[jBK dh nkgDh GkPk ftu ;wMD sZe jh ;hws j? ns/ fJ;dk fe;/ j'o T[d/P bJh fJ;s/wkb BjhA ehsk ik ;edk. ;ko/ ftjkoe ns/ nfXekos wzstk bJh, fBnK fBoD/ dk nzro/Ih ;z;eoD gqwkfDe j't/rk ns/ nwb bkr{ eoB bJh fJ; B{z soihj fdZsh ikt/rh. r?o^ r?o^ r?o^ r?o^fog'oN:'r fog'oN:'r fog'oN:'r fog'oN:'r
Gkos dh ;[gohw e'oN ftZu c"I c"I c"I c"Idkoh dkoh (
(Criminal) nghb nfXeko y/so c"Idkoh nghb Bz(s) 556 of 2009
;kfjp f;zx nghb eosk pBkw gzikp oki
(gqfstkdh) fBoDK
(
(
(
(
JUDGMENT
)
J/Hn?;Hp'gz
J/Hn?;Hp'gzBk, Bk, iZi ( iZi (A.S.BOPANA, J.)

(1) nghbeosk efofwBb nghb Bz 499 of 2005 fwsh 23H01H2008 gzikp ns/ jfonkDk jkJh e'oN, uzvhrVQ dh iZiw?AN B{z u?b/Ai eo fojk j?. jkJh e'oN B/ T[Zes iZiw?AN okjhA;?PB e/; Bzpo 20 of 2002 fwsh 22H02H2005 dh iZiw?AN B{z poeoko oZfynk. d't/A ndkbsK B/ fJZe' fijh iZiw?AN okjhA nghbeosk B{z Xkok 326 nkJhHghH;hH sfjs;Ik:'r ngokX bJh d'Ph mfjokfJnk j?.;Ik dh;[DtkJh s/, jkJh e'oN B/ j'o gfjb{nK dk B'fN; b?Ad/ j'J/ ns/ fJj fXnkB ftZu oZyfdnK fe nghbeok B/ gfjbK jh gzi;kb s'A tZX dh n;b e?d eZNh j? s/ fJj jh ekch j?. jkJh e'oN B/ 20,000$^ dh oew dk w[nktIk th brkfJnk j?. d[yh j' e/, nghbeosk;kv/;kjwD/ fJ; nghb ftZu j?. (2) n;hA Pqh;ePw wj/Ptoh i' nghbeosk tb'A g/P j'J/ dh;bkj pko/;[fDnk j?. n;hA Pqhwsh i;gqhs r'rhnk i' gqshtkdh^oki tb'A g/P j'J/ tehb jB B{z th;[fDnk j? ns/ u?b/Ai ehsh j'Jh iZiw?AN ns/ foekov s/;p{s pko/ th gfVQnk j?. 2019 INSC 843 (3) sZEK d/ fpnkB s'A fJj t/fynk iKdk j? fe fJZe n?cHnkJhHnkoH fJ; nkXko s/ doi j'Jh;h fe fwsh 26H01H2002 B{z 5H30 P.M. ti/ id'A fPekfJseosk^irho f;zx (PW-3) nkgD/ fwqse Gok jopz; f;zx Bkb;c?d/ d/ doZys B/V/ fgzv d/ pkjo nkgD/ fNT{pt?b s/ yVQk;h, d'Ph T[ZE/ jfEnkoK Bkb nkJ/ ns/ fwqse s/ jwbk eo fdZsk. fJ;/ d/ nkXko s/ ekB{zB nB[;ko ekotkJh ehsh rJh ns/ nghbeosk;w/s j'o w[bIwK fiBQK fybk| ekotkJh P[o{ ehsh rJh;h, ndkbs;kjwD/ g/P j'J/ ns/ T[jBK dk NokfJb ubkfJnk frnk.;oekoh tehb B/ ekotkJh ftZu;p{s g/P ehs/ jB. fJj fJ; o'PBh ftZu jh j?, NokfJb e'oN B/ fJ; gfjb{ dk B'fN; fbnk j? ns/ fJ; Bshi/ s/ gj[zfunk j? fe w[bIw fybkc yk;eo nghbeosk fybk| d'P;kps j' u[Zek j? ns/ T[; nB[;ko d'Ph eoko ehsk frnk ns/;Ik dk nkd/P fdZsk frnk;h. ndkbs d/ j[ewK s'A d[yh j'D dk dkntk eoB tkbk nghbeosk jkJh e'oN ftZu gj[zfunk. jkJh e'oN B/ d[pkok;p{sK dh Pbkxk eofdnK,;p{sK B{z ftukfonK ns/;p{sK s/ Go';k ehsk s/ T[go'es fby/ nB[;ko, f;ZN/ s/ gj[zfunk. (4) Pqh;ePw wj/Ptoh, nghbeosk tb'A g/P j'J/ tehb B/ dbhb fdZsh j? fe fJZE/ nghbeosk dk Bkw FIR ftZu BjhA fbnk frnk;h ns/ T[;;fEsh ftZu nghbeosk d'Ph B{z d'Ph mfjokT[Dk ikfJI BjhA j?. (5) jkbKfe dbhb fdZsh rJh,;zpzXs ekriks$;wroh B{z gVQB s/ y[bk;k j'fJnk j? fe nrb/ fszB fpnkBK ftZu nghbeosk dk BK feogkB oZyD bJh fbnk frnk j? ns/ fwqse jopz; f;zx s/ jwbk ehsk j?. iKu eoB s/ nghbeosk;w/s ukoI PhN dkfJo ehsh rJh;h. (6) fJ;;zpzX ftZu, fPekfJseosk^irho f;zx d[nkok dZ;/ rJ/;p{sK dk B'fN; b?Dk T[Zfus j't/rk, fi; B{z PW-3 ti'A gofynk frnk;h. j/mbh ndkbs B/ ftnkge s"o s/ T[BQK;p{sK dk jtkbk fdZsk j?, fi; ftZu irho f;zx (PW-3) B/ ftP/P s"o s/ fJZE/ nghbeosk d/ Bkw dk fIeo ehsk j?. fJ; s'A fJbktk puB f;zx (PW-4) dh rtkjh s'A fJj th y[bk;k j[zdk j? fe T[;B/ nghbeosk d/ Bkw dk fIeo ehsk j?, T[;;fEsh ftZu, jkbKfe w[bIw j'o th jB go fiE''A sZe fe nghbeosk^d'Ph dk;zpzX j?, id'A T[;dk Bkw rtkjK d[nkok fbnk frnk j?, noEks irho f;zx (PW-3) ns/ puB f;zx (PW-4), i' Iywh uPwdhd rtkj;B, fJ; jZd sZe fe nghbeosk^d'Ph feogkB Bkb b?;;h ns/ T[;d/ d[nkok ehs/ ezw pko/ j/mbh ndkbs ns/ T[Zu ndkbs B{z T[BQK d/ f;ZN/ s/ gj[zuD bJh;p{sK T[Zs/ Go';k eoB bJh IkfJI mfjokfJnk frnk;h, i/eo nukBe tkgoh xNBk B{z fXnkB ftZu fbnkfJnk iKdk j? ns/ fJZE/ nghbeosk dh G{fwek B{z fXnkB ftZu oZyd/ j'J/, T[; B{z Xkok 326 nkJhHghH;hH sfjs d'Ph mfjokfJnk frnk j? ns/ j'o;zpzXs w[bIwK B{z Xkok 302 nkJhHghH;h sfjs d'Ph mfjokfJnk frnk j?. (7) T[;;fEZsh ftZu, nghbeosk dh jkIoh, feogkB dk j'Dk ns/ T[; tb'A ehs/ rJ/ ekoi, Iywh j'D tkb/ uPwdhd rtkjK d/;p{s d[nkok;Ekgs j[zdk j?, n;hA fJ; rZb s'A;zs[PN jK fe j/mbh ndkbs d/ Bkb^Bkb jkJh e'oN B/;p{sK dk fXnkB oZyd/ j'J/;jh f;ZN/ s/ gj[zu/ jB ns/ fJ; bJh, u?b/Ai ehsh iZiw?AN d[nkok gj[zu/ f;ZN/ ftZu dyb d/D dk;kv/ e'b e'Jh ekoB BjhA j?. (8) wkwb/ d/ T[; BIohJ/ ftZu, nghb w?foN s'A ofjs j? ns/ T[; nB[;ko ykoi eo fdZsh iKdh j?. HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHi/ nkoHpB{wkEh HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHi/ (J/Hn?;Hp'gzBk) BthA fdZbh, i[bkJh 31, 2019 fv;eb/wo:-;EkBe GkPk ftZu nB[tkd ehsk frnk fBnK fBoDK e/tb w[eZdw/pkIk bJh T[jBK dh nkgDh GkPk ftu;wMD sZe jh;hws j? ns/ fJ;dk fe;/ j'o T[d/P bJh fJ;s/wkb BjhA ehsk ik;edk.;ko/ ftjkoe ns/ nfXekos wzstk bJh, fBnK fBoD/ dk nzro/Ih;z;eoD gqwkfDe j't/rk ns/ nwb bkr{ eoB bJh fJ; B{z soihj fdZsh ikt/rh. Translated by Ms. Kusum Lata, Translator. Typed by Sh. Ajay Abbot.