Full Text
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
LPA NO.424-426/2006
Date of Decision: January 17, 2008 UNION OF INDIA & ORS. ... Appellants
Through Mr. Ashwani Bhardwaj, Advocate.
Through Mr. Varun Prasad, Advocate.
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE REVA KHETRAPAL 1.Whether reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the
JUDGMENT
2. To be referred to the Reporter or not?
3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest? DR.
MUKUNDAKAM SHARMA, CJ (ORAL):
1. This appeal arises out of the impugned order dated 7.12.2005 passed by the learned Single Judge in the writ petition filed by the respondents. The writ petition was filed by the respondents seeking the following reliefs:- “(a) Issue writ, order or direction in the nature of mandamus directing the Respondent No.1 to instantly refer the dispute to the Industrial Adjudicator; and (b) issue writ, order or direction in the nature of mandamus/prohibition directing the Respondents No.2-4 to maintain status quo as regards the services of the petitioner workers till the industrial dispute is finally decided by the industrial adjudicator with specific 2008:DHC:143-DB any other workman even if they want to change the contractor; and
(c) in the alternative, the above interim protection as mentioned in prayer (b) be granted till the disposal of the proposed application for stay that the Petitioners would file before the Industrial Tribunal after the dispute is referred to the Tribunal so that the reference is not made infructuous; and
(d) Pass such other or further order or orders and/or directions as this Hon'ble Court may deem fit and proper to meet the ends of justice.”
2. The learned Single Judge entertained the aforesaid writ petition and while issuing notice, passed an interim order that in the meanwhile status quo as to the engagement of the respondents should be maintained. The respondents filed a contempt petition alleging wilful violation of the aforesaid interim order passed by the learned Single Judge. It was also alleged that despite the said interim order, the services of the respondents were terminated and they were disengaged from the work. The aforesaid writ petition and the contempt petition came up for hearing before the learned Single Judge and the same were disposed of by order dated 7th December, 2005 by issuing the following directions:- “(i) Status quo order made in these proceedings shall enure in favour of the petitioners for a further period of four weeks. They shall approach the tribunal within a period of four weeks with the request to continue the interim order. The status quo shall continue till the disposal of that application. It is made clear that the orders in these proceedings shall not be construed as an expression on the merits of the case and the tribunal is free to consider all the contentions even while deciding the interim application.
(ii) The respondent Nos.1-3 shall ensure that full payment of wages is given to the petitioners for the period July 2004 to 01.12.2004 within a period of four weeks from today;
(iii) That said respondents shall bear the liability of
50% of the wages payable for the period 02.12.2004 to 19.10.2005. These amount shall be paid within eight weeks. This is subject to the final orders of the tribunal which may pass appropriate order having regard to the final outcome of the proceedings either varying or modifying the direction for this period.”
3. In the meantime and in terms of the prayer made in the writ petition, the dispute between the parties was also referred to the Central Government Industrial Tribunal-cum-Labour Court. In the order dated 7th December, 2005 whereby the learned Single Judge disposed of the writ petition, status quo order was made effective for a further period of four weeks with a direction to the workmen to approach the Tribunal for further interim orders. However, a direction was issued to the appellants herein to ensure that full payment of wages is given to the respondents for the period from July, 2004 to 1st December, 2004. There was also a third direction that the appellants should also bear the liability of 50% of the wages payable for the period 2nd December, 2004 to 19th October,
2005. However, it was made clear in the said order itself that the aforesaid order for payment of wages would be subject to the final orders which the Tribunal might pass having regard to the final outcome of the proceedings either varying or modifying the direction for the aforesaid period i.e., 2nd October, 2005. It is the specific case given in (ii) as they ensured that full payment of wages has been made for the period between July, 2004 to 1st December,
2004.
4. Being aggrieved by the aforesaid directions as given in paragraph (iii) of the operative portion of the judgment, the appellants filed the present appeal in which notice was issued and an interim order was passed staying the operation of the impugned order.
5. During the pendency of the appeal in this Court, the Central Government Industrial Tribunal has decided the reference in favour of the Management and against the workmen. It was held in the said reference by the Tribunal that the demand of the CPWD Karamchari Union, that is, the present respondents who are working as wiremen through the contractor in the establishment of the CPWD, for regularisation of their services in the establishment of the CPWD is neither legal nor justified and, therefore, the workmen are not entitled to get any relief as prayed for. Since the said Tribunal has held against the workmen, therefore, as of today there cannot be any liability of making any payment of wages by the appellants for the period between 2nd October, 2005 for, according to the final order passed by the Tribunal, they cannot claim wages from the appellants as they are not the direct employees of the appellants, but were engaged by a contractor who is solely responsible for payment of such
6. Counsel appearing for the respondents/workmen, however, has stated before us that the said respondents are now contemplating a further action and are filing a writ petition in this Court challenging the legality and validity of the aforesaid order passed by the Tribunal.
7. In the facts and circumstances of this case, therefore, we make it clear that if in case any writ petition is filed by the respondents in this Court and the said writ petition is finally allowed, then only the aforesaid issue regarding payment of the wages by the appellants for the period between 2nd October, 2005 would arise for consideration in which event the said issue shall also form part of the judgment of the learned Single Judge.
8. In terms of the aforesaid order, this appeal is disposed of.
9. We, however, make it clear that any observation made by us in this order would not be construed by any authority or by the learned Single Judge, if a writ petition is filed, as views expressed by this Court on the merits as to whether or not the respondents are direct employees of the appellants.
CHIEF JUSTICE REVA KHETRAPAL, J. JANUARY 17, 2008 vk