Sh. Ram Avtar v. Sh. Davinder Singh & Ors.

Delhi High Court · 26 Nov 2007 · 2007:DHC:1509
Kailash Gambhir
MAC. APP. No.19/2006
2007:DHC:1509
civil appeal_allowed Significant

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court enhanced compensation for permanent disability and pain and suffering in a motor accident claim, remanded medical expenses for reconsideration, and directed interest on the enhanced amount.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
MAC. APP. No.19/2006
JUDGMENT
delivered on: November 26,2007 Sh.Ram Avtar ..... Appellant.
Through: Mr.O.P. Mannie, Advocate.
versus
Sh. Davinder Singh & Ors. ..... Respondents
Through: Ms.Suman Bagga, Advocate for respondent No.3.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE KAILASH GAMBHIR,

1. Whether the Reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes

2. To be referred to Reporter or not? Yes

3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest? Yes KAILASH GAMBHIR, J. Oral: * By way of this appeal, the appellant seeks to challenge the impugned award on the ground that the same is quite on the lower side. The appellant has claimed enhancement of compensation. The main grievance of the appellant is that the Tribunal has not taken into consideration the payment of 2007:DHC:1509 Rs.33,000/- towards the expenses incurred by the appellant for his medical treatment after his discharge from the hospital. The second grievance of the appellant is that the Tribunal has granted a lumpsum amount of Rs.[1] lakh towards disability without taking into consideration the loss to the appellant in his earning capacity due to the kind of permanent disablement suffered by him. The third grievance of the appellant is that a meagre amount of Rs.20,000/- has been granted towards pain and sufferings. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and have perused the records. Ms.Suman Bagga, counsel appearing for the respondent has placed reliance on the recent judgment of the Supreme Court reported in 2007 (12) Scale 792, Sunil Kuamr Vs. Ram Singh Gaud to support her argument that in a case of permanent disablement of 45%, the Apex Court has granted interest @ 6% p.a. on the enhanced amount as well as deduced 1/3rd towards miscellaneous expenses. Counsel for the respondent also contends that no future prospects can be considered in the present case as no evidence to this effect was led by the appellant. The Tribunal has taken the income of the appellant at Rs.3,000/- p.m. by taking aid of the Minimum Wages Act. Although the appellant has placed salary certificate showing his income as Rs.4,500/- per month but the Tribunal has not believed the said certificate as no witness from the company where the appellant was stated to be working was summoned to prove the same. The income of the appellant was thus taken at Rs.3,000/p.m. The said wages of Rs.3,000/- are not even as per the Minimum Wages Act as the appellant on the relevant date of accident was matriculate and he has proved his said qualification before the Tribunal vide Ex.PW.1/228. Once the appellant was possessing the said qualification on the date of accident and he was working as an Electrician, therefore, at least the income applicable to a matriculate under the Minimum Wages Act could be taken into consideration. The income of matriculate under the Minimum Wages Act on the relevant date was Rs.3231.90 and making it a round figure, the same is taken as Rs.3,200/-. The multiplier of 16 is applicable under the IInd Schedule of the Motor Vehicles Act as on the date of accident, the appellant was of 40 years of age. This Court has already taken a view that minimum wages get doubled in a period of 10 years and applying the same yardstick and taking an average of both the incomes, the monthly loss of the appellant for suffering 66% disability would come to Rs.4,800/- per month and deducting 1/3rd towards miscellaneous expenses, the net loss would come to Rs.3,200/- and applying multiplier of 16, the total loss would be about Rs.4,05,504/-. The Tribunal has granted a sum of Rs.[1] lakh in all towards the permanent disability and the same is enhanced from Rs.[1] lakh to Rs.[2] lakh. As regards pain and suffering, I find myself in agreement with counsel for the appellant that a meagre amount of Rs.20,000/- has been allowed. The appellant admittedly suffers 66% disability in relation to its left arm which has practically rendered himself totally disfunctional so far as his job of electrician is concerned. Rs.20,000/- would be an inadequate amount towards pain and sufferings and the same is accordingly enhanced to Rs.30,000. As regards, the contention of counsel for the appellant that the Tribunal has not taken into consideration medical bills placed and proved on record by the appellant, the matter is remanded back to the Tribunal. If the said bills have been placed and proved on record and the same have not been already included in the amount of Rs.2,93,000/- as granted by the Tribunal, then the same may be taken into consideration for paying the amount incurred by the appellant towards purchase of medicines and medical treatment after his discharge from the hospital. As regards, the contention of counsel for the respondent that the interest of 6% has been granted by the Supreme Court, perusal of the judgment shows that the sum is on the enhanced amount of compensation. The Tribunal has already awarded interest @ 9% on the award amount from the date of filing of the petition till realisation. The said amount has already been paid to the appellant and, therefore, this Court is not inclined to interfere on the said rate of interest. However, the respondent shall pay interest @ 6% on the enhanced amount of compensation from the date of filing of the petition till realisation. With these directions, the appeal stands disposed of. Parties to appear before the Tribunal on 09.01.2008. November 26, 2007 KAILASH GAMBHIR, J. ga