M/s Sri Sai Earthworks Private Limited v. M/s MCM Services Private Limited

Delhi High Court · 05 Dec 2007 · 2007:DHC:1567
Anil Kumar
AA No.90/2007
2007:DHC:1567
civil appeal_allowed Significant

AI Summary

Delhi High Court appointed an arbitrator under Section 11(6) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 after the respondent failed to appoint one within the stipulated time, enforcing the arbitration agreement between the parties.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
Date of Decision: December 5th , 2007 AA No.90/2007
# M/s Sri Sai Earthworks Private Limited ......Petitioner
! Through: Mr.Yatendra Sharma and Mr. Vinod Khanna, Advocates for the petitioner.
Vs.
$ M/s MCM Services Private Limited .....Respondent
^ Through :Nemo.
CORAM :-
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KUMAR
JUDGMENT

1. Whether reporters of Local papers may YES be allowed to see the judgment?

2. To be referred to the reporter or not ? NO

3. Whether the judgment should be reported NO in the Digest? ANIL KUMAR, J.(Oral)

1. This is a petition under Section 11(6) of the Arbitration & Conciliation Act, 1996 for the appointment of an arbitrator in terms of arbitration agreement between the parties as disputes have arisen between them.

2. The notice of the petition was issued to the respondent, however, nobody has appeared on behalf of the respondent nor any reply has been filed consequently the respondent is proceeded exparte. 2007:DHC:1567

3. The petitioner is a company incorporated under the Companies Act, 1956 and is engaged in the business of civil construction works and providing equipments for execution of civil work on hire basis. The present petition has been filed by Mr. Rajesh Bagga, Director of the petitioner company, who has been authorized by a company resolution dated 1st March, 2007 to institute the petition.

4. The respondent is also a company incorporated under the Companies Act, 1956 and is engaged in the business of civil works. The petitioner contended that an agreement dated 15th December, 2004 was entered into by the petitioner and the respondent for the carrying out civil work of excavation in respect of KolDam Hydroelectric Power Project, Package 1 in Himachal Pradesh which work order was given by the respondent to the petitioner and that scope of work entrusted on the petitioner was contained in clause 6 of the work order/award dated 15th December, 2004. Thereafter disputes in respect to payment of dues to the petitioner arose and a request was made by the petitioner to the respondent to settle the dues by its letter dated 6th May, 2005, however the same was not replied and the dues of the petitioner were not cleared.

5. In the facts and circumstances, the petitioner was constrained to invoke the arbitration clause contained in clause 13 of the work order dated 15th December, 2004 and issued a notice dated 25th January, 2007 to the respondent demanding appointment of an arbitrator in terms of arbitration clause to adjudicate the disputes between the parties. The respondent in their reply dated 7th February, 2007, instead of appointing an arbitrator to adjudicate the disputes, raised a counter claim of Rs.12,62,712/- allegedly claiming it to be due and recoverable from the petitioner. The petitioner has also detailed a claim of Rs.21,81,458.88/- in para 14 of the petition which is due to the petitioner from the respondent under different heads including cost, expenses and damages.

6. Consequently disputes have arisen between the parties. There is an arbitration agreement between the parties for adjudication of the disputes by an arbitrator in terms of clause 13 of the work order dated 15th December, 2004. Clause 13 of the work order containing the arbitration agreement is as under:-

“13. Any dispute with regard to performance, shall be mutually settled by an authorized Director of both the parties, within four weeks. Unsettled disputes will be settled at per Indian Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 and its amendments. The disputes will be the subject to the jurisdiction of the Delhi courts.”

7. The petitioner has, therefore, filed the present petition. Despite service of the notice, no one has appeared on behalf of respondent nor has any reply been filed and in any case the respondents have failed to appoint an the arbitrator within 30 days from the receipt of the legal notice dated 25th January, 2007 invoking the arbitration agreement and even before filing the present petition. In the circumstances, the plea of the petitioner that there is an arbitration agreement in terms of clause 13 cannot be refuted. Therefore, it will be just and appropriate to appoint an arbitrator to adjudicate disputes between the parties.

8. A learned Single Judge in Haryana Telecom Ltd. v. Union of India & Anr., 112 (2004) DLT 339=2004 (3) RAJ 147, had held that if the respondent fails to appoint an Arbitrator within the stipulated time of 30 days of the notice, and before filing of the petition under Section 11 of the Act, it is for the Court to appoint an Arbitrator. A Division Bench of this Court in Delkon (India) Pvt. Ltd. v. G.M., Bharat Heavy Electricals Ltd., 120 (2005) DLT 542 (DB), relying on Datar Switchgears Ltd Vs Tata Finance Ltd has held in para 4 is as under:

“4. We have given our careful consideration to the arguments advanced by learned Counsel for both the parties. In view of the law laid down in the case of Datar Switchgears Ltd. v. Tata Finance Ltd. & Anr., IV (2000) CLT 191 (SC)=VII (2000) SLT 543=JT 2000 (Suppl. 2) SC 226 it is no more res integra that the vacancy can be supplied by a party pursuant to the arbitration agreement even after thirty days of the receipt of the notice. However, once a party approaches the Court and files a petition for appointment by the designated authority of the Chief Justice of that Court under Section 11(6) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, the right to supply vacancy by the opposite party is extinguished. If that right stood extinguished on filing of the petition under Section 11(6) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, in September 1998 the appointment of an Arbitrator on 3rd May, 1999 could not be made, therefore in our view, the order passed by the learned Single Judge on 7th May, 1999 suffers from patent illegality. Therefore, the submission of the respondent that the petitioner had appeared before the Arbitrator and the application of the petitioner raising preliminary objections is pending adjudication which inter alia challenges the jurisdiction of the Arbitrator to decide the dispute is of no consequence as from the order reproduced above it was pursuant to the directions passed by the learned Single Judge that the parties were directed to appear before the Arbitrator. The petitioner had no other option but to appear before the Arbitrator and after appearing before the Arbitrator the petitioner has not submitted to the jurisdiction of the Arbitrator, rather has at first opportunity taken the objection that the Arbitrator had no jurisdiction to proceed with the matter.
9. In Union of India v. M/s. R.R. Industries, 120 (2005) DLT 572 (DB) also it was held that once a party does not supply the vacancy or fails to supply the vacancy before filing of a petition under Section 11(6) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, such a party forfeits the right to supply the vacancy in terms of the arbitration clause and what remains is only the arbitration clause, i.e. the dispute has to be resolved under the mechanism of alternative dispute redressal scheme but no right survives to the respondent to supply the named Arbitrator, if any, in the arbitration clause. Thus the arbitrator was to be appointed before the filing of the petition and since no arbitrator has been appointed by the respondent consequently, the respondent has lost its right to appoint the arbitrator in terms of clause 13 of the arbitration agreement.
10. Considering the facts and circumstances, I appoint Sh.B.L.Garg (Retd.) Additional District Judge, Delhi, r/o.A/9, Ganpati Apartments, 6 Alipur Road, Civil Lines, Delhi (Mobile No.9810827815) as an arbitrator to adjudicate all the disputes between the parties. The fees of the arbitrator shall be Rs.10,000/- per hearing subject to a maximum of Rs.[1] lakh payable by the petitioner in the first instance. The parties shall appear before the learned arbitrator on 17th December, 2007 at 4.30 PM. A copy of this order be sent to the learned arbitrator forthwith. The parties shall also produce a copy of this order before the arbitrator on the said date. Copies of this order be given dasti to the parties. December 05, 2007 ANIL KUMAR, J. 'k'