8f3d02116943f9e379cce6ac7c3001dd4105eaf9970a6729aa1f4d61a0dd04e6

UNKNOWN COURT · 22 Nov 2019
8349-2017
9 (2019) 8 SCC 689
administrative petition_dismissed Significant

AI Summary

The court upheld the legality of enforcement actions under Tamil Nadu statutes, emphasizing strict compliance with procedural safeguards and dismissing the petitioner’s challenge.

Full Text
Translation output
,e;jpa cr;r ePjpkd;wk; chpikapay; nky;KiwaPl;L mjpfhutuk;g[ chpikapay; nky;KiwaPL vz;; 8349-2017 lgps;a{/vd;/ Myhy; Re;juk; /// nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;
?vjph;?
,e;J rka mwf;fl;lis eph;thfj;Jiw Mizah; kw;Wk; gyh; /// vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;fs; jPh;g;g[iu khz;g[kpF ePjpaurh; Kidth; jpU/ jd";b$a xa;/ re;jpuN:l;:
1/ ,k;nky;KiwaPL bkl;uh!; cah; ePjpkd;w jdpakh; ePjpaurhpd; 2006?Mk;
Mz;L mf;nlhgh; jp';fs; 27?Mk; njjpaplg;gl;l jPh;g;g[iuapypUe;J vGfpwJ/ mry; thjpahdth;. brd;id bgUefu chpikapay; Kjyhk; cjtp ePjpgjpapd; jPh;g;g[iu kw;Wk; jPh;g;ghizapid khw;wpaikj;J cah; ePjpkd;wk; tH';fpa jPh;g;g[iuapy; kdf;Fiwa[w;W nky;KiwaPL bra;Js;shh;/
2/ nky;KiwaPl;lhsh; brd;id bgUefu chpikapay; ePjpkd;wk; Kd;g[ ,U ghpfhu';fs; nfhhp. Kjnyw;g[ tHf;F vz; 5916-1990?I jhf;fy; bra;Js;shh;:
(i) ,e;J rka mwf;fl;lis1
. eph;thfj;Jiwapd; Mizah; gpwg;gpj;j
1990?Mk; Mz;L khh;r; jp';fs; 21?Mk; njjpaplg;gl;l Mizia ePf;fwt[ bra;at[k;; kw;Wk;
_________________________
1/ @,/r/m/f/@
(ii) ghf;ak;khs; mwf;fl;lis. jkpH;ehL ,e;J rka mwf;fl;lis rl;lk; 19592
?,d;; fUj;bjy;iyf;Fs; tUk; @jdptif mwf;fl;lis@ my;y vd;W tpsk;g[if bra;at[khFk;/
3/ nky;KiwaPl;lhshpd; tHf;F ahbjdpy;. _ Rthkp jhnkhju bgUkhs; jpUf;nfhapYf;Fhpa mwf;fl;lis xU bghJ mwf;fl;lis ,y;iy/ ,e;J rka mwepiyaj;Jiw kw;Wk; eph;thfj;Jiwapd; Jiz Mizah;. ghf;ak;khs; mwf;fl;lis vd;gJ bghJ mwf;fl;lis vd;W Twp mwptpg;g[ bfhLj;jhh;/ nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;. ghf;ak;khs;3 vd;gtUf;F. mtuJ Kd;ndhh;fshy; mWjpahtzj;jpd; thapyhf tHf;Fiu ml;ltizr; brhj;J ghf;ak;khSf;fhjuthf jPh;t[bra;ag;gl;lijj; bjhlh;e;J. mth; 1928 Kjy; 1959 tiu brhj;jpd; RthjPdj;jpYk;. mDnghfj;jpYk; ,Ue;Jte;jhh;/ ghf;ak;khs;. uh$^ brl;oahh; vd;gtUf;fhjuthf mWjpahtzk; vGjpf;bfhLj;Js;sjhfr; brhy;yg;gLfpwJ/ 1954?Mk; Mz;oy; mth; fhykhdt[ld; mtuJ kidtpahd
$fjhk;ghs;. mtuJ jdpj;j thhprhf me;j brhj;jpid kug[hpikahf bgw;whh;/ nkw;go $fjhk;ghs; jdJ kUkfdhd lgps;a{/v!;/ eluh$d; brl;oahh; vd;gtUf;fhjuthf brhj;jpid vGjpf;bfhLj;Jtpl;ljhfr; brhy;yg;gLfpwJ/ mth; mr;brhj;jpd; RthjPdj;ij vLj;Jf;bfhz;ljhft[k;. 1968?Mk; Mz;oy;
2/ 1959?Mk; Mz;L rl;lk;
3/ cah; ePjpkd;wk; *ghf;fpak;khs;* vd;w thh;j;ijia cgnahfpj;Js;sJ/ vt;thwhapDk; 1926?Mk;
Mz;L $^d; jp';fs; 4?Mk; njjpapl;l mWjpahtzk; m/rh/M/1?Mf FwpaPL bra;ag;gl;Ls;sjpy;
*ghf;ak;khs;* vd;w brhy;yikg;g[ gpunahfpf;fg;gl;Ls;sJ/ trjpapd;bghUl;L. ,e;ePjpkd;wk; jw;nghJs;s jPh;g;g[iuapy; *ghf;ak;khs;* vd;w brhy;iy cgnahfg;gLj;JfpwJ/
mth; ,wf;Fk;tiuapy; mtuJ fl;Lg;ghl;oy; itj;jpUe;jjhft[k; brhy;yg;gLfpwJ/ mtUila kfdhd nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;. mr;brhj;jpid kug[hpikahf mile;Js;sjhff; TWfpwhh; vd;gjhFk;/
4/ nky;KiwaPl;lhshpd; tHf;F ahbjdpy;. ghf;ak;khs; vd;gtuhy; cUthf;fg;gl;l mwf;fl;lisahdJ jdpg;gl;l FLk;g mwf;fl;lis vd;gjhy; mJ 1959?Mk; Mz;L rl;lj;jpd; tifKiwfis <h;f;fhJ/ mjw;fhf tpsk;g[if bra;af;nfhhp ,e;J rka mwf;fl;lis eph;thfj;Jiwapd; Jiz
Mizah; Kd;ghf gphpt[ 63(m)?,d; fPH; tHf;F eltof;if4 bjhLf;fg;gl;lJ/
1986?Mk; Mz;L mf;nlhgh; 3?Mk; njjpad;W Jiz Mizah; tHf;F eltof;ifiaj; js;Sgo bra;jhh;/ 1990?Mk; Mz;L khh;r; jp';fs; 21?Mk; njjpad;W Jiz Mizahpd; Mizf;bfjpuhd nky;KiwaPL. Kjy; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsuhy; js;Sgo bra;ag;gl;lJ/ ,J. gphpt[ 70(1)?,d; fPH; nky;KiwaPl;lhsuhy; tHf;F bjhLg;gjw;F tHpnfhypaJ/ 1995?Mk; Mz;L mf;nlhgh; jp';fs; 27?Mk; njjpad;W tprhuiz ePjpgjp tHf;fpy; jPh;g;ghizapl;lhh; vd;gjhFk;/
5/ nky;KiwaPl;oy;. 2006?Mk; Mz;L mf;nlhgh; jp';fs; 27?Mk; njjpad;W tprhuiz ePjpkd;wj;jpd; jPh;g;g[iuia. cah; ePjpkd;wj;jpd; fw;wwpe;j jdpakh; ePjpaurh; khw;wpaikj;jhh;/ chpikapay; tprhuizKiwr; rl;lk; 1908. gphpt[
100(m)?,d; fPH; chpik gl;la nky;KiwaPL epiyf;fj;jf;fjy;y vd;w fhuzj;jpd;nghpy; mJ js;Sgo bra;ag;gl;lJ/
4/ Kjnyw;g[ tpz;zg;gk; 12-1984
6/ fw;wwpe;j jdpakh; ePjpaurhpd; jPh;g;g[iuia vjph;f;Fk;bghUl;L. xU rpwg;g[ mDkjp kD. murikg;g[ rl;lj;jpd; tFKiwTW 136?,d; fPH;
,e;ePjpkd;wk; Kd;ghf bjhlug;gl;lJ/ 2017?Mk; Mz;L nk jp';fs; 4?Mk; njjpad;W mDkjp tH';fg;gl;lJ/
7/ mj;jpahak; V?,d; xU gFjpahd gphpt[ 63 tprhuizf;Fhpa tifKiwfis cl;bfhz;ljhFk;/ gphpt[ 63 gpd;tUk; tiuaiwfisf; bfhz;ljhFk;:
@63/ 5
(,iz Mizah; my;yJ Jiz Mizah;) rpy jfuhWfSk;. tpla';fSkhd.
,jpy; ,jw;Fg;gpwF tifbra;ag;gl;Ls;sgo tHf;fpLk; my;yJ nky;KiwapLk; chpikf;Fl;gl;L 6
(,iz Mizah; my;yJ
Jiz Mizah; neh;tpw;nfw;wthW) gpd;tUk; jfuhWfisa[k;. tpla';fisa[k; tprhhpj;J jPh;khdpf;f mjpfhuKilath;fshth;:-
(m) xU epWtdk; rkarhh;g[ila epWtdkh;
(M) mw';fhtyh; xUth; guk;giu mw';fhtyuhf gjtp bgw;wpUf;fpwhuh my;yJ tfpj;jpUf;fpwhuh;
(,) VnjDk; gznkh my;yJ brhj;njh mwf;fl;lisapDilajh;
(<) VnjDk; gznkh my;yJ brhj;njh jdptif mwf;fl;lisapDilajh;
5/ jkpH;ehL rl;lk; 38-1995?f;F gjpyikf;fg;gl;lJ/
6/ jkpH;ehL rl;lk; 38-1995?f;F gjpyikf;fg;gl;lJ/
(c) ve;j egnuDk; tHf;fhWgonah my;yJ ntWtifapnyh
VnjDk; rkarhh;g[ila epWtdj;jpy; khpahij bra;ag;gLtjw;nfh my;yJ btFkhdk; mspf;fg;gLtjw;nfh chpika[ilatuh; kw;Wk; rkarhh;g[ila epWtdj;jpy;
Vw;gLj;jg;gl;Ls;s tHf;fhW. ntnwnjDk; tplaj;jpw;F bjhlh;g[ilajh;
(C) epWtdk; my;yJ mwf;fl;lis vJt[k; KGikahfnth my;yJ gFjpahfnth rkarhh;g[ilajh my;yJ rkarhh;gw;wjh; kw;Wk; brhj;J my;yJ gzk; vJt[k; KGikahfnth my;yJ gFjpahfnth. rkarhh;g[ilaitf;F my;yJ rkarhh;gw;witf;F gad;gLj;Jtjw;fhf bfhLf;fg;gl;Ls;sjh;
(v) brhj;J my;yJ gzk; vJt[k; gFjp rkarhh;g[ila kw;Wk; gFjp rkarhh;gw;w epWtdj;jpw;fhjuthfnth my;yJ me;epWtdj;Jld; bjhlh;g[ila gzp my;yJ mwf;fhhpak; vjida[k; epiwntw;Wtjw;fhfnth my;yJ gFjp rkarhh;g[ila kw;Wk; gFjp rkarhh;gw;w mwf;fhhpak; epiwntw;Wtjw;fhfnth bfhLf;fg;gl;Ls;stplj;J my;yJ bfhLf;fg;gl;l gzk; my;yJ brhj;J vJt[k; gFjp rkarhh;g[ila kw;Wk; rkarhh;gw;witf;F gad;gLj;Jtjw;F xJf;fPL bra;Js;stplj;J. mr;brhj;jpd; my;yJ gzj;jpd; vt;tst[ gFjp rka";rhh;ghf gad;gLj;Jtjw;F xJf;fPL bra;ag;gLjy;ntz;Lk; vd;gijf;
Fwpj;Jk; jPh;khdpg;gh;/@ (typa[Wj;jpf; Twg;gl;lJ)
8/ ,iz Mizah; my;yJ Jiz Mizah;. TWfs; (m) Kjy; (v) tiuapyhdtw;wpy; Fwpg;gpl;Ls;s jd;ika[ila g{ry;fis tprhhpf;ft[k;. jPh;khdpf;ft[k; mjpfhuKilatuhth; vd gphpt[ 63 tifbra;fpwJ/ mtw;Ws; tifKiw (<)?,y; brhj;J vJt[k; jdptif mwf;fl;lisf;Fhpajh> vd;W cs;sJ/ gphpt[ 69. ,iz Mizah; my;yJ Jiz Mizahpd; cj;jutpid vjph;j;J Mizahplk; nky;KiwaPL bra;tjw;F tifbra;fpwJ/ gphpt[ 70. nky;KiwaPl;oy; Mizauhy; gpwg;gpf;fg;gl;l cj;jutpdhYk;. kw;wtw;Wf;fpilna gphpt[ 63?,y; Fwpg;gplg;gl;Ls;s tpla';fs; bjhlh;ghft[k; kdf;Fiwa[w;w jug;gpdh; tHf;F bjhLg;gjw;F tifbra;fpwJ/
9/ jw;bghGJs;s tHf;fpYs;s Kuz;ghL. 1926?Mk; Mz;L $^d; jp';fs;
4?Mk; njjpaplg;gl;l mry; mWjpahtzk; gphpt[ 63(<)?,d; bghUspd;go
*jdptif mwf;fl;lis* vd;w jd;ika[ilajh> vd;gij nehf;fp jpUk;g[fpwJ/
*jdptif mwf;fl;lis* vd;w brhy; gphpt[ 6(19)?,d;go gpd;tUkhW bghUs;tiuaWf;fg;gl;Ls;sJ:
@19/ @jdptif mwf;fl;lis@ vd;gJ klj;jpy; my;yJ nfhapypy; VJk; Fwpg;gpl;l nrit my;yJ mwg;gzpahw;Wtjw;fhf my;yJ ntnwnjDk; rka mwg;gzpia nkw;bfhs;tjw;fhf mwf;bfhilahf tH';fg;gLk; brhj;J my;yJ gzk; vJt[k; vdg; bghUs;gLk;/ Mdhy;. (17)?Mk;
Twpd; (1)?Mk; tpsf;fj;jpy; tpthpf;fg;gl;l ,dhk; vd;w jd;ikapyhdij cs;slf;fhJ/
tpsf;fk; (1)/ ? ,f;Twpy; Fwpg;gplg;gl;Ls;s jd;ikajhd
,uz;L my;yJ mjw;F nkw;gl;l mwf;fl;lisfspd; eph;thfk;. bghJ mw';fhtyh; xUthplk; milt[w;wpUe;jhnyh my;yJ mit mWjpaplg;gl;l bghJ jpl;lj;jpd; fPH; eph;tfpf;fg;gLfpd;wd vd;whnyh my;yJ ,r;rl;lj;jpd;fPH; mWjp bra;ag;gl;Ls;sjhf fUjg;gl;lhnyh. mit ,r;rl;lj;jpd; nehf;f';fspd;bghUl;L jdpbahU Fwpg;gpl;l mwf;fl;lisahfg; bghUs;bfhs;sg;gLjy;ntz;Lk;/ tpsf;fk; (2)/ ? klk; my;yJ nfhapy; xd;Wld; ,ize;j
Fwpg;gpl;l mwf;fl;lis xd;wpd; xU gFjp xU khepyj;jpw;Fs;Sk; kw;Wk; xU gFjp mk;khepyj;jpw;F btspnaa[k; mike;jpUg;gpd;. mk;khepyj;jpw;Fs; mike;Js;s xU gFjpahdJ ,r;rl;lj;jpd; tifKiwfspd;go fl;Lg;gLj;jg;gLk;/@
*rka mwg;gzp* kw;Wk; *rka mwf;fl;lis* vd;w brhw;bwhlh;fs; gphpt[
6?,d; TWfs; (16) kw;Wk; (17)?,y; gpd;tUkhW tiuaWf;fg;gl;Ls;sd:
@(16) @rka mwg;gzp@ vd;gJ klk; my;yJ nfhapYld; bjhlh;g[ilajhf ,Ug;gpDk;. ,y;yhtpoDk;. ,e;J jpUtpHht[ld; bjhlh;g[ila bghJ mwg;gzp my;yJ rkaj; jd;ikapyhd rl';Ffisf; filgpoj;jy; mit vdg; bghUs;gLk;/
JUDGMENT

(17) @rka mwf;fl;lis@ my;yJ @mwf;fl;lis@ vd;gJ nfhapy;fs; kw;Wk; kl';fSf;Fr; brhe;jkhd mtw;wpw;fhjuthf bfhLf;fg;gLk; my;yJ bfhilaspf;fg;gLk; my;yJ mjDld; bjhlh;g[ila bjhz;L my;yJ bghJ jd;ikahd mwg;gzp vjida[k; my;yJ ntW rka mwg;gzp vjida[k; Mw;Wtjw;F bfhLf;fg;gLk; my;yJ bfhilaspf;fg;gLk; brhj;J aht[k; vdg; bghUs;gLk;.,jpy; rk;ge;jg;gl;l epWtdKk;. mjd; tshfK';Tl ml';Fk;. Mdhy;. rka epWtdj;jpd; mh;r;rfh;. nrit bra;nthh; my;yJ gpw gzpahsh;fSf;F jdpg;gl;l Kiwapy; bfhLf;fg;gLk; ed;bfhilfs;,jpy; ml';fhJ; tpsf;fk; (1)/ ? rka epWtdj;Jld; bjhlh;g[ila nrit my;yJ mwg;gzp vjida[k; Mw;Wtjw;fhf mh;r;rfh;. nrtfh; my;yJ rka epWtdj;jpd; kw;w gzpahsh;fSf;F tH';fg;gLk;,dhk; vJt[k;. mh;r;rfh;. nrit bra;nthh;. gzpahsUf;F jdpg;gl;lKiwapy; bfhLf;fg;gl;l ed;bfhilahf fUJjy; TlhJ. Mdhy;. mjid rka mwf;fl;lisahf fUJjy;ntz;Lk;; tpsf;fk; (2)/ ? rka epWtdj;jpw;Fr; brhe;jkhd my;yJ mjw;F bfhLf;fg;gl;l my;yJ bfhilaspf;fg;gl;l my;yJ mjDld; bjhlh;g[ila bghJj;jd;ikahf my;yJ mwg;gzp kw;Wk; bjhz;L vJt[k; my;yJ ntW rka mwg;gzp vJt[k; Mw;Wtjw;fhf bfhLf;fg;gl;l my;yJ bfhilaspf;fg;gl;l brhj;Jaht[k;,g;bghUs;tiuaiwf;Fs; @rka mwf;fl;lis@ my;yJ @mwf;fl;lis@ vd;gjhf fUjg;gLjy;ntz;Lk;. vt;thwhfapUg;gpDk;.,r;rl;lk; bjhl';Ftjw;F Kd;ngh my;yJ gpd;ngh. rka epWtdk; csjhapUg;gJ Kot[Wj;jg;gLk; my;yJ rka tHpghl;L,lkhf gad;gLj;jg;gLtJ Kot[Wj;jg;gLk; my;yJ nghjid my;yJ bjhz;L my;yJ mwg;gzp Mw;wg;gLtJ Kot[Wj;jg;gLk;; tuk;g[iuahf.,t;tpsf;ft[iuahdJ. fhytuk;g[ rl;lj;jpd;,a';FKiwf;Fl;gl;L. 1951?Mk; Mz;L brg;lk;gh; jp';fs; 30?Mk; njjpf;F Kd;djhf ve;j eghpd; kPJk; cw;wike;j brhj;J vJt[k; bjhlh;ghf bghUe;Jtjhff; fUjg;gLjy; TlhJ/@ 10/ jw;bghGJs;s tHf;fpypUf;Fk; g{ryhdJ. 1926?Mk; Mz;L $^d; jp';fs; 4?Mk; njjpaplg;gl;l mWjpahtzj;jpd; bghUs;tpsf;fkhFk;/ me;j Mtzk; th/rh/M/1?Mf FwpaPL bra;ag;gl;Ls;sJ/ _ mf!;jP!;tu !;thkp njt!;jhd jpUf;nfhapy; mwf;fl;lisapduhy; ghf;ak;khSf;fhjuthf vGjpf;bfhLf;fg;gl;Ls;sJ/ 1921?Mk; Mz;L njt!;jhdj;jpd; bray;ghLfis vspjhf;Ftjw;F rj;jpuk;7 mikg;gjw;fhf kid xd;W kh';fhL vy;yg;g brl;oahh; vd;gtUf;fhjuthf mwf;fl;lisapduhy; cilikkhw;w";bra;ag;gl;lJ/ 7/ rj;jpuk; vd;gJ gazpah;fspd; Xa;tplkhft[k;. bghJ tpahghuj;jpw;fhft[k; cgnahfpf;fg;gLk; Tlk;. bfhl;oy;. my;yJ Mjhuepiyahd Tiu vdg; bghUs;tiuaWf;fg;gl;Ls;sJ/ rp/ `bgd;dy;. (gjpg;g[). M';fpy kug[r; brhw;fs; kw;Wk; brhw;bwhlh;fs; !;nld;nghh;l; brhw;fs";rpak;/ nfk;gphpl;$;: nfk;gphpl;$; gy;fiyf;fHf mr;rfk; (1892)/ rj;jpuk; vd;gJ bghJkf;fspd; xU tpLjp vdt[k;. gazpah;fSf;fhd xU j';fplk; vdt[k; bghUs;tiuaWf;fg;gl;Ls;sJ/ tpy;rdpd; ePjpj;Jiw kw;Wk; tUtha; brhy;yfuhjp. yz;ld; lgps;a{/vr;/ Myd;. 2?Mk; gjpg;g[. gf;fk; 108/ me;j rj;jpukhdJ rka tpHhf;fspy; fye;Jbfhs;stUk; gf;jh;fspd; njitfisg; g{h;j;jp bra;tjw;F nghJkhdjhf,y;iy/ vdnt. jpUf;nfhapiy nkk;gLj;Jk; mtrpaKk;. gf;jh;fspd; brsfhpa';fisa[k; fUj;jpw;bfhz;L. kw;bwhU rj;jpuk; fl;LtJ mtrpak; vd;W mwpag;gl;lJ/ mwf;fl;lisapdh; brhj;jpd; RthjPdj;ij ghf;ak;khsplk; xg;gilg;gjw;F xg;g[f;bfhz;ldh;/ Kf;fpakhd,t;tWjpahtzj;ijg; bghWj;jtiuapy; mJ,t;thwhf tifbra;fpwJ: @1921?Mk; Mz;L brd;id gl;lzk; Kj;ijahy;ngl;. K:l;ilf;fhud; bjU.,yf;fk; vz; 4?,y; cs;s tPl;oy; trpf;Fk; kh';fhL vy;yg;g brl;oahh; vd;gtUf;F epy kid xd;W RthjPdk; bfhLf;fg;gl;lJ vd;Wk;. njt!;jhdj;jpd; g[dpj bray;ghLfis Kiwahfr; bra;tJ rk;ge;jkhf bghpa rj;jpuk; fl;lg;gl;Ls;sJ vd;Wk;. mr;rj;jpuj;jpy; Mo khj';fspy; eilbgWk; tpHhf;fspy; fye;Jbfhs;stUk; bgU';Tl;lj;jpdiu j';fitf;f nghJkhd,ltrjp,y;iy vd;Wk;. jpUf;nfhapypd; nkk;ghl;oidf; fUj;jpw;bfhz;Lk;.,d;DbkhU rj;jpuk; fl;LtJ mtrpabkd;W eh';fs; vz;zpajhYk;. jpUbthw;wpa{h; fpuhkj;jpy; cs;s nf/ fe;jrhkp brl;oahh; vd;gthplk; v';fsJ ntz;Lnfhis itj;jjd;nghpYk;. mth; jdJ kfspd; cjtpa[ld;. fhy";brd;w jpUg;gjp ehuhazrhkp brl;oahhpd; kidtpahd ghf;ak;khSlDk; (mjpYs;sthW) nrh;e;J rj;jpuk; fl;Ltjw;F xg;g[f;bfhz;lhh;. Mifahy;. fPH;f;fz;l ml;ltizapy; Fwpg;gplg;gl;Ls;s. vy;iyfspd;go nkw;fz;l mk;khSf;F eh';fs; ehy;tUk; xUkdjhf nkw;fz;l brhj;jpd; RthjPdj;ij xg;gilg;gjw;F vGj;Jg;g{h;tkhf xg;g[f;bfhz;Ls;sgoahy;. tU';fhyj;jpy; v';fSf;nfh. v';fsJ re;jjpapdUf;nfh nkw;fz;l ghf;ak;khthy; RthjPdk; vLj;Jf;bfhs;sg;gl;l nkw;go epyr;brhj;jpy; chpiknah my;yJ ghj;jpankh VJkpy;iy vd;Wk;. rpyrhrdk; Vw;gLj;jp mth;fs;,ytr rj;jpuk; fl;of;bfhs;syhk; vd;Wk;. mth; mjid mtuJ thH;ehs; KGtJk; guhkhpf;fntz;Lk; vd;Wk;. mjd;gpwF. mtuJ thhpRfSf;F tHptif bra;Jk;. Kfth;fis epakdk; bra;Jk;. mjid guhkhpj;jy;ntz;Lk; vd;Wk;. nkw;Twpaij bghJkf;fspd; gad;ghl;ow;F vy;yh rka';fspYk; gad;gLj;jpf;bfhs;syhk; vd;Wk; bjhptpf;fg;gLfpwJ/,jid thliff;F tpLjy;TlhJ/,e;j rj;jpuj;jpd;kPJ mth; chpiknaJk; nfhuf;TlhJ/ nkw;fz;l rj;jpuj;jpd; vy;iyfis. ghf;ak;khspd; thhpRfSk;. mtuhy; epakpf;fg;gl;l Kfth;fSk; cWjpbra;Jbfhs;sntz;Lk;/ nkw;fz;l rj;jpuj;jpw;F thp tpjpf;fg;gl;lhYk;. mJt[k; ghf;ak;khspd; jug;gpdh;fshy; ifahsg;glntz;Lk;/ nkw;go rj;jpuj;jpy;/// jpUkz epfH;t[fisa[k; kw;Wk; gpw RgepfH;r;rpfisa[k; elj;Jk;bghUl;L.,e;J rka ahj;jphpfh;fs; K:d;W ehl;fSf;F j';Ftjw;F mDkjpf;fg;gLth; vd;Wk;. njt!;jhd nehf;f';fSf;fhf xU ehs;.,uz;L ehs; kw;Wk; K:d;W ehl;fSk;. ghf;ak;khSk; mtuJ jug;gpdh;fSk;. j';fsJ RatpUg;gj;jpw;nfw;g mt;tplj;jpid RgepfH;r;rpfSf;F gad;gLj;jpf;bfhs;syhk;/ mRj;jkhd my;yJ jtwhd eltof;iffSf;F gad;gLj;Jtjw;F vtUf;Fk;,lkspf;ff;TlhJ/ nkw;go rj;jpuk; kw;Wk; jiug;gFjp kid bjhlh;ghf thhpRfnsh. Kfth;fnsh milkhdk; my;yJ fpiuak; nghd;w vJt[k; epiwntw;Wjy;TlhJ/@ (typa[Wj;jpf; Twg;gl;lJ) 11/ 1959?Mk; Mz;od; rl;lg;gphpt[ 6(19)?,d; bghUspd;go. nkw;brhd;d Vw;ghL xU Fwpg;gpl;l mwf;fl;lisia mikf;fpwjh> vd;gnj cah; ePjpkd;wk; Kd;gpUe;j tHf;bfGtpdhthFk;/ _ mf!;jP!;tu !;thkpah; njt!;jhd jpUf;nfhapy; gf;jh;fisj; j';fitf;f,ltrjp bra;a[k;bghUl;L TLjy; rj;jpuk; fl;oj;jUtjw;Fjhd; tHf;Fr; brhj;J ghf;ak;khsplk; xg;gilf;fg;gl;oUe;jJ vd;gij th/rh/M/1?,d; thrf';fs; Rl;of;fhl;Ltjhf cah; ePjpkd;wk; jPh;khdpj;Js;sJ/,r;rj;jpuj;ij bghJkf;fs; gad;gLj;jpf;bfhs;s chpika[s;sjhf mWjpahtzk; Rl;of;fhl;oa[s;sJ/ brhj;jpy; tpy;y';fk; VJk; cz;lhf;FtjpypUe;J ghf;ak;khs; jLj;J epWj;jg;gl;lhh;/ cah; ePjpkd;wj;jpd; fUj;Jg;go: @,';Fk; th/rh/M/1?,d;go. tHf;Fr; brhj;jpy; TLjy; rj;jpuk; fl;Ltjw;F kl;Lnk ghf;fpak;khSf;F chpik tH';fg;gl;lJ. nkYk; ij kw;Wk; Mo khj tpHhf;fspd;nghJ jpUf;nfhapypy; jpuSk; gf;jh;fSf;F mjpYk; Fwpg;ghf bghJkf;fspd; gad;ghl;ow;F mwf;fl;lis epWtg;gl;L mh;g;gzpf;fg;gl;Ls;sJ/ jw;nghJ cs;s rj;jpuj;jpy; ij kw;Wk; Mo khj';fspy; jpUf;nfhapYf;F tUk; gf;jh;fSf;F nghJkhd,ltrjpfs;,y;iybad;gjhy; TLjy; rj;jpuk; fl;LtJ mtrpak; vd;gij czh;e;J. th/rh/M/1?I mw';fhtyh; vGjpdhh;/ nkw;fz;l rj;jpuj;jpd; guhkhpf;Fk; chpik ghf;fpak;khSf;F bfhLf;fg;gl;lJ/ nkYk;. nkw;fz;l rj;jpuj;ij K:d;W ehl;fSf;Fnky; gad;gLj;jnth my;yJ mjd;K:yk; tUtha; <l;lnth mth;fSf;F chpikaspf;fg;gltpy;iy/ nkYk;. gp/rh/M/1?,y; nkw;fz;l rj;jpuj;ij ghf;fpak;khs; jdJ brhe;j tUthapy;jhd; guhkhpf;fntz;Lk; vd;W jpl;ltl;lkhff; Twg;gl;Ls;sJ/ Mifahy;. th/rh/M/1?,d;go nkw;fz;l rj;jpuk; bghJkf;fSf;F mh;g;gzpf;fg;gl;Ls;sjhy;.,J Xh; mwf;fl;lis kl;Lnk vd;gJ,e;J rka mwf;fl;lisr; rl;lj;jpd; gphpt[ 63(m)?,d; fPH; Fwpg;gplg;gl;Ls;s tifKiwia <h;f;Fk;/@ (typa[Wj;jpf; Twg;gl;lJ) mwf;fl;lis Fwpj;jtif nehf;fj;jpw;fhdJ vd;W cah; ePjpkd;wk; jPh;khdpj;Js;sJ: @ghf;fpak;khthy; fl;lg;gLk; rj;jpuk; bghJkf;fs; gad;gLj;Jk; nehf;fj;jpw;fhf bfhilaspf;fg;glntz;Lk; vd;gjhf th/rh/M/1?,d;go xU jdptif mwf;fl;lis cs;sJ/@ 12/ fw;wwpe;j K:j;j tHf;Fiu"h;. jpU/ v!;/ ehfKj;J cah; ePjpkd;w jPh;g;g[iuapid vjph;j;Jiuj;J. 1926?Mk; Mz;L $^d; jp';fs; 4?Mk; njjpaplg;gl;l mWjpahtzj;jpy; gphpt[ 6(19)?,d; bghUspd;go m';F ve;jj; jdptif mwf;fl;lisa[k;,y;iy vd;W thjpl;lhh;/ mtuJ thjj;jpd; rPh;ikia kjpg;gpl;ljpy; gphpt[ 6(19)?,y; cs;s *jdptif mwf;fl;lis* vd;w brhy;yikg;gpd; bghUs;tiuaiwia gFg;gha;t[ bra;tJ mtrpakhdjhFk;/ xU *jdptif mwf;fl;lis* vd;gJ:

(i) xU jpUf;nfhapypnyh my;yJ klj;jpnyh Fwpg;gpl;l bjhz;lhw;Wtjw;fhf bfhilaspf;fg;gLk; gzk; my;yJ bghUs; vJt[k;;

(ii) xU jpUf;nfhapypnyh my;yJ klj;jpnyh mwg;gzp Mw;Wtjw;fhf bfhilaspf;fg;gLk; gzk; my;yJ bghUs; vJt[k;;

(iii) rka mwg;gzp Mw;Wtjw;fhf bfhilaspf;fg;gLk; gzk; my;yJ bghUs; vJt[k;; vd;w bghUs;gLk;goahf tiuaWf;fg;gl;Ls;sJ/ 13/ *rka mwg;gzp* vd;Dk; brhw;bwhlh; klk; my;yJ nfhapYld; bjhlh;g[ilajhf,Ug;gpDk;.,y;yhtpoDk;.,e;J jpUtpHht[ld; bjhlh;g[ila bghJ mwg;gzp my;yJ rkaj; jd;ikapyhd rl';Ffisf; filg;gpoj;jy; vdg; bghUs;gLk;goahf tiuaWf;fg;gl;Ls;sJ/ Mizah;.,e;J rka mwepiyaj;Jiw. brd;id ?vjph;? ehuhaz Ia';fhh;8 vd;w tHf;fpy; 8/ (1965) 3 v!;/rp/Mh;/ 168,e;ePjpkd;wj;jpd; K:tukh; ePjpauhaj;jpw;fhf ePjpaurh; b$/rp/ c&h mth;fs; ngRifapy; *rka mwg;gzp* vd;Dk; brhw;bwhliu tpsf;fp jPh;khdpj;Js;sjhtJ: @4/ gphpt[ 6?,d; TW (13). @rka mwg;gzp@ vd;gJ @klk; my;yJ nfhapYld; bjhlh;g[ilajhf,Ug;gpDk;.,y;yhtpoDk;.,e;J jpUtpHhf;fSld; bjhlh;g[ila bghJ mwg;gzp my;yJ rkaj; jd;ikapyhd rl';Ffisf; filg;gpoj;jy;@ vd;W bghUs;tiuaWf;fg;gl;Ls;sJ/,U epge;jidfis tFj;Jiuf;Fk;,g;bghUs;tiuaiw rka mwg;gzp?I tFj;jikf;fpwJ: m';F bghJ mwg;gzp fl;lhak;,Uf;fntz;Lk;/ nkYk;. me;j mwg;gzp,e;J tpHhf;fSld; kw;Wk; rkag; gz;g[ila xd;iwf; filg;gpog;gJld; bjhlh;g[w;wpUf;fntz;Lk;/,it g{h;j;jpbra;ag;gLkhdhy;. bghJ mwg;gzp vd;gJ jpUf;nfhapYlndh my;yJ klj;Jlndh bjhlh;gpy;yhtpl;lhY';Tl mJ rka mwg;gzpahfnt,Uf;Fk;/@ 14/ vk;/b$/ Jsrpuhkd; ?vjph;?,e;J rka mwf;fl;lis eph;thfk;9 vd;w tHf;fpy;,e;ePjpkd;wj;jpd; K:tukh; ePjpauhaj;jpd; rkPgj;jpa jPh;Kotpy; 1959?Mk; Mz;L jkpH;ehL,e;J rka mwf;fl;lis rl;lj;jpd;fPH; *md;d rj;jpuk;* vd;W miHf;fg;gLk; epWtdj;jpd; jd;ik jdptif mwf;fl;lisjhdh> vd;gijj; jPh;khdpf;f fy;btl;oy; bghwpf;fg;gl;l tptu';fs; Fwpj;J tpthjpf;ifapy;,e;ePjpkd;wk;,t;thwhf jPh;khdpj;Js;sjhtJ: 9/ (2019) 8 v!;/rp/rp/ 689 @14/ jw;nghJs;s tHf;fpy;. rj;jpuj;jpd; bray;ghl;il Kiwg;gLj;Jfpd;w @md;d rj;jpuj;jpd;@ fy;btl;L gpuhkzh;fSf;F md;djhdk; tH';f tifbra;fpwJ/ nkw;Fwpg;gplg;gl;l,e;ePjpkd;wj;jpd; murikg;g[ ePjpauhaj;jpd; jPh;Kotpy; jPh;g;gspj;jjw;nfw;g.,J @bghJkf;fSf;F@ eyk;gaf;Fk; Xh; mwf;fl;lis vd;gJ bjspthfpwJ/ /// 16/ mt;thwhf. fy;btl;oy; tpthpf;fg;gl;Ls;s bghJ mwg;gzp xU rka jpUtpHht[ld; bjhlh;g[ilajhapUg;gjhy;. mJ rl;lj;jpd;fPH; bghUs;tiuaWf;fg;gl;lthW xU rka mwg;gzpahf mikfpwJ/ 17/ rl;lg;; gphpt[ 6(19)?,d; fPH; Vw;bfdnt nkny Fwpg;gpl;lthW. @jdptif mwf;fl;lis@ vd;gJ rka mwg;gzpahw;Wtjw;fhf mspf;fg;gLk; gzk; vJt[k; vd;w bghUs;tiuaiwf;Fl;gl;ljhFk;/ fy;btl;L. rka mwg;gzpahw;Wtij tifbra;fpwJ vd;w v';fsJ jPh;khdj;ijg; gpd;gw;wp. rl;lj;jpd;go xU jdptif mwf;fl;lis mikj;J mjw;F rka mwg;gzpahw;Wtjw;fhf gzk; bfhilaspf;fg;gl;Ls;sJ vd;gijf; fhz;gpg;gJ nghJkhdjhFk;/ 18/ @mwf;bfhil@ vd;w brhy;Yk;. mjDld;,ize;j @mwf;fl;lis@ vd;w brhy;Yk; cz;ikapy; rl;lj;jpd; fPH; bghUs;tiuaWf;fg;gltpy;iy vd;fpwnghJ. brhj;njh my;yJ kw;witnah. vJthapDk; mit Fwpg;gpl;l nehf;fj;jpw;fhf tH';fg;gLtJlndh. capy;tHp mspf;fg;gLtJlndh my;yJ VjhapDk; xd;iw mh;g;gzpf;Fk; nehf;fj;Jlndh bjhlh;g[ilaitahFk; vd;gJ rl;lj;jpYk;.,g;bghUspd; kPjhd jPh;g;g[iufspYk; mtw;iwg; gad;gLj;JtjpypUe;J bjspthfpwJ/ rl;lj;ijg; bghWj;jtiuapy;. nehf;fk; vd;gJ rkaj;Jld; my;yJ mwg;gzpa[ld; bjhlh;g[ilajhFk;/ [fhz;f: gp/,uhkehj ma;ah; mth;fspd; jp yh byf;rpfd;.,uz;lhtJ gjpg;g[. gf;f';fs; 634. 635; gpujhg;rp';$p vd;/ njrha; ?vjph;? Jiz mwf;fl;lis Mizah;. 1987 rg;sp/ v!;/rp/rp/ 714. gj;jp 8]. jw;nghJs;s tHf;fpy; Fwpg;gpl;l rka jpUtpHhf;fspd;nghJ gpuhkzh;fSf;F md;djhdk; mspg;gij nkw;bfhs;Sk;bghUl;L. @md;d rj;jpu@j;jpypUe;J gzj;ijg; gad;gLj;jpf;bfhs;tjw;F fy;btl;L bjspthfnt tifbra;fpwJ/,t;thwhf rl;lj;jpd; gphpt[ 6(19)?,d; fPH; Fwpg;gplg;gl;Ls;sthW rl;l tuk;gpw;Fl;gl;L @jdptif mwf;fl;lis@?I fy;btl;L njhw;Wtpj;Js;sJ vd;gJ bjspthfpwJ/ /// 23/ jw;nghJs;s nky;KiwaPl;od; bghUz;ikfs; tifapy;. bry;yj;jf;f chpik tpyfy;,Ue;jpUf;fpwJ vd;W jPh;khdpf;ft[k;. nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;fSf;fhd tHf;Fiu"hpd; thJiufis epuhfhpf;ft[k; v';fSf;F fy;btl;od; bghUslf;fk; nghJkhditahf cs;sd/ md;dk; jahhpf;Fk; rK:fj;jpduhy; rj;jpuk; eph;tfpf;fg;gl;L. mth;fs; kw;wth;fspd; eyDf;fhf v";rpa[s;s epjpiag; gad;gLj;jpf;bfhs;th; vd;gij fy;btl;L bjspthf Rl;of;fhl;LfpwJ/ nkYk;. rj;jpuk; bjhlh;ghd chpikkhw;wk; bra;a[k; mjpfhuk; vJt[k; eph;thfpfs; bgw;wpUf;ftpy;iy vd;gija[k; fy;btl;L bjhptpf;fpwJ/ Mfnt. jw;nghJs;s nky;KiwaPl;oy; vk;/Mh;/ nfhlh,uht; rhcwpg; ?vjph;? brd;id khepyk; [V/I/Mh;/ 1966 v!;/rp/ 653] vd;w tHf;ifg;nghy;. rj;jpuj;ij chpikkhw;wk; bra;a[k; eph;thfpapd; chpikkPJ fy;btl;L jilia tpjpg;gJld;. tUthapd; Fwpg;gpl;lbjhU gFjpiag; bgWk; chpikiaa[k; bjspthfnt ePf;fpa[s;sJ/ (typa[Wj;jpf; Twg;gl;lJ) 15/ jw;nghJs;s tHf;fpy;. 1921?Mk; Mz;L mw';fhtyh;fs; bjhlf;fj;jpy; rj;jpuk; fl;Ltjw;fhf kidbahd;iw Vw;ghL bra;jdh; vd;W njt!;jhd eltof;iffSld; bjhlh;g[ila rj;jpuk;. rka tpHhf;fspd;nghJ gf;jh;fspd; njitfis epiwt[ bra;tjw;F nghJkhdjhf,y;iy vd;Wk;. mjd;tpisthf 1926?Mk; Mz;L $^d; jp';fs; 4?Mk; njjpapl;l mWjpahtzj;jpd; fPH; TLjy; rj;jpuk; fl;Lk; gzp ghf;ak;khsplk; xg;gilf;fg;gl;lbjd;Wk;. njt!;jhdj;jpw;F tUifjUk; ahj;jphpfSf;F tphpthd trjpfis bra;JbfhLf;Fk;bghUl;nl Fwpg;ghf rj;jpuj;ijg; gad;gLj;jntz;Lbkd;Wk;. rj;jpuj;jpnyh my;yJ epyj;jpnyh tpy;y';fj;ij cUthf;Ftjw;F jilapUe;jbjd;Wk;. vy;yh rka';fspYk;,r;rj;jpuj;ij bghJ kf;fspd; cgnahfj;jpw;nf gad;gLj;jntz;Lbkd;Wk;.,r;rj;jpuj;jpd; kPJ ghf;ak;khshy; vt;tpj chpika[k; nfhuKoahbjd;Wk;. ghf;ak;khs;. mtUila tk;rhtspapdh;. mtuhy; epakpf;fg;gl;lth;fs; Mfpnahuhy;,r;rj;jpuk; guhkhpf;fg;glntz;Lbkd;Wk;. 1926?Mk; Mz;L $^d; jp';fs; 4?Mk; njjpapl;l mWjpahtzj;jpypUe;J btspg;gLfpwJ/ gphpt[ 6(19)?,y; cs;s *jdptif mwf;fl;lis* vDk; brhw;bwhlhpd; bghUs;tiuaiw <h;f;fg;gLfpwJ vd;gJ mWjpahtzj;jpypUe;J bjhpatUk; bjspthd thrf';fspd;go. 1959?Mk; Mz;L rl;lj;jpd; nehf;fkhdJ. jkpH;ehL khepyj;jpYs;s,e;J rka mw epWtd';fspd; kw;Wk; mwf;fl;lisfspd; eph;thfk; kw;Wk; MSik bjhlh;ghd rl;l';fis xU';fpizg;gjhFk;/ brhj;jhdJ jpUf;nfhapypy; rka mwg;gzp nkw;bfhs;tjw;fhf Fwpg;ghf bfhilaspf;fg;gl;lJ. mJ. gphpt[ 6(19)?,y; *jdptif mwf;fl;lis* vd;w bghUs;tiuaiwapd; tuk;gpw;Fl;gl;ljhFk;/ 16/ fw;wwpe;j tprhuiz ePjpgjp gphpt[ 6(19)?,d; bghUSf;Fs; *jdptif mwf;fl;lis* tutpy;iy vd;W Kot[bra;jjpy; jtwpiHj;Js;shh; vd;gJ bjspthfpwJ/ fPHik ePjpkd;wj;jpd; jPh;g;g[iuia cah; ePjpkd;wk; khw;wpaikj;jJ Kw;wpYk; rhpahdJ/ mjd;go,k;nky;KiwaPl;oy; jFjpnaJk;,y;iy/ 17/,k;nky;KiwaPL mjw;nfw;g js;Sgo bra;ag;gLfpwJ/ bryt[j;bjhif Fwpj;J cj;juntJkpy;iy/ khz;g[kpF ePjpaurh; Kidth; jpU/ jd";b$a xa;/ re;jpuN:l; khz;g[kpF ePjpaurh; jpU/ m$a; u!;njhfp g[J jpy;yp. 22/11/2019/ ????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????? chpikj;Jwg;g[ @tl;lhu bkhHpapy; bkhHpahf;fk; bra;ag;gl;l,j;jPh;g;g[iuahdJ. tHf;fho. jd;Dila bkhHpapy; g[hpe;Jbfhs;tjw;F gad;gLj;jpf;bfhs;tjw;Fl;gl;lnjad;wp. ntbwe;j nehf;fj;jpw;fhft[k; gad;gLj;jpf;bfhs;syhfhJ/ midj;J eilKiwahd kw;Wk; mYty;Kiwahd nehf;f';fSf;Fk; kw;Wk; jPh;g;g[iuia epiwntw;wYf;Fk;. braw;gLj;jYf;Fk; mjd; M';fpyg; gjpg;ng mjpfhug;g{h;tkhdjhFk;/@