Deepak Kukreja & Ors. v. The State (NCT of Delhi) & Ors.

Delhi High Court · 11 Jan 2008 · 2008:DHC:69
V. B. Gupta
Crl.M.C.No. 1205 & 1119 of 2007
2008:DHC:69
criminal appeal_allowed Significant

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court held that it can quash FIRs relating to non-compoundable offences under its inherent powers when parties have amicably settled the dispute, preventing abuse of the court process.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
Crl.M.C.No. 1205 & 1119 of 2007
JUDGMENT
reserved on: 29th November, 2007
Judgment delivered on: 11th January, 2008

1. Crl.M.C.No. 1205 of 2007

1. Deepak Kukreja, s/o Sh.S.C.Kikreja, R/o A-193, Defence Colony, New Delhi-110024.

2. Sh.Subhash Chand Kukreja, s/o Late Sh.K.P.Kukreja, R/o A-154, Defence Colony, New Delhi.

3. Smt.Rooplekha Kukreja, w/o Sh.S.C.Kukreja, New Delhi-110024.....Petitioners Through: Mr.Subhash Sharma, Adv. Vs.

1. The State (NCT of Delhi)

2. Sh.Vineet Arora s/o Sh.K.L.Arora R/o C-476, Defence Colony New Delhi.... Respondents Through: Mr.Navin Sharma, Adv. Mr.Rohit P.Ranjan, Adv. And

2. Crl.M.C.No. 1119 of 2007 Sh.Vineet Arora Crl.M.C.No.1205/2007 2008:DHC:69 s/o Sh.K.L.Arora R/o C-476, Defence Colony New Delhi.....Petitioner Through: Mr.Rohit P.Ranjan, Adv. Vs.

1. The State (NCT of Delhi)

2. Sh.Deepak Kukreja, s/o Sh.S.C.Kikreja, R/o A-193, Defence Colony, New Delhi-110024.

3. Sh.Subhash Chand Kukreja, s/o Late Sh.K.P.Kukreja, New Delhi.

4. Smt.Rooplekha Kukreja, w/o Sh.S.C.Kukreja, New Delhi-110024...... Respondents Through: Mr.Navin Sharma, Adv. Mr.Subhassh Sharma, Adv. Coram: HON'BLE MR.

JUSTICE V.B. GUPTA

1. Whether the Reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes

2. To be referred to Reporter or not? No

3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest? No V.B. GUPTA, J. These two petitions have been filed by the respective petitioners seeking quashing of two different F.I.Rs registered at P.S. Defence Colony.

5,579 characters total

2. Sh.Vineet Arora, complainant, (who is respondent No.2 in Crl.M.C.No.1205/2007) has got the F.I.R. No.636/2005 registered under Sections 323/341/506/34 IPC at P.S.Defence Colony on the allegations that he is a family friend of the petitioner for last more than 10 years and due to some misunderstanding he got the F.I.R. in question registered against the petitioners with the police and now due to intervention of the common friends and respectable elderly persons of the area, the matter has been compromised and a deed of compromise has been drawn and signed between the parties and since both the parties have amicably arrived at a compromise, no useful purpose will be served if the proceedings in the present F.I.R. allowed to be continued and so it is prayed that the proceedings against the petitioners may be quashed/dropped.

3. In Crl.M.C.No.1119/2007, F.I.R. No.638/05 under Sections 323/341/506/509 IPC was registered at P.S. Defence Colony by complainant Deepak Kukreja, who is one of the accused, in F.I.R. No.636/05 against Sh.Vineet Arora, complainant of F.I.R.No.636/2005.

4. It is stated that due to the intervention of common friends and respectable elderly persons, the parties have compromised the matter and a deed of compromise has been drawn and signed between the parties and both the parties have amicably arrived at a compromise and no useful purpose will be served if the proceedings in the present F.I.R. are allowed to be continued as both the parties are family friends.

5. The only objection taken by the counsel for the State in these matters is that the offences which are not compoundable under Section 320 Cr.P.C., the same cannot be quashed by this Court.

6. It has been laid down by this Court in R.S.Arora Vs. State (1995) JCC 439 that:- “It is true that offences which are noncompoundable in relation to the quashing of such offences, the High Court has to act with great caution and circumspection but to agree with the arguments of learned counsel for the State that those offences which are noncompoundable in view of the Section 320 of the Cr.P.C., the High Court will be without power although parties have settled their matter amicably would be to make the provisions of Section 482 of the Cr.P.C. nugatory and ineffective. The Parliament has specifically provided Section 482 in the Cr.P.C. and High Court in exercise of these powers which are plenary are neither fettered by any provision of the Code and certainly not by Section 320 of the Cr.P.C. So long as these powers are exercised by the High Court to secure the ends of justice and to stop abuse of the process of the Court. Compromise in modern society is a sine qua non of harmony and orderly behavior. Compromise is the soul of justice. Exercising the inherent powers, Under Section 482 of the Cr.P.C. in disputes which emanates out of matrimonial differences, landlord-tenant matters or commercial transactions are to advance the course of justice. No useful purpose will be served after the parties have amicably settled their disputes, buried their past, want to live in a sprit of peace and harmony to relegate them before the police and the Courts, that will be sheer abuse of the process of Court and instead of securing justice would amount to perpetuating injustice to such parties, who have compromised their matters.”

7. In the present two petitions also, both the parties are family friends and they are known to each other for the last 10 years and both the parties are resident of the same colony, that is, Defence Colony. So, keeping in view the facts and circumstances of the cases and the fact that the matters have been amicably settled between the parties, no useful purpose will be served if proceedings in these two cases are allowed to be continued.

8. Under these circumstances, both the F.I.Rs. in question, i.e., F.I.R. Nos.636/05 & 638/05 P.S.Defence Colony are, hereby, quashed. However, the petitioners of each case shall pay Rs.5,000/- as costs of the proceedings. Costs be deposited with the Delhi High Court Legal Services Committee within one month from today.

9. List on 18th February, 2008 for compliance. January 11, 2008 V.B.GUPTA, J. Bisht