Full Text
Gkos dh ;[gohw e'oN ftZu c"I c"I c"I c"Idkoh dkoh (
(Criminal) nghb nfXeko y/so c"Idkoh nghb Bz(s) 556 of 2009
;kfjp f;zx nghb eosk pBkw gzikp oki
(gqfstkdh) fBoDK
(
(
(
(
JUDGMENT
J/Hn?;Hp'gz
J/Hn?;Hp'gzBk, Bk, iZi ( iZi (A.S.BOPANA, J.)
(1) nghbeosk efofwBb nghb Bz 499 of 2005 fwsh 23H01H2008 gzikp ns/ jfonkDk jkJh e'oN, uzvhrVQ dh iZiw?AN B{z u?b/Ai eo fojk j?. jkJh e'oN B/ T[Zes iZiw?AN okjhA;?PB e/; Bzpo 20 of 2002 fwsh 22H02H2005 dh iZiw?AN B{z poeoko oZfynk. d't/A ndkbsK B/ fJZe' fijh iZiw?AN okjhA nghbeosk B{z Xkok 326 nkJhHghH;hH sfjs;Ik:'r ngokX bJh d'Ph mfjokfJnk j?.;Ik dh;[DtkJh s/, jkJh e'oN B/ j'o gfjb{nK dk B'fN; b?Ad/ j'J/ ns/ fJj fXnkB ftZu oZyfdnK fe nghbeok B/ gfjbK jh gzi;kb s'A tZX dh n;b e?d eZNh j? s/ fJj jh ekch j?. jkJh e'oN B/ 20,000$^ dh oew dk w[nktIk th brkfJnk j?. d[yh j' e/, nghbeosk;kv/;kjwD/ fJ; nghb ftZu j?. (2) n;hA Pqh;ePw wj/Ptoh i' nghbeosk tb'A g/P j'J/ dh;bkj pko/;[fDnk j?. n;hA Pqhwsh i;gqhs r'rhnk i' gqshtkdh^oki tb'A g/P j'J/ tehb jB B{z th;[fDnk j? ns/ u?b/Ai ehsh j'Jh iZiw?AN ns/ foekov s/;p{s pko/ th gfVQnk j?. 2019 INSC 843 (3) sZEK d/ fpnkB s'A fJj t/fynk iKdk j? fe fJZe n?cHnkJhHnkoH fJ; nkXko s/ doi j'Jh;h fe fwsh 26H01H2002 B{z 5H30 P.M. ti/ id'A fPekfJseosk^irho f;zx (PW-3) nkgD/ fwqse Gok jopz; f;zx Bkb;c?d/ d/ doZys B/V/ fgzv d/ pkjo nkgD/ fNT{pt?b s/ yVQk;h, d'Ph T[ZE/ jfEnkoK Bkb nkJ/ ns/ fwqse s/ jwbk eo fdZsk. fJ;/ d/ nkXko s/ ekB{zB nB[;ko ekotkJh ehsh rJh ns/ nghbeosk;w/s j'o w[bIwK fiBQK fybk| ekotkJh P[o{ ehsh rJh;h, ndkbs;kjwD/ g/P j'J/ ns/ T[jBK dk NokfJb ubkfJnk frnk.;oekoh tehb B/ ekotkJh ftZu;p{s g/P ehs/ jB. fJj fJ; o'PBh ftZu jh j?, NokfJb e'oN B/ fJ; gfjb{ dk B'fN; fbnk j? ns/ fJ; Bshi/ s/ gj[zfunk j? fe w[bIw fybkc yk;eo nghbeosk fybk| d'P;kps j' u[Zek j? ns/ T[; nB[;ko d'Ph eoko ehsk frnk ns/;Ik dk nkd/P fdZsk frnk;h. ndkbs d/ j[ewK s'A d[yh j'D dk dkntk eoB tkbk nghbeosk jkJh e'oN ftZu gj[zfunk. jkJh e'oN B/ d[pkok;p{sK dh Pbkxk eofdnK,;p{sK B{z ftukfonK ns/;p{sK s/ Go';k ehsk s/ T[go'es fby/ nB[;ko, f;ZN/ s/ gj[zfunk. (4) Pqh;ePw wj/Ptoh, nghbeosk tb'A g/P j'J/ tehb B/ dbhb fdZsh j? fe fJZE/ nghbeosk dk Bkw FIR ftZu BjhA fbnk frnk;h ns/ T[;;fEsh ftZu nghbeosk d'Ph B{z d'Ph mfjokT[Dk ikfJI BjhA j?. (5) jkbKfe dbhb fdZsh rJh,;zpzXs ekriks$;wroh B{z gVQB s/ y[bk;k j'fJnk j? fe nrb/ fszB fpnkBK ftZu nghbeosk dk BK feogkB oZyD bJh fbnk frnk j? ns/ fwqse jopz; f;zx s/ jwbk ehsk j?. iKu eoB s/ nghbeosk;w/s ukoI PhN dkfJo ehsh rJh;h. (6) fJ;;zpzX ftZu, fPekfJseosk^irho f;zx d[nkok dZ;/ rJ/;p{sK dk B'fN; b?Dk T[Zfus j't/rk, fi; B{z PW-3 ti'A gofynk frnk;h. j/mbh ndkbs B/ ftnkge s"o s/ T[BQK;p{sK dk jtkbk fdZsk j?, fi; ftZu irho f;zx (PW-3) B/ ftP/P s"o s/ fJZE/ nghbeosk d/ Bkw dk fIeo ehsk j?. fJ; s'A fJbktk puB f;zx (PW-4) dh rtkjh s'A fJj th y[bk;k j[zdk j? fe T[;B/ nghbeosk d/ Bkw dk fIeo ehsk j?, T[;;fEsh ftZu, jkbKfe w[bIw j'o th jB go fiE''A sZe fe nghbeosk^d'Ph dk;zpzX j?, id'A T[;dk Bkw rtkjK d[nkok fbnk frnk j?, noEks irho f;zx (PW-3) ns/ puB f;zx (PW-4), i' Iywh uPwdhd rtkj;B, fJ; jZd sZe fe nghbeosk^d'Ph feogkB Bkb b?;;h ns/ T[;d/ d[nkok ehs/ ezw pko/ j/mbh ndkbs ns/ T[Zu ndkbs B{z T[BQK d/ f;ZN/ s/ gj[zuD bJh;p{sK T[Zs/ Go';k eoB bJh IkfJI mfjokfJnk frnk;h, i/eo nukBe tkgoh xNBk B{z fXnkB ftZu fbnkfJnk iKdk j? ns/ fJZE/ nghbeosk dh G{fwek B{z fXnkB ftZu oZyd/ j'J/, T[; B{z Xkok 326 nkJhHghH;hH sfjs d'Ph mfjokfJnk frnk j? ns/ j'o;zpzXs w[bIwK B{z Xkok 302 nkJhHghH;h sfjs d'Ph mfjokfJnk frnk j?. (7) T[;;fEZsh ftZu, nghbeosk dh jkIoh, feogkB dk j'Dk ns/ T[; tb'A ehs/ rJ/ ekoi, Iywh j'D tkb/ uPwdhd rtkjK d/;p{s d[nkok;Ekgs j[zdk j?, n;hA fJ; rZb s'A;zs[PN jK fe j/mbh ndkbs d/ Bkb^Bkb jkJh e'oN B/;p{sK dk fXnkB oZyd/ j'J/;jh f;ZN/ s/ gj[zu/ jB ns/ fJ; bJh, u?b/Ai ehsh iZiw?AN d[nkok gj[zu/ f;ZN/ ftZu dyb d/D dk;kv/ e'b e'Jh ekoB BjhA j?. (8) wkwb/ d/ T[; BIohJ/ ftZu, nghb w?foN s'A ofjs j? ns/ T[; nB[;ko ykoi eo fdZsh iKdh j?. HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHi/ nkoHpB{wkEh HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHi/ (J/Hn?;Hp'gzBk) BthA fdZbh, i[bkJh 31, 2019 fv;eb/wo:-;EkBe GkPk ftZu nB[tkd ehsk frnk fBnK fBoDK e/tb w[eZdw/pkIk bJh T[jBK dh nkgDh GkPk ftu;wMD sZe jh;hws j? ns/ fJ;dk fe;/ j'o T[d/P bJh fJ;s/wkb BjhA ehsk ik;edk.;ko/ ftjkoe ns/ nfXekos wzstk bJh, fBnK fBoD/ dk nzro/Ih;z;eoD gqwkfDe j't/rk ns/ nwb bkr{ eoB bJh fJ; B{z soihj fdZsh ikt/rh. Translated by Ms. Kusum Lata, Translator. Typed by Sh. Ajay Abbot.