Full Text
WP(C) No.153/1988
Date of Hearing: 05.10.2007
Date of Decision: 30.11.2007 #Vijay Kumar ....Petitioner
! Through: Mr. R.K. Saini
JUDGMENT
2.To be referred to the Reporter or not? 3.Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest?
A.K. SIKRI, J.
:
1. Sh. Johri Mal Sharma, father of the petitioner, was an employee of the respondent-DTC. During the course of his employment with the DTC, he was allotted Staff Quarter No. F-108, DTC Colony, Shadipur, New Delhi. He continued to occupy the said staff quarter during his tenure in the employment of the DTC from where he retired on 30.6.1987 (AN) on attaining the age of superannuation. WP(C) No.153/88 2007:DHC:1542-DB While he was still in service, his son Vijay Kumar (the petitioner herein) was appointed to the post of Assistant Fitter with the DTC on 7.11.1978. With effect from 1.7.1983 he was promoted to the post of Fitter.
2. Few days before his retirement, Sh. Johri Mal Sharma addressed letter dated 10.4.1987 requesting the General Manager (Admn.), DTC, to allot the said staff quarter, which was in his occupation, to his son as per the policy in force. This request was reiterated by Sh. Johri Mal Sharma, when he was on the verge of his retirement, vide letter dated 12.6.1987. There was no immediate reply given to the petitioner's father, who retired on 30.6.1987 and continued to occupy the said staff quarter, which he was entitled to occupy for few months after his retirement, in any case. However, vide letter dated 20.12.1987 the petitioner was informed that the request for allotment in his name could not be acceded to in view of acute shortage of accommodation. According to the petitioner, this was not a legitimate ground to refuse the allotment of the staff accommodation to the petitioner and was only a makebelief, inasmuch as, in the very month in which the petitioner had sought allotment, staff quarters were allotted to other employees, namely, Shri Ashok Kumar, Jr. Clerk and Shri Pal Singh, Asstt. Electrician (Grade II) on the ground that they were eligible dependents of retiring employees. The petitioner, in these circumstances, preferred the instant petition challenging the rejection order dated 22.12.1987 and has sought mandamus seeking direction against the respondent to allot the said Staff Quarter No. F-108, DTC Colony, Shadipur, New Delhi, to him. In the meantime, treating Sh. Johri Mal Sharma as unauthorised occupant of the said staff quarter, DTC referred the matter to the Estate Officer, who initiated proceedings under the Public Premises (Eviction of Unauthorised Occupants) Act (in short the 'PP Act'). Along with the writ petition, the petitioner filed application for stay against dispossession. While issuing notice to show cause in the writ petition on 20.1.1988, in the stay application a Division Bench of this Court directed that proceedings before the Estate Officer may continue but the petitioner should not be dispossessed. On 21.11.1988, after hearing both the parties, Rule DB was issued and direction was passed to continue the interim order till the disposal of the writ petition.
3. Before proceeding to discuss the merits of this case, we may point out that the Estate Officer, after conclusion of the proceedings, passed eviction order dated 7.2.1992 and also directed him to pay the damages. Sh. Johri Mal Sharma preferred appeal against that order under Section 9 of the PP Act. In the said appeal Sh. Johri Mal Sharma prayed for stay against the recovery of damages, which was declined by the learned Additional District Judge. Challenging the said order he filed CM(M) No.300/1993 wherein stay of recovery was granted, which continued from time to time. On 28.2.2007 the said petition was dismissed for non-prosecution as nobody appeared for the petitioner herein.
4. The claim of the petitioner for allotment of staff quarter is based on the Government policy of allotting accommodation occupied by a retiring employee to his/her son, daughter, wife, husband or father if such persons are in the same organisation and have been residing with the retiring employee and further when such son, daughter, husband, wife is entitled for that very type of accommodation. The conditions which the applicant, namely, son/daughter etc. of retiring employee has to fulfill for allotment of accommodation are that: (i) he is a Government servant eligible for allotment of accommodation and (ii) he has been continuously residing with the retiring employee for at least three years, namely, preceding the date of retirement.
5. In the counter affidavit filed by the respondent, applicability of the aforesaid policy is not denied. However, their submission is that the petitioner does not fulfill the eligibility conditions. Insofar as the first contention is concerned, there is no dispute that the petitioner is employed with the respondent corporation. There is no dispute about the dates of appointment as well. The petitioner became the employee of the DTC on 7.11.1978, whereas his father retired from DTC on 30.6.1987. Thus, by the time his father retired, the petitioner had rendered service of more than 8½ years. Much before his father's retirement, the petitioner got promotion to the post of Fitter with effect from 1.7.1983 and, therefore, in that capacity also the petitioner had worked for more than three years before his father's retirement. The entire dispute is on the fulfillment of the second condition, namely, whether the petitioner had continuously resided with his father for the last three years immediately preceding his date of retirement. Interestingly, there is a letter dated 1.5.1986 of the petitioner as per which he started living with his father with effect from 1.5.1986, as is clear from the specific assertion made therein to this effect, which is clear from the following text of the letter:- “It is submitted that previously I used to live somewhere else, but now I have started living with my father Shri Johri Mal, ATS w.e.f. 1.5.1986 at F- 109, DTC Colony because my father does not remain well. You are, therefore, requested to deduct my house rent from my salary of this month as per rules and regulation for which I shall be obliged.”
6. If one is to go by this letter of the petitioner himself, he would not fulfill the aforesaid requisite of allotment. However, learned counsel for the petitioner relied upon communication dated 11.11.1986 addressed to the petitioner in response to his aforesaid letter dated 1.5.1986, which is to the following effect:- “This has reference to your application dt. 1.5.86 received vide D.No. 302 dt. 5.5.86 for stoppage of House Rent allowance from your salary w.e.f. 1.5.86 and onwards because you are residing in the D.T.C. Quarter allotted to your father. “The position has been reviewed from your personal record wherein you have declared your residential address as Qrt. No. F-108, D.T.C. Colony, Shadipur, New Delhi. Accordingly you were asked to produce the documentary proof to this effect. Since you failed to submit the documentary proof and you were not entitled to draw the House Rent allowance during the period from 8.11.78 to 30.6.86 which worked out to Rs.8358.26 and the same is to be deposited by you within 72 hours after the receipt of this memo failing which further action will be taken without any further reference to you.”
7. On the basis of this it was submitted that the petitioner deposited the amount of Rs.8358.26 which was drawn by him as HRA for the period from 8.11.1978 to 30.6.1986 and, therefore, it would be treated that he fulfilled the second eligibility condition as well. However, we are of the opinion that the petitioner cannot take any such mileage from this letter. This communication refers to the petitioner's own application dated 1.5.1986 in which the petitioner had, as noticed above, categorically mentioned that he had shifted to his father's house only with effect from 1.5.1986. On receipt of this letter, the petitioner was asked to produce the documentary proof to the effect that he was staying with his father only from 1.5.1986 onwards, and as he had failed to submit the proof, it was stated that he was not entitled to draw HRA and under these circumstances he was asked to deposit back the amount of HRA which was withdrawn by him. Whether he had withdrawn the HRA correctly, or the action of the DTC asking him to deposit back the said HRA covering the period from 8.11.1978 to 30.6.1986 is proper or not is not the question before us. Fact remains that the petitioner had claimed that he had started living with his father with effect from 1.5.1986 and as per the aforesaid letter he had failed to submit the documentary proof even with respect to this claim. Therefore, holding the petitioner to his own admission that he had started living with his father with effect from 1.5.1986 and reckoning the period from this date, he failed to satisfy the condition of living with his father for at least three years preceding the date of his father's retirement.
8. Confronted with this, learned counsel for the petitioner made alternative submission to the effect that other persons similarly situated were also granted the benefit of allotment of staff quarters, whereas this was denied to the petitioner. He referred to orders dated 28.5.1987 whereby allotment of residential accommodation in favour of Shri Ashok Kakkar, Jr. Clerk and Shri Pal Singh, Asst. Elect. (Grade-II) has been approved in terms of the aforesaid Government instructions. The petitioner has also filed list of some other such wards who were allotted staff quarters under the same category as Annexure-I. However, from the said letters or the list one cannot make out as to whether those persons were granted the benefit of allotment even when they were not fulfilling the eligibility conditions. In the counter affidavit it is specifically mentioned that those persons, who were allotted accommodation after retirement of their father/relations, were duly eligible and entitled to the allotment of the accommodation. Therefore, the petitioner cannot take advantage of any such orders of allotment. No doubt, the request of the petitioner was turned down on the ground that there was shortage of accommodation. However, in any case, whether there was shortage of accommodation or not, the petitioner could lay his claim only on satisfying the eligibility conditions, which he failed to fulfill.
9. The petitioner was granted stay of dispossession and, therefore, he has occupied the premises for all these years. Having regard to the long intervening period, one can legitimately infer that the petitioner would have become entitled to the said accommodation even as per his own merit. If that is so, there is no question of dispossession of the petitioner now. Insofar as payment of penal rent is concerned, the Estate Officer had passed order to this effect against which the petitioner had filed an appeal under Section 9 of the PP Act, which was dismissed. The petitioner preferred CM (Main) which has also been dismissed. The consequence of that would be that the petitioner is liable to pay the damages as assessed by the Estates Officer.
10. Subject to the aforesaid, insofar as the present petition is concerned, the same is dismissed as devoid of any merits. No costs.
(A.K. SIKRI) JUDGE November 30, 2007 (VIPIN SANGHI) HP/nsk JUDGE