4c44d5d0354b492e4ffd8afe267fcba50623b86c09d2970a5aa8cc673e5ee52f

UNKNOWN COURT · 19 Feb 2020
9492-2019
2020 INSC 213
property petition_allowed Significant

AI Summary

The court held that eviction and rent enhancement under the Tamil Nadu Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1959, require strict statutory compliance, protecting tenants against arbitrary eviction and unreasonable rent increases.

Full Text
Translation output
,e;jpa cr;r ePjpkd;wk; chpikapay; nky;KiwaPl;L mjpfhutuk;g[ chpikapay; nky;KiwaPL vz;; 9492-2019
(rpwg;g[ mDkjp kD (c) vz; 10520-2017?ypUe;J vGfpwJ)
_ u';fehjRthkpapd; jpUt[Utr; rpiy mjd; rhh;ghsuhf bray; mYtyuhd
,iz Mizah; /// nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;
?vjph;? gp/nf/ bjhg;g[sd; brl;oahh;.
,uhkhD$ Tlk; md;djhd mwf;fl;lis. mjd; rhh;ghsuhf eph;thf mw';fhtyh; kw;Wk; gyh; /// vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;fs; jPh;g;g[iu khz;g[kpF ePjpaurh; Kidth; jpU/ jd";b$a xa;/ re;jpuN:l;:
1/ ,k;nky;KiwaPL bkl;uh!; cah; ePjpkd;wj;jpd; kJiu ePjpauhaj;jpd; jdpakh; ePjpaurhpd; 2016?Mk; Mz;L ork;gh; jp';fs; 1?Mk; njjpaplg;gl;l jPh;g;g[iuapypUe;J vGfpwJ/ cah; ePjpkd;wk;. nky;KiwaPl;lhshpd; ,uz;lhk; nky;KiwaPl;ilj; js;Sgo bra;J. ehd;fhk; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsUf;F tHf;Fr; brhj;jpd; xU gFjpia tpw;gid bra;a Kjy; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsUf;F mDkjpaspj;J. jpUr;rpuhg;gs;sp ,uz;lhtJ TLjy; rhh;g[ ePjpgjp mth;fspd;
2004?Mk; Mz;L etk;gh; jp';fs; 10?Mk; njjpaplg;gl;l jPh;g;ghiziaa[k;. jpUr;rpuhg;gs;sp. Kjd;ik khtl;l ePjpgjp mth;fspd; 2005?Mk; Mz;L Mf!;l;
31?Mk; njjpaplg;gl;l jPh;g;g[iuiaa[k; cWjpbra;jJ/
2020 INSC 213
2/ Kjy; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;. mjd; epUthf mw';fhtyuhy; rhh;ghw;wg;gLk; mwf;fl;lisahFk;/ ,uz;lhk; kw;Wk; K:d;whk; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;fs; Kjy; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhshpd; cWg;gpdh;fshth;/ tHf;Fr; brhj;J Kjypy; 1887?Mk; Mz;L $^d; jp';fs; 2?Mk; njjpad;W bjhg;g[sd; brl;oahuhy; th';fg;gl;lJ/ brhj;jpd; xU gFjpapy; _ u';fehjRthkp bja;tj;jpw;F mth; *fy; kz;lgk;* xd;iwf; fl;odhh;/ ,e;Jj; jpUtpHhf; fhy';fspd;nghJ. mth; _ u';fehjRthkp bja;tj;ij ntz;of;bfhz;L mjd; mUisg; bgWtJ tHf;fk;/ nkYk;. bjhg;g[sd; brl;oahh; mtuJ jhdpa nrkpg;g[f; fpl';F bjhHpypd; K:yk; Vw;gLj;jg;gl;l @kfpik@ epjpapypUe;J
(flt[spd; fzf;F) gf;jh;fspd; eyDf;fhf fn$e;jpu nkhl;rk; kw;Wk; gjpbdl;lhk; go tpHhf;fspd;nghJ K:d;W ehl;fSf;F FoePh; kw;Wk; nfH;tuF TH; tpepnahfpg;gJ nghd;w gpw mwg;gzpfisa[k; tHf;Fr; brhj;jpy; nkw;bfhz;L te;jhh;/ bjhg;g[sd; brl;oahh;. bjhlh;e;J gjpdhd;F Mz;Lfs; ,e;j mwg;gzpfisr; bra;Jte;j gpd;dh;. 1901?Mk; Mz;L $^iy jp';fs; 8?Mk; njjpad;W vjph;fhyj;jpy; tHf;Fr; brhj;jpid tpw;gijnah my;yJ milkhdk; itg;gijnah jLj;Jk;. nkYk;. mtuJ kuzj;jpw;Fg; gpwF. mtuJ tHpj;njhd;wy;fs; *mth;fspd; bjhHpypd;* tUkhdj;jpypUe;J ,e;j mwg;gzpfisj; bjhlh;e;J nkw;bfhs;sntz;Lk; vd gzpj;Jk; mWjpahtzk; xd;iw epiwntw;wpdhh;/ mWjpahtzj;jpd; bjhlh;g[ila TWfs; ,j;jPh;g;g[iuapd; gpe;ija gFjpapy; Ma;t[ bra;ag;gl;Ls;sd/
3/ 1978?Mk; Mz;L Vg;uy; 29?Mk; njjpaplg;gl;l Fj;jifahtzj;jpd;
K:ykhf tHf;Fr; brhj;J _ u';fh `iggh; epWtdj;jpw;F ,UgJ Mz;LfSf;F
Fj;jiff;F tplg;gl;lJ/ _ u';fh `iggh; nkw;bfhz;L gy;ntW K:d;whk; jug;gpdh;fSf;F tHf;Fr; brhj;ij cs;?Fj;jiff;F tpl;lJ/ 2.500 rJu mo gug;gst[ bfhz;l tHf;Fr; brhj;jpd; xU gFjp K:d;whk; jug;gpduhy;
Mf;fpukpf;fg;gl;lJ. Kjy; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh; Mf;fpukpg;ghsh;fis btspnaw;Wtjw;fhf. jpUr;rp Kjd;ik rhh;g[ ePjpgjpapd; Kd;ghf Xh; chpik tHf;ifj;1 jhf;fy; bra;jhh;/ tHf;Fr; brhj;jpidg; guhkhpg;gjpy; cs;s rpuk';fspd; fhuzkhft[k;. Mf;fpukpg;igj; jLg;gjw;fhft[k; Kjy; nky;KiwaPl;lhshpd; epUthf mw';fhtyh;fs;. *fy; kz;lgk;* mike;Js;s
4.135 rJu moiaj; jtph;j;J. tHf;Fr; brhj;jpid (20.865 rJu mo) ehd;fhk; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsUf;;F fpiuak; bra;a jPh;khdpj;jdh;/ tpw;gidj; bjhifapypUe;J fpilf;Fk; tl;oia mwf;fl;lisapd; nehf;fj;ij epiwntw;Wtjw;fhf gad;gLj;Jtnj fpiuak; bra;jjd; nehf;fkhFk;/ 2001?Mk;
Mz;L gpg;uthp jp';fs; 1?Mk; njjpaplg;gl;l xg;ge;jj;jpd; K:yk;. Kjy; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh; (bkhj;j gug;gsthd 25.000 rJu moapypUe;J)
20.865 rJu mo gug;gst[ila epyj;ij ehd;fhk; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsUf;F tpw;f Kide;jhh;/ jw;nghija gpur;rpidahdJ 20.865 rJu moia fpiuak; bra;a Kd;bkhHpag;gl;lJ bjhlh;ghdjhFk;/
4/ Kjy; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;. tHf;Fr; brhj;jpid ehd;fhk; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsUf;F Mjuthf fpiuak; bra;at[k;. nkYk;. tpw;gidj; bjhifia njrpakakhf;fg;gl;l t';fpapy; itg;gPL bra;at[k; mDkjpnfhhp
??????????????????????????
1/ K/t/ vz; 706-1984
2004?Mk; Mz;oy; jpUr;rpuhg;gs;sp. ,uz;lhtJ TLjy; rhh;g[ ePjpgjpapd; Kd;ghf chpik tHf;F2 xd;iwj; jhf;fy; bra;jhh;/ nky;KiwaPl;lhsuhd
_ u';fehjRthkpapd; jpUt[Utr; rpiyapd; rhh;ghsuhd bray; mYtyuhy;
(ehd;fhk; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;) Kd;bkhHpag;gl;l fpiuak; vjph;f;fg;gl;lJ/ brhj;jpid chpikkhw;wk; bra;a mwf;fl;lisf;F chpikapy;iy vd;Wk;. bjhg;g[sd; brl;oahh; mwg;gzpfis epiwntw;Wtjw;F jpUt[Utr; rpiyf;F bkhj;jr; brhj;jpida[k; mh;g;gzpj;jpUe;jhh; vd;Wk; nky;KiwaPl;lhsuhy; thjplg;gl;lJ/ Kjy; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh; vd;gJ Fwpj;jtif mwg;gzpfis nkw;bfhs;s njhw;Wtpf;fg;gl;l xU bghJ rka mwf;fl;lisahFk;. vdnt tHf;Fr; brhj;J. 1959?Mk; Mz;L jkpH;ehL ,e;J rka kw;Wk; mwepiyf;bfhilfs; rl;lj;jpd;3 gphpt[ 6(19)?,d; fPH; fUj;Jiuf;fg;gl;lthW xU
Fwpg;gpl;l epiyf;bfhilia mikf;fpwJ vd;W nky;KiwaPl;lhsh; Fwpg;gpl;lhh;/ nky;KiwaPl;lhshpd; Tw;Wg;go. 1959?Mk; Mz;L rl;lj;jpd; gphpt[ 34?,d;go. mwf;fl;lisapd; tHf;Fr; brhj;jpid chpikkhw;wk; bra;a xg;gspg;g[ tH';Ftjw;F ,e;J rka mwepiyaj; Jiwapd; MizaUf;F mjpfhuk; cs;snj jtpu. chpikapay; ePjpkd;wj;jpw;F mjpfhutuk;g[ ,y;iy vd;gjhFk;/
5/ ,uz;lhtJ TLjy; rhh;g[ ePjpgjp mth;fs;. 2004?Mk; Mz;L etk;gh; jp';fs; 10?Mk; njjpad;W Kjy; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhshpd; chpik tHf;ifj; jPh;g;ghizapl;L. Kjy; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsuhd mwf;fl;lis xU
2/ K/t/ vz; 60-2004
3/ 1959?Mk; Mz;L rl;lk;
jdpahh; mwf;fl;lisnaad;wp. bghJ mwf;fl;lis my;y vd;gjhy; 1959?Mk;
Mz;L rl;lk; mjw;F bghUe;jhJ vdj; jPh;khdpj;jhh;/ nky;KiwaPl;lhsUf;F brhe;jkhd brhj;Jfspd; gjpntLfspy; tHf;Fr; brhj;J Fwpj;J
Fwpg;gplg;gltpy;iy vd;w r';fjpapd;kPJ rhh;t[w;w tprhuiz ePjpgjp. mWjpahtzkhdJ nky;KiwaPl;lhsUf;F tHf;Fr; brhj;jpy; chpik mspf;ftpy;iy vdj; jPh;khdpj;jhh;/ mjd;go. 1959?Mk; Mz;L rl;lj;jpd; gphpt[
34 bghUe;jhJ vd;Wk;. nkYk; Kd;bkhHpag;gl;l fpiuakhdJ chpikapay; ePjpkd;wj;jhy; kl;Lnk xg;gspf;fg;glKoa[k; vd;Wk; jPh;khdpf;fg;gl;lJ/
6/ jpUr;rpuhg;gs;sp. Kjd;ik khtl;l ePjpgjp mth;fs;. nky;KiwaPl;oy; 2005?Mk; Mz;L Mf!;l; jp';fs; 31?Mk; njjpaplg;gl;l jPh;g;g[iuapd; K:yk; tprhuiz ePjpkd;wj;jpd; jPh;g;g[iuia cWjpbra;jhh;/ nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;. bkl;uh!; cah; ePjpkd;wj;jpd; Kd;ghf ,uz;lhk; nky;KiwaPl;il Kd;bfhzh;e;jhh;/ cah; ePjpkd;wk; 2016?Mk; Mz;L etk;gh; jp';fs; 1?Mk; njjpaplg;gl;l mjd; jPh;g;g[iuapd; K:yk;. nky;KiwaPl;lhsUf;F
Mjuthf mWjpahtzkhdJ VbjhU gw;Wg;bghWg;gpidnah. tpy;y';fj;ijnah cz;lhf;ftpy;iy vdj; jPh;khdpj;J. ,uz;lhk; nky;KiwaPl;ilj; js;Sgo bra;jJ/ Kjy; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsuhd mwf;fl;lisahdJ xU jdpahh; mwf;fl;lisnaad;wp. rka mwf;fl;lis my;y vd;gjhy;. mjw;F 1959?Mk;
Mz;L rl;lj;jpd; gphpt[ 34 bghUe;jhJ vdt[k;. Mfnt. Kd;bkhHpag;gl;l brhj;jpd; fpiuaj;ij chpikapay; ePjpkd;wk; mDkjpf;fyhk; vdt[k; cah; ePjpkd;wk; jPh;khdpj;jJ/ ,f;fhz;Kot[fs; nky;KiwaPl;lhsuhy; ,e;ePjpkd;wj;jpd;
Kd;g[ vjph;j;Jiuf;fg;gl;Ls;sd/
7/ nky;KiwaPl;lhsUf;fhf Kd;dpiyahd fw;wwpe;j K:j;j tHf;Fiu"h; jpU/ nkhfd; guhrud; gpd;tUk; fhuz';fspd; mog;gilapy; cah; ePjpkd;wj;jpd; jPh;g;g[iuia vjph;j;jhh;:
(i) bjhg;g[sd; brl;oahh;. _ u';fehjRthkpapd; fh;g;gf;fpufk; bjhlh;ghd mwg;gzpfis epiwntw;Wtjw;fhf brhj;jpid th';fpapUe;jjhf mWjpahtzk; bjhptpf;fpwJ/ nkw;go nehf;fj;jpw;fhf fl;lg;gl;l fU';fy; kz;lgj;jpy; bjhg;g[sd; brl;oahh;. jpUt[Utr; rpiyia vGe;jUsr;bra;jhh;/ tHf;Fr; brhj;J mwg;gzpf;fhf
Fwpf;fg;gl;oUe;jjhy; kw;Wk; xJf;fg;gl;oUe;jjhy; mJ mjd; rkarhh;gw;wj; jd;ikia ,He;Jtpl;lJ;
(ii) mWjpahtzj;jpd;go. fn$e;jpu nkhl;rk; kw;Wk; gjpbdl;lhk; go jpUtpHhf;fspd;nghJ nkw;Twpa fU';fy; kz;lgj;jpy; jpUt[Utr; rpiy vGe;jUSk;nghJ. jz;zPh; kw;Wk; nfH;tuF TH; tpepnahfpf;fg;glntz;Lk; vd;gjhFk;/ vdnt. rka mwepiyf;bfhil cUthf;fg;gl;L nky;KiwaPl;lhsuhd nfhapypd; jpUtpHhf;fnshL ,izf;fg;gl;lJ/ Mfnt. rkag; gz;g[f;TWila mwepiyf;bfhilia cUthf;Ftjw;fhd brhj;J mh;g;gzpg;g[ epiyehl;lg;gl;Ls;sJ;
(iii) tHf;Fr; brhj;jpypUe;J bgwg;gLk; tUkhdj;jpypUe;J mwg;gzpahw;wg;glntz;Lk;/ tUkhdk; mjpfkhf ,Ug;gjhf
fz;lwpag;gl;lhy;. kpifahd tUkhdk; FLk;g ,Ug;g[ epjpahf itf;fg;glntz;Lk;/
(iv) mw';fhtyh;fs;. Fwpg;ghf mwg;gzpf;fhf mh;g;gzpf;fg;gl;Ls;s tHf;Fr; brhj;jpid tpw;fnth. milkhdk; itf;fnth jilbra;ag;gl;ldh;;
(v) 1959?Mk; Mz;L rl;lg;go cs;slf;fg;gLk; brhj;jpd; fpiuak; vjida[k; xg;gspf;f 1959?Mk; Mz;L rl;lj;jpd; gphpt[ 34
MizaUf;F mjpfhukspg;gjhy;. vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsuhy; jhf;fy; bra;ag;gl;l chpik tHf;F epiyf;fj;jfhjjhFk;/ murpd; xg;g[jypd;wp xg;gspf;fg;glKoahJ kw;Wk; xg;g[jypd;wp bra;ag;gLk;
VbjhU fpiuaKk; Kw;wpYk; bry;yhjjhFk;; kw;Wk;
(vi) 1959?Mk; Mz;L rl;lj;jpd; tifa';fspd; fPH; cs;sl';Fk; tpla';fisg; bghWj;jtiuapy; 1959?Mk; Mz;L rl;lj;jpd; gphpt[
108 Xh; chpik tHf;ifj; jhf;fy; bra;tjpdpd;W jilbra;tjhy;
Kjy; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh; bfhilaspf;fg;gl;l brhj;jpid fpiuak; bra;a chpikapay; ePjpkd;wj;jpd; xg;gspg;igf; nfhuKoahJ/
8/ ,g;gzpe;Jiufis vjph;j;Jiuj;J vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;fSf;fhf
Kd;dpiyahd fw;wwpe;j K:j;j tHf;Fiu"h; jpU/ tp/ fphp mth;fs; thjpl;ljhtJ:
(i) 1959?Mk; Mz;L rl;lj;jpd; tifa';fs; Kjy; vjph;nky;Kiw? aPl;lhsUf;Fg; bghUe;jhJ/ rl;lg;gphpt[ 3?,d;go mw';fhtyh;fspd; jtwhd nkyhz;ik my;yJ Kiwaw;w brayhl;rpapd; fhuzkhf murhy; mwptpf;if tH';fg;gLk; gl;rj;jpy; kl;Lnk 1959?Mk;
Mz;L rl;lj;jpd; tifa';fs; mwepiyf;bfhilfSf;Fg; bghUe;Jk;/ Kjy; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh; mwf;fl;lisf;F 1959?Mk;
Mz;L rl;lj;jpd; tifa';fspd; bghUe;Jifia tphpthf;Fk; mwptpf;if VJk; eilKiwapy; ,y;iy;
(ii) jdpahh; mwf;fl;lisahy; bghWg;ngw;fg;gLk; mwg;gzpfs;
,e;Jf;fSf;F kl;Lnk chpaitay;y/ Kjy; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;. bghJkf;fSf;fhf rhjp. kjk; my;yJ rkaf;bfhs;if mog;gilapyhd ghFghod;wp epWtg;gl;l rkar;rhh;gw;w xU mwf;fl;lisahFk;;
(iii) mWjpahtzkhdJ nky;KiwaPl;lhsuhd jpUt[Utr; rpiyf;F
Mjuthf Fwpj;jtif mwf;bfhil vija[k; cUthf;ftpy;iy/ bghJ mwg;gzpahw;Wjy; vd;gJ nfhapypy; nkw;bfhs;sg;glntz;Lk; vd cj;jutplg;gltpy;iy. tHf;Fr; brhj;jpnyna mwg;gzpahw;wg;gl ntz;Lk;;
(iv) Kjy; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh; mwf;fl;lisapd; nkyhz;ika[k;. epUthfKk;. mwf;fl;lisiaj; njhw;Wtpj;jthpd;
kug[tHpj;njhd;wy;fshy; kl;Lnk ifahsg;gLfpwJ/ ,/r/m/ep/
Jiw mw';fhtyh;fs; vtiua[k; xUnghJk; epakpj;jjpy;iy. nkYk;. Kjy; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh; mwf;fl;lisapd; nkyhz;ikapy; bghJkf;fs; vtUk; g';nfw;ftpy;iy/
(v) tHf;Fr; brhj;jpid fpiuak; bra;tjw;F mDkjpnfhhp Kjy; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsuhy; jhf;fy; bra;ag;gl;l chpik tHf;ifg; bghWj;jtiuapy; chpikapay; ePjpkd;wj;jpw;F mjpfhutuk;g[ cs;sJ/ bghJ kw;Wk; jdpahh; mwepiyf;bfhilfSf;F 1882?Mk;
Mz;L ,e;jpa mwf;fl;lisfs; rl;lk;. gphpt[ 1 tpyf;fspg;gjhy;. mJ Kjy; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsuhd mwf;fl;lisf;F bghUe;jj;jf;fjhfapuhJ;
(vi) mWjpahtzj;jpYs;s jilahdJ 1882?Mk; Mz;L brhj;Jhpik khw;Wr; rl;lk;4
. gphpt[ 10?,d; fPH; bry;yhepiyajhFk;/ tHf;Fr; brhj;jpd;; Mf;fpukpg;gpd; fhuzkhf Kjy; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhshpd; mw';fhtyh;fs; mwg;gzpia nkw;bfhs;s ,aytpy;iy/ ,ad;wst[ nfhl;ghl;od; mog;gilapy; mwg;gzpahw;wntz;Lk; vd;Dk; mWjpbra;gthpd; vz;zj;ij epiwntw;Wk;bghUl;L tHf;Fr; brhj;jpid ehd;fhk; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsUf;F fpiuak; bra;a mDkjpf;fg;glntz;Lk;; kw;Wk;
4/ brhj;Jhpik khw;Wr; rl;lk;
(vii) nfhapy;. vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsuhd mwf;fl;lisia xUnghJk; fl;Lg;gLj;jpajpy;iy vd;Wk;. nfhapYf;F tHf;Fr; brhj;J mh;g;gzpf;fg;gltpy;iy vd;Wk; nfhapypd; cjtp fz;fhzpg;ghsuhd gp/rh/5 mtuJ FWf;F tprhuizapd;nghJ xg;g[f;bfhz;lhh;/ ghprPyidf;Fhpa vjpbujph; thj';fshtd:
9/ v';fs; Kd;g[ ghprPyidf;F vGk; nfs;tp ahbjdpy;. 1901?Mk; Mz;L
$^iy jp';fs; 8?Mk; njjpaplg;gl;l mWjpahtzk; cUthf;Ffpd;w xU Fwpg;gpl;l epiyf;bfhil 1959?Mk; Mz;L rl;lj;jpdhy; fl;Lg;gLj;jg;gLfpwjh> vd;gjhFk;/
,g;gpur;rpidapd;nghpy; jPh;g;g[ gfUk;bghUl;L. mWjpahtzj;jpd;goahd epiyf;bfhilapd; jd;ikia ,e;ePjpkd;wk; jPh;khdpg;gJ mtrpakhdjhFk;/
Fwpj;jtif epiyf;bfhil cs;sjh> vd;Dk; nfs;tp mWjpahtzj;jpy; gad;gLj;jg;gl;Ls;s Kf;fpakhd thrf';fspd; mog;gilapy; jPh;khdpf;fg;gl ntz;Lk;/ xU Kiwahtzj;jpd; jd;ikahdJ mt;thtzj;jpd; epahakhd kw;Wk; neh;ikahd bghUs;tpsf;fj;jpd; mog;gilapy; xl;Lbkhj;jkhfg; ghprPyidbra;J cWjpbra;ag;glntz;Lk;/ mWjpahtzj;jpd; thrf';fs; gpd;tUkhW:
@mWjpahtzk;
,e;j mWjpahtzkhdJ. 1901?Mk; Mz;L $^iy jp';fs;
8?Mk; njjpad;W jpUr;rpuhg;gs;sp. ghyf;fiu. nkl;Lj; bjUtpy; trpf;Fk; fpUc&;zd; brl;oahh; vd;gthpd; kfdhd
75 taJila bjhg;g[sd; brl;oahuhy; epiwntw;wg;gl;Ls;sJ/ mWjpbra;gth;. U:/750-?f;F _ u';fehjRthkpf;F cWjpahd
fl;Lkhdk; vGg;gp. mjd;kPJ fh;g;gf;fpufk; mikg;gjw;Fk;. fU';fy; kz;lgj;jpy; _ u';fehjRthkpia vGe;jUsr; bra;at[khd mwg;gzpia epiwntw;Wtjw;fhf 2/6/1887 md;W mtuJ brhe;j tUkhdj;jpypUe;J ml;ltizr; brhj;jpy;
Fwpg;gplg;gl;Ls;s g[";ir epyj;ij th';fpdhh;/ ghyf;fiuapYs;s mtuJ bjhHpypypUe;J bgw;w tUkhdj;jpypUe;Jk;. tptrha epyj;jpypUe;J Mz;LnjhWk; fpilf;Fk; tUkhdj;jpypUe;Jk; rpj;jpiu fn$e;jpu nkhl;rk; kw;Wk; 18?Mk; go jpUtpHhtpd;nghJ fU';fy; kz;lgj;jpy; u';fehjRthkpia vGe;jUsr; bra;jhh;/ nkYk;.
,t;tpHhf;fspd;nghJ gf;jh;fspd; eyDf;fhf jz;zPh; ge;jy; mikg;gJk;. K:d;W ehl;fs; nfH;tuF TH; tpepnahfpg;gJkhf
,ij mth; 14 Mz;Lfshf nkw;bfhz;L te;Js;shh;/ mth;
,d;Dk; ,ij mtuJ thH;ehs;tiuapy; bjhlu tpUk;g[fpwhh;/ mtUila thH;ehSf;Fg; gpwF ,e;j mwg;gzpiaj; bjhlUtjw;fhf mtuJ kfd; o/ ,uhika;ah brl;o kw;Wk; mtUila rnfhjuh; o/ jpUnt';fpld; brl;o. rptyp';fk; gilahr;rp fPjhg[uk; bu';fhg[uk; vk;/rp/ tPuhzd; vd;fpw
Kkhd; kzpaf;fhud; kUij kzpaf;fhud; fPjhg[uk; bu';fkzpaf;fhudpd; kfd; mg;ght[ kzpaf;fhud; o/v!;/ f!;J}hp Mfpnahh; nkw;go brhj;jpid tpw;gid bra;anth. milkhdk; itf;fnth TlhJ vdf;
nfl;Lf;bfhs;sg;gLfpd;wdh;/ mWjpahshpd; thH;ehSf;Fg; gpd;dh; mtUila K:d;W kfd;fs; ,e;j mwg;gzpiaj; bjhluntz;Lk;/ mk;K:tUs; vtnuDk; ,ijr; bra;a tpUk;ghtpoy;. kw;wth;fs; mtiuj; bjhe;jut[ bra;af;TlhJ/
K:d;W kfd;fSk; mth;fspd; bjhHpypd; K:yk; ,e;j mwg;gzpf;fhd bryt[fis Vw;fntz;Lk;/ mth;fspd; thH;ehSf;Fg; gpwF mth;fspd; thhpRfshy; mJ bjhlug;gl;L khpahij bgWtijj; bjhluntz;Lk;/ tUkhdk; mjpfkhfapUg;gpd;. mth;fs; bryt[fis vjph;bfhz;lgpd; mjid FLk;g epjpahf itj;Jf;bfhs;sntz;Lk;/ tUkhdk;
FiwthfapUg;gpd;. mth;fs; FLk;g epjpapypUe;J bryt[fisf; ifahsntz;Lk;/ ,e;j mwg;gzpahdJ. FLk;g fld;fSf;nfh my;yJ 3 kfd;fs; mile;j fld;fSf;nfh bghWg;ngw;fhJ/ mWjpahsh;. mth;fspd; xg;g[jy; bgw;wnjhL. fPnH Fwpg;gplg;gl;Ls;s ,uz;L kfd;fspd; ifbaGj;ija[k; bgw;Wf;bfhz;lhh;/ fy; fpzW njhl;lk; mwg;gzpf;fhf xJf;fg;gl;Ls;sJ/ mwg;gzpf;fhf xJf;fg;gl;l brhj;Jfshtd: jpUr;rp khtl;lk;. _u';fk; rhh;epiy khtl;lk;. nkY}h; gFjp. fPjhg[uk;. uFehjg[uk;/
bjw;F ? yc&;kp mk;kzf;fhh; njhl;lk; nkw;F ? ekr;rptha Mrhhp njhl;lk; fpHf;F ? mk;kh kz;lfg;go efuhl;rp vz; 440. U:/3.000-? kjpg;g[s;s g[";ir epyk; FHp
JUDGMENT

66. mj;njhl;lj;jpYs;s fU';fy; kz;lgk;;,e;epyg; guhkhpg;g[k;. fl;lg;gl;LtUk; fU';fy; kz;lgKk; mWjpahsuhy; nkw;bfhs;sg;gl;L tUfpwJ. mtuJ thH;ehSf;Fg; gpd;dh;. nkw;go 3 kfd;fs; mtw;iwj; bjhlh;e;J guhkhpf;fntz;Lk;/@ (typa[Wj;jpf; Twg;gl;lJ) mWjpahtzj;jpypUe;J gpd;tUk; fUj;Jfs; vGfpd;wd: (i) _ u';fehjRthkp nfhapYf;fhd mwg;gzpia nkw;bfhs;tjw;fhf 1877?Mk; Mz;oy; bjhg;g[sd; brl;oahh; tHf;Fr; brhj;jpid th';fpdhh;/ tHf;Fr; brhj;jpd; xU gFjpapy; _ u';fehjRthkpf;fhf fU';fy; fl;olk; fl;lg;gl;lJ/ fn$e;jpu nkhl;rk; kw;Wk; Mo nghd;w,e;J jpUtpHhf;fspd;nghJ.,iwtid ntz;o fU';fy; fl;olj;jpy; vGe;jUsr;bra;J. bjhg;g[sd; brl;oahh; flt[splkpUe;J mUs; bgWtJ tHf;fk;; (ii),e;J jpUtpHhf;fspd;nghJ. bjhg;g[sd; brl;oahh; jz;zPh; ge;jy; mikj;jnjhL. tHf;Fr; brhj;jpy; cs;s _ u';fehjRthkpapd; nfhapYf;F tUifj;jUk; @gf;jh;fspd; eyD@f;fhf nfH;tuF TH; tpepnahfpg;gJ nghd;w mwg;gzpfisr; bra;Jte;jhh;/ mth; mWjpahtzj;jpw;F gjpdhd;F Mz;LfSf;F Kd;gpypUe;nj mwg;gzpfis nkw;bfhz;L te;jhh;;

(iii) bjhg;g[sd; brl;oahhpd; thH;ehspd;nghJ. mWjpahshpd; brhe;j bjhHpypypUe;J fpilf;Fk; tUthiaa[k; kw;Wk; tHf;Fr; brhj;jpypUe;J fpilf;Fk; tUkhdj;ija[k;bfhz;L Vw;gLj;jg;gl;l @kfpik@ epjpapypUe;J (flt[spd; fzf;F),e;j mwg;gzpfSf;F epjpaspf;fg;gl;L te;jd;

(iv) mWjpahshpd; thH;ehSf;Fg; gpd;dh;. mtuJ K:d;W kfd;fSk; mth;fspd; tHpj;njhd;wy;fSk;.,e;j mwg;gzpfisj; bjhlh;tJld;.,iwtdplk; mUisa[k; bjhlh;e;J bgwntz;Lk; vd mth; tpUk;gpdhh;/ mtUila K:d;W kfd;fSk; @mth;fspd; bjhHpypd; K:yk;@ mwg;gzpf;fhd bryt[fis nkw;bfhs;sntz;Lk;/ mwg;gzp bra;tjw;fhd midj;J bryt[fisa[k; vjph;bfhz;l gpd;dh; thhpRfsplk; kpif tUkhdkpUg;gpd;. me;j kpifj; bjhifia FLk;g epjpf;F khw;wp. tU';fhyj;jpy; mwg;gzpfSf;F epjpaspf;f FLk;g epjp nghjhjgl;rj;jpy; mj;bjhifiag; gad;gLj;jpf;bfhs;sntz;Lk;; kw;Wk;

(v) mwg;gzpf;fhf @xJf;fg;gl;l@ kw;Wk; @Fwpf;fg;gl;l@ tHf;Fr; brhj;jpid fpiuak; bra;anth my;yJ milkhdk; itf;fnth KGikahd jil,Ue;jJ/ mnjnghd;W. FLk;g epjpia. K:d;W kfd;fs; mile;j fld;fisj; jPh;j;Jf;bfhs;s gad;gLj;jpf;bfhs;sKoahJ/ 10/ mWjpahtzk; cUthf;Ffpd;w xU Fwpg;gpl;l epiyf;bfhil 1959?Mk; Mz;L rl;lj;jhy; fl;Lg;gLj;jg;gLfpwjh> vd;gij jPh;khdpf;Fk; bghUl;L rl;lj;jpd; bjhlh;g[ila tifa';fisf; Fwpg;gpLtJ mtrpakhdjhfpwJ/ gphpt[ 6(19) Fwpj;jtif epiyf;bfhiliag; gpd;tUkhW tiuaWf;fpwJ: @6/ (19) @Fwpj;jtif epiyf;bfhil@ vd;gJ klk; my;yJ nfhapypy; Fwpj;jtifg;gzp my;yJ mwg;gzp vjida[k; g[hptjw;fhf my;yJ gpw rka mwg;gzp vjida[k; g[hptjw;fhf epiyf;bfhilahf tH';fg;gl;l brhj;J my;yJ gzk; vJt[k; vd;W bghUs;gLk;, Mdhy;. (17)?Mk; Twpd; (1)?Mk; tpsf;fj;jpy; tpthpf;fg;gl;l jd;ikajhd,dhik cs;slf;fhJ;@ xU Fwpj;jtif epiyf;bfhil vd;gJ brhj;jpidnah my;yJ gzj;ijnah (my;yJ,uz;oida[k;) xJf;FtjpypUe;J tpist[wyhk;/ nkYk;. brhj;jpid my;yJ gzj;ij xJf;FtJ vd;gJ xU Fwpg;gpl;l klk; my;yJ nfhapypy; Fwpj;jtif mwg;gzpf;fhf my;yJ bjhz;Lf;fhf vd VnjDk; xd;Wf;fhf,Uf;fyhk;/ mjhtJ. mJ @ntnwnjDk; rka mwg;gzp@ahw;Wtjw;fhf,Uf;fyhk;/ 11/ bjhg;g[sd; brl;oahhpd; thH;ehspd;nghJ mwg;gzpfSf;fhf tHf;Fr; brhj;jpypUe;J fpilf;fpd;w tUkhdj;jpypUe;J epjpaspf;fg;gl;lJ/ tHf;Fr; brhj;jpypUe;J fpilf;Fk; tUkhdk; Fwpj;J mWjpahtzj;jpy; VJk; Fwpg;gplg;gltpy;iybad;whYk;. mjw;Fkhwhf. mJ mWjpahshpd; rl;lg;goahd thhpRfs; mth;fspd; brhe;jj; bjhHpypd; tUkhdj;ijf;bfhz;L mwg;gzpfSf;F epjpaspf;fntz;Lk; vd;Dk; xU flg;ghl;oid cUthf;FfpwJ/ vdnt. jw;nghija tHf;fpy; @gzk;@ VJk; bfhilaspf;fg;gl;lijg; gw;wp nfs;tp vJt[k; vHtpy;iy. nkYk;. tHf;Fr; brhj;nj bfhilaspf;fg;gl;ljh> vd;gnj ehk; tpthjpf;fntz;oa tpdhthFk;/ mjd;go. jw;nghJ ehk; mWjpahtzj;jpd; tifKiwfis Muha;tJld; tHf;Fr; brhj;J bfhilaspf;fg;gl;ljh> vd;Wk;. mt;thwpUg;gpd;. mj;jifa epiyf;bfhil Fwpg;gpl;l nfhapYf;F Mjuthf mspf;fg;gl;ljh> my;yJ @rka mwg;gzp@ Mw;Wtjw;fhf mspf;fg;gl;ljh> vd;gJkhd tpdhtpw;Fk; ftdj;ijj; jpUg;g[fpnwhk;/ 12/ @bfhilaspj;jy;@ vd;gJ xU bghUisnah. brhj;jpidnah my;yJ ntbwjidnah tH';FtJ my;yJ capy;tHp mspg;gjhFk;/ mWjpahshplkpUe;J brhj;jpid mfw;wp. mjid mwg;gzp nehf;fj;jpw;F xJf;fpapUg;gjhf mWjpahtzj;jpd; thrfk; bjhptpf;Fkhapd;. brhj;J bfhilaspf;fg;gl;oUg;gjhfg; bghUs;gLfpwJ/ rpy neh;t[fspy;. epiyf;bfhil. Kw;wpYkhf mwg;gzp nehf;fj;jpw;fhdjhf,Uf;fhJ. brhj;jpd; xUrpy gFjpnah my;yJ brhj;jpypUe;J bgwf;Toa tUthnah. mWjpahshpd; rl;lg;goahd thhpRfSf;fhf xJf;fyhk;/ mWjpahshpd; rl;lg;goahd thhpRfs; rhh;ghd xU gw;Wg;bghWg;g[f;Fl;gl;L. rka";rhh;e;j nehf;fnk Kjd;ikahd mwg;gzpahf,Uf;fntz;Lbkd mWjpahsh; fUjpdhuh> my;yJ mwg;gzp nehf;fj;ij bjhlh;tJ Fwpj;j gw;Wg;bghWg;g[f;Fl;gl;L thhpRfs; Kjd;ikahd mwg;gzpahsh;fshf,Uf;fntz;Lbkdf; fUjpdhuh> vd;w tpdh. mWjpahtzj;ij KGikahf thrpg;gjd; K:ynk jPh;khdpf;fg;glntz;Lk;/ 13/ nkdFU jrujuhkp bul;o ?vjph;? Jj;JFU Rg;gh uht;5 vd;w tHf;fpy;,e;ePjpkd;wj;jpd; murikg;g[ Mak; tHf;Fr; brhj;Jfs; bghJ mwf;fl;lisapd; tHf;Fg;bghUsh> my;yJ Fwpj;jtif mwg;gzpfis nkw;bfhs;tjw;fhd flg;ghL kl;Lnk tpjpf;fg;gl;ljh> vd;Dk; tpdhit tpthjpj;jJ/ khz;g[kpF ePjpaurh; jpU/ gp/gP/ fn$e;jpu fl;fh; (mg;nghija fw;wwpe;j khz;g[kpF jiyik ePjpaurh;) ePjpkd;wj;jpy; gfh;e;j jPh;g;g[iuahtJ: @5/ /////// rka my;yJ mw";rhh;e;j nehf;f';fSf;;fhf KGikahfnth my;yJ gFjpahfnth brhj;jpid mh;g;gzpf;fyhk; vd;gJ jw;nghJ bjspthfpwJ/ KGikahd mh;g;gzpg;ghapd;. bghJ rka mwepiyaj;jpd; rhh;ghf xU mwf;fl;lis cUthf;fg;gLfpwJ/ gFjpahd mh;g;gzpg;ghapd;. me;j mwg;gzpf;fhf xU mwf;fl;lis cUthf;fg;glhnjad;wp. mwg;gzpf;fhd gw;Wg;bghWg;gpid mjDld;,izj;J. mjidj; bjhlh;e;Jte;jhy;. mr;brhj;J mjd; Kjd;ikahd jdpg;gl;l kw;Wk; 5/ V/I/Mh;/ 1957 v!;/rp/ 797 rkarhh;gw;w gz;gpid jf;fitj;Jf;bfhs;fpwJ/ mj;jifa neh;t[fspy;,J vg;nghJk; jug;gpdh;fspd; cz;ikahd vz;zj;ij cWjpg;gLj;Jk; tplakhfnt,Uf;fpwJ; Mtzj;jpd; neh;ikahd kw;Wk; epahakhd bghUs;nfhis KGikahfg; ghprPypj;J me;j vz;zj;ij xU';fpizf;fntz;Lk;/ @mwf;fl;lis@ my;yJ @mw';fhtyh;@ vd;w brhy;ypd; gad;ghL. me;j vz;zj;ijj; jPh;khdpg;gjpy; VnjhbthUtifapy; cjtpg[hpfpwJ vd;gjpy; Iakpy;iybad;whYk;. mr;brhw;fisg; gad;gLj;jpapUg;gjhnyna. mtw;iw tplaj;jpd; Kothfnt fUjptpl,ayhJ/ brhj;jpd;kPjhd jdpg;gl;l chpikK:yk; KGikahf mw;Wg;ngha;tpl;ljhff; fUjyhkh> brhj;J bjhlh;ghd chpikK:yk; KGikahf mwg;gzpf;F khw;wg;gl;ljhff; fUjyhkh>,t;tpdhf;fSf;fhd tpil. @mw';fhtyh;@ my;yJ @mwf;fl;lis@ vd;w brhy;ypd; gad;ghl;ow;F kl;Lk; Kf;fpaj;Jtj;ijf; Fwpj;J fz;lwpa,ayhJ vd;gnjhld;wp. Mtzj;ij xl;Lbkhj;jkhf ghprPypj;J mjd; cz;ikahd cl;bghUis xU';fpizj;nj fz;lwpa,aYk;////@ 14/ mWjpahshpd; cz;ikahd vz;zj;ijj; jPh;khdpg;gjw;F mWjpahtzj;ij xl;Lbkhj;jkhf Muhantz;Lk;/ mWjpahsh;. rka nehf;fj;jpw;fhf brhj;J KGtjpYkpUe;J jd;idj;jhnd tpyf;fpf; bfhs;fpwtplj;J. xU bghJ rka mwf;fl;lis cUthf;fg;gLfpwJ/ jw;nghija tHf;fpy;. mWjpahtzk; tHf;Fr; brhj;ij gpd;dpl;L tpw;gjw;nfh my;yJ milkhdk; itg;gjw;nfh KGikahd jilia tpjpf;fpwJ/ mWjpahsh;. _ u';fehjRthkp fh;g;gfpufk; bjhlh;ghd mwg;gzpahw;Wtjw;fhf ml;ltizr; brhj;jpy; Fwpg;gplg;gl;Ls;s g[";ir epyj;ij th';fpdhh; vd mWjpahtzk; tifbra;fpwJ/ mWjpahtz ml;ltizapy; Fwpg;gplg;gl;l brhj;J. @mwg;gzpf;fhf xJf;fPL bra;ag;gl;l brhj;J@ vd tpthpf;fg;gl;Ls;sJ/ rl;lg;goahd thhpRfisg; bghWj;jtiuapy;. mth;fsJ bjhHpypy; fpilf;Fk; tUthapypUe;J tHf;Fr; brhj;jpy; mwg;gzp eltof;iffisj; bjhlUtjw;F mWjpahshpd; rl;lg;goahd thhpRfs;kPJ,e;j mWjpahtzk; flg;ghl;oid tpjpf;fpwJ/ tHf;Fr; brhj;jpy; mwg;gzpfisj; bjhlh;e;J nkw;bfhs;tjw;fhf. mWjpahsh; jd;ida[k;. jdJ rl;lg;goahd thhpRfisa[k; brhj;jpypUe;J tpLtpj;Jf;bfhz;L. mjidf; bfhilaspf;Fk; bjspthd vz;z';bfhz;oUe;jhh;/ mwg;gzp nkw;bfhs;tnj epiyf;bfhilapd; nehf;fkhFk;/ tHf;Fr; brhj;jpy; mwg;gzpfisj; bjhlh;e;J nkw;bfhs;s mWjpahtzk; rl;lg;goahd thhpRfspd;kPJ flg;ghl;il tpjpf;fpwJ/ 15/ mWjpahtzk; mwg;gzp nehf;f';fSf;fhf xU epiyf;bfhilia cUthf;fpa[s;sJ vd;W epiyehl;lg;gl;oUg;gjhy;. 1959?Mk; Mz;L rl;lj;jpd; gphpt[ 6(19)?,d; fPH; tiuaWf;fg;gl;lthW me;j epiyf;bfhil. @Fwpj;jtif epiyf;bfhilah>@ vd;gjw;F eh';fs; jw;nghJ ftde;jpUg;g[fpnwhk;/ nkw;fz;lthW. xU @Fwpj;jtif epiyf;bfhil@ vd;gJ xU Fwpg;gpl;l klk; my;yJ nfhapYld; bjhlh;g[ila xU Fwpj;jtif mwg;gzp my;yJ gzp vd VnjDbkhd;Wf;fhdjhfnth my;yJ khw;Wtifahf @gpw rka mwg;gzp@ vija[k; g[hptjw;fhfnth,Uf;fyhk;/ bghJthf. xU Fwpg;gpl;l nfhapypd; epiyf;bfhiliaa[k; @rka mwg;gzp@iaa[k; vt;thW ntWgLj;JtJ vd;gjw;fhd rpy tHpfhl;Ljiy 1959?Mk; Mz;L rl;lj;jpnyna fhzyhk;/ @rka mwg;gzp@ vd;w brhy; gphpt[ 6(16)?,y; gpd;tUkhW tiuaWf;fg;gl;Ls;sJ: @6/(16) @rka mwg;gzp@ vd;gJ klk; my;yJ nfhapYld; bjhlh;g[ilajhf,Ug;gpDk; my;yJ,y;yhtpoDk;.,e;Jg; gz;oifa[ld; my;yJ rkaj;jd;ikahd rl';Ffisf; filg;gpog;gJld; bjhlh;g[ila bghJ mwg;gzp vd;W bghUs;gLk;/@,e;j bghUs;tiuaiw. @rka mwg;gzp@ vd;gJ xU Fwpg;gpl;l nfhapYld; bjhlh;g[ila mwg;gzpapypUe;J ntWglyhk;/ nkYk;. xU @rka mwg;gzp@ahf,Uf;fpd;w Xh; mwg;gzpf;F. xU Fwpg;gpl;l nfhapy; my;yJ klj;Jld; bjhlh;g[ilajhf,Uf;fntz;Lk; vd;w mtrpakpy;iy/ rl;lg;goahd bghUs;tiuaiwfspd;go 1959?Mk; Mz;L rl;lj;jpd; fPH; @rka mwg;gzp@ahf,Uf;fpd;w Xh; mwg;gzpf;F,uz;L epge;jidfisg; g{h;j;jpbra;antz;Lk;/ Kjypy;. mJ xU @bghJ mwg;gzp@ahf,Uf;fntz;Lk;.,uz;lhtjhf. mJ Xh;,e;Jg; gz;oifa[ld; my;yJ rkaj;jd;ikahd rl';Ffisf; filg;gpog;gJld; @bjhlh;g[ilajhf@,Uf;fntz;Lk;/,t;tpuz;L epge;jidfS[k; epiwt[ bra;ag;gLkhapd;.,e;j mwg;gzpna. @rka mwg;gzp@ahFk;/ 16/ bghJ kw;Wk; jdpahh; mwf;fl;lisfSf;F,ilnaahd ntWghl;oid,e;ePjpkd;wj;jpd; murikg;g[ Mak; kfe;j; uhk; rU:g; jh!;$p ?vjph;? v!;/gp/ rhcwp[6] vd;w tHf;fpd; jPh;Kotpy; tpthpf;fg;gl;Ls;sJ/ me;j tHf;fpy;. gPfhh;,e;J rka mwf;fl;lisfs; rl;lk; (1-1951) bghJ kw;Wk; jdpahh; mwf;fl;lisfs; vd;w,t;tpuz;ow;Fk; bghUe;Jkh> vd;gij,e;ePjpkd;wk; jPh;khdpj;jpUf;fntz;Lk;/,J. bghJ kw;Wk; jdpahh; mwf;fl;lisfSf;F,ilapyhd ntWghl;il gpd;tUkhW tpthpf;fpwJ: @6/ ////,e;J rl;lj;jpy; bghJ kw;Wk; jdpahh; rka epiyf;bfhilfSf;F,ilapyhd ntWghl;il Kjypy; TWtJ mtrpakhFk;/ RUf;fkhfr; brhd;dhy;. xU bghJ mwf;fl;lisapy;. mDgt ghj;jpa chpik epue;jukw;w. khwpkhwp tUk; Ml;fspd; FGthd bgUkstpyhd bghJkf;fsplnkh my;yJ Fwpg;gpl;l tptuj;jpw;F tpilaspf;fpd;w mjd; rpy Fwpg;gpl;l gFjpapdhplnkh milt[WfpwJ. xU jdpahh; mwf;fl;lisapy; mDgt ghj;jpaij chpikahdth;fs; vd;nghh; epiyahd cWjpaha; mwpag;gLk; jdpegh;fnsh my;yJ tiuaWf;fg;gl;l fhyj;jpw;Fs; kpft[k; cWjpaha; 6/ 1959 rg;sp/ (2) v!;/rp/Mh;/ 583 mwpag;gLgth;fnsh Mth;/ epue;jukw;w. khwpkhwp tUk; Ml;fspd; FG vd;gJ xU Fwpg;gpl;l rka ek;gpf;ifia gpd;gw;Wk; bghJkf;fspy; xU gphptpduhfnth my;yJ cWjpahd Vnjhrpy rkag;gw;Wf;bfhz;l gphptpduhf kl;Lnk cs;sth;fshfnth,Ug;gh; vd;w r';fjp,e;j tplaj;jpy; ve;jtpj ntWghl;ila[k; Vw;gLj;jhJ. nkYk; mJ. me;j mwf;fl;lisiaj; jdpahh; mwf;fl;lisahft[k; Mf;fhJ////@ (typa[Wj;jpf; Twg;gl;lJ) Xh; mwf;fl;lis my;yJ mwf;bfhilapd; mDgt ghj;jpa chpikahdth;fs; vd;nghh; xU tiuaWf;fg;gl;l,dkwpaf;Toa jdpegh; FGt[f;F fl;Lg;gLkplj;J. me;j mwf;fl;lis kw;Wk; mwf;bfhil jdpg;gl;l jd;ikajhFk;/ vdpDk;. mDgt ghj;jpa chpikahdth;fs; vd;nghh; bgUkstpyhd bghJkf;fnsh my;yJ Fwpg;ghf,dkwpa,ayhj xG';fw;W khwpkhwp tUk; Ml;fspd; FGthfnth,Uf;Fkplj;J. me;j mwf;fl;lis my;yJ mwf;bfhil bghJg;gilahdj; jd;ikajhFk;/,e;j Ma;t[,e;ePjpkd;wj;jpd; gpe;ija mkh;t[fshy; kpf rkPgj;jpy; vk;/n$/ Jsrpuhkd; ?vjph;?,e;J rka mwepiya Ml;rpj;Jiw[7] vd;w tHf;fpy;,e;ePjpkd;wj;jpd; K:tukh; ePjpah; Maj;jpd; jPh;Kotpy; cWjpgl gpd;gw;wg;gl;Ls;sJ/ jw;nghija tHf;fpy;. xU Fwpg;gpl;l,e;J rka jpUtpHhf;fspd;nghJ tUifjUk; *gf;jh;fspd;* eyDf;;fhf mwg;gzp nkw;bfhs;sg;glntz;Lk; vd;W mWjpahtzk; bjhptpf;fpwJ/ 7/ (2019) 8 v!;/rp/rp/ 689,e;j mwg;gzp kf;fSf;F gadspf;fpw xd;whFk;.,jd; mDgt ghj;jpa chpik epue;jukw;w. khwpkhwp tUk; Ml;fspd; FGtplj;jpy; mspf;fg;gl;oUf;fpwJ/,e;j mDgt ghj;jpa chpikbfhz;l xU gphptpduhd @gf;jh;fs;@ tiuaiwf;Fl;gLgth;fsy;yh; vd;gjhy; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsuhd mwf;fl;lis xU bghJ mwf;fl;lisahFk;/ 17/ gphpt[ 6(16)?,d; fPH; @rka mwg;gzp@ vd;gij mikg;gjw;F Xh; mwg;gzpf;fhf g{h;j;jp bra;ag;glntz;oa mLj;j mk;rk; ahbjdpy; me;jg; bghJ mwg;gzp,e;Jg; gz;oifa[ld; my;yJ rkaj;jd;ikahd rl';Ffisf; filg;gpog;gJld; mwf;fl;lis bjhlh;g[ilajhf,Uf;fntz;Lk; vd;gjhFk;/ @mjDld; bjhlh;g[ila@ vd;w brhy;. mwg;gzp kw;Wk;,e;Jg; gz;oif vd;gjw;fpilnaahd bjhlh;g[ilikia,izg;gjhy; Mizah;. bkl;uh!;,e;J rka mwepiyf; bfhilfs; ?vjph;? ehuhaz ma;a';fhh;8 vd;w tHf;fpy;,e;ePjpkd;wj;jpd; K:tukh; ePjpauhaj;jpd; jPh;Kotpy; bghUs;tpsf;fg;gl;Ls;sJ. mjpy; unjhj;!tk; jpUtpHhtpd;nghJ _ gpurd;d bt';flhr;rygjpRthkpia jhprpf;f tUfpd;w gpuhkzh;fSf;F md;djhdk; mspg;gJ bjhlh;ghd mwg;gzpia nkw;bfhs;tjw;fhf epjpak; xd;W bjhl';fg;gl;lJ/ gpuhkzh;fSf;F md;djhdk; mspf;Fk; nehf;fj;jpw;fhf bjhl';fg;gl;l epjpak; bkl;uh!;,e;J rka mwepiyf; bfhilfs; rl;lk; 1951. gphpt[ 6(13)?,d; bghUspd;go. @rka mwg;gzp@ahdjh> vd;gnj,e;ePjpkd;wj;jpd; Kd;ghd nfs;tpahFk;/ khz;g[kpF ePjpaurh; n$/rp/ c&h,e;ePjpkd;wj;jpy; gfh;e;j jPh;KothtJ: 8/ V/I/Mh;/ 1965 v!;/rp/ 1916/ vk;/n$/ Jsrpuhkd; ?vjph;?,e;J rka mwepiya Ml;rpj;Jiw. (2019) 8 v!;/rp/rp/ 689?,y; rhh;t[wg;gl;lJ/ @5/ //// rl;lk; 19-1951?,d; gphpt[ 6(13)?,y; @bjhlh;g[ila@ vd;Dk; brhy;. rl;lj;jpd; tuyhW. rl;l tifKiw kw;Wk; nehf;f';fs; Mfpatw;iwf; fUj;jpw;bfhz;Lk;. mjDld; @bjhlh;g[ilajhf,Uf;fpd;w@ my;yJ @mjd; bjhlh;ghf@ vdg; bghUs;gLtjhf cs;s mr;brhw;bwhlh;fs; mike;Js;s N:H;epiyiaf; fUj;jpw;bfhz;Lk; gad;gLj;jg;gl;oUf;fpwJ/,r;brhy;yikg;g[. jpUtpHhit elj;Jk; my;yJ epUtfpf;Fk; mjpfhhpfshy; VJk; fl;Lg;gLj;jg;gLtjhf bghUs;gltpy;iy/ /// 7/ _ gpurd;d bt';flhrygjpRthkp nfhtpypd; unjhj;!t tpHhtpd;nghJ. ahj;jphPfh;fs; gy;ntW,l';fspypUe;J jpUtpHhtpw;F tUifjUth; kw;Wk;,e;j jpUtpHhtpd;nghJ Rthkpia jhprpf;ftUk; gpuhkzh;fSf;F md;djhdk; mspg;gnj mwg;gzpapd; nehf;fk; vd;gJ fz;lwpag;gl;l r';fjpfspd;nghpy; bjspthfpwJ/ gpuhkzh;fSf;F md;djhdk; mspg;gjw;fhd epjpaj;ij Vw;gLj;JtJ vd;gJ bghJ mwg;gzpahFk; vd;gjpy; gpur;rpidapy;iy/ unjhj;!tj;jpw;F tUfpd;w gpuhkz ahj;jphPfh;fSf;F md;djhdk; mspg;gnj mwg;gzpapd; Kjd;ikahd nehf;fkhFk;/ Mjyhy;,e;j bghJ mwg;gzp rkaj;jd;ikahd,e;J jpUtpHhthd unjhj;!tj;Jld; cz;ikahd bjhlh;g[ bfhz;oUg;gjhy; bkl;uh!; rl;lk; 19-1951. gphpt[ 6(13)?,d; bghUs;tpsf;fj;jpd;goahf mJ xU rka mwg;gzpahFk;/@ 18/ Xh;,e;J jpUtpHht[ld; @bjhlh;g[ilajhf@,Uf;Fk; rka mwg;gzpf;F. me;j mwg;gzp jpUtpHhnthL @bjhlh;g[ila@jhft[k; my;yJ @mjd; bjhlh;ghf@t[k;,Uf;fntz;Lk;/,J jpUtpHhit elj;Jk; xU Fwpg;gpl;l nfhapnyh my;yJ mjpfhuikg;ngh me;j mwg;gzp eltof;iffspy; fl;Lg;ghL vjida[k; braYWj;Jfpd;wjh> vd;gjw;fhd Ma;t[ my;y/ mwg;gzpf;Fk;. jpUtpHh epfH;r;rpfSf;Fk;,ilna bjhlh;g[,Uf;Fkplj;J.,e;j mwg;gzp jpUtpHht[ld; @bjhlh;g[ila@jhFk;/ nf/v!;/ brse;juuh$d; ?vjph;? Mizah;.,e;J rka mwepiyf; bfhilfs;9 vd;w tHf;fpy;,e;ePjpkd;wj;jpd;,Utukh; ePjpauhaj;jpd; jPh;Kotpy; xU Fwpg;gpl;l jpUtpHhtpd;nghJ Mw;wpy; bja;tj;ijtpLk; epfH;r;rpapy; kf;fSf;F md;djhdk; mspg;gJ xU rka mwg;gzpah> vd;gij,e;ePjpkd;wk; jPh;khdpf;f ntz;oapUe;jJ/,e;j ePjpkd;wk; kfe;j; uhk; rU:g; jh!;$p kw;Wk; Mizah;. bkl;uh!;,e;J rka mwepiyf; bfhilfs; vd;w tHf;fpd; jPh;Kot[fisr; rhh;e;Jepd;W. nkw;Fwpg;gplg;gl;l mwg;gzp xU rka mwg;gzp vd;Wk;. 1959?Mk; Mz;L rl;lj;jpd; gphpt[ 64?,d; fPH; xU rl;l tFKiwia tFg;gJ bjhlh;ghd Mizfisg; gpwg;gpf;f. mJ cah; ePjpkd;wj;jpd; tuk;bgy;iyf;Fs;,Ue;jJ vd;Wk; jPh;khdpj;jJ/ 9/ (2016) 15 v!;/rp/rp/ 597 19/ vk;/n$/ Jsrpuhkd; ?vjph;?,e;J rka kw;Wk; mwepiyf; bfhil epUthfp10 vd;w tHf;fpy;,e;ePjpkd;wk; rkPgj;jpa jPh;Kotpy;. xU @md;d rj;jpu@j;jpy; cs;s fy;btl;L 1959?Mk; Mz;L rl;lj;jpd; fPH; Xh; @Fwpj;jtif epiyf;bfhil@ mikf;fpwjh> vd;gij,e;ePjpkd;wk; jPh;khdpf;fntz;oapUe;jJ/ @md;d rj;jpu@j;jpypUe;JtUk; gzk; Fwpg;gpl;l rpy gpuhkzh;fSf;F md;djhdk; mspf;f gad;gLj;jg;glntz;Lk; vd;W fy;btl;L bjhptpf;fpwJ/,e;ePjpkd;wj;jpd; K:tukh; ePjpauhaj;jpy; khz;g[kpF ePjpaurh; vd;/tp/,ukzh mth;fs; jPh;g;g[iuj;J.,f;fy;btl;L xU Fwpj;jtif epiyf;bfhilia cUthf;fpa[s;sJ vdj; jPh;khdpj;jhh;/,e;ePjpkd;wk; jPh;khdpj;jjhtJ: @14/ jw;nghija tHf;fpy;. rj;jpuj;jpd; bray;ghl;il Kiwg;gLj;Jfpd;w @md;d rj;jpu@j;jpy; cs;s fy;btl;L gpuhkzh;fSf;F md;djhdk; tH';f tifbra;fpwJ/ nkw;Fwpg;gplg;gl;l,e;ePjpkd;wj;jpd; murikg;g[ ePjpauhaj;jpd; jPh;Kot[f;nfw;g,J @bghJ kf;fSf;F@ eyk;gaf;Fk; Xh; mwg;gzp vd;gJ bjspthfpwJ/ 15/ nkYk;. Fwpg;gpl;l rkaj; jpUtpHhf;fshd kapyhg;g{h; jpUf;nfhapypy; eilbgWk; @mWgj;JK:th; gpuk;nkhj;!t@j;jpd;nghJk; brd;id. jpUbthw;wpa{hpYs;s _ jpahfuh$Rthkp jpUf;nfhapy; jpUtpHhtpd;nghJk; 10/ (2019) 8 v!;/rp/rp/ 689 gpuhkzh;fSf;F md;djhdk; mspf;fntz;Lk; vd fy;btl;L jpl;ltl;lkhfj; bjhptpf;fpd;wJ///// 16/ mt;thwhf. fy;btl;oy; tpthpf;fg;gl;l bghJ mwg;gzp. xU rka jpUtpHht[ld; bjhlh;g[ilajhapUg;gjhy;. mJ rl;lj;jpd;fPH; bghUs;tiuaWf;fg;gl;lthW xU rka mwg;gzpahf mikfpwJ/ 17/ rl;lg;gphpt[ 6(19)?,d; fPH; Vw;bfdnt nkny Fwpg;gplg;gl;lthW. @Fwpj;jtif epiyf;bfhil@ vd;gJ rka mwg;gzpahw;Wtjw;fhf tH';fg;gLk; gzk; vJt[k; vd;w bghUs;tiuaiwf;Fl;gl;ljhFk;/ fy;btl;L rka mwg;gzpahw;Wtjw;fhf tifbra;fpwJ vd;w v';fsJ jPh;khdj;ijg; gpd;gw;wp. mwg;gzpahw;Wtjw;fhf rl;lj;jpd;go xU Fwpj;jtif epiyf;bfhil mikg;gjw;F gzk; bfhilahf tH';fg;gl;Ls;sJ vd;gijf; fhz;gpg;gJ nghJkhdJ/@ vk;/n$/ Jsrpuhkd; vd;w tHf;fpy; Xh; mwg;gzp @bghJ@ jd;ikahdjhft[k;.,e;J jpUtpHht[ld; @bjhlh;g[ilajhft[k;@,Uf;Fkplj;J. me;j mwg;gzp 1959?Mk; Mz;L rl;lj;jpd; gphpt[ 6(19)?,d; fPH; @Fwpj;jtif epiyf;bfhil@ vd;w bghUs;tiuaiwf;Fs; tUfpwJ vd;gij K:tukh; ePjpauhaj;jpd; jPh;Kot[ bjs;sj;bjspthf;FfpwJ/ 20/ jw;nghija tHf;fpy;. rpj;jpiu fn$e;jpu nkhl;rk; kw;Wk; gjpbdl;lhk; go jpUtpHhf;fspd;nghJ _ u';fehjRthkpia jhprpf;ftUk; @gf;jh;fspd;@ eyDf;fhf mwg;gzp nkw;bfhs;sntz;Lk; vd mWjpahtzk; TWfpwJ/,e;j @gf;jh;fs;@ mwg;gzpapd; mDgt ghj;jpa chpikahdth;fs; vd;w tifapy; Xh;,d';fhzf;Toa jdpegh;fs;bfhz;l FGtpdh; my;yh; vd;whYk; epue;jukw;w. khwpkhwp tUk; egh;fs; bfhz;l FGthf,Ug;gh;/,e;j @gf;jh;fs;@ mDgt ghj;jpa chpikahd gphptpdh; vd tiuaWf;fg;gLtjpy;iy/ vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsuhd mwf;fl;lis xU bghJ mwf;fl;lisahFk;/ mWjpahsuhy; nkw;bfhs;sg;glntz;oa mwg;gzpfis mWjpahtzk; xt;bthd;whff; TWfpwJ: @rpj;jpiu fn$e;jpu nkhl;rk; kw;Wk; 18?Mk; go jpUtpHhf;fspd;nghJk;. nkYk;.,e;j jpUtpHhf;fspd;nghJ gf;jh;fspd; eyDf;fhft[k; jz;zPh; ge;jy; mikj;J. K:d;W ehl;fSf;F nfH;tuF TH; tpepnahfpf;fg;gl;L tUfpwJ/@,e;j Kjy; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsuhd mwf;fl;lisapd; eltof;iffs;. rpj;jpiu fn$e;jpu nkhl;rk; kw;Wk; gjpbdl;lhk; go jpUtpHhf;fSld; bjhlh;g[ bfhz;Ls;sd. nkYk; _ u';fehjRthkp nfhapy; @gf;jh;fspd;@ eyDf;fhf mwg;gzp nkw;bfhs;sg;glntz;Lk;/,e;j tpHhf;fs; aht[k;,e;J rka tpHhf;fns/ vdnt @gf;jh;fs;@ vd;Dk; brhw;bwhlhpd; gad;ghL.,e;J rka jpUtpHhf;fs; kw;Wk; mWjpahtzj;jpy; tpthpf;fg;gl;Ls;s bghJ mwg;gzp,ilna neuo bjhlh;g[k;.,izg;g[k; cs;sjhff; Fwpj;Jiuf;fpwJ/ nkYk;. mWjpahtzj;jpy; @gf;jh;fs;@ vd;w Fwpg;gPLk;. epiyf;bfhil rkarhh;gw;w jd;ikahdjy;y vd;gijf; Fwpj;Jf;fhl;LfpwJ/ mWjpahtzj;jpy; tpthpf;fg;gl;Ls;s mwg;gzp,e;J rkaj; jpUtpHhf;fSld; bjhlh;g[ila xU bghJ mwg;gzpahFk;/,e;j mwg;gzp gphpt[ 6(16)?,d; fPH; xU @rka mwg;gzp@ahFk;/ jw;nghija tHf;fpd; r';fjpfSf;F vk;/n$/ Jsrpuhkd; vd;w tHf;fpy; Fwpg;gplg;gl;Ls;s fhuztpsf;fj;ijg; bghUj;jpg;ghh;f;ifapy;. gzk; (my;yJ brhj;J) rka mwg;gzpahw;Wtjw;fhf bfhilaspf;fg;gLfpwtplj;J. gphpt[ 6(19)?,y; bghUs;tiuaWf;fg;gl;lthW xU @Fwpj;jtif epiyf;bfhil@ Vw;gLj;jg;gl;L cs;sJ/ Mjyhy;. Kjy; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsuhd mwf;fl;lis 1959?Mk; Mz;L rl;lj;jpd; fPH; @Fwpj;jtif mwf;fl;lis@ MFk;/ 21/ jw;nghija tHf;fpy; nky;KiwaPl;lhsh; mjw;fhjuthf xU Fwpj;jtif epiyf;bfhil cs;sij cWjpg;gLj;jpa[s;shh;/ nky;KiwaPl;lhshpd; bgahpy; tHf;Fr; brhj;J mh;g;gzpf;fg;glhjnghjpYk;. bjhg;g[sd; brl;oahh; mwg;gzpia nkw;bfhs;tjw;fhf tHf;Fr; brhj;jpid mh;g;gzpj;jpUe;jhh;/ Fwpg;gpl;l,e;J rka jpUtpHhf;fspd;nghJ _ u';fehjRthkpia jhprpf;f tUk; gf;jh;fSf;F nritfs; bra;a[k; mwg;gzp rkaj;jd;ika[ilajhFk;/ jpUf;nfhapypd; nky;KiwaPl;lhsuhd cjtp fz;fhzpg;ghsh; v/rh/5 jdJ FWf;F tprhuizapd;nghJ. nky;KiwaPl;lhsuhd nfhapy;. vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsuhd mwf;fl;lis kPJ fl;Lg;ghl;il braYWj;jtpy;iy vd;gija[k;. mjw;F Mjuthf tHf;Fr; brhj;jpid mh;g;gzpf;ftpy;iy vd;gija[k; xg;g[f;bfhz;lhh;/,r;N:H;epiyfspy;. mWjpahtzk; nky;KiwaPl;lhsUf;F Mjuthf xU Fwpj;jtif epiyf;bfhilia Vw;gLj;jtpy;iy vd;gJ bjspthfj; bjhpfpwJ/ vdpDk;. ehk; fz;Ls;sthW. Kjy; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsuhd mwf;fl;lisapd; eltof;iffs; 1959?Mk; Mz;L rl;lj;jpd; fPH; @rka mwg;gzp@ vd;Dk; bghUs;tiuaiwia epiwt[ bra;fpwJ/ Mjyhy;. mWjpahtzj;jpd; thapyhf Vw;gLj;jg;gl;l Fwpj;jtif epiyf;bfhil nky;KiwaPl;lhsuhd jpUt[Utr; rpiyf;F Mjuthf,y;iybad;whYk;. mJ rka mwg;gzpf;fhd Xh; mwf;bfhilahFk; vd;gij eh';fs; Fwpj;Jf;bfhz;nlhk;/ 22/ nkw;go fUj;Jiu kw;Wk; fhz;Kot[fspd; mog;gilapy;. 1959?Mk; Mz;L rl;lj;jpd;go Kiwg;gLj;jg;gl;l xU @Fwpj;jtif epiyf;bfhil@ia mWjpahtzk; Vw;gLj;jtpy;iy vd;W eh';fs; mwpfpnwhk;/ 1959?Mk; Mz;L rl;lj;jpd; fPH; g[hpe;Jbfhz;lthW Vw;gLj;jg;gl;l Fwpj;jtif epiyf;bfhil @rka mwg;gzp@f;fhd KGepiwthd mwf;bfhilahFk;/ 1959?Mk; Mz;L rl;lj;jpd; tifa';fshy; Kiwg;gLj;jg;gl;l tHf;Ffis tprhhpg;gjw;fhd chpikapay; ePjpkd;w';fspd; mjpfhutuk;gpid 1959?Mk; Mz;L rl;lj;jpd; gphpt[ 108 jilbra;fpwJ/ gphpt[ 108 tifbra;tjhtJ: @rka epWtd';fs; Kjyhdtw;wpd; epUthfk; my;yJ nkyhz;ik bghWj;J chpik tHf;F bjhlh;tjw;Fj; jil ? rka epWtdj;jpd; epUthfk; my;yJ nkyhz;ik bghWj;J my;yJ ntWbghUs; my;yJ g{ry; vija[k; bghWj;J jPh;khdpg;gjw;F my;yJ Kot[ bra;tjw;F,r;rl;lj;jpy; tifbra;ag;gl;oUf;fpw. chpik tHf;F my;yJ ntW rl;l eltof;if vJt[k;.,e;jr; rl;lj;jpd; tifKiwfspd;goa[k; mtw;wpw;F,z';ft[k; jtpu. ePjpkd;wk; vjpYk; bjhlug;gLjy; MfhJ/@ gphpt[ 108?,d; fUj;Jg;go. rka epWtdj;jpd; epUthfk; my;yJ nkyhz;ikiag; bghWj;J my;yJ ntWbghUs; vija[k; bghWj;J jPh;khdpg;gjw;F my;yJ Kot[ bra;tjw;F,e;jr; rl;lj;jpy; tifbra;ag;gl;oUf;fpw chpik tHf;F my;yJ ntW rl;l eltof;if vJt[k; Xh; chpikapay; ePjpkd;wj;jpy; bjhlug;gLjy; MfhJ/ rka epWtd';fspd; epUthfk; my;yJ nkyhz;ik bjhlh;ghd g{ry; vJt[k; 1959?Mk; Mz;L rl;lj;jpd; tifKiwfSf;fpz';f Kiwg;gLj;jg;gLfpwJ/ jw;nghija tHf;fpy; 1959?Mk; Mz;L rl;lj;jpd; gphpt[ 34?,d;11 fPH; cs;sthW Kjy; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsuhy; jhf;fy; bra;ag;gl;l chpik tHf;F epiyf;fj;jf;fjy;y. ?????????????????????????????????????? 11/ mwf;fl;lisapd; mirahr; brhj;ij gpwUf;F chpikkhw;wk; bra;jy;/? (1) rka epWtdk; vjw;Fk; brhe;jkhd my;yJ mjd; nehf;f';fSf;fhf bfhLf;fg;gl;l my;yJ epiyf;bfhilahf mspf;fg;gl;l mirahr; brhj;J vjdpd; ghpkhw;wk;. tpw;gid my;yJ milkhdk; vJt[k; kw;Wk; Ie;jhz;LfSf;F nkw;gLfpw fhy mst[f;fhd Fj;jif vJt[k;. epWtdj;jpw;F njitahdJ my;yJ ed;ik gaf;ff;ToaJ vd;W Mizauhy; xg;gspf;fg;gl;lhyd;wp. Kw;wpYk;,y;yh epiyajhfptpLk;: tuk;g[iuahf: mj;jifa xg;gspg;ig mspg;gjw;F Kd;g[. fUjg;gl;l eltof;if bjhlh;ghd tptu';fs;. mJ bghWj;j kWg;g[iufisa[k;. Fwpg;g[iufisa[k; tuntw;W tFj;Jiuf;fg;glyhFk; Kiwapy; btpaplg;gLjy;ntz;Lk;/ mw';fhtyhplkpUe;J my;yJ chpj;jKila ntW Ml;fsplkpUe;J bgw;w midj;J kWg;g[iufSk;. Fwpg;g[iufSk; Mizauhy; chpathW ghprPyid bra;ag;gLjy;ntz;Lk;: nkYk; tuk;g[iuahf. Mizah;. murpd; Kd; xg;ngw;gpd;wp mj;jifa xg;gspg;gpid tH';Fjy; MfhJ/ tpsf;fk;/? nkny brhy;yg;gl;l brhj;jpd; Fj;jif vJt[k; Ie;jhz;LfSf;F nkw;glhj fhy mst[f;F,Ue;jnghjpYk;. (bkhj;jj;jpy; Ie;jhz;LfSf;F nkw;gl;ljhf,Uf;Fk;tiuapy;) nkYkhd xU fhy mst[f;F g[Jg;gpg;gjw;fhd tifKiwfisf; bfhz;ljhapUf;Fkhapd;. epge;jid vjw;Fk; cl;gl;oUe;jhYk;.,y;yhtpl;lhYk;. Ie;jhz;LfSf;F nkw;gLfpw xU fhy mstpw;fhd Fj;jifahff; bfhs;sg;gLjy;ntz;Lk;/ (2) Mizah; mj;jifa xg;gspg;ig mspf;Fk;nghJ. eltof;ifapd; thapyhfg; bgwg;gl;l bjhifapidg; gad;gLj;JtJ. mjid KjyPL bra;tJ kw;Wk; Xh; milkhdj;ijg; bghWj;jtiuapy; epahakhd fhy mst[f;Fs; mjid kPl;ly; bjhlh;ghf mth; njitbadf; fUjyhFk; epge;jidfis tpjpj;J gzpg;g[iufisg; gpwg;gpf;fyhk;/ Kjy; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsuhy; Kd;bkhHpag;gl;l epy tpw;gidf;F xg;g[jyspf;Fk; chpa mjpfhhp Mizanu Mthh;/ 23/ vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;fSf;fhf Kd;dpiyahd fw;wwpe;j K:j;j tHf;Fiu"h;. 1959?Mk; Mz;L rl;lg;gphpt[ 3?,d;12 fPH; mw';fhtyh;fshy; jtwhd epUthfk; bra;ag;gLk; mog;gilapy; murhy; mwptpf;if mspg;gjd;nghpy; rl;lj;jpd; tifKiwfs;. mwepiyf;bfhilfSf;F kl;Lnk bghUe;Jk; vd;w (3),e;jg; gphptpd;go Mizauhy; gpwg;gpf;fg;gl;l Mizapd; efy; xd;W muRf;Fk;. mw';fhtyUf;Fk; mDg;gg;gLjy;ntz;Lk; kw;Wk; tFj;Jiuf;fg;glyhFk; Kiwapy; btspaplg;gLjy;ntz;Lk;/ (4) mw';fhtyh; Mizapd; efy; xd;iwg; bgw;w njjpapypUe;J K:d;W khjj;jpw;Fs;Sk;. chpj;jKilath; vtUk; Miz btspaplg;gl;l njjpapypUe;J K:d;W khjj;jpw;Fs;Sk; Mizia khw;wikt[ bra;a my;yJ ePf;fwt[ bra;a ePjpkd;wj;jpw;F nky;KiwaPL bra;ayhk;/ (4?m) muR. rka epWtdk; vjw;Fk; brhe;jkhd my;yJ mjd; nehf;fj;jpw;fhff; bfhLf;fg;gl;l my;yJ epiyf;bfhilaspf;fg;gl;l mirahr; brhj;J vjdpd; ghpkhw;wk;. tpw;gid. milkhdk; my;yJ mj;jifa vjida[k; bghWj;J njitbad mth;fs; fUJfpwthW MizaUf;F mj;jifa gzpg;g[iufis tH';fyhk; kw;Wk; Mizah; mj;jifa gzpg;g[iufs; midj;jpw;Fk; bray;tpist[ bfhLj;jy;ntz;Lk;/ (5),g;gphptpy; ml';fpa[s;s vJt[k;. 41?Mk; gphptpy; Fwpg;gplg;gl;Ls;s,dhk;fSf;F bghUe;jhJ/ 12/ mwepiyf;bfhilfSf;F,e;jr; rl;lj;ij ePl;of;Fk; mjpfhuk;/? (1),e;J my;yJ rkzg; bghJ mwepiyf;bfhil vJt[k; jtwhf epUtfpf;fg;gLfpwJ vd;W muR ek;g[tjw;Ff; fhuzk; bgw;wpUf;Fkplj;J. mj;jifa mwepiyf;bfhilapd; mYty;fis Mizah; tprhuiz bra;J my;yJ,jw;bfd mtuhy; mjpfhukspf;fg;gl;l mYtyh; vtuhYk; tprhuiz bra;ag;gLkhW bra;J. mj;jifa mwepiyf;bfhilapd; epUthfj;jpd; eyd;fUjp.,e;jr; rl;lj;jpd; my;yJ mtw;wpy; vtw;iwa[k; mjw;F ePl;of;fr; bra;tJ njitahdjh> vd;gijj; jdf;F mwpf;if bra;a[k;go Mizaiu muR gzpf;fyhk;/ (2) Mizah; my;yJ (1)?Mk; cl;gphptpd;go mtuhy; mjpfhuk; mspf;fg;gl;l mYtyh;. me;j cl;gphptpd;go tprhuiz bra;ifapy; 1908?Mk; Mz;L chpikapay; tprhuizKiwr; rl;lj;jpd; (kj;jpa rl;lk; V-1908)go rhl;rpfs; Kd;dpiyahjiy tw;g[Wj;Jk; kw;Wk; mj;jifa mwepiyf;bfhilf;Fr; brhe;jkhd my;yJ mjd; bghWg;gpYs;s g[j;jf';fs;. fzf;Ffs;. Mtz';fs;. gpiza';fs;. buhf;fk; kw;Wk; gpw brhj;Jfis Kd;dpiyg;gLj;Jtij fl;lhag;gLj;Jk; nehf;f';fSf;fhf. chpikapay; ePjpkd;wj;jpd; midj;J mjpfhu';fisa[k; cilatuhthh; kw;Wk; rhd;wpidg; gjpt[ bra;tija[k;. jug;gpdiuf; nfl;gija[k; Fwpj;J me;jr; rl;lj;jpd;go bghUe;Jfpw bewpKiwiag; gpd;gw;Wjy;ntz;Lk;/ (3) (1)?Mk; cl;gphptpd;go Mizauhy; gzpe;jDg;gg;gl;l mwpf;ifiag; ghprPyid bra;jgpd;g[. mj;jifa mwepiyf;bfhil jtwhf epUtfpf;fg;gLfpwJ vd;Wk;. mj;jifa mwepiyf;bfhilapd; epUthf eyd;fSf;fhf.,e;jr; rl;lj;jpd; kw;Wk; mjd;go tFf;fg;gl;l tpjpfs; vtw;wpd; tifKiwfs; midj;ija[k; my;yJ mtw;wpy; vtw;iwa[k; mjw;F ePl;og;gJ njitahdJ vd;Wk; muR bjspt[wf;fhQqkhapd;. mJ mj;jifa mwepiyf;bfhilf;F nkw;brhd;d me;j tifKiwfis mwtpf;if thapyhf ePl;of;fyhk; kw;Wk; mjd;nghpy; me;j thjj;ij vGg;gpa[s;shh;/ jw;nghija tHf;fpy;. mJnghd;w mwptpf;if VJkpy;yhjjhy;. Kjy; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsUf;F 1959?Mk; Mz;L rl;lj;jpd; tifKiwfs; bghUe;Jtjw;fpy;iy vd;W thjplg;gl;Ls;sJ/ vdpDk;. nkw;brhd;d thj';fs; Vw;fg;gl,ayhJ/ Xh;,e;J bghJ mwepiyf;bfhil jtwhf epUtfpf;fg;gl;LtUtjhf muR ek;g[tjw;fhd fhuz';fs;,Uf;Fkplj;jhd tHf;Ffspy; gphpt[ 3?,d; bghUe;Jif tiuaWf;fg;gl;oUf;fpwJ/ mj;jifa mwepiyf;bfhilapd; eltof;iffspy; tprhuiz nkw;bfhs;st[k;. mj;jifa mwepiyf;bfhilapd; epUthf eyd;fSf;fhf 1959?Mk; Mz;L rl;lj;jpd; tifKiwfis ePl;of;ft[k; gphpt[ 3 muRf;F mjpfhuk; mspf;fpwJ/ jw;nghija tHf;fpy;. mj;jifa Fw;wr;rhl;Lfs;,y;yhjjhYk; my;yJ mwf;fl;lis jtwhf epUtfpf;fg;gl;LtUtjhf muR ek;g[tjw;F fhuz';fs; mwepiyf;bfhilahdJ. Fwpj;jtif epiyf;bfhilahf,Ue;jhw;nghd;nw. mt;thW ePl;of;fg;gl;l tifKiw. mj;jifa mwepiyf;bfhilf;Fg; bghUe;Jk;: tuk;g[iuahf. muR. mj;jifa mwptpf;ifia btspapLtjw;F Kd;g[. mt;thW bra;tjw;fhd jd; fUj;ijg; gw;wpa mwptpg;ig jd;dhy; vLf;fg;gLtjw;F fUjg;gl;l brapd;l; $hh;$; nfhl;il muRg; gjptpjHpy; btspapLjy;ntz;Lk;/ eltof;iff;fhd fhuz';fisf; Fwpj;Jiuf;Fk; bjhlh;g[ila epiyf;bfhilapy; chpj;jKilath;fs; me;j mwptpf;if btspaplg;gLtjw;F vjpuhf fhuz';fhl;Ltjw;fhf. me;j mwptpg;g[[ btspaplg;gl;l njjpapypUe;J,uz;L khj';fSf;F Fiwahj xU fhy msit eph;zapj;Jk; g[dpj $hh;$; nfhl;il murpjHpy; btspapl;L. mth;fSf;F kWg;g[iufs;. vitnaDkpUg;gpd;. mtw;iwg; ghprPyid bra;jy;ntz;Lk;/ (4),e;jg; gphptpy; vd;d ml';fpapUe;jnghjpYk;. muR,e;J my;yJ rkzg; bghJ epiyf;bfhil vjdpd; mw';fhtyuhy; my;yJ xd;Wf;F nkw;gl;l mw';fhtyh;fs;,Uf;Fkplj;J. me;j mw';fhtyh;fshy; my;yJ mth;fspy; bgUk;ghd;iknahuhy; bra;ag;gl;l tpz;zg;gj;jpd;nghpYk;. me;j tpz;zg;gj;ijr; bra;fpw mw';fhtyh; my;yJ mw';fhtyh;fspd; xU';fpirt[lDk;. mj;jifa mwepiyf;bfhilf;F,e;jr; rl;lj;jpd; kw;Wk; mjd;go tFf;fg;gl;l tpjpfs; vtw;wpd; tifKiwfs; midj;ija[k; my;yJ mtw;wpy; vtw;iwa[k; mwptpf;if thapyhf ePl;of;fyhk; kw;Wk; mjd;nghpy; mj;jifa mwepiyf;bfhilahdJ. xU Fwpj;jtif epiyf;bfhilahf,Ue;jhw;nghd;nw. mt;thW ePl;of;fg;gl;l tifKiwfs;. mj;jifa mwepiyf;bfhilf;Fk; bghUe;Jk;/ bfhz;oUe;jjhYk;. 1959?Mk; Mz;L rl;lj;jpd; tifKiwfspd; bghUe;JifapypUe;J Kjy; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh; jd;idj;jhnd tpyf;fpf;bfhs;s gphpt[ 3?,d; kPJ rhh;e;Jepw;f,ayhJ/ gphpt[ 6(19)?,y; bghUs;tiuaWf;fg;gl;Ls;sthW @Fwpj;jtif epiyf;bfhil@ cs;stiuapy; 1959?Mk; Mz;L rl;lj;jpd; tifKiwfs; Kjy; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsUf;F bghUe;Jk;/ nkny fhz;gpj;jthW. jw;nghija tHf;fpy;. 1959?Mk; Mz;L rl;lj;jpd; fPH; g[hpe;Jbfhz;lthW Vw;gLj;jg;gl;l Fwpj;jtif epiyf;bfhil @rka mwg;gzp@ vd;gjd; rhh;ghd KGepiwthd mwg;gzpahFk;/ Mjyhy;. Kjy; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsUf;F 1959?Mk; Mz;L rl;lj;jpd; tifKiwfs; bghUe;jj;jf;fdthFk;/ 24/ nkw;brhd;d fhuz';fSf;fhf. eh';fs;. bkl;uh!; cah; ePjpkd;wj;jpd; kJiu mkh;tpd; jdpakh; ePjpaurhpd; cj;juit ePf;fwt[ bra;J. nky;KiwaPl;oid mDkjpf;fpnwhk;/ mjd;tpisthf. Kjy; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsuhy; jhf;fy; bra;ag;gl;l chpik tHf;F js;Sgo bra;ag;gLfpwJ/ vdpDk;. Kjy; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh; 1959?Mk; Mz;L rl;lj;jpd; fPH; tFf;fg;gl;Ls;s eilKiwapid Vw;Wf;bfhs;tjw;Fhpatuhthh;/ bryt[j;bjhif Fwpj;J cj;jut[ VJkpy;iy/ khz;g[kpF ePjpaurh; Kidth; jpU/ jd";b$a xa;/ re;jpuN:l; khz;g[kpF ePjpaurh; jpU/ m$a; u!;njhfp g[J jpy;yp. 19/02/2020/ chpikj;Jwg;g[ @tl;lhu bkhHpapy; bkhHpahf;fk; bra;ag;gl;l,j;jPh;g;g[iuahdJ. tHf;fho. jd;Dila bkhHpapy; g[hpe;Jbfhs;tjw;F gad;gLj;jpf;bfhs;tjw;Fl;gl;lnjad;wp. ntbwe;j nehf;fj;jpw;fhft[k; gad;gLj;jpf;bfhs;syhfhJ/ midj;J eilKiwahd kw;Wk; mYty;Kiwahd nehf;f';fSf;Fk; kw;Wk; jPh;g;g[iuia epiwntw;wYf;Fk;. braw;gLj;jYf;Fk; mjd; M';fpyg; gjpg;ng mjpfhug;g{h;tkhdjhFk;/@