Full Text
Date of Decision: December 6th , 2007 AA No.529/2006
# M/s UP State Bridge Corporation ......Petitioner
! Through: Mr.Vivekanand, Advocate.
Vs.
$ Delhi Development Authority and Anr .....Respondents
^ Through : Mr.Bhupesh Narula, Advocate.
JUDGMENT
1. Whether reporters of Local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
2. To be referred to the reporter or not ?
3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest? ANIL KUMAR, J.(Oral)
1. This is a petition under Section 11(6) of the Arbitration & Conciliation Act, 1996 for the appointment of an arbitrator in terms of arbitration agreement between the parties as the disputes have arisen.
2. The petitioner is a public sector undertaking of the government of Uttar Pradesh and is engaged in the work of the construction of Bridges. Sh.Arun Kumar, Deputy Project Manager of the petitioner, AA 529 of 2006 2007:DHC:1579 has signed, verified and instituted the petition who is duly authorized.
3. The petitioner contended that the respondents invited tender for execution of works as detailed under para (iii) of the petition which are as under:a) Construction of clover leaf to Sarita Vihar flyover at the intersection of NH-2 and road no. A. b) Construction of clover leaf to Noida more flyover (under construction at inter section of NH -24 NPOIDA more on Delhi side, c) Construction of culvert on slip road on Delhi side of NOIDA more Flyover, d) Widening of existing culvert on NH-24 near NOIDA More Flyover.
4. Pursuant to the notice inviting tender, the petitioner submitted the tenders for the aforesaid works which was accepted and the works were awarded to the petitioner by the respondents by letter dated the 24th February, 2003 bearing number F. 6(28) EE/FD-4/DDA/2002 – 2003 issued by the Executive Engineer flyover division no. 4, DDA on behalf of the respondents for Rs. 6, 33, 00, 000/-. The stipulated date for commencement and completion of all the works was on 10th March 2003 and 9th April, 2004 respectively. The petitioner contended that despite all the efforts made by the petitioner to execute and complete the work within the stipulated time, the work could not be completed within the stipulated time and was prolonged much beyond the stipulated period on account of persistent delays, faults, failures and breaches of contract, attributable wholly to the respondents as a result of which huge losses were incurred by the petitioner which the respondents were liable to make good. The completion of work at Noida More and at Sarita Vihar were recorded as on 31st March, 2005 and 30th June, 2005 respectively.
5. Thereafter the respondents issued show cause notice to the petitioner in terms of letters dated 13th October, 2005 and 14th October, 2005 under clause 2 of the contract. Show cause notices were replied by the petitioner on 25th October, 2005 refuting the allegations made therein. Subsequently, a penalty of Rs.20,000/- and Rs.50, 000/- was imposed on the petitioner on account of delay in completion of work at the Sarita Vihar and Noida More site respectively which was communicated to the petitioner by respondents letters dated 10th November, 2005 and 30th November,
2005. The imposition of penalty by the respondents was refuted by the petitioner in its letter dated 31st December, 2005 on the ground that the delay was occasioned on account of lapses on the part of the respondents due to which huge losses were suffered by the petitioner. Thereafter final bills were raised by the petitioner, however, the respondents declined to make payment against the final bills despite repeated requests made by the petitioner for release of payment.
6. Since no payment was forthcoming and as the claims of the petitioner were declined by the subordinate officer of the respondent, therefore, the petitioner was constrained to invoke the arbitration clause and issued a letter dated 27th October, 2006 addressed to the respondent no.2, who is the competent authority in terms of the arbitration clause 25, and demanded appointment of an arbitrator in terms of arbitration agreement to adjudicate the claims of the petitioner. By a letter dated 1st December, 2006, the respondents appointed Shri Pramod Kumar, SE of DDA as an arbitrator, however, the copy of the letter appointing an arbitrator was not sent to the petitioner. The Arbitrator appointed by the respondent declined to be an arbitrator and intimated about it by his letter date 5th December,
2006. Arbitrator appointed declined to be an Arbitrator on account of having dealt with/inspected all the works in question in the capacity of the Executive Engineer, East Zone.
7. As the petitioner did not know about the appointment of arbitrator by the respondent and the appointed arbitrator declining to act as an arbitrator, consequently, the petitioner has filed the present petition for appointment of an independent and impartial arbitrator by this Court on the ground that the disputes and claims as raised by the petitioner are to be decided in accordance with Arbitration agreement and the respondents have failed to appoint an arbitrator within thirty days of demand being made for the appointment of the arbitrator.
8. Till the filing of the petition, the respondents did not appoint an arbitrator, therefore, notice was issued to the respondents. A reply has been filed by the respondents objecting to the appointment of an arbitrator by the Court on the ground that on 27th October, 2006 the petitioner applied for appointment of an arbitrator and on 22nd November, 2006, Sh. Pramod Kumar, was appointed as an arbitrator by the respondent. Appointment of arbitrator was communicated to the Arbitrator by respondents by letter dated 1st December, 2006 which was dispatched to the petitioner on 4th December, 2006 which is before the date of filing of the petition. The respondent contended that Sh.Pramod Kumar did not enter upon the reference and gave his resignation on 5th December, 2006 and that within 30 days of the date of resignation of Sh. Pramod Kumar, the respondent has appointed Sh.S.S.Jain, SE(Arbn)-1 as a sole arbitrator in place of Sh.Pramod Kumar by letter dated 21st December, 2006 bearing number F4(62)Arbn/FD-4/06/DDA/417 and a copy of the same was sent to the petitioner as well. The respondent has therefore prayed for dismissal of the petition on the ground that there is no cause of action for instituting the petition as an arbitrator has already been appointed by the EM /DDA which is the appointing authority, within 30 days from the date of resignation of Sh. Pramod Kumar.
9. I have heard the counsel for the parties. The issue which needs adjudication is whether an arbitrator was appointed by the respondent within thirty days of the demand being made by the petitioner for appointment of arbitrator for adjudication of disputes in terms of arbitration agreement or before the filing of the present petition. The petition was filed on 18th December, 2006 and the notice on the petition was issued on 20th December, 2006.
10. There is an arbitration agreement between the parties for adjudication of the disputes by an arbitrator in terms of clause 25 of the agreement which has not been disputed by the parties. Clause 25 of the agreement containing the arbitration agreement is as under:- “Clause 25: Settlement of Disputes and Arbitration Except where otherwise provided in the contract all questions and disputes relating to the meaning of the specifications designs, drawings and instructions hereinbefore mentioned and as to the quality of workmanship or materials as used on the work or as to any other question, claim, right, matter or thing whatsoever in any way arising out of or relating to the contract designs, drawings, specifications, estimates instructions orders or these conditions or otherwise concerning the works or the execution or failure to execute the same whether arising during the progress of the work or after the cancellation, termination completion or abandonment thereof shall be dealt with as mentioned hereinafter: i) If the contractor considers any work demanded of him to be outside the requirement of the contract, or disputes any drawings, record or decision given in writing by the Engineer in charge on any matter in connection with or arising out of the contract of carrying out of the work, to be unacceptable, he shall promptly within 15 days request the Superintending Engineer in writing for written instructions or decision. Thereupon, the Superintending engineer shall give his written instructions or decision within a period of one month from the receipt of contractor’s letter. If the Superintending Engineer/Project Manager fails to give his instructions or decision in writing within the aforesaid period or if the contractor is dissatisfied with the instructions or decision of the Superintending Engineer/Project Manager, the contractor may within 15 days of the receipt of Superintending Engineer/Project Manager’s decision appeal to the Engineer Member who shall accord an opportunity to the contractor to be heard. If the later so desires and to offer evidence in support of his appeal. The Engineer Member shall give his decision within 30 days of receipt of contractor’s appeal. If the contractor is dissatisfied with this decision, the contractor shall within a period of 30 days from receipt of the decision, give notice to the Engineer Member for appointment of arbitrator failing which the said decision shall be final binding and conclusive and not referable to adjudication by the arbitrator. ii). Except where the decision has become final, binding and conclusive in terms of sub Para (i) above disputes or differences shall be referred for adjudication through arbitration a sole arbitrator appointed by the Engineer member, DDA. If the arbitrator so appointed is unable or unwilling to act or resign his appointment or vacates his office due to any reason whatsoever shall be appointed in the manner aforesaid. Such personal shall be entitled to proceed with the reference from the stage at which it was left by his predecessor. It is a term of this contract that the party invoking arbitration shall give a list of disputes with amounts claimed in respect of each such dispute along with the notice for appointment of arbitrator and giving reference to the rejection by the chief engineer of the appeal. It is also a term of this contract that no person other than a person appointed by Engineer member, DDA as aforesaid should act as arbitrator and if for any reason that is not possible, the matter shall not be referred to arbitration at all. It is also a term of this contract that if the contractor does not make any demand for appointment of arbitrator in respect of any claims in writing as aforesaid within 120 days of receiving the intimation from the Engineer in charge that the final bill is ready for payment, the claim of the contractor shall be deemed to have been waived and absolutely barred and Government shall be discharged and released of all liabilities under the contract in respect of these claims. The arbitration shall be conducted in accordance with the provisions of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act,1996 (26 of 1996) or any statutory modification or re-enactment thereof and the rules made thereunder and for the time being in force shall apply to the arbitration proceedings under this clause It is also a term of this contract that the arbitrator shall adjudicate on only such disputes as are referred to him by the appointing authority and give separate award against each dispute and claim referred to him and in all cases where the total amount of the claims by any party exceeds Rs. 1,00,000/- the arbitrator shall give reasons for the award. It is also a term of the contract that if any fees are payable to the arbitrator these shall be paid equally by both the parties. It is also a term of the contract that the arbitrator shall be deemed to have entered on the reference on the date he issues notice to both the parties calling them to submit their statement of claims and counter statement of claims. The venue of the arbitration shall be such place as may be fixed by the arbitrator in his sole discretion. The fees, if any, of the arbitration shall, if required to be paid before the award is made and published, be paid half and half by each of the parties. The cost of the reference and of the award (including the fees, if any, of the Arbitrator) shall be in the discretion of the arbitrator who made direct to any by whom and in what manner, such cost or any part thereof shall be paid and fix or settle the amount of cost to be so paid. It is also a term of the contract that wherever and whenever decision of Superintending Engineer/Project Manager is final in terms of the contract, would not be open to arbitration.”
11. In terms of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 an arbitrator is to be appointed within 30 days from the receipt of the notice invoking the arbitration clause or before filing the present petition. Sh.Pramod Kumar was appointed as an arbitrator within 30 days of the issuance of notice dated 27th October, 2006 invoking the arbitration clause by the petitioner. If the Arbitrator was appointed by the respondents on 22nd November, 2006 who was intimated by letter dated 1st December, 2006 which was not communicated to the petitioner and if such an appointment is valid then in case of unwillingness of the Arbitrator to act on account of the Arbitrator having dealt with the matter earlier, appointment of another arbitrator within thirty days when the arbitrator showed his unwillingness to act as an arbitrator, will be valid and the petitioner will not be entitled for any relief is to be considered in this petition.
12. If the appointment of Shri Pramod Kumar was valid, then on Arbitrator showing his unwillingness to act as an arbitrator, the respondents do not get right to appoint another arbitrator, rather the vacancy which had occurred on account of appointed arbitrator not agreeing to act as an arbitrator, should have been filled under Section 15 (2) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. For filling the vacancy which had occurred under section 15 of the Act, the respondents should have given notice to the petitioner, which was not done, rather present petition was filed before the vacancy could be filled by the respondents by appointing Shri S.S.Jain as an arbitrator. The arbitration agreement between the parties also contemplates that on account of Arbitrator appointed being unable or unwilling to act or resign the subsequent Arbitrator shall be entitled to proceed form the stage at which it was left by his predecessor. The petitioner was intimated about the substituted Arbitrator only after the petition under Section 11(6) of the Arbitration & Conciliation Act, 1996 was filed by the petitioner on 18th December, 2006 in which the notice was issued to the respondent on 20th December, 2006 and a substituted Arbitrator was appointed only on 21st December, 2006. The Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 contemplates appointment of an arbitrator and not arbitrator entering upon reference. If an arbitrator is validly appointed who has not issued notice to the parties to appear before him and if such an arbitrator decides not to act as an arbitrator, it will create a vacancy as contemplated under section 15 (1)(a) of the Act which can be filled under section 15(2) of the Act. Section 15 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 is as under:-
13. Learned counsel for the petitioner, in the facts and circumstances, contends that since the vacancy had to be filled by a substituted Arbitrator, therefore, without prejudice to rights and contentions of the petitioner, the Arbitrator already appointed by the respondent be appointed as an Arbitrator and the present petition be treated as a petition under Section 15(2) of the Arbitration & Conciliation Act, 1996 for appointment of a substituted Arbitrator in place of earlier Arbitrator who showed his unwillingness to act as an Arbitrator.
14. In the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case, therefore, Shri S.S. Jain, SE, (Arbitration-I) is appointed as a substituted Arbitrator by this Court who will adjudicate all the disputes between the parties and his appointment shall not be by his designation. The present petition in terms hereof is disposed of. December 6th, 2007 ANIL KUMAR J. 'sdp'