G P Chobey v. Ishwar Industries Ltd; K.K Golyan v. Ishwar Industries Ltd

Delhi High Court · 12 Oct 2022 · 2022:DHC:4264-DB

Suresh Kumar Kait; Saurabh Banerjee

CONT.APP.(C) 19/2022 & 20/2022

2022:DHC:4264-DB

civil appeal_allowed

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court allowed appeals seeking clarification on whether monetary amounts imposed in a contempt order were fines or costs, stayed the original order, and directed the Single Judge to clarify the nature and consequences of the payments.

Full Text

CONT.APP.(C) 19/2022 & 20/2022
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
Date of Decision: 12.10.2022

CONT.APP.(C) 19/2022
G P CHOBEY ..... Appellant
Through: Mr. Dinesh Agnani, Sr. Advocate with Mr. C. P. Vig, Advocate

VERSUS

M/S ISHWAR INDUSTRIES LTD ..... Respondent
Through: Ms.Ekta Mehta & Ms.Akanksha Agrawal, Advs.

CONT.APP.(C) 20/2022
K.K GOLYAN ..... Appellant
Through: Mr. Dinesh Agnani, Sr. Advocate with Mr. C. P. Vig, Advocate

VERSUS

ISHWAR INDUSTRIES LTD ..... Respondent
Through: Ms.Ekta Mehta & Ms.Akanksha Agrawal, Advs.

CORAM:

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SURESH KUMAR KAIT
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SAURABH BANERJEE

JUDGMENT

(oral)

CM APPL.43325/2022 (exemption) in CONT.APP.(C) 19/2022

CM APPL.44149/2022 (exemption) in CONT.APP.(C) 20/2022

1. Allowed, subject to all just exceptions.

2. The applications are accordingly disposed of. 2022:DHC:4264-DB CM.APPL.43326/2022 (delay) in CONT.APP.(C) 19/2022 CM.APPL.44150/2022 (delay) in CONT.APP.(C) 20/2022

3. Present applications have been filed on behalf of the appellants seeking condonation of delay of 6 days in filing the appeals.

4. In view of the reasons stated in the present applications, the delay of 6 days in filing the appeals is condoned.

5. Accordingly, the present applications are allowed and disposed of. CONT.APP.(C) 19/2022 in CM APPL.43324/2022 CONT.APP.(C) 20/2022 in CM APPL.44148/2022

6. The above captioned two petitions have been filed by the petitioners seeking setting aside of order dated 21.07.2022 passed by the learned Single Judge of this Court in EX.F.A.5/2021 titled as “M/s Nulon India Ltd. vs. Ishwar Industries Ltd.”

7. The appellants have challenged the impugned order dated 21.07.2022.

8. We have perused the same and vide para 24, the learned Single Judge has observed as under:

“24. Considering the above settled legal position and that the Contemnors have repeatedly made false and incorrect statements to the Court and have also raised misleading pleas in their pleadings and submissions only to remain in possession of the suit property for more than 15 years after the suit was filed, the contemnors are held guilty of contempt of this Court. The apologies tendered are accepted by the Court subject to the condition that the Contemnors-Mr.K.K. Golyan, Director and Mr.G.P. Chobey, the Authorized Representative of the appellant/Objector company shall pay Rs.50,00,000/- and Rs.20,00,000/- respectively, to the respondent, within three months. If the said payments are not made, the Contemnors would be liable to be sentenced to imprisonment for 15 days each. Ordered accordingly. If the amounts as directed are paid, the show cause notice for contempt shall stand discharged and adjustment of 50% of the said amount shall be given by the Executing Court as part of the amount payable under the decree.”

9. Learned counsel for the appellants submits that the amount(s) of Rs.50,00,000/- and Rs.20,00,000/- imposed towards fine are beyond the scope of Section 12 of the Contempt of Courts Act whereas counsel for the respondent submits that the said amount(s) have not been imposed towards fine and are towards costs in terms of Section 35A of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 and only if the contemnors fail to pay the same, they will be liable to a sentence of imprisonment for 15 days each.

10. Since the said order is not clear to that extent, therefore, we hereby dispose of the present appeals requesting the learned Single Judge to clarify para 24 of the impugned order dated 21.07.2022.

11. In view of above discussion, both the appeals are disposed of.

12. Till the learned Single Judge passes fresh order, the direction passed in the order dated 21.07.2022 shall remain stayed.

(SURESH KUMAR KAIT) JUDGE (SAURABH BANERJEE)

JUDGE OCTOBER 12, 2022

G P Chobey v. Ishwar Industries Ltd; K.K Golyan v. Ishwar Industries Ltd

AI Summary

Full Text

JUDGMENT

Contact Us for a Free Consultation