Full Text
CM(M) No.1873/2006 # Gyanender Prasad Tewari ........
Petitioner ! through: Mr.S.P. Pandey, Advocate
Kumar Bhall, Advocates for respondent no.1.
JUDGMENT
1. Whether reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Y
2. To be referred to the Reporter or not? Y
3. Whether judgment should be reported in Digest? Y: PRADEEP NANDRAJOG, J.
1. Vide impugned order dated 19.7.06 applications filed by the petitioner Gyanendra Prasad Tiwari and respondent No.2 Subhash Kumar Tiwari under Order I Rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure seeking impleadment of the petitioner as a defendant has been dismissed.
2. Relevant facts to be noted for the purpose of adjudication of the matter in issue within the confines of Order I 2007:DHC:1500 Rule 10 CPC are that the respondent no.2 (hereinafter referred to as the plaintiff) filed a suit for specific performance of an agreement to sell dated 18.6.90 with possession of plot bearing Muncipal No.325, Deepali, Pitam Pura, Delhi (hereinafter referred to as the suit property) against the respondent no.2 (hereinafter referred to as the defendant).
3. Material allegations in the plaint are that the defendant represented to the plaintiff that he is the sole and exclusive owner of the the suit property on the basis of a registered Will dated 13.2.1980 executed by the father of the defendant bequeathing the suit property in favour of the defendant and his elder brother i.e. the petitioner and that a relinquishment deed dated 28.5.90 was executed by the petitioner relinquishing all his rights and interest in the suit property in favour of the defendant. That original Will and the Relinquishment Deed were delivered by the defendant to the plaintiff. That after delivery of the said documents and believing the representation made by the defendant pertaining to the ownership of the suit property to be true the plaintiff entered into an agreement to sell dated 18.6.90 with the defendant for the sale of suit property for a total sale consideration of Rs.4,00,000/-. That pursuant to the said agreement a sum of Rs.1,95,000/- was paid by the plaintiff to the defendant. That the balance sale consideration was to be paid by the plaintiff at the time of the execution and registration of the sale deed. That the defendant failed to perform its part of the obligations under the agreement. That the plaintiff was always ready and willing to perform its obligations under the agreement.
4. In the written statement filed by the defendant it was pleaded that the documents namely agreement to sell dated 18.6.90, will dated 13.2.80 and relinquishment deed dated 28.5.90 which formed the basis of the plaintiff's suit are forged and fabricated. That the defendant was not the sole and exclusive owner of the suit property. That the defendant and the petitioner were joint owners of the suit property. Relevant portions of the written statement of the defendant read as under:- “PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS:..............
5. That the present suit has been filed by the plaintiff on the basis of false and forged documents which were never executed/handed over by the defendant to the plaintiff within his own knowledge, therefore, the present suit is liable to be dismissed................
7. That even otherwise the defendant being only the legal heir of Late Sh. Jagannath Prasad Tiwari and having only undivided share in the ancestral suit property, discredit the grant of relief of specific performance or possession or damages against him and in favour of the plaintiff.
REPLY ON MERITS:..............
5. That para 5 of the plaint is wrong, baseless, concoted and emphatically denied. It is specifically denied that it was represented to the plaintiff that the elder brother of the defendant, namely, Sh. G.P. Tiwari had executed any relinquishment deed and muchless one dated 28.5.90 in favour of the defendant or that the defendant became owner of the suit plot as alleged. It is also particularly denied that the defendant entered into any agreement to sell with the plaintiff as alleged. It is respectfully submitted that no relinquishment deed was ever executed by Sh. G.P. Tiwari in favour of the defendant and they are still joint owners of the suit plot............”
5. Petitioner and respondent no.2 filed two independant applications seeking impleadment of the petitioner as a defendant by virtue of sub-rule 2 of Rule 10 of Order I of the Code of Civil Procedure.
6. Substantially, averments in the said applications are same as the averments made by the defendant in his written statement.
7. Paras 4, 5 and 6 of the application filed by the defendant read as under:-
9. After considering the respective stands of the parties, vide impugned order dated 19.07.06 the learned Trial Judge had dismissed the said applications.
10. In support of the petition, learned counsel for the petitioner had contended that the matter in controversy in a suit has to be considered not only with reference to the case set up in the plaint but even the defence set up in the written statement. It was urged that the defendant has categorically pleaded that the documents relied upon by the plaintiff are forged and fabricated and that the defendant and petitioner are the joint owners of the suit property. That in view of the defence taken by the defendant the petitioner is a necessary party and is entitled to be impleaded as a defendant in the suit as he would be affected by the decision in the suit.
11. Per contra, learned counsel for the plaintiff/respondent no.1 had contended that a plaintiff is a dominus litus and cannot be compelled to litigate against a person qua whom no relief has been prayed for. Counsel further urged that the expression “all the questions involved in the suit” means only the questions or disputes between the parties to the dispute and do not include a question or dispute between one or more of the parties and a third party. That the petitioner is neither a necessary nor a proper party, nor his presence is necessary before the Court in order to enable the Court to effectually and completely adjudicate upon and settle all questions involved in the suit.
12. Learned Counsel for the plaintiff relied upon the following authorities:i. Panne Khushali & Anr v Jeewanlal Mathoo Khatik & Anr AIR 1976 MP 148 (FB): In said case, it was held that the strangers to the contract making a claim adverse to the title of the defendant (vendor) contending that they are the co-owners of the contracted property are neither necessary nor proper party and are therefore not entitled to be joined as parties to the suit. ii. Ram Bilash Pandey & Ors v Jai Narayan Gupta & Ors AIR 1984 Pat 218: In the said case, a suit for specific performance of contract for sale entered into by certain members of a joint Hindu family was filed. Other members of the family claimed to be impleaded on the ground that the property which was sought to be sold was joint family property and that it was acquired with joint family funds. Noting the decision in Panne Kushali's case (supra) and the fact result of the decree even if adverse to intervenors shall not bind the intervenors, it was held that the members claiming to be impleaded were neither necessary party nor proper party to the suit and could not be given benefit of Order I Rule 10(2) of the CPC. iii. Anil Kumar Singh v Shivnath Mishra (1995) 3 SCC 147 and Kasturi v Iyyamperumal AIR 2005 SC 2813: In said cases, it was held that the intervenors who are not party to the agreement of sale are not necessary party to the suit for specific performance for the reason their presence is not necessary in order to determine the dispute as to specific performance.
13. Learned counsel for the petitioner relied upon the following judgments:i. Sumtibai & Ors v Paras Finance Co. JT 2007 (11) SC 749: In said case, noting the decision in Kasturi's case (supra), the Supreme Court has observed as under:-
ii. Dinesh Kumar Gupta v Manish Kumar FAO No.545/01 decided on 08.05.02: In said case, appellants sought impleadment in a suit for specific performance of an agreement to sell on the ground that the defendant had entered into an earlier agreement to sell with them with respect to same property. Holding that the appellants are proper parties to the suit, the Division Bench of this Court allowed the appeal.
14. Before proceeding to discuss the legal position it is important to note the relevant statutory provision. Order I Rule 10(2) of the Code of Civil Procedure reads as under:- “(2) Court may strike out or add parties:- The Court may at any stage of the proceedings, either upon or without the application of either party, and on such terms as may appear to the Court to be just, order that the name of any party improperly joined, whether as plaintiff or defendant, or whose presence before the Court may be necessary in order to enable the Court effectually and completely to adjudicate upon and 'settle all the questions involved in the suit, be added'.”
15. A reading of the statutory provision shows that the sweep of the legislative provision is controlled by the expression 'settle all the questions involved in the suit, be added'. Meaning thereby, an inquiry under Order I Rule 10(2) is not to focus on whether the applicant is a person who ought to have been joined as a necessary party to the suit. The focus of inquiry is limited to the question whether the applicant could be impleaded on the premise that his presence before the Court may be necessary in order to enable the Court to effectually and completely adjudicate upon and settle the questions involved in the suit.
16. A perusal of the commentaries under Order I Rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure reveal a plethora of decisions which have considered the ambit of the power of the Court in impleading a person as a proper party. The authorities have explained the meaning of the phrase 'all the questions involved in the suit'.
17. The decisions illustrate a wide spectrum of instances when intervention was allowed and when refused.
18. From the decisions, no discernible principle governing the discretionary power of the Court emerges, for the simple reason, the spectrum of claims is fairly wide and therefore it would be inadvisable to cast the discretionary power in a straight jacket of an inflexible formula. However, one principle emerges, that the language employed in the rule vests a very wide discretion in the Court.
19. In the leading case of Razia Begum v Anwar Begum AIR 1958 SC 886 the Supreme Court had laid down the following principles regarding the power of the Court to implead parties by virtue of Rule 10(2) of the Code of Civil Procedure:-
20. A reference may also be made to the decision of the Supreme Court reported as Ramesh Hirachand Kundanmal v Municipal Corporation of Greater Bombay 1992 (2) SCC 224. In the said case, the plaintiff was a dealer on the land held by the Hindustan Petroleum Corporation and was in possession of a service station. The Municipal Corporation issued a notice to the plaintiff for demolition of a certain construction alleging that it was unauthorized. The plaintiff filed a suit for permanent injunction against the Municipal Corporation. Hindustan Petroleum applied for being impleaded as a defendant on the ground that it had material to show that the structure was unauthorized. The prayer was granted by the Courts below. The plaintiff approached the Supreme Court. Allowing the appeal and setting aside the order, the Supreme Court held that the Hindustan Petroleum Corporation was neither necessary nor proper party to the proceedings. It was held that the person to be joined must be one whose presence is necessary as a party. The test is not whether his presence is necessary for the correct solution of the dispute before the Court but whether the order would affect him or his interest would be prejudiced. Relevant discussion is being noted herein below:-