Full Text
?vjph;? o/ nkhfd; kw;Wk; xUth; /// vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;(fs;) jPh;g;g[iu khz;g[kpF ePjpaurh; jpU/ tpdPj; ruz;: nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;. jkpH;ehL. kJiu khtl;lk;. kdfphp fpuhkj;jpy;.
JUDGMENT
2 Vf;fh; kw;Wk; 43 brd;l; epyj;ij Vyf;fpiuak; bgw;wtuhthh;. me;j Vyj;ij cah; ePjpkd;wk;,d;ikahf;fpa[s;sjhy;,k;nky;KiwaPL vGfpwJ/ 2/,t;tHf;fpd; bghUz;ikfspd; RUf;fk; ahbjdpy;. 1?Mk; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsuhd o/ nkhfd; vd;gth; jd;Dila kfdpd; ez;guhd,uhn$e;jpuDf;F cj;jputhjpahthh;/,uhn$e;jpud;,uz;lhk; vjph;nky;Kiw? aPl;lhsuhd (,jpy;,jw;Fg;gpwF rPl;L epWtdk; vd RUf;fkhf miHf;fg;gLk;) _uhk; rpl;!; gz;l;. jkpH;ehL ypkpbll; vd;w epWtdj;jpypUe;J 40 khj jtizf; fhyj;jpw;F U:/5.00.000-? (U:gha; Ie;J,yl;rk;)?f;fhd rPl;L vLj;J. U:/3.37.500-? (U:gha; K:d;W,yl;rj;J Kg;gj;njHhapuj;J IE}W)?f;F 18/1/2000?Mk; njjpaplg;gl;l flDWjpr; rPl;il epiwntw;wpdhh;; mjw;fhf. 1?Mk; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsUk; kw;Wk; mtUila kfDk; bghWg;ghsh;fshapdh; kw;Wk; ml;ltizr; brhj;jhdJ Jiz gpizakhf epiwntw;wg;gl;lJ/ nkw;go,uhn$e;jpud;. 40 jtizfSs; 25 jtizfisr; brYj;jpdhh;. mjd;gpd;dh;. v";rpa jtizfisr; brYj;jj; jtwptpl;lhh;/ nkw;go,uhn$e;jpuDf;F. mth; brYj;jj; jtwpa U:/1.84.840-? (U:gha; xU,yl;rj;J vz;gj;J ehd;fhapuj;J vz;Qq}w;W ehw;gJ)?k;. mjw;F Mz;L tl;o 24 rjtPjKk; brYj;jf; nfhhp. xU mwptpg;g[ mDg;gg;gl;lJ/ 2?Mk; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsuhd rPl;L epWtdkhdJ. bjd; kJiu. rPl;L Jiz gjpthsh; Kd;ghf. 1982?Mk; Mz;ila,e;jpa rPl;L gz;L rl;lg;gphpt[ 64(1)(m)?,d; fPH; tHf;F jhf;fy; bra;jJ; mjpy;. 21/1/2002?Mk; njjpaplg;gl;l vjputh; thuh jPh;tk; tH';fg;gl;L. 1?Mk; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;. 2?Mk; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsUf;F U:/1.95.631-? (U:gha; xU,yl;rj;J bjhd;D}w;iwe;jhapuj;J mWE}w;W Kg;gj;bjhd;W) brYj;JkhW gzpf;fg;gl;lhh;/ 1?Mk; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;. vjputh; thuh jPh;tk; Fwpj;J jdf;F VJk; bjhpahbjd thjpl;lhh;/ 3/ 2?Mk; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsuhd rPl;L epWtdkhdJ. vjputh; thuh jPh;tj;ij epiwntw;Wtjw;fhf. kJiu 1?Mk; TLjy; rhh;g[ ePjpkd;wj;jpd; Kd;ghf epiwntw;W kD vz; 21-2003?I jhf;fy; bra;jJ/ 4/ 1?Mk; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhshpd; kfd;. epiwntw;W eilKiw mwptpg;igg; bgw;wJk;. epYitj; bjhifia jtizfshfr; brYj;jj; Jt';fpdhh;/ vdpDk;.,jw;fpilapy;. tHf;Fr; brhj;jhdJ. 1/3/2010 md;W Vyk; tplg;gl;L. mjpy;. nky;KiwaPl;lhsh; U:/1.77.000-? (U:gha; xU,yl;rj;J vGgj;njHhapuk;)?Md mjpf bjhiff;F Vyk; nfl;gtuhfp. mj;bjhifia mth; itg;gPL bra;jgpd;dh;. me;j VykhdJ 4/3/2010 md;W cWjpbra;ag;gl;lJ/ nkw;go bghUz;ikfs; bjhpate;jJk;. 1?Mk; vjph;nky; KiwaPl;lhshpd; kfd;. 2?Mk; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsuhd rPl;L epWtdj;ij mQqfp. bkhj;jj; bjhifiaa[k; brYj;jpdhh;/ 1?Mk; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;. tHf;Fr; brhj;jpd; Vyj;ij ePf;fwt[ bra;af;nfhhp. 10/3/2010 md;W epiwntw;W tpz;zg;g vz; 208-2010?,d; K:yk; chpikapay; tprhuizKiwr; rl;lk;. 1908 (c/tp/K/r/) rl;lg;gphpt[ 151. Miz XII. tpjp 89?,d; fPH; rPuha;t[itj; jhf;fy; bra;jhh;/ nkw;go tpz;zg;gj;jpd; epYitf; fhyj;jpy;. bkhj;j epYitj; bjhifa[k; 1?Mk; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsuhy; brYj;jg;gl;ljhy;. 2?Mk; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsuhd rPl;L epWtdj;jpdhy; epYitapy;yhr; rhd;W tH';fg;gl;L. mg;bghUz;ikahdJ epiwntw;W ePjpkd;wj;jpd; ftdj;jpw;F bfhz;Ltug;gl;lJ vd;gJ Fwpg;gplj;jf;fjhFk;/ 5/ tHf;fhdJ. vt;tpj Kd;ndw;wKkpd;wp Vwj;jhH ehd;fhz;LfSf;F epYitapy; itf;fg;gl;lJ;,jw;fpilapy; 1?Mk; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh; 12/9/2011 md;W tHf;Fr; brhj;ij K:d;whk; jug;gpdUf;F tpw;Wtpl;lhh;/ mjd;gpd;dh;. 1?Mk; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsuhy; jhf;fy; bra;ag;gl;l rPuha;thdJ. 1/4/2014 md;W js;Sgo bra;ag;gl;L. Vyf;fpiuak; bgw;wtuhd nky;KiwaPl;lhshpd; bgahpy; 21/7/2014 md;W fpiuar; rhd;W tH';fg;gl;lJ/ mjd; mog;gilapy;. Vyf;fpiuak; bgw;wtuhd nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;. brhj;jpd; mDgtj;ijbaLf;f Kad;W. mJ fpiuak; bgw;wtuhd 3?Mk; jug;gpduhy; Ml;nrgpf;fg;gl;lJ; K:d;whk; jug;gpduhd fpiuak; bgw;wthpd; KiwaPl;od; mog;gilapy; 1?Mk; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsUk; kw;Wk; mtUila FLk;g cWg;gpdh;fSk; ifJ bra;ag;gl;L. gpd;dh; gpizapy; tpLtpf;fg;gl;ldh;/ gpizapy; tpLtpf;fg;gl;l gpd;dnu. jdf;F rPuha;t[ js;Sgo bra;ag;gl;lJ Fwpj;J bjhpa[k; vd;Wk;. cj;jutpd; rhd;wplg;gl;l efiyg; bgw;wgpd;dh;. mth; cah; ePjpkd;wj;jpy; chpikapay; rPuha;t[ kDitj; jhf;fy; bra;jhh; vd;Wk;. mJ. 2/8/2018?Mk; njjpaplg;gl;l tphpthd jPh;g;g[iuapd; K:yk; mDkjpf;fg;gl;Ls;sJ vd;Wk;. mjd; brayhf;fg; gFjp fPnH jug;gl;Ls;sJ vd;Wk;. 1?Mk; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh; thjpLfpd;whh;: @Kotpy;:
(m) chpikapay; rPuha;t[ kD mDkjpf;fg;gl;L. 1/3/2014?Mk; njjpaplg;gl;l ep/k/ vz; 21-2003?,y; jhf;fy; bra;ag;gl;l ep/tp/ vz; 208-2010?,y; kJiu 1?Mk; TLjy; rhh;g[ ePjpkd;wj;jpdhy; gpwg;gpf;fg;gl;l vjph;g;gpw;Fs;shd cj;juthdJ ePf;fwt[ bra;ag;gLfpwJ kw;Wk; 4/3/2010?Mk; njjpaplg;gl;l Vyf;fpiuaKk; ePf;fwt[ bra;ag;gLfpwJ/
(M) rPuha;t[ kDjhuuhd cj;jputhjpahdth;.,t;t[j;jutpd; efiyg; bgw;w,U thu';fSf;Fs;shf. 4/3/2010 md;W itg;gPL bra;ag;gl;l bkhj;j fpiuaj; bjhifahd U:/1.77.000-?I 4/3/2010?Mk; ehs; Kjy; itg;gPL bra;ag;gLk; ehs; tiuapy;. Mz;L tl;o 9 rjtPjj;Jld; epiwntw;W ePjpkd;wkhd kJiu. 1?Mk; TLjy; rhh;g[ ePjpkd;wj;jpy; itg;gPL bra;a[khW gzpf;fg;gLfpd;whh;; (,) 2?Mk; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsuhd fpiuak; bgw;wth;. epiwntw;W ePjpkd;wj;jpd; Kd;g[ njitahd tpz;zg;gj;ijj; jhf;fy; bra;tjd; K:yk;. bjhifiag; bgw;Wf;bfhs;s chpika[ilatuhthh;; (<) gjpt[j; Jiwapd; bjhlh;g[ila gjpthsh;.,jw;nfw;wthW njitahd gjpt[fis nkw;bfhs;st[k; kw;Wk; 2?Mk; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsuhd Vyf;fpiuak; bgw;wtUf;fhjuthf tH';fg;gl;l 21/7/2014?Mk; njjpaplg;gl;l fpiuar; rhd;W bjhlh;ghd gjpit Kwpf;ft[k;. mtUf;F jftyspj;J chpa cj;jut[fisg; gpwg;gpf;FkhW epiwntw;W ePjpkd;wkhdJ. mjhtJ. kJiu. I?Mk; TLjy; rhh;g[ ePjpkd;wkhdJ gzpf;fg;gLfpwJ;
(c) cl;gphpt[ (M)?,y; gzpf;fg;gl;lJnghd;W. rPuha;t[ kDjhuh; bjhifia itg;gPL bra;j,U thu';fSf;Fs;shf. nkw;go gzpfis Kof;FkhW epiwntw;W ePjpkd;wkhdJ gzpf;fg;gLfpwJ; (C) 4/3/2010 md;W elj;jg;gl;l Vyj;ijj; bjhlh;e;J. 2?Mk; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;-Vyf;fpiuak; bgw;wtuhy; itg;gPL bra;ag;gl;l bjhifia jpUk;gr; brYj;JkhW nfhhp. rPuha;t[ kDjhuh;. njitahd tpz;zg;g';fisj; jhf;fy; bra;a chpika[ilatuhthh;; mt;tpz;zg;gkhdJ. epiwntw;W ePjpkd;wj;jpdhy; 1?Mk; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;-rPl;L epWtdj;jpw;F mwptpg;g[ kw;Wk; nghjpa tha;g;g[fs; tH';fg;gl;l gpd;dh; Kot[ bra;ag;glntz;Lk; kw;Wk; mj;jifa tpz;zg;gkhdJ jhf;fy; bra;ag;gl;l,U khj';fSf;Fs;shf nkw;go gzpfs; Kof;fg;glntz;Lk;/ bryt[j;bjhiffs; Fwpj;J cj;juntJkpy;iy/ mjd;tpisthf. bjhlh;g[ila gy;tif kDf;fs; Kof;fg;gLfpd;wd/@ 6/ cah; ePjpkd;wj;jpd; Kd;g[ 1?Mk; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhshpd; Fwpg;ghd tHf;F ahbjdpy;. mtUf;F Kd;dwptpg;g[ tH';fg;glhjjhy;. bjd; kJiu. rPl;Lf;fhd Jiz gjpthsh; Kd;g[ 2?Mk; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;-rPl;L epWtdj;jpdhy; jhf;fy; bra;ag;gl;l kDthdJ epiyf;fj;jf;fjy;y vd;gjhFk;/ neuoahf tpiy kjpg;g[ U:/1.77.000-?Mf eph;zapf;fg;gl;lJ; chpikapay; tprhuizKiwr; rl;lj;jpd; fPHhd kw;Wk;,e;ePjpkd;wj;jpdhy; tH';fg;gl;l kjpg;gpw;Fk; kpft[k; FiwthdjhFk; vd;W';Tl thjplg;gl;lJ/ 1?Mk; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;.,uhn$e;jpud; vd;w xUtUf;F cj;jputhjp kl;Lnk vd;Wk;. Jizg; gjpthsh;. 1?Mk; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsUf;bfjpuhf eltof;if vLg;gjw;F Kd;ghf. Kjypy;,uhn$e;jpudplkpUe;J bjhifia tN:ypg;gJ Fwpj;J ghprPypj;jpUf;fntz;Lk; vd;W';Tl nkYk; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsuhy; thjplg;gl;lJ/ 1?Mk; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhshpd; Fwpg;ghd tHf;F ahbjdpy;. Vyk; tplg;gl;l xU thuj;jpw;Fs;shf. bkhj;j bjhifiaa[k; mth; brYj;jp. 2?Mk; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsuhy; epYitapd;ikr; rhd;W tH';fg;gl;lJ; mJFwpj;J epiwntw;W ePjpkd;wk; fUj;jpw;bfhs;shky;. Vwj;jhH ehd;F Mz;LfSf;F tHf;if epYitapy; itj;Jtpl;lJ vd;gjhFk;/ Miz XXI. tpjp 89?,d; eilKiwfs; gpd;gw;wg;gltpy;iy vd;w fhuzj;jpd; mog;gilapy;. 1?Mk; TLjy; rhh;g[ ePjpkd;wj;jpdhy; rPuha;t[ js;Sgo bra;ag;gl;lJ bjhlh;ghf. @Vyj;ij ePf;fwt[ bra;tjw;fhd tpz;zg;gKk; c/tp/K/r/. gphpt[ 151?,d; fPH; jhf;fy; bra;ag;gl;lJ@ vd;Wk;. bkhj;j Vyj;bjhifa[k; 1?Mk; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsuhy; 2?Mk; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;rPl;L epWtdj;jpw;F brYj;jg;gl;lijaLj;Jk; kw;Wk; me;epWtdkhdJ. epYitapd;ikr; rhd;iw tH';fpaijaLj;Jk;. Miz XXI. tpjp 89 nfhUtJnghd;W. Vyj;bjhifia 5# tl;oa[ld; ePjpkd;wj;jpy; itg;gPL bra;aj;njitapy;iy vd;Wk;. 1?Mk; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsuhy; thjplg;gl;lJ/ 7/ cah; ePjpkd;wj;jpd; Kd;g[ nky;KiwaPl;lhshpd; Kjd;ikahd thjk; ahbjdpy;. c/tp/K/r/. Miz XXI. tpjp 89?,d; tpjpKiwfs; gpd;gw;wg;glhikahy;. epiwntw;W ePjpkd;wj;jpdhy; rPuha;thdJ rhpahfnt js;Sgo bra;ag;gl;Ls;sJ/ mJ mg;goapUf;f. VykhdJ rhpahfnt elj;j itg;gPL bra;J. mjw;Fl;gl;L cWjpbra;ag;gl;lJ vd;gjhFk;/ 8/ cah; ePjpkd;wkhdJ,U jug;gpdh;fspd; thj';fisa[k; ftdj;jpw;bfhz;L. @rl;l tpjpfisg; bghUj;jp mtw;wpd; bghUj;jj;ij Ma;t[bra;a[k; Kd;dh;. Fwpg;gpl;l tHf;fpd; bghUz;ikfs; kw;Wk; N:H;epiyfis ePjpkd;wk; ftdpf;fntz;Lk;@ vdf; fUj;J bjhptpj;jJ/ 1?Mk; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh; cj;jputhjpna md;wp. fldhspay;y vd;Wk;. 1?Mk; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsuhy; 2?Mk; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;-rPl;L epWtdj;jplk; bkhj;j bjhifa[k; itg;gPL bra;ag;gl;L. mjw;F 2?Mk; vjph;nky; KiwaPl;lhsuhy; Kiwahd epYitapd;ikr; rhd;W tH';fg;gl;L. mJ Kiwahf epiwntw;W ePjpkd;wj;jpd; ftdj;jpw;F bfhz;Ltug;gl;lJ vd;Wk;. mJ. epiwntw;W ePjpkd;wj;jpdhy; ghprPypf;fg;gltpy;iy vd;Wk;,t;thwhf Vy njjp Kjy; xU thu fhyj;jpw;Fs;shfnt. rPuha;thdJ jhf;fy; bra;ag;gl;lijaLj;Jk; kw;Wk; bkhj;j epYitj; bjhifa[k; jPh;t[ bra;ag;gl;lijaLj;Jk;. Vyk; cWjp bra;ag;gl;lij epahag;gLj;jKoahJ vd;Wk; cah; ePjpkd;wk; Fwpg;gpl;lJ/ c/tp/K/r/. gphpt[ 151?,d; fPG';Tl tpz;zg;gk; jhf;fy; bra;ag;gl;oUe;jJ. bkhj;j epYitj; bjhifa[k; brYj;jg;gl;ljhYk; kw;Wk; 1?Mk; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh; cj;jputhjpna md;wp. fldhspay;y vd;gjhYk;. mjd;fPHhd thdshtpa mjpfhukhdJ. jw;bghGija tHf;fpd; N:H;epiyfspy; gad;gLj;jg;gl;oUf;fntz;Lk; vd;Wk; cah; ePjpkd;wk; jPh;g;gspj;jJ/ @brhj;JhpikahdJ. murikg;g[r; rl;lg;goahd chpikahFk;. mJ jw;bghGija tHf;FKiwapy; kPwg;glf;TlhJ@ vd;gijf; Fwpg;gpl;L cah; ePjpkd;wkhdJ chpikapay; rPuha;t[ kDit mDkjpj;jJ/ @jw;bghGija tHf;fhdJ. cz;ikapy; fldhspahy; bra;ag;gl;l nkhroahyhdjhFk;. cj;jputhjpahdth;. jd;Dila brhj;ij,He;J. tHf;Fr; brhj;jpy; jd;Dila chpikiaf; fhf;f. cah; ePjpkd;wj;jpd; fjt[fisj; jl;odhh;@ vdt[k;. cah; ePjpkd;wk; nkYk; Kot[ bra;jJ/ 1?Mk; vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;cj;jputhjpapd; brhj;jhdJ gwpf;fg;gl mDkjpf;fg;gl;oUf;Fkhdhy;. mtUf;F mjpfg;goahd jP';fpiHf;fg;gl;oUf;Fk; vd cah; ePjpkd;wk; Fwpg;gpl;lJ/,t;tHf;fpd; mj;jifa bghUz;ikfs; kw;Wk; N:H;epiyfspy;. chpikapay; kDthdJ. nkw;Fwpg;gplg;gl;l gzpj;jy;fSld; mDkjpf;fg;gl;lJ/ 9/ c/tp/K/r/. Miz XXI. tpjp 89?,d; tpjpKiwfs; gpd;gw;wg;gltpy;iy vd;w fhuzj;jpd; mog;gilapy;. 1?Mk; vjph;nky;Kiw? aPl;lhshpd; rPuha;thdJ. rPuha;t[ ePjpkd;wj;jpdhy; js;Sgo bra;ag;gl;ljd; mog;gilapnyna. nky;KiwaPl;lhshpd; thjk;,Uf;fpwJ/ v';fSila fUj;jpy;. nkw;go tpdhthdJ. cah; ePjpkd;wj;jpdhy; tphpthf tpthjpf;fg;gl;Ls;sJ. tHf;fpd; Fwpg;gpl;l bghUz;ikfs; kw;Wk; N:H;epiyfspd; mog;gilapy; cah; ePjpkd;wj;jpdhy; nkw;bfhs;sg;gl;l KothdJ.,e;jpa murikg;g[r; rl;lk;. tFKiwf;TW (Mh;of;fy;) 136?,d; fPH; FWf;fPl;il nfhUtjhf,y;iy vd eh';fs; fUJfpd;nwhk;/ v';fSila fUj;jpy;. jug;gpdh;fSf;fpilapyhd ePjpahdJ Vw;bfdnt tH';fg;gl;Ltpl;lJ;,t;tHf;fpd; Fwpg;ghd bghUz;ikfs; kw;Wk; N:H;epiyfspy; c/tp/K/r/. Miz XXI. tpjp 89?,d; fPHhd tpz;zg;gk; my;yJ mjd; tpjpKiwfs; gpd;gw;wg;glhik Fwpj;J. ve;jtpj tpjpiaa[k; tFf;fhky;. cah; ePjpkd;wj;jpdhy; nkw;bfhs;sg;gl;l Kotpy;. eh';fs; FWf;fpl tpUk;gtpy;iy/ mjw;fpz';f.,k;nky;KiwaPlhdJ js;Sgo bra;ag;bgWfpwJ/ rl;l tpdhthdJ btspg;gilahf tplg;gLfpwJ/ bryt[j;bjhiffs; Fwpj;J cj;juntJkpy;iy/ khz;g[kpF ePjpaurh; jpU/ cja; cnkc&; yypj; khz;g[kpF ePjpaurh; jpU/ tpdpj; ruz; g[J jpy;yp. 24/04/2020/ ??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????? chpikj;Jwg;g[ @tl;lhu bkhHpapy; bkhHpahf;fk; bra;ag;gl;l,j;jPh;g;g[iuahdJ. tHf;fho. jd;Dila bkhHpapy; g[hpe;Jbfhs;tjw;F gad;gLj;jpf;bfhs;tjw;Fl;gl;lnjad;wp. ntbwe;j nehf;fj;jpw;fhft[k; gad;gLj;jpf;bfhs;syhfhJ/ midj;J eilKiwahd kw;Wk; mYty;Kiwahd nehf;f';fSf;Fk; kw;Wk; jPh;g;g[iuia epiwntw;wYf;Fk;. braw;gLj;jYf;Fk; mjd; M';fpyg; gjpg;ng mjpfhug;g{h;tkhdjhFk;/@