Full Text
Translation output
O li ™ HIGH COmT OF DELffl AT NE^ DELHI ;
ATI T) Q'7^'^/9ni R & ClVt APPL- No.35/o5/.2vl"
• KsssssjSiKnmffR^rru s." sss v.*..
^ Ms.Sliefali Jeen & Ms. ;Romya
Khanna,Advs. ,
ATI T) Q'7^'^/9ni R & ClVt APPL- No.35/o5/.2vl"
• KsssssjSiKnmffR^rru s." sss v.*..
^ Ms.Sliefali Jeen & Ms. ;Romya
Khanna,Advs. ,
VERSUS
i governmentofnotofDELHIANDORS.
Through; Mr. Santosh Kr. Tripathi, ASC
(GNCTD) with Mr. Shashank
Tiwari&Mr.ArpitBisht,Advs.for
R1 &2, , _
Mr. Abhay Prakash Sahay, CGbG with Ms.Indira Goswami,Adv.for
R-3.
38076-
+ WP(C) 9279/2018 & CM APPL. Nos. 35851/2018
. Petitioner
Through: Mr. Rakesh K. Khanna, Sr Adv. with Mr. Kaushal Yadav, Ms.Shefali Jeen & Ms,. Romya
Khanna,Advs.
Through; Mr. Santosh Kr. Tripathi, ASC
(GNCTD) with Mr. Shashank
Tiwari&Mr.ArpitBisht,Advs.for
R1 &2, , _
Mr. Abhay Prakash Sahay, CGbG with Ms.Indira Goswami,Adv.for
R-3.
38076-
+ WP(C) 9279/2018 & CM APPL. Nos. 35851/2018
. Petitioner
Through: Mr. Rakesh K. Khanna, Sr Adv. with Mr. Kaushal Yadav, Ms.Shefali Jeen & Ms,. Romya
Khanna,Advs.
VERSUS
. '
^ governmentofnotofDELHIANDORS.
Through: Mr. A.S. Chandiok, Ms.iManmeet
Arora,Ms.Plerinder KaurBrar,Mr. Sarvesh -Singh, Mr.;,, T^asvi
Ghoudhary, Mr. Rishabh Sureka &
Ms. Shatakshi Shahi, Advs. for applicants. >0^ f
Mr. Anuj Aggarwal, ASG tor
GNCTDforRl&^ ^ !
2019:DHC:7430-DB
"2_> with Ms.Indira Goswami,Adv.for
. R-3.
^ M/SSay SECURITYAGENCY with Mr. Kaushal Yadav, Ms.Shefali Jeen & Ms. Romya
Khanna,Advs.
^ governmentofnotofDELHIANDORS.
Through: Mr. A.S. Chandiok, Ms.iManmeet
Arora,Ms.Plerinder KaurBrar,Mr. Sarvesh -Singh, Mr.;,, T^asvi
Ghoudhary, Mr. Rishabh Sureka &
Ms. Shatakshi Shahi, Advs. for applicants. >0^ f
Mr. Anuj Aggarwal, ASG tor
GNCTDforRl&^ ^ !
2019:DHC:7430-DB
"2_> with Ms.Indira Goswami,Adv.for
. R-3.
^ M/SSay SECURITYAGENCY with Mr. Kaushal Yadav, Ms.Shefali Jeen & Ms. Romya
Khanna,Advs.
VERSUS
governmentofnotofDELHIANDORS.
Throush; Mr. Santosh Kr. Tripathi, ASC
(GNCTD) with Mr. Shashank
Tiwari&Mr.ArpitBisht,Advs.for
R1 & 2.
Mr. Anurag Ahluwalia,CGSC with
Mr. Abhigyan Siddhant, Adv. for
UOI.
COKAlVIi tioiv'RT F MR.JUSTICE G.S.SISTANI
HON'BLEMR.JUSTICEANUPJAIRAMBHAMBHAN
0/„ 23.10.2019
Inthesethreewritpetitions,commonquestionhasbeenraised.
For the sake ofconvenience,we may note the prayer m W.P.(C)
9253/2018.
"(a) issue appropriate wnV order or direetiom m the nature ofmandamusdirectingthe respondentNos.I and
2to strietlyfollow the guidelines in inviting the tenders for deployment ofsecurity agencies in the Government medical institutes, contained in policy decision dated
19.02.2007. . ■ fh.
(b) issue appropriate writ order or directions in the
-2^
No GEM/20!8/B/683I0dt.16.08.2018imitingbidsfrom the civil contractorsfor deploying the security guards andsupervisorsin GovernmentMedicalInstitutes.
(c)pass such other andfurther orders as this Hon ble
Court may deemfitandproper.
Duringthecourseofhearingtoday,itispointed-outthatthesubject matter of these writ petitions, which is tender bearing No.
GBPH 155624_1, has already been awarded; and the petitioners havebeenrejectedastheywerenottechnicallyqualified.
Resultantly,allthe writpetitionshavebecomeinfiaictuous.
Mr Khanna,learnedsenior counselforthe petitionerssubmitsthat whilethepetitionsmaybedismissedaswithdrawn, thepetitionerswould takerecourseto such remedy as maybe availabletothem in accordance withlaw.andthatthereforethequestionsraisedinthese petitionsbeleft open. -i- ■ A
These writpetitions and the applieations are aeeordingly ismisse as withdrawn.
Leave as prayedfor,is granted.
Alltheinterim ordersstand vaeated.
Dastiunderthe signatures ofCourtMaster.
G.S.SISTANI,J.
ANUP JAIRAMBHAMBHANI,J.
OCTOBER 23,2019/m/
Throush; Mr. Santosh Kr. Tripathi, ASC
(GNCTD) with Mr. Shashank
Tiwari&Mr.ArpitBisht,Advs.for
R1 & 2.
Mr. Anurag Ahluwalia,CGSC with
Mr. Abhigyan Siddhant, Adv. for
UOI.
COKAlVIi tioiv'RT F MR.JUSTICE G.S.SISTANI
HON'BLEMR.JUSTICEANUPJAIRAMBHAMBHAN
0/„ 23.10.2019
Inthesethreewritpetitions,commonquestionhasbeenraised.
For the sake ofconvenience,we may note the prayer m W.P.(C)
9253/2018.
"(a) issue appropriate wnV order or direetiom m the nature ofmandamusdirectingthe respondentNos.I and
2to strietlyfollow the guidelines in inviting the tenders for deployment ofsecurity agencies in the Government medical institutes, contained in policy decision dated
19.02.2007. . ■ fh.
(b) issue appropriate writ order or directions in the
-2^
No GEM/20!8/B/683I0dt.16.08.2018imitingbidsfrom the civil contractorsfor deploying the security guards andsupervisorsin GovernmentMedicalInstitutes.
(c)pass such other andfurther orders as this Hon ble
Court may deemfitandproper.
Duringthecourseofhearingtoday,itispointed-outthatthesubject matter of these writ petitions, which is tender bearing No.
GBPH 155624_1, has already been awarded; and the petitioners havebeenrejectedastheywerenottechnicallyqualified.
Resultantly,allthe writpetitionshavebecomeinfiaictuous.
Mr Khanna,learnedsenior counselforthe petitionerssubmitsthat whilethepetitionsmaybedismissedaswithdrawn, thepetitionerswould takerecourseto such remedy as maybe availabletothem in accordance withlaw.andthatthereforethequestionsraisedinthese petitionsbeleft open. -i- ■ A
These writpetitions and the applieations are aeeordingly ismisse as withdrawn.
Leave as prayedfor,is granted.
Alltheinterim ordersstand vaeated.
Dastiunderthe signatures ofCourtMaster.
G.S.SISTANI,J.
ANUP JAIRAMBHAMBHANI,J.
OCTOBER 23,2019/m/
JUDGMENT