7d1a28aa10cb2bb070cee5501e166a82eaf2ca2623865f77318de932294794fe

UNKNOWN COURT · 19 Jan 2023
466-2017
criminal appeal_dismissed Significant

AI Summary

The High Court upheld the murder conviction under Section 302 IPC, holding that the prosecution proved the appellant's guilt beyond reasonable doubt despite minor inconsistencies.

Full Text
Translation output
,e;jpa cr;r ePjpkd;wk;
Fw;wtpay; nky;KiwaPl;L mjpfhutuk;g[
Fw;wtpay; nky;KiwaPL vz;; 466-2017
$hd; me;njhzprhkp (v) $hd; /// nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;(fs;)
?vjph;? khepy murpd; rhh;ghf fhty; Ma;thsh; /// vjph;nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;(fs;) jPh;g;g[iu khz;g[kpF ePjpaurh; jpU/ vk;/Mh;/ c&h:
1/ ,';Fs;s nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;?1?Mk; mry; vjphpahy; Kd;bfhzug;gl;l nkw;fz;l nky;KiwaPl;oidj; js;Sgo bra;J. ,/j/r/. gphpt[ 302 c-,/ gphpt[
201?,d; fPH; jz;of;fg;glf;Toa Fw;w';fSf;fhf tpjpf;fg;gl;l Fw;wj;jpw;fhd jPh;g;g[ kw;Wk; jz;lidj; jPh;g;gpid cah; ePjpkd;wk; cWjpbra;jJ/ Fw;wtpay; nky;KiwaPL vz; 171-2015?,y; bkl;uh!; cah; ePjpkd;wj;jhy; gpwg;gpf;fg;gl;l
22/7/2016?Mk; njjpaplg;gl;l vjph;g;g[f;Fs;shd ,Wjpj; jPh;g;g[iu kw;Wk; cj;jut[ld; kdf;Fiwa[w;W mjpUg;jpaile;jjhy; 1?Mk; mry; vjphp jw;nghija nky;KiwaPl;oid Kd;bfhzh;e;Js;shh;/
2/ muRj;jug;gpd; tHf;fhdJ vjph;g;g[f;Fs;shd jPh;g;g[iuapd; ,uz;lhk; gj;jpapy; cah; ePjpkd;wj;jhy; tphpthf vLj;Jiuf;fg;gl;Ls;sJ/ muRj;jug;g[ tHf;fpd;go. m/rh/1?f;F brhe;jkhd thfdj;ij (nlf;rp) Xl;Ltjw;fhf mtuhy; ,we;Jnghdth; Xl;Leuhfg; gzpakh;j;jg;gl;lhh;/ jd;Dila kidtpf;F
bjhptpj;jg; gpd;dh; ,we;Jnghdth; 26/6/2006 md;W fhiy 6/30 kzpastpy; jdJ tPl;iltpl;Lr; brd;whh;/ mjd;gpd;dh; mth; tPL jpUk;gtpy;iy/
2/1/ bfh";rfhyj;jpw;F v/1?';Tl nlf;rp Xl;of;bfhz;oUe;jhh; vd;wtifapy; ,we;Jnghdtiu mtUf;Fj; bjhpe;jpUe;jJ/ Fw;wthspfs; midtUk; ,we;Jnghdtuhy; Xl;lg;gl;lr; rPUe;ij thliff;F vLj;J
J}uj;jpy; cs;s jdpikahd ,lj;jpw;F mtiuf; Tl;or;brd;w gpd;dh;. mtiuf; bfhd;wgpd; ,we;JnghdtUf;Fr; brhe;jkhd rPUe;J kw;Wk; gpw brhe;j cilikfis jpUor;bry;tjw;F 23/5/2006 md;W rjpj;jpl;lk; jPl;odh;/ muRj;jug;g[ tHf;fpd;go nkw;brhd;d rjpj; jpl;lj;jpd; nkw;nfhshf. 26/5/2006 md;W v/2 Kjy; v/5 tiuapyhdth;fs; bghs;shr;rp njh;Kl;o ngUe;J epWj;jj;jpy; v/1?I re;jpj;jdh;/ gpd;dh; v?1?Mdth; ,we;Jnghdthplk;ngrp.
,we;Jnghdtuhy; Xl;lg;gl;l nlf;rpapy; cLkiyg;ngl;il bry;tjw;fhf mtiu
Xl;Leuhf epakpj;jhh;/ mjd;go. njh;Kl;o ngUe;J epiyaj;jpw;F
,we;Jnghdth; nlf;rpapy; te;jile;jhh;/ gpd;dh;. midj;J Ie;J vjphpfSk; nlf;rpapy; Vwpdh;/ nlf;rp cLkiy nehf;fp g[wg;gl;lJ/ mk;khgl;o vDk; fpuhkj;ij beU';Fk;nghJ xU jdpikahd ,lj;jpy;. rpwpJneuk; rPUe;ij epWj;Jk;go vjphp ,we;Jnghdthplk; nfl;lhh;/ ,we;Jnghdth; rPUe;ij epWj;jpdhh;/ rPUe;J mirahepiyf;F te;jt[ld;. jpObud;W v/2
,we;Jnghdthpd; fGj;ij bewpj;jhh;/ v/3 kw;Wk; v/4 ,we;Jnghdthpd; iffisf; fl;odh; kw;Wk; ,we;Jnghdthpd; fhy;fis v/5?Mdth; fapWfshy; fl;odhh;/ mjd;gpd;. rPUe;jpd; Kd; kw;Wk; gpd; ,Uf;iffSf;F ,ilna
,we;Jnghdtiu mth;fs; itj;jdh;/ v/3 Kjy; v/5 tiuapyhdth;fs;
rPUe;jpd; gpd;,Uf;ifapy; mkh;e;Jbfhz;L ,we;Jnghdth; mHtpy;iy vd;gij cWjpbra;jdh;/ rPUe;J v/1?My; Xl;lg;gl;lJ/ kuzKw;wth;
,we;Jtpl;lhh;/ midj;J Ie;J vjphpfSk; ,we;Jnghdthpd; rlyj;ij
FHpapy;nghl;L mjid vhpj;jdh;/ mjd;gpd;dh;. midj;J Ie;J vjphpfSk; rPUe;Jld; rk;gt ,lj;jpypUe;J Xotpl;ldh;/
2/2/ m/rh/1 26/6/2006 md;W ,we;Jnghdtiu bjhiyg;ngrpapd; K:yk; bjhlh;g[bfhs;tjw;F Kaw;rpj;jhh;. Mdhy;. mtuJ bjhiyngrp mizj;Jitf;fg;gl;oUe;jjhy; m/rh/1 ,we;Jnghdthpd; tPl;ow;Fr; brd;W m/rh/3?I re;jpj;jhh;/ nkYk; 26/6/2006?f;F gpd;dh; fhiy 6/30 kzpapypUe;J
,we;Jnghdtiug; ghh;f;ftpy;iy vd;W m/rh/3 mthplk; bjhptpj;jhh;/ njLjYf;Fg; gpd;dh; ,we;Jnghdth; fz;lwpag;gltpy;iy vd;gjhy;. 30/6/2006 md;W fhty;Jiwapdhplk; m/rh/1 g[fhh; mspj;jhh;/ m/rh/11. mg;nghjpUe;j fhty; cjtp Ma;thsh;. ,/j/r/. gphpt[ 406?,d; fPH; Fw;w vz; 363-2006?,y; xU tHf;fpidg; gjpt[ bra;jhh;/ mjd;gpd;dh;. mjpfhutuk;g[ila ePjpkd;wj;jplk;
K/j/m/ xg;gilf;fg;gl;lJ/ mjd;gpd;g[. m/rh/11 g[yd;tprhuiziaj; bjhl';fpdhh;/ rk;ge;jg;gl;l rhl;rpfspd; thf;FK:y';fis mth; gjpt[ bra;jhh;/ vdpDk;. mjd;gpd;dh; m/rh/11. 4/2/2007 md;W fz;Lgpof;fg;glhj tHf;F vd;W
Koj;jdh;/ fw;wwpe;j Fw;wtpay; ePjpj;Jiw eLth; Kot[ mwpf;ifia
Vw;Wf;bfhz;lhh;. vdpDk;. m/rh/22?f;F v/1?My; vGjg;gl;ljhf brhy;yg;gLk; fojkhdJ 29/12/2007 md;W mtuhy; bgwg;gl;L. mjd; mog;gilapy; mth; kw;w vjphpfSld; gpur;rpidapYs;s nlf;rpia xg;ge;jk; bra;J. Xl;Leiu
(,we;Jnghdth;) Tl;or;brd;W. mtiuf;bfhd;W rlyj;ij vhpj;J nlf;rpia
vLj;Jr;brd;wdh; vd;W v/1 xg;g[f;bfhz;ljhff; Twg;gLfpwJ/ nkw;fz;l fojj;jpy; gjpt[ bra;ag;gl;oUf;Fk; xg;g[jy; thf;FK:yj;jpd;go rPUe;jpd; rpy ghf';fs; v/2 Kjy; v/5 tiuapyhdth;fshy; vLj;Jr;bry;yg;gl;lJ/ nkw;fz;;l fojj;Jld; 30/12/2007 md;W m/rh/22 fhty; epiyaj;jpw;Fr; brd;W m/rh/30?aplk; ,e;jf; fojj;ij xg;gilj;jhh;/ mjd; mog;gilapy; g[yd;tprhuiz bjhl';fpaJ/ v/1?,d; thf;FK:yj;jpd; mog;gilapy;. rPUe;J kiwj;J itf;fg;gl;oUe;j ,lKk; kw;Wk; rlyj;ijg; g[ijf;fg;gl;oUe;j
,lKk; fz;lwpag;gl;lJ/ vdnt rlyk;. v/1?,d; Fwpg;gPLgo fz;lwpag;gl;lJ/ m/rh/30?Mdth; ,/j/r/. gphpt[fs; 302 kw;Wk; 396?,d; fPHhd tHf;Ffis xd;whf khw;wpdhh;/ m/rh/30. v/1?I ifJbra;jhh;/ g[yd;tprhuizapd;nghJ. v/1?,d; btspg;gLj;jg;gl;l thf;FK:yj;jpd;nghpy;. ,ae;jpukw;w rPUe;ija[k; v/1?My; milahsk; fhzg;gl;lJnghd;W m/rh/16?aplkpUe;J Jizf;fUtpiaa[k; m/rh/30 kPl;blLj;jhh;/ v/1?,d; bjhptpf;fg;gl;l thf;FK:yj;jpd;nghpy;. rPUe;jpd;
,ae;jpuKk;. Jizg;bghwpa[';Tl kPl;blLf;fg;gl;lJ/ ,jw;FKd;g[ Th;e;J ftdpf;fg;gl;lJnghd;W. v/1?My; milahs';fhl;lg;gl;l ,lj;jpypUe;J g[ijj;j rlyj;ij njhz;obaLj;jdh;/ ,we;Jnghdthpd; rlyf;Tuha;t[ elj;jg;gl;lJ/ gy fha';fs; fhzg;gl;ld/ g[ydha;t[ Kotile;jjd;nghpy;. midj;J vjphpfSf;Fk; vjpuhf m/rh/30 Fw;w mwpf;if jhf;fy; bra;jhh;/ ,t;tHf;F mkh;t[ ePjpkd;wj;jpw;F nky;tprhuizf;fhf mDg;gpitf;fg;gl;lJ/ Fw;wthsp
Fw;wj;ij kWj;Jiuj;jjhy;. mth;fs; midtUk; ,/j/r/?,d; gphpt[ 302?,d; fPHhd Fw;wj;jpw;fhft[k;. ,ju Fw;wj;jpw;fhft[k; tprhhpf;fg;gl;ldh;/
2/3/ muRj;jug;gpdh; bgUkstpyhd rhl;rpfis tprhhpj;jdh;/ v/1?My; bfhLf;fg;gl;l btspg;gLj;Jjy; thf;FK:yj;jpd;nghpy; ,we;Jnghdtuhy;
Xl;lg;gl;l rPUe;ij ahhplkpUe;J fhty; Jiwapdh; ifg;gw;wpdhh;fnsh me;j m/rh/16?I Kf;fpakhd rhl;rpahf Twyhk;/ muRj;jug;g[ rhl;rpa';fs; Kot[w;w gpd;dh;. F/e/r/. gphpt[ 313?,d; fPH; vjphpapd; TLjyhd thf;FK:yk; gjpt[ bra;ag;gl;lJ/ mth;fSf;F vjpuhd rhl;Liufis vjphp kWj;Jiuj;jhh;/ vjphp mth;fSila vjph; tHf;Fiuapy; v/j/rh/1?I tprhhpj;jdh;/ rhl;rpa';fis kjpg;gPL bra;jjd;nghpy; fw;wwpe;j tprhuiz ePjpkd;wk; ,';Fs;s nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;? v/1?f;F jz;lidj; jPh;g;g[ tH';fpaJ/ mwpthh;e;j tprhuiz ePjpkd;wj;jhy; gpwg;gpf;fg;gl;l Fw;wj; jPh;g;g[ kw;Wk; jz;lidj; jPh;g;g[f;fhd jPh;g;g[iu kw;Wk; cj;juit cah; ePjpkd;wj;jpdhy; nfs;tpf;Fs;shd jPh;g;g[iu kw;Wk; cj;jut[
K:yk; cWjpbra;ag;gl;lJ/ ,jd;fhuzkhfnt. nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;?1?Mk; mry; vjphpapd; mwpt[Wj;jy;go jw;nghija nky;KiwaPlhFk;/
3/ nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;?Fw;wthspapd; rhh;ghf fw;wwpe;j tHf;Fiu"h; jpUkjp-bry;tp/ vd;/v!;/ ehg;gpid Kd;dpiyahdhh; kw;Wk; khepy murpd; rhh;ghf fw;wwpe;j tHf;Fiu"h; Kidth; jpU/ v!;/ n$hrg; mhp!;lhl;oy;
Kd;dpiyahdhh;/
4/ jw;nghija tHf;fpy; muRj;jug;g[ tHf;fhdJ. NH;epiy rhl;rpa';fspd; mog;gilapy; kl;LnkahdJ vd;W vjphpapd; rhh;ghf M$uhd fw;wwpe;j tHf;Fiu"h; Kidg;g[ld; thjpl;lhh;/ xU Fw;wthspiaj; jz;og;gjw;F Kd;dh; r';fpypapy; cs;s xt;bthU bjhlh;g[k; epWtg;glntz;Lk; vd;Wk;. me;jtifapy; Fw;wthspapd; Fw;wj;ij vjph;j;J bty;yKoahj
Kotpw;F mJ tHptFf;fntz;Lk; vd;gJ ed;F epiyepWj;jg;gl;l rl;lkhFk; vd;Wk; thjplg;gl;lJ/
4/1/ jw;nghija tHf;fpy; ,we;JnghdtUila kuzkhdJ. kdpjf;bfhiy vd;gij muRj;jug;gpy; epU:gpf;ftpy;iy vd;Wk;. mt;tz;znk rlyf;Tuha;t[ bra;j kUj;Jtuhy; kuzj;jpw;fhd fhuzk; Fwpj;J ve;jbthU cWjpahd fUj;Jiuiaa[k; tH';fKoatpy;iy vd;Wk; thjplg;gl;lJ/
4/2/ jw;nghija tHf;fpy;. mwpthh;e;j tprhuiz ePjpkd;wKk;. cah; ePjpkd;wKk; xg;g[jy; thf;FK:yk;-ePjpKiw rhuh thf;FK:yj;jpd; mog;gilapy; vjphpf;F jz;lidj; jPh;g;g[ tH';fpaJ vd;W gzpe;Jiuf;fg;gl;lJ/ epiyepWj;jg;gl;l rl;lf; fUj;Jiuapd;go ePjpKiw rhuh thf;FK:yk; xU gytPdkhd rhl;rpakhFk; vd;W thJiuf;fg;gl;lJ/ vjphpapd; xg;g[jy; thf;FK:yj;jpw;F nkw;nfhshd kPsg;bgWifahdJ jpUlg;gl;l bghUl;fspd; ifa[ilikf;F mg;ghw;gl;L vija[k; epiyehl;ltpy;iy vd;Wk;. bfhiy bra;jjhf vjphpiaj; bjhlh;g[gLj;jtpy;iy vd;Wk; thjplg;gl;lJ/
4/3/ vjphpapd; rhh;ghf Kd;dpiyahd fw;wwpe;j tHf;Fiu"h; thjpl;lJ ahbjdpy;. jw;nghija tHf;fpy;. v/1?My; fhz;gpf;fg;gl;l
,lj;jpypUe;J rlyj;ij kPl;blLj;jJk;. v/1?My; milahs';fhzg;gl;l
,lj;jpypUe;J Jizg;bghwp kw;Wk; ,ae;jpukpy;yhky; rPUe;ij kPl;blLj;jJk; mjd;gpd;dh;. m/rh/16?aplkpUe;J rPUe;jpd; Jizg;bghwpia kPsg;bgw;wJk; ek;gKoahjjhFk;/ Vbddpy; xg;g[jy; thf;FK:yk;-bjhptpf;fg;gl;l thf;FK:yj;jpd;
mog;gilapy; mJ ,Ue;jJ/ vdnt. cah; ePjpkd;wj;jpdhy; tpthpf;fg;gl;l
NH;epiyfs; muRj;jug;g[ tHf;fpid Mjhpf;ftpy;iy vd;W rkh;g;gpf;fg;gl;lJ/
4/4/ v/1?My; milahs';fhzg;gl;l ,lj;jpypUe;J rlyj;ij kPl;blLj;jijg; bghWj;jkl;oy;. 31/12/2007 md;W ifJf;Fg; gpd;dh;. fhty;Jiwapdh; Kd;g[ v/2 mspj;j jd;dpr;irahd xg;g[jy; thf;FK:yj;jpy; g[ijf;fg;gl;l ,lj;ij mth; bjhpag;gLj;jpdhh; vd;W nkw;bfhz;L thjplg;gl;lJ/ g[ijf;fg;gl;l ,lkhdJ v/2?My; bjhptpf;fg;gl;lJ vd;W gzpe;Jiuf;fg;gl;lJ/ vdnt. rlyk; g[ijf;fg;gl;oUe;j ,lkhdJ fhty;
JiwapdUf;F Kd;Tl;ona bjhpe;jpUe;jJ/
4/5/ m/rh/22?Mdth; 29/12/2007 md;W ePjpKiw rhuh xg;g[jy; thf;FK:yk; bgw;wijaLj;J. mth;. 30/12/2007 md;W fhty;Jiwapdhplk; xg;gilj;j me;jf; fojj;jpy; rlyk; g[ijf;fg;gl;l ,lk; Fwpj;J
Fwpg;gplg;gl;oUe;jJ vd;W nkYk; thjplg;gl;lJ/ 29/12/2007 md;nw g[ijf;fg;gl;l
,lkhdJ bjhpag;gLj;jg;gl;oUe;jJ/ fhty;Jiwapdh; m/rh/22?Dila
J}z;Ljypd;nghpy; 30/12/2007 md;W v/1?I ifJbra;jdh; vd;W rkh;g;gpf;fg;gl;lJ/ me;jtifapy; m/rh/22?f;F Kfthpaplg;gl;L 29/12/2007 md;W bgwg;gl;ljhfr; brhy;yg;gLk; ePjpKiwrhuh xg;g[jy; thf;FK:y fojj;ij ek;gntKoahJ vd;fpw mstpy; mjid fPHik ePjpkd;w';fs; ek;gtpy;iy/ nkw;fz;l fojkhdJ cah; ePjpkd;wj;jhy; epuhfhpf;fg;gl;lJ vd;W rkh;g;gpf;fg; gl;lJ/ vdnt. xl;Lbkhj;j g[yd;tprhuiza[k; re;njfj;jpw;Fhpabjd;W Twyhk;/ vdnt. mjid rhh;t[w ,ayhJ vd;Wk; vLj;Jiuf;fg;gl;lJ/
4/6/ v/1?,d; xg;g[jy; thf;FK:yj;jpypUe;J g[ijf;fg;gl;l ,lkhdJ fz;lwpag;gltpy;iy. khwhf ePjpKiwrhuh xg;g[jy; thf;FK:yk; kw;Wk; v/2?,d; xg;g[jy; thf;FK:yj;jpypUe;J Vw;bfdnt fz;lwpag;gl;lJ vd;W
Kidg;g[ld; vLj;Jiuf;fg;gl;lJ/ vdnt. nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;?vjphpf;F v/1?My; bra;ag;gl;ljhf brhy;yg;gLk; btspaPl;od;nghpy; rlyk; kPl;blLf;fg;gl;ljd; mog;gilapy; jz;lidj; jPh;g;g[ tH';fpapUf;fKoahJ vd;Wk; thjplg;gl;lJ/
4/7/ ,e;jr; NH;epiyapy; v/1?My; milahs';fhzg;gl;l ,lj;jpypUe;J kPsg;bgw;w Jizg;bghwp kw;Wk; ,ae;jpukpy;yhky; kPl;blLf;fg;gl;l rPUe;ijg; bghWj;jkl;oy;. nkw;brhd;dtw;wpw;F cah; ePjpkd;wkhdJ m/rh/16?,d; rhl;rpaj;ij rhh;t[w;wJ vd;W vLj;Jiuf;fg;gl;lJ/ vdpDk;. mwpthh;e;j tprhuiz ePjpkd;wk; m/rh/16?,d; rhl;rpaj;ij epuhfhpj;J rh/bgh/1. rh/bgh/2 kw;Wk; rh/bgh/3 mjhtJ Kiwna rPUe;J. ,ae;jpuk; kw;Wk; Jizg;bghwp kPsg;bgw;wj;ij re;njfpj;jJ vd;W thjplg;gl;lJ/ m/rh/16?,d; rhl;rpaj;ij
Vw;Wf;bfhs;ifapy; mwpthh;e;j tprhuiz ePjpkd;wj;jpdhy; gjpt[ bra;ag;gl;l rhl;rpaj;ij MH;e;J Muhanth kw;Wk;-my;yJ tpthjpf;fnth cah; ePjpkd;wk; jtwptpl;lJ/
4/8/ ,e;jr; NH;epiyapy; m/rh/17?aplkpUe;J ,ae;jpug;bghwpapd; kPsg;bgWif kw;Wk; rPUe;jpd; Jizg;bghwp kPsg;bgWifiag; bghWj;jtiuapy;. jpULnghd bghUl;fs; kPl;blLf;fg;gl;lJ bjhlh;ghf ,Ue;j midj;J rhl;rpfSk; m/rh/17 kw;Wk; m/rh/23 nghd;nwhUk; rh/bgh/1?Md rPUe;jpd; kPsg;bgWifia Mjhpf;ftpy;iy vd;W vLj;Jiuf;fg;gl;lJ/ vdnt. rhl;Liuf;fg;gl;l xg;g[jy; thf;FK:yj;jpw;F nkw;nfhshf rPUe;J
xypg;bgUf;fpfs; vd;W brhy;yg;gLgtw;wpd; kPsg;bgWif kw;Wk; Jizg;bghwp.
,ae;jpug;bghwp vd rhl;Liuf;fg;gLgtw;wpd; kPsg;bgWifia Vw;Wf;bfhs;s
KoahJ vd;W rkh;g;gpj;jdh;/
4/9/ vdnt. nkw;fz;l NH;epiy rhl;rpaj;jpd; kPJ kl;Lnk muRj;jug;g[ tHf;F rhh;e;Js;sJ vd;gijaLj;J. vjphpf;F vjpuhd fLikahd
Fw;wr;rhl;Lfis epiyehl;Lk;bghUl;L bka;g;gpf;fj;jf;f xt;bthd;Wk; ek;gpf;if xt;thjJk;. FiwghLilaJkhFk; vd;gjhy;. Fw;wj; jz;lidia epiyehl;Lk;bghUl;L xt;bthU bjhlh;gpid epiyehl;lt[k; my;yJ-kw;Wk; vjphpapd; Fw;wj;ij re;njfj;jpw;F mg;ghw;gl;L muRj;jug;gpdh; epU:gpf;f ntz;Ltd vJnth. mjid muRj;jug;g[ bra;aj;jtwptpl;lJ vd;gJk; vLj;Jiuf;fg;gl;lJ/
4/10/ v/1?Mdth; bra;ahj Fw;wj;jpw;fhf Vw;bfdnt 15 Mz;Lfhyk; rpiwapy; fHpj;Jtpl;lhh; vd;gjhy;. jw;nghija nky;KiwaPl;oid mDkjpj;J vjphpia tpLjiy bra;a[k;go ntz;Liuj;J nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;?vjphpapd; rhh;ghf Kd;dpiyahd fw;wwpe;j tHf;Fiu"h; nkw;bfhz;L thJiuj;jhh;/
5/ khepy murpd; rhh;ghf Kd;dpiyahd fw;wwpe;j tHf;Fiu"h; jw;nghija nky;KiwaPl;oid vjph;j;Jiuf;ifapy;. jw;nghija tHf;fpy; v/1?My; milahs';fhl;lg;gl;l kw;Wk; fhz;gpf;fg;gl;l ,lj;jpypUe;J g[ijj;j rlyj;ij njhz;obaLj;jdh; vd;W Kidg;g[ld; vLj;Jiuf;fg;gl;lJ/ v/1?My; g[ijf;fg;gl;l ,lk; fhz;gpf;fg;gl;lJk; kw;Wk; mtuhy; rlyk; milahsk; fhzg;gl;lJk; muRj;jug;ghy; Kiwahf epU:gpf;fg;gl;Ls;sJ/ khDltpay; epg[zhpd; rhl;rpaKk; Vw;Wf;bfhs;sg;gl;lJ/ v/1?My; mspf;fg;gl;l
bjhptpf;fg;gl;l thf;FK:yj;jpd; mog;gilapy; jpULnghd rPUe;J';Tl kPsg;bgwg;gl;lJ vd;W thjplg;gl;lJ/ v/1?My; bfhLf;fg;gl;l bjhptpf;fg;gl;l thf;FK:yj;jpd; mog;gilapy; m/rh/17?,d; fhg;g[g;bghWg;gpy; ,ae;jpug;bghwp kw;Wk; Jizg;bghwp ,Ug;gJ fz;lwpag;gl;lJ vd;W thjplg;gl;lJ/ v/1?My; rpy ghf';fs; tpw;fg;gl;Ltpl;lJ vd;W m/rh/17 rhl;rpak; mspj;Js;sjhf rkh;g;gpf;fg;gl;lJ/ nkw;Twpa Kf;fpakhd NH;epiyfs; F/e/r/. gphpt[ 313?,d; fPHhd jdJ TLjyhd thf;FK:yj;jpy; vjphpahy; tpsf;fkspf;fg;glntapy;iy vd;W gzpe;Jiuf;fg;gl;lJ/ ePjpkd;wk;(fshy;) v/j/rh/1?,d; rhl;rpak; epuhfhpf;fg;gl;lJ vd;Wk; vLj;Jiuf;fg;gl;lJ/ vdnt. ,/j/r/?tpd; fPHhd
,ju Fw;wj;jpw;fhft[k; kw;Wk; gphpt[ 302?,d; fPGk; jz;of;ff;Toa
Fw;wj;jpw;fhf vjphpf;F jz;lidj; jPh;g;g[ tH';fpajpy; fPHik ePjpkd;w';fs; ve;jj; jtWk; ,iHf;ftpy;iy vd;Wk; gzpe;Jiuf;fg;gl;lJ/
5/1/ nkw;fz;l thj';fis Kd;itj;J. jw;nghija nky;KiwaPl;oidj; js;Sgo bra;a[khW ntz;of;bfhz;ldh;/
6/ khepy muR mj;Jld; vjphpapd; rhh;ghf Kd;dpiyahd fw;wwpe;j tHf;Fiu"iu eh';fs; nfl;lwpe;njhk;/ nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;?1?Mk; vjphpia
,/j/r/. gphpt[fs; 302 kw;Wk; 201?,d; fPH; jz;of;ff;Toa Fw;wj;jpw;fhd
Fw;wthsp vd;gij cWjpbra;ifapy; mwpthh;e;j tprhuiz ePjpkd;wk; kw;Wk; cah; ePjpkd;wj;jpdhy; gjpt[ bra;ag;gl;l fhz;Kot[fis eh';fs; KGtJkhf ghh;itapl;nlhk;/
6/1/ xg;g[jy; thf;FK:yj;jpd;nghpy; mtUf;F jz;lidj; jPh;g;g[ tH';fg;gl;lJ vd;gjhy;. NH;epiy rhl;rpaj;jpd; neh;tpYk; kw;Wk;
r';fpypj; bjhlh;g[ila epfH;t[fs; KGtJkhf bka;g;gpf;fg;gl;L epiyehl;lg;gl;lhyd;wp. xg;g[jy; thf;FK:yj;jpd;nghpy; mtUf;F jz;lidj; jPh;g;g[ tpjpf;fg;gl;oUf;fkhl;lhJ vd;gJ nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;?1?Mk; vjphpapd; rhh;ghd tHf;fhFk;/ vdpDk;. fw;wwpe;j tprhuiz ePjpkd;wk; kw;Wk; cah; ePjpkd;wj;jhy; gpwg;gpf;fg;gl;l jPh;g;g[iu(fs;) kw;Wk; cj;jut[(fs;)?ypUe;J. xg;g[jy; thf;FK:yj;jpd; mog;gilapy; nky;KiwaPl;lhsUf;F jz;lid tpjpf;fg;gl;ljhf TwptplKoahJ/ jw;nghija tHf;fpy;. mth; Fw;wk;g[hpe;jhh; vd;W vjphpapd; xg;g[jy; thf;FK:yj;jpy; ,y;iy vd;gJ ePjpkd;wj;jhy; rhh;t[wg;gl;lJ/ m/rh/22?f;F 1?Mk; vjphpahy; mDg;gg;gl;ljhff; Twg;gLk; fojkhdJ ,uz;lhk; epiy rhl;rpak; vd;gjhy; cah; ePjpkd;wj;jhy; ek;gg;gltpy;iy. nkYk; mJ bka;g;gpf;fg;gltpy;iy vd;gij ftdj;jpy; bfhs;sntz;oajhfpwJ/ vdnt. mt;tifapy; fojk;-fojj; bjhlh;igg; bghWj;jkl;oy; cah; ePjpkd;wk; mjw;F mjpf Kf;fpaj;Jtk; mspf;ftpy;iy/ vdnt. fojk;-fojj;bjhlh;gpy; bfhLf;fg;gl;Ls;s xg;g[jy; thf;FK:yj;jpd;nghpy; nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;?1?Mk; vjphpf;F jz;lid tpjpf;fg;gl;ljhff; TwKoahJ/
6/2/ vdpDk;. mnjrkaj;jpy;. Kd;djhd tHf;F 4/2/2007 md;W fz;Lgpof;fg;glhj tHf;F vd;W Kof;fg;gl;Ltpl;ljhy;. 30/12/2007 md;W fhty;Jiwapduhy; bgwg;gl;l fojj;bjhlh;g[-fojnk ,t;tHf;fpid kPz;Lk; bjhl';Ftjw;fhd fhuzk; vd;gijf; fhzKofpwJ/ mjd;gpd;dh;. m/rh/30?My; cs;sgoahd g[ydha;t[ bjhl';fg;gl;lJ/ mjd;gpd;dh;. g[ydha;tpd;nghJ
,we;Jnghdthpd; rlyj;ij g[ijj;jpUe;j ,lj;ij 1?Mk; vjphp bjhptpj;jhh;/
1?Mk; vjphpahy; milahs';fhzg;gl;l ,lj;jpypUe;J g[ijf;fg;gl;l rlyj;ij
njhz;obaLj;jdh;/ vdnt. rlyk; g[ijf;fg;gl;l ,lk; Fwpj;J jdpg;gl;l
Kiwapy; mwpe;jpUe;jjhfr; brhy;yg;gLk; vjphpahy; bjhptpf;fg;gl;l
,lj;jpypUe;J vjphpapDila ntz;Ljypd;nghpy; rlyk; fz;blLf;fg;gl;lJ vd;gJ tHf;fhFk;/ mjd;gpd;dh;. vYk;g[fs; kw;Wk; kz;ilXL kPJ kugQq nrhjid kw;Wk; nkw;bghUj;Jjy; nrhjid elj;jg;gl;L mJ ,we;JnghdtUila rlyk;jhd; vd;gJ epU:gpf;fg;gl;lJ/ nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;?v/1?f;F vjpuhf jz;lidj;jPh;g;g[ tH';Ftjw;fhd Kjy; tYthd NHikt[ ,Jjhd;/
6/3/ mjd;gpd;dh;. bjhlh;g[ila rkaj;jpy; ,we;Jnghdtuhy; Xl;lg;gl;l rPUe;J';Tl vjphpapd; ntz;LWj;jj;jpdhnyna m/rh/16?aplkpUe;J jpUk;gg;bgwg;gl;lJ/ vdnt. nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;?1?Mk; vjphpahy; bjhptpf;fg;gl;l egh; kw;Wk; ,lj;jpypUe;J ,we;Jnghdtuhy; Xl;lg;gl;l rPUe;Jk; kPsg;bgwg;gl;lJ/ nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;?1?Mk; vjphpahy; jpULnghd rPUe;J m/rh/16?f;F tpw;fg;gl;lJ. mtiu tprhhpj;jjhy; muRj;jug;gpdh;
Kd;Twg;gl;ltw;iw btw;wpfukhf epU:gpj;jdh;/ ,J nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;?1?Mk; vjphpf;F vjpuhd ,uz;lhtJ tYthd NHikt[ MFk;/
6/4/ mjd;gpd;dh;. nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;?1?Mk; vjphpahy; tpw;fg;gl;l
,ae;jpug;bghwp kw;Wk; Jizg;bghwp m/rh/17?aplkpUe;J kPsg;bgwg;gl;lJ vd;gij epU:gpj;jjpy; muRj;jug;g[ btw;wpbgw;wJ/ 1?Mk; vjphpahy; bfhLf;fg;gl;l bjhptpf;fg;gl;l thf;FK:yj;jpd;nghpy; m/rh/17?,d; fhg;g[g; bghWg;gpypUe;J jpULnghd rPUe;J ,ae;jpug;bghwp kw;Wk; Jizg;bghwp
Mfpait kPl;blLf;fg;gl;Ls;sJ/ m/rh/17 gpwH;rhl;rpahf khwptpl;lnghjpYk;. vt;thwpUg;gpDk;. mnjneuj;jpy;. 1?Mk; vjphpahy; bfhLf;fg;gl;l
bjhptpf;fg;gl;l thf;FK:yj;jpd;nghpy; m/rh/17?aplkpUe;J ,ae;jpug;bghwp kw;Wk;
Jizg;bghwp kPl;blLf;fg;gl;lJ m/rh/30?Md fhty;Jiw rhl;rpapid tprhhpj;jjd; K:yk; muRj;jug;ghy; epiyehl;lg;gl;L bka;g;gpf;fg;gl;Ltpl;ljhy;. nkw;brhd;dtw;wpd;nghpy; m/rh/30?I ek;gkWg;gjw;fhd ve;jf; fhuzj;ija[k; eh';fs; fhztpy;iy/ ,J nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;?1?Mk; vjphpf;F vjpuhd kw;bwhU
NH;epiyahFk;/ vdnt. ,/j/r/. gphpt[fs; 302 kw;Wk; 201?,d; fPHhd
Fw;w';fSf;fhf vjphp?nky;KiwaPl;lhsUf;F mwpthh;e;j tprhuiz ePjpkd;wKk; cah; ePjpkd;wKk; nkw;Twpa tYthd NHikt[fspd; mog;gilapy; jz;lidj; jPh;g;g[ tpjpj;jijaLj;J. ,e;jpa murikg;g[r; rl;lj;jpd; tFKiwf;TW
136?,d; fPHhd mjpfhu';fisr; braYWj;Jtjpy; jiyapLtjw;F eh';fs; ve;jf; fhuzj;ija[k; fhztpy;iy/
6/5/ jw;nghJ. kuzKw;wthpd; kuzk; rlyf;Tuha;t[ mwpf;ifapy; cs;sJnghy; kdpjf;bfhiy vd;gija[k;. kuzj;jpw;fhd fhuzk; fz;Lgpof;fg;glKoatpy;iy vd;gija[k; muRj;jug;g[ bka;g;gpf;fj; jtwptpl;lJ vd;W nky;KiwaPl;lhshpd; rhh;ghf Kd;itf;fg;gl;l gzpe;Jiufisg; bghWj;jtiuapy;. rlyk; vhpf;fg;gl;L gy khj';fSf;Fg; gpd;dh; mJ fz;lwpag;gl;ljhy; kuzkhdJ kdpjdhy; epfH;j;jg;gl;lJ vd;gij muRj;jug;g[ bka;g;gpg;gjw;fhd rhj;jpakpy;iy vd;gJ ftdj;jpw;bfhs;sg;glntz;oajhfpwJ/ vdpDk;. mnjrkaj;jpy;. cah; ePjpkd;wj;jpdhy; rhpahf Th;e;J Muhag;gl;lJ nghd;W. nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;?1?Mk; vjphpahy; ,we;Jnghdthpd; rPUe;J jpUlg;gl;L vLj;Jr;bry;yg;gl;l gpd;dh; ,we;Jnghdth; bfhy;yg;gl;L ,Ue;jhh; vd;gij
,ju NHikt[fspd; K:ykhf muRj;jug;gpdh; epiyehl;o bka;g;gpj;Js;sdh;/
7/ nkw;Twpa r';fjpfs; kw;Wk; NH;epiyfis MH;e;J Muha;e;jjpy;.
,/j/r/. gphpt[fs; 302 kw;Wk; 201?,d; fPH; jz;of;ff;Toa Fw;w';fSf;fhf nky;KiwaPl;lhsh;?1?Mk; vjphpia jz;lidf;Fl;gLj;jp mwpthh;e;j tprhuiz ePjpkd;wj;jpdhy; tpjpf;fg;gl;l Fw;wj; jPh;g;g[ kw;Wk; jz;lidj; jPh;g;gpd; jPh;g;g[iu kw;Wk; cj;juit cWjpbra;J nky;KiwaPl;il mDkjpj;jjpy; cah; ePjpkd;wk; ve;jbthU jtiwa[k; ,iHf;ftpy;iy vd;gjpy; eh';fs; kpFjpahf kdepiwtilfpnwhk;/
7/1/ nkw;fz;ljd; epkpj;jkhft[k;. nkw;Twpa fhuz';fSf;fhft[k;
,e;ePjpkd;wj;jpd; jiyaPL njitaw;wjhFk;/ ,k;nky;KiwaPL js;Sgo bra;tjw;FhpaJ vd;gjhy; mjd;go js;Sgo bra;ag;gLfpwJ/ khz;g[kpF ePjpaurh; jpU/ vk;/Mh;/ c&h khz;g[kpF ePjpaurh; jpU/ rp/o/ utpFkhh; g[J jpy;yp.
19/01/2023/
??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????? bghWg;g[Jwg;g[
@tl;lhu bkhHpapy; bkhHpahf;fk; bra;ag;gl;l ,j;jPh;g;g[iuahdJ. tHf;fho. jd;Dila bkhHpapy; g[hpe;Jbfhs;tjw;F gad;gLj;jpf;bfhs;tjw;Fl;gl;lnjad;wp. ntbwe;j nehf;fj;jpw;fhft[k; gad;gLj;jpf;bfhs;syhfhJ/ midj;J eilKiwahd kw;Wk; mYty;Kiwahd nehf;f';fSf;Fk; kw;Wk; jPh;g;g[iuia epiwntw;wYf;Fk;. braw;gLj;jYf;Fk; mjd; M';fpyg; gjpg;ng mjpfhug;g{h;tkhdjhFk;/@
JUDGMENT