Full Text
Date of Decision: 17.1.2008 LPA No. 254/2001 The Chief of Army Staff and Ors. .... Appellants
Advocates who appeared in this case :
For the appellants : Ms.Jyoti Singh, Advocate
For the respondent : Mr. N.L.Bareja, Advocate
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE J.M. MALIK 1.Whether the Reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the
JUDGMENT
2.To be referred to Reporter or not? 3.Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest?
J.M. MALIK, J. (Oral)
1. The facts of the above-said letter patents appeal are these. The respondent, Trilochan Behera, was enrolled as LPA No. 254/2001 2008:DHC:145-DB Sepoy/tailor(Unit) in the Army Corps of Signal in June, 1984. On being tipped off, the search of the belongings of the respondent was conducted by Lt. Kuldip Singh adjutant of the same unit in the presence of other two witnesses on 26th February, 1994, but in the absence of the respondent and the following incriminating materials were recovered: “(a) Rubber Stamp Adjt - 4 Corps Engineering Signal Regmt. (b) Rubber Stamp - Authorised to travel by AC Sleeper
(c) Bottle containing ink remover.
(d) Old concession vouchers and railway warrants.”
2. The summary court martial held that the charge against the respondent stood proved and dismissed the respondent from service. Aggrieved by that order the respondent filed a writ petition before this Court and this Court vide order dated 6th February, 2001 accepted his writ petition and declared that the proceedings of the summary court martial were void because it had failed to follow the Army Rules 22 and 115(2). The learned Single Judge also came to the conclusion that there is nothing on the record to show that the preliminary enquiry under Rule 22 was held. It was also observed that the document produced along with the counter affidavit in Annexure B, which is stated to be the record of proceedings itself, shows that it was recorded on 28th March, 1994. However, the case of the appellants is that the hearing of charges commenced on 28th February, 1994 at 12:45 hours and was closed at 13.30 hours. The signatures of the respondent were not obtained anywhere on the entire proceedings running into 13 pages. The appellants themselves claim that summary evidence was recorded on 05.03.1994 and 07.03.1994 and additional summary evidence was recorded on 19th March, 1994. The learned Single Judge observed, “A perusal of the record would show that the relevant rules prescribing the procedure had not been followed. The whole thing is clearly made-up.” It was further held that the appellants while holding the summary court martial, had proceeded on the basis that the respondent had admitted the guilt and the provisions under Army Rule 115 were not complied with.
3. Aggrieved by this order, the appellants have approached this Court. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties. Counsel for the appellants vehemently argued that all the mandatory rules were complied with. She submitted that there is no requirement of law that the accused must sign the plea of guilt. She argued that the respondent had made the confession out of his own volition and now he wants to wriggle out of it by turning around and finding faults with the proceedings. She argued that the wrong mention of date appears to be a human error and hence a typographical mistake crept in. Inspite of writing it as 28th February, 1994 it was wrongly typed as 28th March, 1994. She explained that there is no allegation of bias. The respondent himself made a statement, “I repent for the mistake I have done. I want to continue serving as my family is dependent on my income only.” Counsel for the appellants also drew our attention towards the statement of Kuldeep Singh, who stated that he identified the accused who was present before the Court. Then, there is a certificate issued by Major P.K.Agarwal, the officer who recorded the summary of evidence, wherein he certified, “I certify that I had cautioned the accused NO. 14257873K UINK (Tailor 'U') Trilochan Behera in terms of Army Rule 23(3). The individual declines to make any statement in the presence of independent witness JC-367262F Nb Sub MH Biswas.” Lastly, she pointed out that all the proceedings were held in the presence of witnesses and the question of manipulation of any document does not arise.
4. We find force in the order of Single Judge in a measure, however, our reasoning is wee bit different. The appellant has produced before us the true copies of the record. This record goes to show that no ordersheet was ever prepared. The respondent has also placed on record the copies furnished to him. All these copies go to show that the proceedings were initiated on 28th March, 1994. It is pertinent to note that 28th March, 1994 was written on a paper with a heading, “trial by summary court martial under the Army Act”. Annexure P-1 reveals that the date is mentioned as “28th March, 1993”. The next connected paper mentions the date as 28th March, 1994. The certificate of Col. K.C. Mehta, Commanding Officer, also mentions the date as 28th March, 1994. Succinctly stated ExPI mentions the date as “28th March 1993”, three other papers out of abovesaid 13 pages mention the date as 28th March, 1994, the charge sheet mentions the date as 22nd March, 1994. There can be human error at one place. If the same type of human error occurs at so many places, an integument of suspicion envelopes the entire proceedings of the above-said Court Martial. It is difficult to fathom as to how this type of mistake occurred time and again. Although, there is no allegation of bias, yet the possibilities of its being manipulated cannot be ruled out particularly when the record is being produced for the scrutiny of this Court.
5. Secondly, the signatures of the respondent were not obtained on any of these proceeding. The plea of the respondent was recorded on a printed format. The column of arraignment reads as under: “By the Court-How say you No. 14257873K ULNK Trilochan Behera are you guilty or not guilty of the................... charge preferred against you?” The answer is recorded as “Guilty”. It does not mention what was the charge though a separate chargesheet has been placed on record which is dated 22nd March, 1994, which is not signed by the respondent. The complete plea of guilt of the respondent was not recorded.
6. In Sashidhara Kurup Vs. Union of India and Ors., 1994 Cri.L.J., 375 (Gauhati), his Lordship Dr.H.K.Sema, the then judge of the High Court, was pleased to hold: “7......... Recording of the plea of the accused as nearly as possible in the words which is used by the accused has an important significance because unless the plea of the accused is recorded as nearly as possible in the words which is used by the accused the appellate court is deprived of the privilege to examine as to whether the plea made by the accused amounts to admission of guilt or not.” However, in the next page, the following question was put to the respondent: “Do you wish to make any statement in reference to the charge or in mitigation of punishment? This question was put to the respondent after he had pleaded guilty, to which the respondent replied, “I repent for the mistake I have done. I want to continue serving as my family is dependent on my income only.” It is also noteworthy that no date is mentioned on this paper. Not even under the signatures of the Judge, Col. K.C.Mehta.
7. Counsel for the respondent has drawn our attention towards guide to Summary Court Martial issued in the year 1984, Heading (b) Arraignment at pages 7 & 8, it is mentioned: “(iii) If the accused pleads guilty to the charge, the implications of the plea should be explained to the accused(s) by the officer holding the trial vide AR 115(2). He should also make the following record on page 'B' of the proceedings in the presence of the accused and obtain his signature thereon:- “Before recording the plea of guilty offered by the accused, the Court explains to the accused the meaning of the charge(s) to which he had pleaded guilty and ascertains that the accused understands the nature of the charge(s) – to which he has pleaded guilty. The Court also informs the accused the general effect of that plea and the difference in procedure which will be followed consequent to the said plea. The Court having satisfied itself that the accused understands the charge(s) and the effect of his plea of guilty accepts and records the same. The provisions of Army Rule 115(2) are complied with.” (Signature) (Signature) Accused The Court
(iv) Failure to comply with the procedure explained in sub-para 16(b) (iii) above will amount to violation of the procedural safe guard provided in AR 115(2) and violation of Article 14 of the Constitution of India and the punishment awarded will have to be set aside. (Auth: HQ Western Command letter No 0337/1/A[3] dated 30 Oct 84 attached as Appx F and Judgment of J & K High Court, see Pritpal Singh v. Union of India (J & K) 1984 (3) SLR 680.)”
8 In Prithpal Singh Vs. Union of India and others(supra) that is, 1984(3) SLR 675 (J & K), it was held:
9. Now, we turn to the procedure laid down in Rule 115 of the Army Rules. The certificate which bears the date 28th March, 1994 is reproduced as follows:- “Before recording of plea of guilty offered by the accused the Court explained to the accused the meaning of the charge to which he had pleaded guilty and ascertained that the accused had understood the nature of the charges to which he had pleaded guilty. The Court also informed the accused the general effect of the plea and the difference in procedure which will be followed consequent to the said plea. The Court having satisfied itself that the accused understands the charges and the effect of his plea of guilty accepts and records the same. The provision of Army Rule 115 (2) are thus complied with”. There are no other proceedings in this context.
10. It clearly goes to show that this certificate was prepared after the respondent had pleaded guilty. This is apparent that the provisions of Rule 115(2) were not complied with. The said rule runs as under:
11. This formality should have been done before the plea of guilt of the respondent was recorded. There is no indication in the charge dated 22nd March, 1994 that the Commanding Officer had already undergone this formality. That is why in the absence of ordersheets and other proceedings, the position does not begin to jell. The preparation of ordersheets would have gone a long way to illustrate the position more vividly on this hazy record. It is also not understandable as to why did the Commanding Officer fail to correct the date of 28th March, 1994. Again, the certificate given by him under Rule 115(2) of the Army Rules is on a separate paper. The possibility of its being manipulated cannot be ruled out. Such like certificates can be prepared at any time. This justifies the need for obtaining the signatures of the accused viz. to lend authenticity to such a record.
12. In a recent authority reported in Sukanta Mitra Vs. Union of India and Ors., 2007 (2) 197 (J & K), it was held:
14. The learned counsel for the respondent also cited a case reported in Uma Shanker Pathak Vs. Union of India and others, 1989 (3) SLR 405 by Allahabad High Court, wherein it was held: