M/S ARVIND CONSTRUCTION CO. LTD v. M/S ENGINEERING PROJECT (INDIA) LTD

Delhi High Court · 17 Jan 2008 · 2008:DHC:141
BADAR DURREZ AHMED
EX. P. 265/2007 & EA Nos.546-547/2007
2008:DHC:141
civil petition_dismissed

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court clarified the correct amount payable under an arbitration award made a rule of court and ordered attachment of the judgment debtor's bank account for recovery if payment is not made within two weeks.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
JUDGMENT
delivered on: 17.01.2008
EX. P. 265/2007 & EA Nos.546-547/2007
M/S ARVIND CONSTRUCTION CO. LTD ... Decree Holder
- versus - M/S ENGINEERING PROJECT (INDIA) LTD... Judgment Debtor
Advocates who appeared in this case:
For the Decree Holder : Mr U. Hazarika with Mr Manjeet Singh
For the Judgment Debtor : Mr Manoj K. Das
CORAM:-
HON'BLE MR JUSTICE BADAR DURREZ AHMED

1. Whether Reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment ?

2. To be referred to the Reporter or not ?

3. Whether the judgment should be reported in Digest ? BADAR DURREZ AHMED, J (ORAL)

1. There has been some controversy with regard to the extent of payment that the judgment debtor has to make to the decree holder in full and final satisfaction of the decree. The arbitrator had awarded an amount of Rs 1,23,56,587/- as well as a sum of Rs 38,25,000/- in favour of the decree holder. Interest on encashment of the bank guarantee to the extent of Rs 8,84,500/- had also been awarded by the arbitrator. The total of the amounts 2008:DHC:141 1,23,56,587/- and Rs 38,25,000/- till realisation or the date of the decree whichever was earlier. The amount had not been paid. An application had been moved for making the award a rule of the court and the same was done on 06.01.1995. Therefore, the date of the decree would be 06.01.1995. On the date of the decree, the amount payable by the judgment debtor to the decree holder was Rs 2,76,24,471/-. This became the decretal amount. While making the award a rule of the court, this court directed that the said amount would be payable alongwith interest @ 12% from the date of decree till realisation.

2. A sum of Rs 1.[5] crores was paid by the judgment debtor by way of deposits made in court in two installments of Rs 75 lakhs each made on 02.01.1997 and 16.01.1997. The decretal amount plus interest calculated upto 16.01.1997 would come to Rs 3,42,92,480/-. After deducting the amount of deposit made, the balance amount remaining to be paid as on 16.01.1997 would be Rs 1,92,92,480/-. The interest on this balance amount, which entirely consisted of part of the principal amount, would run @ 12% from 17.01.1997 to 17.01.2008. The extent of interest would be Rs 2,54,66,074/-. Therefore, the amount payable as of today by the judgment debtor to the decree holder would be Rs 4,47,58,554/-. This settles the controversy with regard to the extent of the liability of the judgment debtor under the decree.

3. It must be noted that the counsel for the decree holder had claimed a much higher sum, as indicated by the computations submitted by him. He submitted that the amount of Rs 3,47,05,918/- as stated in the execution petition initially is incorrect and the amount due to the decree holder is actually Rs 5,71,45,231/-. The learned counsel for the judgment debtor had contended that the amount payable by the judgment debtor was Rs 1,83,70,503/-.

4. I have examined the matter in detail and have come to the conclusion that both the judgment debtor and the decree holder are wrong in their computations. The computation has already been clarified above. A sum of Rs 4,47,58,554 stands payable by the judgment debtor to the decree holder as on 17.01.2008. In case the said payment is not made by the judgment debtor to the decree holder within two weeks, the account of the judgment debtor bearing No.05011001154 in Dena Bank, 46, Ground Floor, Scope Complex, Lodi Road, New Delhi-110003 would stand attached to the said extent for the purpose of realisation of the decretal amount. The judgment debtor shall not transfer any funds from the said account other than for the purposes of making payment under the decree in excess of the decretal amount as determined above. This petition stands disposed of. ( BADAR DURREZ AHMED )