Full Text
W.P.(C) 1781/1986
# Smt. Sundri .... Petitioner ! Through : Mr. Arun Srivastava, Proxy
Counsel for Mr. P.R. Aggarwal, Advocate.
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE ARUNA SURESH
JUDGMENT
(1) Whether reporters of local paper may be allowed to see the judgment? Not necessary (2) To be referred to the reporter or not? Not necessary (3) Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest ? Not necessary O R D E R % 02.01.2008 Per Thakur, J (oral)
1. In Ram Chand and others v. Union of India – (1994) 1 SCC 44, one of the grounds on which the validity of the land acquisition proceedings was challenged by the land owners was that the said proceedings had not been completed within a reasonable period. The Court examined the explanation offered by the authorities for the delay in the completion of the WP(C) 1781/1986 2008:DHC:1-DB proceedings and came to the conclusion that the same was not acceptable. There was, in the opinion of the Court, no cogent explanation for the non-completion of the proceedings even after the pronouncement of the judgment of the Supreme Court in Aflatoon v. Union of India - AIR 1974 SC 2077. Having said so, the Court upheld the acquisition proceedings while protecting interest of the land owners by directing that they shall be paid an additional amount of compensation @12% p.a. from the date of expiry of two years reckoned from 23rd August, 1974 till the date of the making of the awards by the Collector. The Court observed: “According to us, after the judgment of this Court in Aflatoon case on August 23, 1974, the reasonable time for making the awards was about two years from that date. Beyond two years, the time taken for making of the awards will be deemed to be unreasonable. As such, after expiry of the period of two years, some additional compensation has to be awarded to the cultivators. Taking into consideration the interest of the cultivators and the public, instead of quashing the proceedings for acquisition, we direct that the petitioners shall be paid an additional amount of compensation to be calculated at the rate of twelve per cent per annum, after expiry of two years from August 23, 1974, the date of the judgment of this court in Aflatoon case till the date of the making of the awards by the Collector, to be calculated with reference to the market value of the lands in question on the date of the notifications under subsection (1) of Section 4.”
2. Relying upon the above decision, the Supreme Court, in Murari and others v. Union of India and others – (1997) 1 SCC 15, granted a similar relief to the petitioners and observed: “After overall consideration of the issues involved in these transfer cases and the appeals we find no ground to take a different view than the one taken by the High Court in the impugned judgment. Consequently, the acquisition proceedings could not be quashed on any grounds. We also find ourselves in respectful agreement with the view taken by this Court in the case of Ram Chand. Consequently, the appeals fail and are hereby dismissed. The transfer cases are allowed in terms of the order made in the case of Ram Chand directing that the transfer petitioners and the appellants shall be paid an additional amount of compensation to be calculated at the rate of 12 per cent per annum, after the expiry of two years from the date of decision of Aflatoon case i.e., 23.8.1974 till the date of making of the awards by the Collector, to be calculated with reference to the market value of the land in question on the date of notification under Section 4(1) of the Act. In the facts and circumstances of the case we make no order as to costs.”
3. In the case at hand, the acquisition proceedings were initiated in the year 1965 by a preliminary notification dated 6.3.1965 followed by a declaration under Section 6 of the Land Acquisition Act dated 7.1.1969. An award followed but only on 19.9.1986 i.e. nearly 16 years later. The proceedings in the present petition are as in the cases mentioned above challenged on the ground of unreasonable delay in the completion of the same. A similar challenge in respect of the very same notifications and land in the very same village was examined by a Division Bench of this Court comprising Swatanter Kumar and Madan B. Lokur, JJ. in Balwant & Ors. v. Union of India and others – 119 (2005) DLT 458. Relying upon the decisions of the Supreme Court in Murari and others (supra) and the Full Bench of this Court in Roshanara Begum v. Union of India & Ors. - 61 (1996) DLT 206, the Court disposed of the petition with the direction that the owners shall be entitled to the same relief as was granted to the owners in Murari's (supra) case. There is, in our opinion, no reason for us much less a cogent one to strike a discordant note. In fairness to counsel for the petitioner, we must mention that even he limited his prayer in the petition to the disposal of the petition on the lines of Ram Chand and Murari's cases (Supra) disposed of by the Supreme Court and in Balwant & Ors.(supra) disposed of by this Court.
4. In the circumstances, therefore, while rejecting the petitioner's challenge to the acquisition proceedings, we direct that the petitioner shall be entitled to compensation at the rate of 12 per cent per annum on the amount of compensation representing the market value of the land as on the date of notification under Section 4 on the analogy of the decision in the Murari's (supra) case. No cost. T.S. THAKUR, J ARUNA SURESH, J JANUARY 02, 2008 jk