Full Text
WP(C) No.460, 557, 643 and 2115/2007
Date of Hearing: 13.12.2007
Date of Decision: 11.01.2008 #Dr. Asha Aggarwal ...Petitioner in WP(C) No.460/07
Dr.(Mrs.) Sushila Dhaon ...Petitioner in WP(C) No.557/07
Dr.P.B. Saxena ....Petitioner in WP(C) No.643/07
Dr. C.M. Mittal ....Petitioner in WP(C) No.2115/07
! Through: Mr.Rajeev Sharma for the petitioner in WP(C) No.460/07
Mr.Dileep Tandon for the petitioner in WP(C) No.557/07
Mr.A.P. Dhamija for the petitioner in WP(C) No.643
Mr.S.P. Mehta for the petitioner in WP(C) No.2115/07.
460, 557 and 643/07 Mr.Amit K. Paul for the respondent/
MCD in WP(C) No.2115/07.
JUDGMENT
2.To be referred to the Reporter or not? 2008:DHC:83-DB
3.Whether the judgment should be reported in the
Digest? A.K. SIKRI, J.
:
1.All the petitioners in these petitions constitute one homogeneous group and raise common grievance. They were working as General Duty Medical Officers (GDMO) with the Director General, Central Health Services, Ministry of
Health and Family Welfare, Government of India. Their age of retirement was 60 years. In case of other three categories of doctors, namely, Teaching Specialists, Non-
Teaching Specialists and Public Health Specialists, the
Government (respondents) herein decided to enhance the age of superannuation to 62 years vide notification dated
16.11.2006. Since same benefit of increase in age was not extended to GDMOs, the respondents felt that they were discriminated against, as according to them, they broadly fall in the same group in which other three categories of doctors belong to inasmuch as, it is one service which is divided into four sub cadres and, therefore, the impugned action of the respondents suffered from vice of inequality and thus, violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India. All these petitioners filed separate application
2008:DHC:83-DB under Section 19 of the Administrative Tribunals Act before the Central Administrative Tribunal, Principal Bench, New Delhi. However, the Tribunal has not accepted their contention and all these applications are dismissed. The orders passed by the Tribunal are assailed in these petitions.
2.In view of commonality of the subject-matter as well as the legal principles involved, we heard all these petition together. Naturally, one common judgment would suffice to cover these writ petitions and we propose to proceed accordingly.
3.For the sake of brevity, facts of WP(C) No.460/2007 are taken note of. The Central Health Services (CHS) was constituted by the Government of India way back in the year
1960. It was declared a Class I Service in 1973. In 1982, this service was restructured by dividing into four categories, namely, General Duty Medical Officers, Teaching Specialists, Non-Teaching Specialists and Public Health Specialists. After initial recruitment into their respective cadres, there are separate channel of promotions up to Senior Administrative Grade (SAG level). Beyond that, for promotion to Higher Administrative Grade (HAG level) all the four cadres are treated as feeder cadres. Thus, the four 2008:DHC:83-DB tributaries merge at HAG level and thereafter flow in the same/common direction. The highest post in the CHS is that of Director General, which can be manned by any doctor belonging to these four categories.
4. The petitioner was appointed as GDMO on 24.3.1971. She was promoted as Senior Duty Medical Officer with effect from 25.11.1982 and then as CMO on 15.1.1989. Further promotion as Chief Medical Officer (NFSG) was accorded to her with effect from 1.1.1992. She was given SAG pay scale on 8.2.2005.
5. As mentioned above, as per the recruitment rules, the age of retirement for all the doctors belonging to the four cadres is 60 years. The Government of India felt concerned with high attrition rate of government doctors through voluntary retirement, resignation and foreign assignments. In order to diagnose the cause and to suggest the remedy/treatment for this aforesaid sickness, a High Power Committee was constituted. The purpose, thus, was to examine as to why an unusual number of government doctors were leaving their jobs to take employment in foreign countries/domestic private sector and to suggest measures to prevent abnormal attrition in government cadres. This High Power Expert 2008:DHC:83-DB Committee was headed by Sh.Javed A. Chawdhury, former Health Secretary, Government of India along with seven other members.
6. After an indepth analysis of the situation, the Committee submitted its report in May 2006. In its detailed report, various nuances and intricacies of the problem were discussed, including their causes and number of recommendations made. One of the recommendations was that the retirement age of CHS doctors be enhanced from 60 to 62 years. Justification for such a move was also given to which we shall advert to at the appropriate stage. This report was considered by the Government of India which resulted in issuances of notification dated 16.11.2006. However, vide this notification while the age of superannuation for doctors belonging to other three categories was fixed as 62 years, in so far as GDMOs are concerned, they were left out and such a benefit was not extended to them.
7. As mentioned above, the petitioners herein filed separate applications before the Tribunal challenging the notification dated 16.11.2006 as arbitrary, discriminatory and violative of the provisions of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of 2008:DHC:83-DB India. There is a common judgment in the case of the petitioners in WP(C) No.460/2007, 557/2007 and 643/2007. In so far as the petitioner in WP(C) No.2115/2007 is concerned, he is a medical doctor in MCD and, therefore, he has directly approached this Court by filing petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India for same relief on same grounds.
8. In a brief order dated 11.1.2007 passed by the learned Tribunal, the entire reasoning given for dismissing the application is contained in para- 6 alone and we reproduce the same to ascertain the mind of the Tribunal. 9.“6. The subject matter of the application relating to enhancement of the age of superannuation of a class/category of officers is a matter of policy, which the Government is competent to decide. In a catena of judgments of the Apex Court, it has been held time and again that courts should not interfere in policy matters. In the present case, again, the applicants have not been individually discriminated against in the impugned order of the Government. As stated by the applicants, the impugned order excludes an entire sub-cadre (GDMO). The applicants have also not established any mala fides. We, therefore, do not consider it necessary to interfere with the decision of the Government.” 2008:DHC:83-DB
10. The Tribunal, thus, perceived it as a matter of policy of the Government in not extending the benefit to GDMOs and on the premise that not few individuals, but the entire subcadre of GHMO is excluded and there is no mala fides, there is no reason to interfere with the decision of the Government.
11. Before we reproduce the legal submissions made by the learned counsel for the petitioners in these petitions, we may refer to one development which has taken place after the pronouncement of the impugned judgment by the Tribunal and during the pendency of these petitions. It is because of the reason that much sustenance in support of their arguments was sought to be drawn by the learned counsel for the petitioners from this event.
12. It is well known that the Central Government has already constituted the Sixth Pay Commission (in short 'Sixth CPC'), which, at present, is proceeding with the deliberations. The Ministry of Health and Family Welfare-CHS-V Section, Government of India, has addressed Office Memorandum dated 1.8.2007 to the Sixth CPC precisely on the same subject, namely, enhancement of superannuating age of the 2008:DHC:83-DB categories of officers to which the petitioners belong. This O.M. reads as under:- “Subject:-Proposal for enhancement of age of superannuation of General Duty Medical Officers of Central Health Service, from 60 to 62 years-reg. The undersigned is directed to forward herewith a proposal for enhancement of age of superannuation of General Duty Medical Officers of Central Health Service from 60 to 62 years, for consideration of 6th Central Pay Commission.”
13. Along with this memo, the proposal, which is forwarded, details the background and also highlights the problem of attrition of doctors from CHS. It traces out the history by pointing out the constitution of J.A. Chawdhury Committee and the decision to enhance the retirement age of the specialist doctors of CHS belonging to three sub cadres. What is important is that this proposal highlights the justification for increasing the age of superannuation of the doctors of GDMO sub cadre as well. It would be apt to reproduce that portion of the proposal in its entirety:-
14. So much so, this proposal also outlines the benefits and additions, which would be advantageous in case the retirement age of GDMOs is increased to 62 years. According to the proposal, following are going to be the beneficial effect of increasing the retirement age from 60 to 62 years:- 2008:DHC:83-DB “i) Deferment of retirement benefits by two years apart from reduced amount of gratuity as the factor for calculating gratuity is linked to the age and keeps on reducing with advancement in age. ii) Service delivery would improve as GDMOs including those possessing P.G. Qualification would be available for longer periods to fill in gaps created by shortage of Specialists. iii) GDMOs who supplement specialists would become available for a longer period. iv) Discontentment vis-a-vis specialists would be eliminated and thus the GDMOs would supplement and assist specialist in a cordial atmosphere. v) Central Health Service will be attractive and more doctors would opt for the same. vi) Experienced manpower would be available for a longer period.”
15. Based on the aforesaid, first argument of Mr.Rajeev Sharma, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner in one of the petitions, was that when the Government itself recognizes the need to increase the age of retirement and has itself made out “a strong case for increasing the retirement age of the GDMOs from 60 to 62 years on the lines of special doctors in the same CHS and is submitted for consideration of the Sixth CPC”, there was no reason to exclude GDMOs from this benefit, in the first instance, when 2008:DHC:83-DB recommendations of the J.A. Chawdhury Committee were implemented. He further submitted that reading of the report of the high-power committee headed by Sh. Chawdhury would reveal that exercise was done for all the sub-cadres of CHS including GDMOs and there was no reason or occasion to exclude the GDMOs while conferring the benefit upon the other three sub-cadres. Mr.Sharma took us to the relevant passages of the said report highlighting the reasons which prevailed with the Committee in recommending the increase in age. Therefore, according to the learned counsel, it was a totally irrational and arbitrary decision not to extend the benefit to the categories of the petitioners. On legal front he submitted that such a decision was clearly violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution as it was discriminatory in nature by treating the GDMOs differently from other three categories, though they were at par in so far as the objective behind the move to increase the retirement age is concerned. He further submitted that the reasons, which were sought to be given by the respondents in the counter affidavit denying the extension of benefit of the said action to the petitioner, were totally illusory and make-belief. He also submitted that all 2008:DHC:83-DB four sub-cadres were part of the main cadre of CHS and there could have been no discrimination between these subcadres as it was not open to the Government to create separate class within the class. He referred to certain judgments of the Apex Court to butress his legal submissions. These are:i) Union of India and Ors. Vs. K.T. Shastri, (1990) 1 SCC 509. ii) T.S. Thiruvengadam Vs. Secretary to Government of India, 1993) 2 SCC 174.
16. Other counsel adopted the aforesaid arguments. In addition, submission was made that because of the fact that these GDMOs entered the service at the average age of 29 years, with age of retirement as 60 years, they are not able to complete 33 years of service, which is needed to earn maximum pension and that in itself is a justification for enhancing the age of retirement to 62 years. Reference was also made to para-20 of the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of B. Prabhakar Rao & Ors. Vs. State of Andhra Pradesh and Ors., 1985 (Suppl.) SCC 432, which reads as under:-
17. Mr.A.K. Bharadwaj, Advocate, who appeared for the respondents in all these petitions, except the writ petition relating to MCD (wherein Mr.Amit K. Paul, Advocate appeared for MCD), countered the aforesaid submission by arguing that it was a policy decision to enhance or not to enhance the age of retirement. No person had any legal right to claim enhancement of age of retirement. Submission of Mr.Bharadwaj was that it was the prerogative of the Government to decrease or enhance the age of retirement and claim for increase of age of retirement was clearly inadmissible as held by the Supreme Court in the case of Union of India & Ors. Vs. Bhola Nath Pandey, JT 1998 (5) SC 344. He further submitted that in so far as the petitioners are concerned, they could not be felt aggrieved as their service conditions remained the same. If the age of retirement was enhanced in other three categories, good luck of doctors belonging to those categories could not be viewed as the bad luck of the petitioners. He also submitted that it was a conscious decision taken as the doctors in 2008:DHC:83-DB those three services were not comparable to GDMOs. There were some differences and it was the job of the Expert Committee to look into those. For this reason, the learned counsel argued, the matter was referred to Sixth CPC and the GDMOs were required to await the recommendation of the CPC. He also submitted that the Chawdhury Committee had itself demarcated the difference between the said three cadres and the GDMOs by observing: “The average age of entry of GDMOs is around 29 years and that of Specialists is 35 years. Therefore, for the Specialists who generally have a service span of 25 years, the benefit of maximum period of five years of added pensionable service is not sufficient and they still fall short of the maximum pensionable service of 33 years.”
18. Referring to the CHS Rules for Recruitment/Promotion of these sub-cadres, he submitted that the terms and conditions attached to GDMOs and other Specialists cadres are different. He also tried to explain that the CHS consists of four sub-cadres, viz., (i) Teaching; (ii) Non-Teaching; (iii) Public Health; and (iv) General Duty Medical Officer (GDMO) with cadre strength of approximately 4700. They are mostly posted in Medical Colleges, Hospitals and Dispensaries. The 2008:DHC:83-DB recruitment to the Specialists sub-cadres is made through UPSC in the minimum pay scale of Rs.10,000-15,200 whereas in case of GDMOs to which the applicant belongs, the entry level is in the pay scale of Rs.8,000-13,500/-. The minimum qualification for appointment of doctors to Specialist sub-cadres is Post Graduate. On the other hand, the GDMOs are only medical graduate possessing MBBS qualification. Thus, the doctors like the applicant belonging to GDMO sub-cadre are not on similar footings as that of Specialists. He referred to the following observations of the Supreme Court in the case of Union of India & Ors. Vs. Lt. (Mrs.) E. Lakats, (SCSLJ 1997 (2) 364:-
19. According to him, following were the reasons in meeting out different treatments to GDMOs and the other three Specialists services:a) Shortage of doctors in Specialist subcadres; b) Late entry into services; c) Implementation of Government decision to reserve 27% seats in Central Educational 2008:DHC:83-DB Institutions for OBC candidates.
20. We have considered the respective submission. At the outset, we may point out that in so far as the Chawdhury Committee is concerned, it went into the question of enhancement of age for the entire cadre of CHS, including GDMOs and did not draw any distinction. The recommendation also generally covers all the sub-cadres and is not limited to the three Specialists sub-cadres. Para 2.[5] of the report, which mentions unattractive prospects in CHS, specifically includes GDMOs sub-cadre as well. The genesis of the entire problem, because of which the matter was referred to the said Committee, was that the members of the CHS were leaving their jobs to take employment in foreign countries/domestic private sector. The Government felt that it was a disturbing trend as it points to a dangerous attrition of professional manpower from the public health system. The brief given to the said Committee was, thus, “to examine/analyse the circumstances causing this trend and to suggest short-term and medium term measures to prevent abnormal attrition in Government cadres.” Subcadre of GDMO was clearly included in this study. One of the reasons found by the said Expert Committee for high 2008:DHC:83-DB rate of attrition was that the doctors had to wait for a very long period in the NFSG scale before they were promoted to SAG level. Para 4.5.[3] of the report reveals that whereas it was taking 22 years to get into SAG as a Specialist, the period for GDMO was around 30 years. Thus, considering that the average age of entry for Specialists is around 35 years and GDMOs is around 29 years, many are unlikely to get the SAG scale during their service. As compared to this, in many Central service cadres, officers achieved SAG scale after 17-18 years of service, i.e. by the age of 45. Two things follow from the reading of para 4.5.3, namely, (i) reason for attrition is the late promotion to SAG level which applied to both Specialists as well as GDMOs. Thus, the GDMOs are covered not only in the study but by the same reason for attrition; (ii) even when average age of entry for GDMOs was 29 years and that of Specialists 35 years, for promotion to SAG it takes 22 years for the Specialists and 30 years for GDMOs. Thus, the early entry into the service by about 6 years is offset by late promotion to SAG as compared to Specialists where the GDMOs lag behind by 8 years. Therefore, the reason given by the respondents that for Specialists, age of retirement was enhanced because 2008:DHC:83-DB they were entering the service at the age of 35 years, whereas the GDMOs were entering the service at the average age of 29 years loses its sheen. Moreover, we find that this was not at all the reason given by the Committee as the extracted portion highlighted by Mr.Bharadwaj, learned counsel for the respondents, is under the head “Terminal Benefits” contained in para 4.8. In that para, the Committee has pointed out that these doctors are not able to earn maximum pension, which again is a cause common to GDMOs as well as Specialists. In any case, in the said para, the measure suggested was there should be better terminal benefits. The suggestion of retirement is dealt with distinctively in para 4.7. These two suggestions to deal with the problem, along with many others, namely, increase in retirement age and giving better terminal benefits, are totally distinct from each other. No doubt, the report of any such High-Power Committee is recommendatory in nature and it is for the Government to accept or not to accept the suggestion and it is also the prerogative of the Government to accept such suggestions with modifications. However, when suggestions are given in respect of all four sub-cadres and the Government denies the benefit thereof to one 2008:DHC:83-DB particular cadre, there have to be justifiable reasons for doing so to avoid the criticism of the action on the ground of arbitrariness and hostile discrimination. In this context, we may consider the validity of reasons given by the respondents. As extracted above, the reasons given are shortage of doctors in specialist sub-cadres, late entry into service, implementation of Government decision to reserve 27% seats for OBC. No doubt, it is for the Government to consider this aspect and if the reasons are well-founded, Courts are not to interfere with such an exercise undertaken by the Government. However, if the so-called reasons in reality are non-existence, or the reasons because of which benefit is extended to specialist sub-cadres are applicable in case of GDMOs as well, the case of discrimination is made out. For comparison of this nature, obviously courts are not to embark upon such enquiries. However, here we find that the exercise is done by the Government itself in its proposal to the Sixth Central Pay Commission where “strong case” is made out for enhancing the age of retirement GDMOs as well. From the portion of the said proposal reproduced above, it is manifest that one of the justifications given is to enhance the age of superannuation is that it is needed to 2008:DHC:83-DB supplement the shortage of specialists. Late entry into service in support of GDMOs is also accepted and recognised by the Government in its proposal, which aspect CAT has also dealt with in detail by analysing the recommendations of the Chawdhury Committee. As far as implementation of the Government decision to reserve seats for OBC candidates is concerned, not only as per the counter affidavit there is only a proposal to this effect, we fail to understand as to how it would not be applicable to GDMOs once such a reservation is provided. In view of our examination of the issue in the aforesaid perspective, judgments cited by the learned counsel for the respondents would be of no avail. The moot question in the circumstances arises as to what should be the direction in such a case. After all, vide OM dated 1.8.2007 proposal is sent to the Sixth CPC for consideration to enhance the age of superannuation of GDMOs from 60 to 62 years. In view of this proposal, matter is yet to be looked into by the Sixth CPC. Though we find prima facie that it was not justified to exclude GDMOs and action of the Government suffers from vice of hostile discrimination and is, therefore, violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution, we do not express our 2008:DHC:83-DB final opinion on this aspect and would leave the matter to the Sixth CPC to decide about the justification for the enhancement of the age of GDMOs. However, at the same time we are of the opinion that if the Sixth CPC recommends enhancement of age of retirement of GDMOs to 62 years and the Government accepts that recommendation, it would be clear vindication of the stand of the petitioners who belong to the category of GDMOs. In such as case, the interest of justice would be subserved by giving effect to the decision of enhancement of age from the date the other subcadres were given, i.e., vide OM dated 16.11.2006.
21. We may note that all these petitioners have retired as they were made to retire at the age of 60 years. If and when the age of retirement of GDMOs is increased with effect from 16.11.2006, the petitioners shall also be accorded benefit thereof and their deemed date of retirement shall be extended by two years and consequential benefits of arrears of pay etc. shall be given to them.
22. These writ petitions are allowed partly to the aforesaid extent and disposed of accordingly. 2008:DHC:83-DB
(A.K. SIKRI) JUDGE January 11, 2008 (VIPIN SANGHI) HP.
JUDGE 2008:DHC:83-DB IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI +WP(C) No. 557/2007 Date of Hearind: 13.12.2007 Date of Decision: 11.01.2008 #Dr. Asha Aggarwal...Petitioner in WP(C) No.460/07 Dr.(Mrs.) Sushila Dhaon...Petitioner in WP(C) No.557/07 Dr.P.B. Saxena....Petitioner in WP(C) No.643/07 Dr. C.M. Mittal....Petitioner in WP(C) No.2115/07 ! Through: Mr.Rajeev Sharma for the petitioner in WP(C) No.460/07 Mr.Dileep Tandon for the petitioner in WP(C) No.557/07 Mr.A.P. Dhamija for the petitioner in WP(C) No.643 Mr.S.P. Mehta for the petitioner in WP(C) No.2115/07.
VERSUS
$Union of India and Anr.....Respondents ^ Through Mr.A.K. Bharadwaj with Mr.Shivender Chopra for the respondent/UOI in WP(C) Nos. 460, 557 and 643/07 Mr.Amit K. Paul for the respondent/ MCD in WP(C) No.2115/07. CORAM:- *THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE A.K.SIKRI THE HON'BLE MR.
JUSTICE VIPIN SANGHI
1. Whether Reporters of Local papers may be allowed to see the Judgment?
2. To be referred to the Reporter or not?
3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the 2008:DHC:83-DB Digest? A.K. SIKRI, J.: For orders, see WP (C) No. 460/2007.
(A.K. SIKRI) JUDGE January 11, 2008 (VIPIN SANGHI) HP.
JUDGE 2008:DHC:83-DB IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI +WP (C) No. 643/2007 Date of Hearind: 13.12.2007 Date of Decision: 11.01.2008 #Dr. Asha Aggarwal...Petitioner in WP(C) No.460/07 Dr.(Mrs.) Sushila Dhaon...Petitioner in WP(C) No.557/07 Dr.P.B. Saxena....Petitioner in WP(C) No.643/07 Dr. C.M. Mittal....Petitioner in WP(C) No.2115/07 ! Through: Mr.Rajeev Sharma for the petitioner in WP(C) No.460/07 Mr.Dileep Tandon for the petitioner in WP(C) No.557/07 Mr.A.P. Dhamija for the petitioner in WP(C) No.643 Mr.S.P. Mehta for the petitioner in WP(C) No.2115/07.
VERSUS
$Union of India and Anr.....Respondents ^ Through Mr.A.K. Bharadwaj with Mr.Shivender Chopra for the respondent/UOI in WP(C) Nos. 460, 557 and 643/07 Mr.Amit K. Paul for the respondent/ MCD in WP(C) No.2115/07. CORAM:- *THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE A.K.SIKRI THE HON'BLE MR.
JUSTICE VIPIN SANGHI
1. Whether Reporters of Local papers may be allowed to see the Judgment?
2. To be referred to the Reporter or not?
3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the 2008:DHC:83-DB Digest? A.K. SIKRI, J.: For orders, see WP (C) No. 460/2007.
(A.K. SIKRI) JUDGE January 11, 2008 (VIPIN SANGHI) HP.
JUDGE 2008:DHC:83-DB IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI +WP(C) No. 2115/2007 Date of Hearind: 13.12.2007 Date of Decision: 11.01.2008 #Dr. Asha Aggarwal...Petitioner in WP(C) No.460/07 Dr.(Mrs.) Sushila Dhaon...Petitioner in WP(C) No.557/07 Dr.P.B. Saxena....Petitioner in WP(C) No.643/07 Dr. C.M. Mittal....Petitioner in WP(C) No.2115/07 ! Through: Mr.Rajeev Sharma for the petitioner in WP(C) No.460/07 Mr.Dileep Tandon for the petitioner in WP(C) No.557/07 Mr.A.P. Dhamija for the petitioner in WP(C) No.643 Mr.S.P. Mehta for the petitioner in WP(C) No.2115/07.
VERSUS
$Union of India and Anr.....Respondents ^ Through Mr.A.K. Bharadwaj with Mr.Shivender Chopra for the respondent/UOI in WP(C) Nos. 460, 557 and 643/07 Mr.Amit K. Paul for the respondent/ MCD in WP(C) No.2115/07. CORAM:- *THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE A.K.SIKRI THE HON'BLE MR.
JUSTICE VIPIN SANGHI
1. Whether Reporters of Local papers may be allowed to see the Judgment?
2. To be referred to the Reporter or not?
3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the 2008:DHC:83-DB Digest? A.K. SIKRI, J.: For orders, see WP (C) No. 460/2007.
(A.K. SIKRI) JUDGE January 11, 2008 (VIPIN SANGHI) HP.