Smt. Uganti & Ors v. Shri Hakim & Ors

Delhi High Court · 08 Jan 2008 · 2008:DHC:44
Kailash Gambhir
FAO No. 268/1999
2008:DHC:44
civil appeal_allowed Significant

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court allowed the appeal to revise compensation in a motor accident death case, emphasizing the need for proper income evidence and awarding additional damages for loss of consortium, love and affection, funeral expenses, and loss of estate.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
FAO No. 268/1999
JUDGMENT
delivered on: January 08 ,2008 Smt. Uganti & Ors. ..... Appellants.
Through: Mr. Y.R. Sharma, Advocate
versus
Shri Hakim & Ors. ..... Respondents
Through: Nemo
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE KAILASH GAMBHIR,

1. Whether the Reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes

2. To be referred to Reporter or not? Yes

3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest? Yes KAILASH GAMBHIR, J. Oral: By way of this appeal the appellants seek to challenge the impugned award dated 22.04.1999, primarily, on the ground that the Tribunal has not correctly assessed the income of the deceased, secondly, the Tribunal has not paid any compensation towards loss of consortium in favour FAO No. 268/1999 Page No.1 of 6 2008:DHC:44 of his widow and thirdly, no amount has been paid towards loss of love and affection and the funeral charges also. Before adverting to deal with the contentions raised by counsel for the appellants, it would be appropriate to give brief facts of the case as under:- On 1.4.95 Sh. Prem Singh was coming from residence on his cycle and was going to his place of work. At about 8.30 A.M. he reached near Lal Kaun Petrol Pump on M.B.Road, New Delhi and was on left side of the road at that time a truck bearing registration no. HYU 551 driven by the driver in a rash and negligent manner and at a very fast speed came from behind and struck against the deceased from behind without blowing any horn or giving any signal. As a result the deceased fell down and came under the wheel of the aforesaid truck. From the accident spot he was removed to AIIMS, Delhi where he succumbed to his injuries. Nobody has been appearing from the respondents side. This is despite the fact that the New India Assurance Company is now duly represented by the designated counsel, Mr. Kamal Choudhary. The regular matters cannot be unduly delayed just on account of the absence of the FAO No. 268/1999 Page No.2 of 6 lawyers representing the Insurance Company. I have heard learned counsel for the appellants at considerable length and have perused the record. Counsel for the appellants contends that the deceased was doing the job as stitching cotton worker and was earning an amount of Rs.5,000/- to 6,000/- per month. Counsel further contends that the deceased is survived by his young widow and the child but the Tribunal has not awarded any amount of compensation towards the loss of consortium. No amount towards loss of love and affection has been awarded by the Tribunal. Similarly, no amount has been awarded for funeral expenses and loss of estate. A perusal of the award shows that the appellants have failed to establish the deceased's income being claimed by them. No documentary evidence was produced by the concerned employee to prove the income of the deceased. In this regard the Supreme Court in Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Meena Variyal,(2007) 5 SCC 428 has held as under:- “It was necessary for the claimants to establish what was the monthly income and what was the dependency on the basis of which the compensation could be adjudged as payable. Should not any FAO No. 268/1999 Page No.3 of 6 Tribunal trained in law ask the claimants to produce evidence in support of the monthly salary or income earned by the deceased from his employer company? Is there anything in the Motor Vehicles Act which stands in the way of the Tribunal asking for the best evidence, acceptable evidence? We think not. Here again, the position that the Motor Vehicles Act vis-vis claim for compensation arising out of an accident is a beneficent piece of legislation, cannot lead a Tribunal trained in law to forget all basic principles of establishing liability and establishing the quantum of compensation payable. The Tribunal, in this case, has chosen to merely go by the oral evidence of the widow when without any difficulty the claimants could have got the employer Company to produce the relevant documents to show the income that was being derived by the deceased from his employment. In any event of the matter, the deceased was a skilled worker and the Tribunal has wrongly applied the minimum wages as applicable to unskilled labourer. The minimum wages for the skilled workman as on the relevant date of accident was Rs.1,919/-. The Tribunal has not considered any increase in the minimum wages as it is a matter of common knowledge under the Minimum Wages Act the wages get doubled within a period of ten years. The FAO No. 268/1999 Page No.4 of 6 Tribunal has applied 17 as multiplier against which no grievance has been made. In the above facts and circumstances of the case, the average of income of the deceased would come to Rs.1,919/- which is taken to have doubled within a period of ten years and taking a mean of the same, the same would come to Rs.2878.50 p.m. After deducting 1/3rd from the same, the annual income of the deceased would come to Rs.23,028/- p.a. and multiplying the same by multiplier of 17, the total compensation towards financial dependence would come to Rs.3,91,476/-. Since the Tribunal has not awarded any compensation towards loss of consortium, therefore, a sum of Rs.50,000/is awarded towards loss of consortium as the deceased is survived by a young widow. Rs.10,000/- is awarded towards funeral expenses, Rs.25,000/- towards loss of love and affection and Rs.10,000/- is granted for loss of estate. Thus, the total compensation comes out to Rs.4,86,476/-. Since the appellant has already received the compensation amount in terms of the award, the differential amount shall be paid by the respondents along with upto date interest from the date of filing of the petition till realisation @ 7.5% FAO No. 268/1999 Page No.5 of 6 per annum. With the above directions, the appeal stands disposed of. January 08, 2008 KAILASH GAMBHIR, J. ns FAO No. 268/1999 Page No.6 of 6