Full Text
M/S. VINDHYA TELELINKS LTD. ..... Plaintiff
Through Mr. Vishnu Mehra, Advocate
Through
JUDGMENT
1. Whether reports of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes.
2. To be referred to the Reporter or not? Yes.
3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest? Yes. MR.
JUSTICE S. RAVINDRA BHAT
1. This is a proceeding questioning an arbitration award, under Section 30 of the Arbitration Act, 1940 (hereafter “the Act”). The case appeared in the list of Final matters, for regular hearing by the court. When it was taken up for hearing, none appeared on behalf of the objector, Mahanagar Telephone Nigam Ltd (hereafter called “MTNL”). The case was heard, and shown in the category of “part heard” matters on the next date of hearing, i.e 4-1-2008. On that day CS(OS) 625A/1996 1 of 13 2008:DHC:63 too, there was no appearance on behalf of MTNL. Hearing of the suit was, therefore, completed; the matter was reserved for orders.
2. The claimant in arbitration, ie. Vindhya Telelinks Ltd (hereafter referred to as “the claimant”) raised disputes and claimed that the MTNL had unjustifiably withheld amounts payable to it, in terms of an agreement. The reasons for withholding those sums of money were that MTNL alleged that the claimant short supplied quantities of cables. As the agreement contained an arbitration clause, the claimant sought recourse to it; a sole arbitrator was appointed by the MTNL. In the statement of claim, a sum of Rs.6,20,000/- was sought towards damages; the claimant also sought for award of interest.
3. In the arbitration proceedings, parties led extensive documentary evidence; they also relied on oral testimony of their witnesses. The arbitrator held that the claimant was entitled to the sum of Rs.6,20,000/- with interest @ 19% p.a.; worked out to Rs. 1,86,000/- from 7-7-1993 to 9-1-1996.
4. It is alleged by the MTNL that the award has to be set aside, as it is an unreasoned one. It is alleged that according to the terms of the contract between the parties, MTNL had the right to reject the goods within a specified period after their supply. Reliance CS(OS) 625A/1996 2 of 13 has been placed on clauses 15, 16 and 21 of the agreement. It is alleged that the materials on record disclose that there was short supply and the cables were received provisionally, without prejudice to the right of the objector MTNL to reject them for not complying with the agreed terms. The MTNL has placed reliance on two joint inspection reports to contend that the claimant did not dispute shortage in supply of cables. It is alleged, in the objections that according to a circular governing MTNL, issued on 11-101984, drums containing cables whose seals were undamaged were not required to be opened; at the time of supply, they could be opened later. If any defect or deficiency were found at that stage, the MTNL’s right to object to the supplier was left intact and preserved.
5. MTNL relies upon the endorsements issued by it, while receiving the goods, to say that the right to conduct a quality check at a later stage, was reserved. The advertence to quality had to be understood in the context; it included shortfall in quantities. It is alleged that clause 15 provided for issuance of “taking over” certificate (of the consignment). Ten percent of the balance consideration of the goods were payable only after that document was issued; in this case, however, the claimant pressed the MTNL to issue it, even without actual verification. As this was done, the MTNL could not be made to suffer a disadvantage for short supply discovered CS(OS) 625A/1996 3 of 13 later. The issue of various documents even leading to full payment did not absolve the claimant of its obligations to supply the goods according to the terms of contract. They violated these. In overlooking these aspects, and coming to contrary conclusions, the arbitrator misconducted himself, rendering the award liable to be set aside. Reliance is placed on clause 16.[1] of the contract to say that it contains a warranty that the contractor (claimant) agreed to supply the goods free from all defects; it should be responsible for any defects in hardware or software which may develop later. This condition discloses that the obligations of the contractor did not cease with supply or the payment of all amounts.
6. It is alleged that the findings by the arbitrator that actual lengths of each drum were measured and certified by the Quality Assurance unit is erroneous. The unit was not entitled to check the quantities supplied. According to MTNL the claimant’s witness did not dispute that inspection of the unwound cables was done by a unit, not empowered to do so. Therefore, the MTNL could not be prejudiced if upon actual inspection, at a later date, the quantities were found to be short; they constituted actionable deficiency in quality, entitling it to recover the amounts from other amounts payable to the claimant. It is alleged that the property is deemed to have passed to the consignee only in terms of the contract; in this case, the title to the goods CS(OS) 625A/1996 4 of 13 therefore passed only after inspection. It is alleged that this aspect was overlooked by the arbitrator; the award is therefore vitiated and liable to be set aside. The award of interest too has been attacked; the MTNL avers, in addition that the 10% amount could have been retained by it to ensure performance. It is also alleged that the arbitrator erred in not awarding the counter claim preferred by MTNL, towards the excess payments illegally recovered by the claimant, viz. Rs. 3,87,713/- (after adjusting the sum of Rs.6,20,000/from Rs.10,07,713/- claimed as payable by the claimant).
7. The claimant has contested the objections of MTNL. It alleges that the award cannot be challenged as a non-speaking one, because it is based on evidence. The MTNL had nominated its arbitrator, who is an expert and a high ranking retired official. It is alleged that the findings of fact do not show any perversity or misconduct of the magnitude which would empower a court to interfere with the award. The claimant alleges that the MTNL obtained delivery of the goods at all material times and issued “taking over” certificates. In these circumstances it could not have disputed the quantities after four to six months. The claimant has also averred that the award does not disclose any misconduct by the arbitrator requiring it to be set aside. The claimant also alleges that the receipt of goods was not subject to any further or future verification; its CS(OS) 625A/1996 5 of 13 version is that after release of 90% of payment, the MTNL issued Bill Copy Payable Challan along with Goods Receipt Note (GRN) which constituted in form and substance the “take over certificate” under Clause 15. The 10% balance payment was premised on this event.
8. The claimant contests that MTNL could have sought to recover amounts, including the 10% balance, after releasing payments. It is alleged that the MTNL did not intimate about any shortage in quantities supplied; if indeed that were the position, the balance payment would have been withheld.
9. During the hearing, Mr. Vishnu Mehra, learned counsel for the claimant relied on the award and the original records. These show that the arbitrator was unimpressed with the assertion of MTNL that the claimant had sought and was given excess unjustified payments. The arbitrator noticed that the counter claims for these amounts were made only after the reference was sought; at no point did the MTNL ever make a claim or raise dispute in this regard from the claimant. Counsel contended that there was no material to support the objection that the TOC (taking over certificate) was issued without reference to the exact quantities; the MTNL could not substantiate its plea that such documents were issued to the claimant, at its asking. Counsel also urged that the internal circulars of MTNL could not have been binding on the contractor; they could have been referred to only CS(OS) 625A/1996 6 of 13 if incorporated in the contract, or referred to in it. It was also urged that once the cables were supplied, as they admittedly were, the MTNL had the option of recording its objections or reservations at that time; if these deficiencies were not made good, it could withhold the balance amounts. However, at every stage, the goods were accepted and the relevant certificates issued. In these circumstances, after having taken custody of the contracted goods, disputes about shortfall in the quantities could not have been raised. The reliance on clause 16.[1] it was contended, was in apposite as it referred only to quality; during the evidence, the witness for MTNL admitted that there was no condition dealing with quantities.
10. The extent and scope of a court’s power interfere with an arbitration award, under the Act is well settled. From a long line of decisions, starting with Union of India –vs- A.L. Ralia Ram AIR 1963 SC 1685 down to the recent decision in Food Corporation of India –vs- Chandu Construction 2007 (4) SCC 697, it has been consistently held that misconduct does not merely point to moral lapse or perversity in findings, but also to something unreasonable which would fall outside the jurisdiction of the arbitrator. It has also been held that the standard to be applied is irrationality, caprice, arbitrariness or acting beyond the terms of the agreement, while arriving at a finding that the award is vitiated due to misconduct of CS(OS) 625A/1996 7 of 13 the arbitrator (See Bhagwati Oxygen Ltd. –vs- Hindustan Copper Ltd. 2005(6) SCC 462; Rajasthan State Mines and Minerals Ltd. v. Eastern Engineering Enterprises and Another, (1999) 9 SCC 283). Likewise, it has been held (U.P. State Electricity Board v. Searsole Chemcials Ltd. (2001) 3 SCC 397), that where the arbitrator had applied his mind to the pleadings, considered the evidence adduced before him and passed an award, the Court cannot interfere by reappraising the matter as if it were an appeal.
11. Another test indicated by the Supreme Court - Chandu Construction(supra) and Bharat Coking Coal Ltd. v. M/s. Annapurna Construction, (2003) 8 SCC 154,) was that where the arbitrator travels beyond the contract he acts in excess of jurisdiction in which case, the award passed by him becomes vulnerable and can be questioned in an appropriate Court.
12. The undisputed facts here are that the MTNL placed an order on the claimant for supply of Armoured Jelly Filled Underground cables, on 20-12-1990. Clause 11.[1] stipulated that 90% of the payment had to be made after the bills were passed and duly certified by the Assistant General Manager, Materials Management, and on production of agreed documents. Clause 15 prescribed for what was known as the “taking over certificate” to be issued by MTNL, after receipt of the cable at its stores. Clause 16.[1] stipulated a CS(OS) 625A/1996 8 of 13 warranty that the goods were of the assured quality; Clause 16.[2] obliged the contractor to replace any item found to be deficient in any manner. The supplies were made to the stores of the MTNL on various dates, between April and June, 1991. The MTNL received the goods; later the taking over certificate was issued. The entire 100% payment was also released. In October, 1991, letters were written to the claimant by MTNL, alleging that the cables supplies were of lower quantities. Joint inspection of representatives of the parties were undertaken in November 1991 at the premises of the MTNL. At that stage, it was recorded that the outer seals of the drums in which the cables had been supplied, were broken. The MTNL alleged shortage of 405 meters of cables; the claimant denied any liability, alleging that the agreed quantity had been supplied, and the alleged deficiencies had occurred in the premises of MTNL. The latter sought to recover the amounts in other contracts, by withholding payments. Parties went to arbitration, on these allegations.
13. This Court has carefully examined the award, as well as the original record of arbitration, which is a part of the record of this case. The award, so far as it directs payment to the claimant, is a non-speaking one. As held by the Supreme Court in Raipur Development Authority –vs- Chokhamal Contractors, AIR 1989 SC 721, it is not obligatory for an arbitrator to give reasons, unless the CS(OS) 625A/1996 9 of 13 arbitration clause spells out such a duty. In Engineers Syndicate v. State of Bihar,(2007) 3 SCC 99, speaking about the ruling in Raipur Development, the Supreme Court held as follows: “This Court, in the above judgment has categorically held that it was not open to the High Court to speculate where no reasons are given by the arbitrator, as to what impelled the arbitrator to arrive at his conclusion. The Court declined to recognise the power of the Court to attempt to probe the mental process by which the arbitrator had reached his conclusion where it was not disclosed by the terms of his award. It is also further observed in the said judgment that the Court in dealing with an application to set aside an award has not to consider whether the view of the arbitrator on the evidence is justified and that the arbitrator’s adjudication is generally considered binding between the parties, for he is a tribunal selected by the parties and the power of the Court to set aside the award is restricted to cases set out in Section 30.”
14. In the above back ground, it would be necessary to see whether the award is in any way unreasonable, or contrary to provisions of law, as far as it allows the claim of the contractor. The materials on record, which include the documents filed by the parties, suggest that all payments had been made to the claimant, including the balance payments, after the issuance of the taking over certificate under clause 15. The MTNL, after these events, started contesting that the agreed quantities had not been supplied and that there were CS(OS) 625A/1996 10 of 13 shortages. These events led to a reference to arbitration.
15. A textual examination of the award and the materials, so far as it relates to the grant of the claim, does not disclose any error or perversity which measures the standard of legal misconduct.
16. As far as the reasoning of the award, declining the counter-claim of MTNL is concerned, it would be apparent that till invocation of the arbitration clause, no such demand for payment was made. The arbitrator examined the materials, and reasoned that after having accepted the goods unreservedly, the MTNL could not, in terms of the contract, have disputed the quantities.
17. The exception taken to the award, so far as it is based on the terms of the contract, an unfounded. Facially, clause 16.[1] deals with quantity. The examination of MTNL’s witness too brings home the point that no reservation with regard to accepted quantities was contemplated, (in favour the MTNL) in the document. Similarly the objection that the taking over certificate was issued due to pressure of the claimant, (which led to release of all payments) is not based on contemporary documents, forming part of the record, or brought out during examination of witnesses. Therefore the argument about payment being a result of coercion (and consequently the MTNL being free to raise the issue of shortage and excess payment to the CS(OS) 625A/1996 11 of 13 claimant) is without basis.
18. MTNL has adverted to joint inspection reports, which were produced in arbitration, to say that there were admitted shortages. This is sought to be made a ground to allege legal misconduct, by the arbitrator. The court is of opinion that this plea to is unmerited. No single factor can be seen in isolation of other relevant materials. The claimants letters and pleadings deny such shortages and show its disclaimer of liability, on the ground that the goods were in the custody of MTNL for sometime, after the allegation of shortage was made.
19. On an application of the established tests to determine what constitutes “misconduct” under Section 30 to the facts of this case, as apparent from the award and record of arbitration proceedings, this court funds no infirmity in the award, declining the MTNL’s counter-claim.
20. That leaves the court to determine the claim for interest. The arbitrator awarded 19% interest, pendente lite and quantified it. The court discerns no legal infirmity in this having regard to the law on the aspect, and the rate of interest prevalent at the time. Interest @ 18% p.a. Has been claimed till realization. In view of the intervening events, when the interest rates have declined, there is no CS(OS) 625A/1996 12 of 13 justification for granting this part of the claim, under Section 17.
21. In view of the above reasoning, Suit No. 625-A/1996 is dismissed as being without merit. The award of arbitrator is made rule of court, with direction that the MTNL is liable to pay interest @ 10% p.a. pendent lite interest, for the duration of proceedings in this Court, and future interest to the claimant, till realization, at the same rate. This direction is necessary and in the interests of justice, since the claimant had approached the Court, and sought for post award interests.
22. A decree shall be drawn in the above terms. Costs, quantified at Rs.25,000/- are payable to the claimant.
S. RAVINDRA BHAT,J
(JUDGE) JANUARY 10, 2008