Dilshad Colony Residents Welfare Assn. v. Lt. Governor G.N.C.T. of Delhi & Ors.

Delhi High Court · 05 Dec 2007 · 2007:DHC:1572-DB
T.S. Thakur; Veena Birbal
W.P.(C) 7988/2007
2007:DHC:1572-DB
administrative appeal_allowed Significant

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court directed the revocation or relocation of a liquor vend licence granted in violation of statutory rules in a residential area near schools, emphasizing protection of residents' rights and lawful administrative action.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
W.P.(C) 7988/2007
DILSHAD COLONY RESIDENTS WELFARE ASSN. ..... Petitioner
Through : Mr. K.K. Rai, Sr. Adv. with Ms. Megha Mishra, Ms. Lakshmi Ramachandran, Mr. Sanjiv Kumar, Mr. Anil Kumar, Advocates
VERSUS
LT.GOVERNOR G.N.C.T. OF DELHI & ORS. ..... Respondents
Through : Ms. Zubeda Begum, Adv. for R-1 to 3, 5
Ms. Avnish Ahlawat, Ms. Nidhi Gupta, Advs. for respondent No.4
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE T.S. THAKUR
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE VEENA BIRBAL
JUDGMENT

1. Whether reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Not Necessary

2. To be referred to the Reporter or not? Not Necessary

3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest? Not Necessary O R D E R % 05.12.2007 Per Thakur, J (oral) This petition has been filed in public interest. It seeks a mandamus directing respondents No.1 and 4 to cancel the licence of the liquor vend running from premises D-51, Dilshad Colony, Delhi – 110095 with a further direction to them not to open any liquor shop in the residential area of the locality in proximity to Blocks A, B, D & E of the said colony. A prayer for taking appropriate action against those who have established the liquor vend and for payment of compensation to the petitioner association who represents 2200 flat owners in the locality has also been made.

2. The petitioner society represents the residents of A, B, D & E residential blocks of Dilshad Colony. According to the averments made in the petition, the petitioner is a representative body of nearly 10,000 persons including women and school going children residing in the said colony. 2007:DHC:1572-DB 21 of the Constitution as also the Punjab Excise Act and the rules regulating the grant of licences for sale of liquor, in particular contrary to Rule 33 of Delhi Liquor Licences Rules, 1976, the respondents have opened a liquor vend at D-51, Dilshad Colony. This vend is according to the petitioner, not only against the spirit of the statute and the rules that are framed by the competent authority but also causes grave inconvenience and harassment to the residents of the colony. The petition refers to the complaints that have been lodged by the residents of the area complaining misbehaviour by those who consume liquor sold at the vend generally and the nuisance and harassment caused to the women living in that locality in particular. The petition also refers to the presence of a MCD Primary School at a distance of just about 10 yards from the liquor vend and other educational centres like coaching centres in the neighborhood where children from the locality go to study. The petition complains that despite repeated representations made to the authorities by the residents of the colony, nothing fruitful has been done to close down or shift the vend from its present location leaving no option for the petitioners except to approach this court in public interest. The petition also relies upon the recommendations made by the Lokayukta, Government of NCT of Delhi against the running of the liquor vend from its present location. A copy of the Lokayukta report on the subject has also been enclosed with the petition. Reference has also been made to the news items and articles appearing in the Press relating to the continuance of the liquor vend.

3. The respondents have filed a Counter affidavit in which it is inter alia stated that the continuance of the vend at its present location does not violate any statutory provision or any rule framed under the Excise Act. It refutes the allegation that the vend is located near any educational question was inspected by the Site Selection Committee who reported that the present location was ideal for running the vend as it had shops in its vicinity. The counter affidavit also draws support from the observation made by the Chief Secretary on the report submitted by the Lokayukta. It was, according to the respondents, the suitability of the site and not the political position of the MLA or the Councilor who owns the premises that the vend was opened at its present location.

4. We have heard learned counsel for the parties at some length and perused the record. The continuance of the vend at its present location, it appears to be giving rise to considerable criticism and dissatisfaction among the residents in the locality who have been representing to the authorities for its closure apart from approaching the newspapers to ventilate their grievance. The Lokayukta has similarly been approached by the aggrieved residents who appears to have gone into the entire issue and come to the conclusion that the opening of the vend in question smacked of political influence and extraneous considerations. This is evident from the following passage appearing in the report made by the Lokayukta: “12. The undisputed fact is that a number of families live in the residential buildings D-51 and D-52. The liqour vend has been opened in the ground floor of property No. D-51. Now if a liquor vend is to remain open in the ground floor upto 10PM in the summer and upto 9 pm in the winter, one can well imagine the plight and agony of the residents of property No. D-51 and D-52 and residents of the adjoining buildings.

13.

14. The Lokayukta is constrained to observe that the files smell of political influence and/or extraneous considerations in the grant of liquor vend licence for opening of liquor vend at premises D-51, Dilshad Colony, Delhi. The licence has been issued in violation of the Delhi Liquor License Rules, 1976 and the Notification dated 3rd May, 1995 issued by the Lt. Governor. The property is purchased on 30th August, 2001. The Sale Deed describes in unmistaken terms the property to be a 'dwelling unit' and the plot of land only to be used for the property as a shop, obtained the commercial electricity licence, obtained NOC from the MLA for opening liquor vend and in the application form the proposed premises is stated to be in “approved commercial complex”. In spite of the fact that the Sale Deed is on record, the Excise Department and the DSCSC shut their eyes to the description of the property given in the Sale Deed. The Rent Agreement clearly shows a profit sharing arrangement and the landlord has to be paid 12.5% of the gross profit. The inspection team declared the shop to be fit for grant of L-2 licence on the ground that the area where the shop is located has become commercial by 'usage'. The Inspection Team completely ignored the fact that properties D-51 are totally residential apartments and all other buildings situated in that locality are residential. The Excise Collector and the Managing Director, DSCSC completely ignored the importance of the provisions of Rule 33(8) of Delhi Liquor License Rules, 1976 and the Notification dated May 3, 1995 issued by the Lt. Governor. The opening and closing hours of the liquor vend fixed in the licence also are shocking. The convenience of the residents has been totally ignored. The laws of the land are meant to be obeyed and enforced and not disobeyed and flouted.”

5. The Lokayukta has accordingly recommended that the licence granted opening of the IMFL/Beer vend at D-51, Dilshad Colony be set aside and revoked. The recommendations read as under: “RECOMMENDATIONS

15. On the facts and in the circumstances discussed above, I would recommend to the Hon'ble Lt. Governor that the licence granted for opening of IMFL/Beer vend at D-51, Dilshad Colony, Delhi be immediately quashed.”

6. In the light of the above recommendations and also keeping in view the fact that liquor vend in question is surrounded by multi-storeyed residential flats, the grievance made by the petitioner association who has espoused the cause of the residents does not appear to be entirely misconceived. The continuance of a liqour vend in a thickly populated area which is primarily and predominantly residential in character is bound to create difficulties for the residents especially when they have school and college going children. The presence of educational institutions in the the presence of a vend including the harassment and inconvenience which the residents are likely to face by reason of people making use of the facility at times misbehaving with the residents makes the present an excellent case for intervention.

7. Ms. Zubeda Begum, learned counsel for the respondent was, in the above background, candid enough to say that the respondents can, if so directed by the Court, look for an alternate location to which the vend can be shifted. She submitted that since the vend is a very lucrative source of revenue for the State and is doing good business and since the relocation of the same is likely to involve hiring of another building, the respondents could be given time till 30th March, 2008 to shut down and/or relocate the vend to some other premises which complies with the requirement of the Act and the Rules.

8. In the result, we allow this petition but only in part and to the extent that the respondents shall shut down and/or relocate the vend as expeditiously as possible but not later than 31st March, 2008.

9. No costs. T.S. THAKUR,J VEENA BIRBAL, J DECEMBER 05, 2007 pk