1437720db3c278eea22d3e9ab4ca1eb83ff41c554de2547393d947791e101df7

2019 INSC 1369

J}j;Jf;Fo midj;J kfsph; fhty; epiyaj;jpy; gzpg[hpe;J bfhz;oUe;jnghJ. 2017?Mk; Mz;L $^d; jp';fs; 1?Mk; ehsd;W jdJ gzp tpyfiy bfhLj;J. jd;idg; gzpapypUe;J tpLtpf;FkhW nfhhpdhh;/ gzp tpyfyhdJ 2017?Mk; Mz;L $^d; jp';fs; 12?Mk; ehsd;W Vw;Wf;bfhs;sg;gl;lJ/ vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;. 2017?Mk; Mz;L $^iy jp';fs; 13?Mk; ehsd;W gzp tpyfiyj; jpUk;gg;bgw vz;zp. xU jftiy mDg;gpdhh;/ vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;. cah; ePjpkd;wj;jpy; ePjpg;nguhiz kD1 xd;iwj; jhf;fy; bra;jhh;. rl;lj;jpw;Fl;gl;L. mk;KiwaPl;ilg; ghprPypj;J. chpa cj;jut[fisg; gpwg;gpf;FkhW fhty;Jiw jiytUf;F cj;jutpl;L. 2018?Mk; Mz;L khh;r; jp';fs; 1?Mk; ehsd;W mJ Kof;fg;gl;lJ/ 4/ fhty;Jiw jiyth;.2 2018?Mk; Mz;L $^d; jp';fs; 2?Mk; ehsd;W KiwaPl;il epuhfhpj;J. cj;jut[ xd;iwg; gpwg;gpj;jhh;/ mt;thW bra;ifapy;. fh/J/j/. jkpH;ehL fhty;Jiw rhh;g[ gzpfs;.3 rpwg;g[ tpjpfspd; tpjp 35(m)?,d; tifa';fs;kPJ rhh;t[w;whh;/ ePjpg;nguhiz kDtpy;4 fhty;Jiw jiythpd; cj;juthdJ. fw;wwpe;j jdpakh; ePjpaurh; Kd;ghf vjph;f;fg;gl;L. 2018?Mk; Mz;L Mf!;l; jp';fs; 21?Mk; ehspl;l cj;jutpd; K:yk; js;Sgo bra;ag;gl;lJ/ vdpDk;. vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsuhy; jhf;fy; bra;ag;gl;l _______________________ 1/ ePjpg;nguhiz 3888-18 2/ @fh/J/j/@ 3/ @tpjpfs;@ 4/ ePjpg;nguhiz kD vz; 18211-2018

ePjpg;nghiz nky;KiwaPL5 mDkjpf;fg;gl;lJ/ 2016?Mk; Mz;L jkpH;ehL muR CHpah;fspd; (gzp epge;jidfs;) rl;lk;.6 gphpt[ 50?,d;go mwptpg;g[ fhyk; 90 ehl;fs; vd;gJ njitahdJ vd;w Kot[f;F ePjpah; <uhak; te;jJ/ cah; ePjpkd;wf; fUj;jpd;go. ,e;j 90 ehl;fs; fhy mst[ vd;gJ mjpfhu mikg;g[f;F kl;Lkpd;wp. gzp tpyfy; fojk; mspj;j egh;. jdJ gzp tpyfy; fojj;ij jpUk;gg;bgwntz;Lkh vd;gij kWghprPyid bra;tjw;Fk; gad; mspf;Fk;tpjkhd jpl;lkplg;gl;ljhFk;/ mwptpg;g[ fhyk; fhyhtjpahFk;tiu fhj;jpUf;fhky;. gzp tpyfy; fojj;ij Vw;Wf;bfhz;ljw;fhf cah; ePjpkd;wk; nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;fis FiwTwp. mjd;goahf Koit ePf;fwt[ bra;jJ/ mjd;gpd;. gzpiaj; bjhlh;tjw;F kPz;Lk; gzpapykh;j;jpf;bfhs;s jPh;tspf;fg;gl;lJ/ 5/ cah; ePjpkd;wk;. 2016?Mk; Mz;L rl;lj;jpd; gphpt[ 50?,d; tifa';fspd; kPJ rhh;t[w;wntisapy;. vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh; tpjpfspd; tpjp 35(m)?My; fl;Lg;gLj;jg;gLfpwhh; vd;W nky;KiwaPl;lhsh; rhh;ghf Kd;dpiyahd fw;wwpe;j tHf;Fiu"h; Muk;gj;jpy; thjpl;Ls;shh;/ nkYk;. cah; ePjpkd;wj; jPh;g;g[iuapy; vLFwpg;gplg;gl;Ls;s gphpt[ 50(2)?,d; tifa';fspy; tpLghLs;sJ/ mJ. tifaj;jpd; bghUs;tpsf;fj;jpy; cs;sl';fpapUf;ff;TLk; vd;W thjplg;gl;lJ/ gzp tpyfy; fojk; xUKiw Vw;Wf;bfhs;sg;gl;Ltpl;lhy;. mijj; jpUk;gg;bgWtjw;F vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsUf;F tha;g;gpy;iy vd;W fw;wwpe;j tHf;Fiu"h; thjpl;lhh;/ _______________________ 5/ ePjpg;nguhiz nky;KiwaPL vz; 1596-2018 6/ @rl;lk; 2016@

6/ ,e;j thjj;ij vjph;j;J. 2017?Mk; Mz;L $^d; 12?Mk; ehsd;W gzp tpyfy; fojj;ij Vw;Wf;bfhs;tJ vd;gJ tpHpg;g[g;gzp kw;Wk; gpw muR mYtypypUf;Fk; jilia ePf;fp. ,irt[ bgWtjw;F cl;gl;ljhy;. mJ rl;lg;go bry;yj;jf;fjy;y vd;W vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh; rhh;ghf typa[Wj;jg;gl;lJ/ nkYk;. gzp tpyfy; fojj;ij jpUk;gg;bgWtjw;F gzpahsUf;F 90 ehl;fs; tha;g;gspf;fg;gl;oUe;jJ/ nkYk;. ,jw;fpilapy; gzp tpyfy; fojk; Vw;Wf;bfhs;sg;gLkhdhy;. mJ ve;j chpikj; jFjpiaa[k; ghjpf;fhJ vd;w ePjpah; <uhaj;jpd; fhuz tpsf;fj;ij fw;wwpe;j tHf;Fiu"h; Mjhpj;jhh;/ 7/ tpjpfspd; tpjp 35(m)?,d; tifa';fs;. 2016?Mk; Mz;od; rl;lg;gphpt[ 50?f;F xj;jpirahdit/ fhtyuhd vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;. tpjp 35(m)?My; fl;Lg;gLj;jg;gl;lhh;/ ,J gpd;tUkhW vLFwpg;gplg;gl;Ls;sJ: @35(M)/ gzp tpyfy; fojj;ij Vw;Wf;bfhs;Sjy;: (m) gzpapYs;s CHpah; epakd mjpfhu mikg;gplk; neuoahf vGj;JK:ykhf Fiwe;jgl;rk; K:d;W khj';fSf;FKd; mwptpg;g[ bfhLj;J. jdJ mLj;j nkyjpfhhpf;F xU efiyf; Fwpapl;L mDg;gp. gzptpyfpf;bfhs;syhk;/ mj;jifa K:d;Wkhj mwptpg;g[f;fhyk; vd;gJ epakd mjpfhu mikg;ghy; mt;twpg;ig bgWk; ehspypUe;J fzf;fplg;gLjy;ntz;Lk;/ M) muR CHpahpd; gzp tpyfy; mwptpg;g[ Vw;Wf; bfhs;sg;gLtjw;F Kd;ghf. mjid jpUk;gg;bgw;Wbfhs;syhk;/

epakd mjpfhu mikg;ghy; gzp tpyfy; Vw;Wf;bfhs;sg;gl;l gpwF. gzp tpyfy; jpUk;gg;bgWjy; mDkjpf;fg;glhJ/ ,) epakd mjpfhu mikg;ghdJ. gzp tpyfy; mwptpg;g[ fhyhtjpahFk; ehSf;F Kd;gy;yhj xU njjpapypUe;J gzp tpyfiy Vw;Wf;bfhs;snth. mjw;F fhuz';fisf;Twp epuhfhpf;fnth. mt;twpg;g[ fhyhtjpahFk; ehSf;F Kd;dnuh gzp tpyfy; mwptpg;gpd;nghpy; cj;jut[fs; gpwg;gpj;jy;ntz;Lk;/ mj;jifa cj;jut[ gpwg;gpf;fg;gltpy;iybadpy;. mt;twpg;g[ fhyk; fhyhtjpahdjd;nghpy; gzp tpyfy; Vw;Wf; bfhs;sg;gl;ljhf fUjg;gLjy;ntz;Lk;/@ 8/ gzp tpyfYf;F Kd;g[ gzpahsh; xUth; epakdk; bra;a[k; mjpfhu mikg;gpw;F vGj;JK:ykhf Fiwe;jgl;rk; K:d;W khj';fSf;FKd; mwptpg;g[ bfhLf;fntz;Lk; vd;W tpjp 35(m)?,d; TW (m) fl;lisapLfpwJ/ TW (M)?,d; fPH; mwptpg;ghdJ Vw;fg;gLtjw;F Kd;g[. jpUk;gg; bgw;Wf;bfhs;sg;glyhk;/ epakd mjpfhu mikg;ghy; gzptpyfy; Vw;Wf;bfhs;sg;gl;l gpd;dh;. mjidj; jpUk;gg;bgWjy; mDkjpf;fg;gLtjpy;iy vd;gjhFk;/ TW (,)?,d;go. mwptpg;g[ fhyhtjp njjpf;F Kd;dh; gzptpyfy; mwptpg;gpd;nghpy; epakd mjpfhu mikg;g[ Mizfisg; gpwg;gpf;f ntz;oajhfpwJ/ gzp tpyfy; Vw;Wf;bfhs;sg;gl;oUf;Fkhdhy; Vw;Wf;bfhs;sg;gLk; njjpahdJ mwptpg;g[ fhyhtjpahd njjpf;F gpd;duhf ,Uj;jyhfhJ/ MiznaJk; gpwg;gpf;fg;gltpy;iybadpy; gzp tpyfyhdJ

mwptpg;g[ fhyk; fhyhtjpahdjd;nghpy; Vw;Wf;bfhs;sg;gl;ljhff; fUjg;gLfpwJ vd;gjhFk;/ tpjpfs; (M) kw;Wk; (,) tpjp 35(M)?,d; tifa';fs; kpf bjspt[g;gLj;JtjhtJ: (i) gzp tpyfiy Vw;Wf;bfhs;tjw;F Kd;g[ mJ jpUk;gg; bgwg;glntz;Lk;; kw;Wk; (ii) mij Vw;Wf;bfhs;tjd;nghpy; gzp tpyfiy jpUk;gg;bgWtjw;fhd chpikia gzpahsh; ,Hf;fpwhh;/ nkYk;. gzp tpyfiy Vw;Wf;bfhs;ifapy;. mJ vg;bghGjpypUe;J braYf;FtUk; vd;W xU njjpiaf; Fwpg;gpLtjw;F mjpfhuk; mspf;fg;gl;Ls;sJ/ mJ. mwptpg;g[ njjp fhyhtjpahd gpwfhd njjpahf ,Uj;jyhfhJ/ mjhtJ mjpfhu mikg;g[. mwptpg;g[ fhyhtjpahtjw;F Kd;ghf cs;s xU njjpapy; gzp tpyfiy rl;lhPjpahf Vw;Wf;bfhs;syhk;/ gzp tpyfiy Vw;Wf;bfhz;ljd;nghpy; gzp Kot[f;F te;JtpLfpwJ/ nkYk;. gzpahshpd; gzp tpyfiy jpUk;gg;bgWtjw;fhd tha;g;gpy;iy vd;W tpjp 35(m)?,d; TW (,)?ypUe;J bjspthfpwJ/ 9/ jw;nghija tHf;fpy; 2017?Mk; Mz;L $^d; jp';fs; 1?Mk; ehsplg;gl;l gzp tpyfyhdJ. 2017?Mk; Mz;L $^d; jp';fs; 12?Mk; ehsd;W Vw;Wf;bfhs;sg;gl;lJ vd;W nkw;Twg;gl;l bghUz;ikfspypUe;J Rl;of;fhl;lg;gl;Ls;sd/ mjw;Fg;gpwF 2017?Mk; Mz;L $^iy 13?Mk; ehsd;W. mjhtJ. xU khjk; fHpj;Jj;jhd; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh; gzp tpyfiyj; jpUk;gg;bgw vz;zpdhh;/ gzp tpyfiy Vw;Wf;bfhs;tjd;nghpy; mJ braYf;F te;JtpLtjhy;. mij jpUk;gg;bgWtjhy; ve;jg; gaDkpy;iy/ gzp tpyfiy

Vw;Wf;bfhz;lJ bry;yj;jfhjJ vd;W thjj;jpy; eh';fs; jFjp vjida[k; fhztpy;iy/ gpwg;gpf;fg;gl;l MizahdJ. gzp tpyfy; Vw;Wf;bfhs;sg;gl;lij bjspthfr; Rl;of;fhl;LfpwJ/ vdpDk;. tpHpg;g[g;gzp kw;Wk; CHy; jLg;g[j;Jiw VnjDk; vjpuhd fUj;Jfis Rl;of;fhl;oapUe;jhnyh my;yJ rpwg;g[ gphpt[ Fw;wg; g[ydha;t[j; Jiwahy; VnjDk; vjpuhd Fwpg;g[iu bra;jpUe;jhnyh gzp tpyfy; ,uj;J bra;ag;gLk; vd;W Miz tifbra;fpwJ/ tHf;fpd; bghUz;ik vd;gJ gzp tpyfy; Vw;ghdJ 2017?Mk; Mz;L $^d; 12?Mk; njjpad;W Koe;Jtpl;lJ/ ,e;epiy ,Uf;Fk;nghJ rl;lg;go jpUk;gg;bgWjypy; gandJkpy;iy/ 10/ tpjpfspd;go. nfhug;gLfpd;w mwptpg;g[ fhykhd 90 ehl;fSf;Fs; gzp tpyfiy Vw;Wf;bfhz;lhY';Tl. mjidj; jpUk;gg;bgw gzpahsUf;F tha;g;g[s;sJ vd;w Kot[f;F te;jjpy; cah; ePjpkd;wk; epahag;gLj;jg;gltpy;iy/ ,e;j bghUs;tpsf;fk; tpjp 35(M)?,d; tifa';fSf;F Kw;wpYk; KuzhdjhFk;/ 11/ mjd;go eh';fs; nky;KiwaPl;il mDkjpj;J. fw;wwpe;j jdpakh; ePjpauruhy; ePjpg;nguhiz kD js;Sgo bra;ag;gl;lij cWjpbra;J. 2019?Mk; Mz;L khh;r; jp';fs; 27?Mk; njjpapl;l cah; ePjpkd;wj;jpd; vjph;g;g[f;Fs;shd jPh;g;g[iu kw;Wk; cj;juit ePf;fwt[ bra;fpnwhk;/ bryt[j; bjhif Fwpj;J cj;juntJkpy;iy/

12/ vdpDk;. g[jpa epakdj;jpw;fhf tpz;zg;gpg;gjw;Fk;. VnjDk; bjhpt[Kiw elf;Fk;nghJk; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhshpd; tHpapy; ,t;t[j;jut[ FWf;fplhJ kw;Wk; mj;jifa tpz;zg;gk; VJk; rl;lj;jpw;Fl;gl;L ghprPypf;fg;glyhk; vd;gijj; bjspthf;Ffpnwhk;/ khz;g[kpF ePjpaurh; Kidth; jpU/ jd";b$a xa;/ re;jpuN:l; khz;g[kpF ePjpaurh; jpU/ cwphpc&pnfc&; uha; g[J jpy;yp. 13/12/2019/ //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// chpikj;Jwg;g[ @tl;lhu bkhHpapy; bkhHpahf;fk; bra;ag;gl;l ,j;jPh;g;g[iuahdJ. tHf;fho. jd;Dila bkhHpapy; g[hpe;Jbfhs;tjw;F gad;gLj;jpf;bfhs;tjw;Fl;gl;lnjad;wp. ntbwe;j nehf;fj;jpw;fhft[k; gad;gLj;jpf;bfhs;syhfhJ/ midj;J eilKiwahd kw;Wk; mYty;Kiwahd nehf;f';fSf;Fk; kw;Wk; jPh;g;g[iuia epiwntw;wYf;Fk;. braw;gLj;jYf;Fk; mjd; M';fpyg; gjpg;ng mjpfhug;g{h;tkhdjhFk;/@

JUDGMENT