M/s Shivaai Industries (P) Ltd v. Delhi Transport Corporation

Delhi High Court · 18 Jan 2008 · 2008:DHC:167
A.K. Sikri
OMP No. 466 of 2005
2008:DHC:167
civil appeal_allowed Significant

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court upheld the contractual dispute resolution mechanism including arbitration and mediation for licence fee disputes between advertisement contractors and DTC, granting interim relief subject to payment of undisputed dues.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
OMP No. 465 of 2005 and OMP No. 466 of 2005 Pronounced on : January 18, 2008
JUDGMENT

1. OMP No. 465/2005 # M/s. International Avenues & Anr......Petitioners ! through: Mr. Rajiv Nayar, Sr. Advocate with Mr. S.K. Maniktala and A.P. Singh, Advocates

VERSUS

$ Delhi Transport Corporation.....Respondent ^ through: Mr. Parag Tripathi, Sr. Advocate with Mr. Sumeet Pushkarna, Advocate Ms. Sumita Kapil for the MCD.

2. OMP No. 466/2005 # M/s. Shivaai Industries (P) Ltd......Petitioners

VERSUS

Advocate CORAM:- *THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE A.K.SIKRI

1. Whether Reporters of Local papers may be allowed to see the Judgment?

2. To be referred to the Reporter or not?

3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the 2008:DHC:167 A.K. SIKRI, J.

1. Since the disputes involved in these petitions are common, the same were heard together and are being disposed of vide this common order. However, for the sake of brevity, facts of OMP No. 465/2005 are taken.

2. Petitioner No.2, as sole proprietor of petitioner No.1, responded to the Notice Inviting Tenders (NIT) issued by respondent Delhi Transport Corporation (hereinafter referred to as ‘DTC’) for appointment of area-wise agents for display of advertisement boards on the DTC Bus Queue Shelters (for short, ‘BQS’) and Time Keeping Booths (for short, ‘TKB’) for a period of three years. He was declared a successful bidder in respect of 7 zones and was granted sole advertisement rights on all the BQSs and TKBs in respect of the above-said zones for a period of three years. The names of the zones, licence fee payable and the date of allotment, in a tabulated form, are as under:- S.No. Zone licence Fee/Month Date of Allotment

1. West Zone – I Rs. 8,45,834 7.6.05

2. Central Zone - I Rs. 10,45,836 7.6.05

3. Central Zone - II Rs. 10,54,168 7.6.05

4. Karol Bagh Zone Rs. 9,58,334 17.5.05

22,132 characters total

5. Shahdara (N) Zone-I Rs. 5,26,000 16.9.05

6. Shahdara (S) Zone - II Rs. 12,76,668 16.9.05

7. West Zone - II Rs. 7,27,210 16.9.05

3. This monthly licence fee, as per the terms of allotment, was payable in equal proportions to the DTC and the MCD. In the event of delay, late payment of charges @ 2% p.m. are payable. The petitioners were also to make deposit of security amount, equivalent to three months licence fee payable in equal petitioners gave the requisite security amount in respect of the Central Zone-II by means of a bank guarantee for Rs.31,62,504/-, in respect of other zones the security could not be deposited by the petitioners by due date and they requested the respondent for extension of time to furnish the bank guarantee for the remaining allotments.

4. Insofar as payment of licence fee is concerned, case of the petitioners is that it was paid upto 30.10.2005. One of the terms of the allotment is that licence fee is payable as per the actual number of BQSs and TKBs in a particular zone and if in a given month the number of BQSs and TKBs increase or decrease, the licence fee shall also be proportionately increased or decreased. Obviously the allotment of these BQSs and TKBs was for the purpose of display of advertisement thereon by the petitioners. Petitioners could book the advertisement from the prospective advertisers and charge them accordingly. Therefore, according to the petitioners, availability of BQSs and TKBs in a particular zone becomes important. The petitioners also state that it is obligatory on the part of the respondent to conduct such surveys/investigation to find out the exact number of BQSs and TKBS in a particular zone. This is important because in view of mass infrastructural development going on in the entire city in the form of building and widening of roads, construction of new flyovers and other infrastructural activities, these shelters are being dismantled, removed and demolished. Petitioners, therefore, made representations and requested the respondent to carry out joint inspection/survey as various heed to these requests. Even on certain occasions when the survey was carried out, the respondent did not give full effect to such surveys as it deliberately did not give due adjustment in respect of the missing and/or non-existing shelters. Without giving such adjustments and reducing the licence fee proportionately, respondent has been pressuring the petitioners to pay full amounts of monthly licence fee as per the original agreement. This act on the part of the respondent is perceived by the petitioner as arbitrary and illegal as the petitioners are entitled to proportionate reduction in the licence fee. Thus, according to the petitioners disputes and differences have arisen on the question of proportionate reduction of licence fee, which depends on the exact availability of BQSs and TKBs and the amount payable on that basis. Agreement entered into between the parties contains arbitration clause, i.e. Clause 34, in case of disputes, the operative part of which is reproduced below:- “34.

ARBITRATION IN CASE OF DISPUTE a. There shall be a Dispute Settlement Committee which shall try to settle all disputes at the first stage. The Dispute Settlement Committee shall consist of CGM, Addl. CAO, concerned Dy. CGM and Sr. Manager Law. If the Committee fails to resolve the issue, it shall be referred for arbitration. Chairman-cum-M.D. Shall be the final authority in all litigation/arbitration. He can nominate any arbitrator for settlement of disputes. Chairman-cum-M.D.'s decision shall be final and binding on all the parties. All questions and disputes between the parties, the settlement of which has not been herein specifically recorded, shall be referred to the Sole arbitration of the Chairman-cum-Managing Director, Delhi Transport Corporation or any other officer so nominated and appointed by him. There shall be no bar to the reference of dispute to the arbitration of such an officer of the Corporation appointed by the Chairman-cum- Managing Director even though the said officer may have dealt with the matter and had expressed his opinion

5. Since, according to the petitioners, disputes and differences have arisen between the parties as to their respective rights and obligations under the agreement/contract in question, which are to be adjudicated upon in the manner specified in clause 34, petitioners are in the process of invoking the said arbitration clause. In the meantime, present petition is filed under Section 9 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 praying for temporary injunction to the effect that respondent be restrained from terminating the allotment/contract of the petitioner, and/or, from interfering in any manner whatsoever in the display of commercial advertisements of the petitioner on BQSs and TKBs of the respondent being displayed and ought to be displayed under its aforesaid contract/allotment in respect of the above 7 zones.

6. When this matter came up for preliminary hearing on 19.12.2005, while issuing notice, ex parte injunction was granted restraining the respondent from terminating the contract. After notice, matter came up for hearing on 31.1.2006 when direction was given to the petitioners to make payment of the licence fee as per the agreement without prejudice to the rights and contentions of the parties in this petition. Taking note of the arbitration clause which provides for Dispute Settlement Committee, it was also directed that the said Committee shall try to settle all disputes in the first instance. Petitioners were directed to make a request for settlement of dispute by the said Committee without one week from that date with directions to the Committee to endeavour to resolve the

7. It is inter alia stated that the petitioner was found to be the highest bidder (H-1) in the 7 zones and was awarded the contract for advertisement on the BQSss and TKBs of the said zones. Award letters were accordingly issued accepting the bid of the petitioners provisionally and requiring it to complete the formalities within seven days of the issue of the award letters. These formalities included payment of advance licence fee and security deposit equivalent to three months licence fee of each zone in the shape of bank guarantee of an agreement for the contract of each zone separately with the respondent. The petitioners, however, failed to complete these formalities in time. Number of reminders were sent to the petitioners; however, in respect of six zones petitioners have not submitted the bank guarantees. All these letters sent for completing these formalities are collectively filed as Annexure R-1. It is stated that the petitioners executed the agreement belatedly on 25.7.2005 and 9.11.2005. The petitioners were also in the habit of making delayed payments of licence fee, repair and maintenance charges and interest and because of these irregular payments number of letters were written to the petitioners from time to time.

8. It is also mentioned that cheques given by the petitioners towards monthly licence fee have also bounced/returned dishonoured on various occasions. The petitioners, on 12/13.01.2006, have paid the amount of these bounced/returned cheques by way of a demand draft, which payment is for the period upto October 2005 and no payment towards monthly licence fee, repair and maintenance charges as well as interest on the late payment after October 2005. The outstanding dues in respect of each zone, according to the respondent at the time of filing the reply, were as under:- Name of the Zone Outstanding Amount Central Zone - I Rs. 37,32,335 Central Zone - II Rs. 21,92,197 West Zone - I Rs. 23,72,007 West Zone - II Rs. 29,86,023 Karol Bagh Rs. 2,86,899 Shahdra (N) Rs. 17,33,071 Shahdra (S-I) Rs. 39,79,071 Total (Rs.) Rs. 1,92,81,603 On the verification/survey of BQSs and TKBs, the stand of the respondent is that in terms of clause 9(vi) (c to c – para 15). Copies of these letters are filed as Annexure R-4 with the reply.

9. The matter was strenuously argued by both sides and orders were reserved on earlier occasion. However, after some time the matter was listed again as it was felt that clarification on certain aspects is required. After the listing of the matter afresh, it took different direction. Better sense prevailed on both the parties and conciliatory mood set in. The petitioners approached the respondent for reconciliation of accounts. They also offered to make payment of entire undisputed amount. The petitioners also permitted the respondent to encash the bank guarantees given by them against the outstanding payments. In these circumstances, following common order in respect of both the petitions was passed on 28.7.2006:- “Learned counsel for the petitioner states that petitioner has approached the respondent for reconciliation of the accounts. He further mentions that petitioner has offered to make payment of entire undisputed amount. He counsel for the petitioner, further assures that the entire admitted outstanding amount payable till 31.7.2006 shall be paid by the first week of August 2006. The license fee as well as repair and maintenance charges etc. under the contract for the month of August 2006 shall be paid by the end of August 2006. He further states that for ongoing contracts, fresh bank guarantees shall be furnished by 7th August 2006. For future period also, the charges shall be paid regularly and in time. To resolve the issue regarding missing shelters etc., the petitioner shall approach the Dispute Settlement Committee on 4.8.2006 at 3.00 p.m. List on 1st September 2006. Dasti to counsel for the parties.”

10. On subsequent dates, orders were passed from time to time which would indicate that the petitioners kept on complying with certain directions. In respect of 12 agreements, instead of furnishing bank guarantees, the petitioners gave 12 cheques representing the amount of the bank guarantees. In respect of two zones, namely, Karol Bagh and West Zone-II, as bank guarantees were not furnished, on 1.9.2006 order was passed permitting the respondent to terminate those contracts. During this period, the petitioners had been paying the licence fee as well, though belatedly.

11. The main dispute was about 117 BQS which was referred to the Grievance Settlement Committee. On 1.9.2006, following order was passed in respect of settlement of these 117 BQS:- “There are about 1900 Bus Queue Shelters (BQS) which are covered by the aforesaid 14 contracts. The dispute is in respect of 117 BQSs which is pending before the Grievance Settlement Committee. In respect of remaining BQSs since there is no dispute, there is no reason not to make payment of licence fee as per the contract in respect of those BQSs. Representative of the petitioner shall visit the office of the Chief General Manager on 4.9.2006 at 5:00 PM for reconciliation of the statement of dues as far as arrears are concerned. It is stated by the learned counsel for the petitioner on instructions that in so far as dues of August 2006 are concerned, the same shall be paid before the next date. He further states that the petitioner shall endeavour to

12. The Dispute Settlement Committee filed its report in February

2007. DTC were to calculate financial implications based on the said report. The gist of this report and the disputes which remained to be resolved are set out in the order dated 20.2.2007 and regarding 26 BQS, in respect of which dispute persisted, the matter was referred for mediation. It would, therefore, be appropriate to reproduce this order in entirety, which is to the following effect:- “The petitioner had, on an earlier occasion, raised dispute in respect of 117 Bus Queue Shelters (hereinafter called the 'Shelters'), which, according to the petitioner, were non-existent and the licence fee in respect of those shelters was demanded by the respondent-DTC. It was directed that Dispute Settlement Committee would go into this aspect. As per the report of the Dispute Settlement Committee, which has been filed, particulars of 13 shelters were repeated and, therefore, the dispute was only in respect of 104 shelters. These are divided into three categories. In Category A, 38 shelters are mentioned in respect of which the respondent-DTC had already agreed to give the rebate. Category B gives the particulars of 40 shelters in respect of which the Settlement Committee has recommended grant of rebate to the petitioner. In Category C, particulars of remaining 26 shelters are given and in respect of these shelters, it is stated in the report that the petitioner is not entitled to any rebate. It is agreed by the learned counsel for the petitioner that the bills for licence fee, which are raised by the respondent-DTC do not include these 38 shelters. In respect of 40 shelters covered by Category B, it is stated by the learned counsel for the respondent-DTC that the exact amount of rebate to which the petitioner would be entitled, is being worked out, which should not be more than Rs.40 lacs. The exact figure shall be worked out within one week and communicated to the petitioner. The dispute, therefore, remains in respect of 26 shelters, particulars whereof are given in Category C of the report. Learned counsel for the respondent states, on instructions, that the respondent has no objection if dispute regarding these 26 shelters is referred for mediation. It is also agreed between the parties that in case mediation fails, the matter can be adjudicated by the process of arbitration as per the arbitration clause in the contract. Learned counsel for the petitioner states that in addition to the aforesaid shelters, report in respect of which is filed by the Dispute Settlement Committee, the petitioner has been writing to the respondent-DTC about other shelters, which were to time indicating the particulars of those shelters and the dates from which they were demolished, for one reason or the other. The petitioner shall, within two days, give particulars of all these shelters in a tabulated form to the respondent-DTC along with copies of the letters, which were written pointing out demolition of these shelters to the respondent. Learned counsel for the respondent states that the position in respect of these shelters shall also be verified and report submitted within four weeks. Orders have been passed from time to time directing the petitioner to give the licence fee regularly. Learned counsel for the respondent informs that the petitioner has been giving post-dated cheques. However, it is not disputed that if there is delay in payment, the petitioner is paying interest also for the delayed period in terms of the agreement. The petitioner shall file an affidavit of the payments given and the interest component included in those payments, within one week from today. The Managing Director/Chairman of the petitioner shall also file affidavit to the same effect. Undertaking given by Mr.Amrit Pal Singh, who is present in the Court, is reiterated to the effect that all these cheques would be honoured on presentation. Mr. Singh states that cheques towards licence fee for February 2007 has already been handed over to the respondent-DTC today. Dispute regarding 26 shelters covered by Category C of the report is referred to the Delhi High Court Mediation and Conciliation Centre. Parties shall appear before the said Mediation Centre on 28.2.2006 at 3:30 PM. List before the Court for further proceedings as well as to await the report of the Mediation Centre on 29.3.2007.”

13. Without taking specific note of further developments, suffice is to state that the mediation has succeeded and the Mediator has submitted the report. It is agreed that both the parties would be bound thereby and act thereon. That apart, the disputes which now persists are of the following nature:-

(i) the petitioners had been paying the licence fee belatedly and had undertaken that for late payment they would pay the interest. The interest component, as calculated by the DTC, is substantial. The petitioners are disputing the same. There is, thus, a dispute about the exact amount payable as interest on late payments and licence fee. The indicating the amount payable on this account. In case of dispute, the matter shall be dealt with in accordance with the arbitration clause;

(ii) the contract period in respect of some of the zones have expired which are not renewed. However, in respect of those zones, namely, South Zone-I, South Zone-III, South Zone-IV, Civil Lines-II, Najafgarh(R)–I and City Zone-I, though the contract expired in November 2007, monthly extension was given, i.e. up to 7.12.2007. Though there was no formal extension thereafter, in anticipation of further extension by one month, the petitioners had given a sum of Rs.[1] crore in the form of demand draft and cheque on 13.12.2007. As the contract was not awarded to anybody and the aforesaid amount was given, on 20.12.2007 order was passed extending this contract by one month, i.e. up to 7.1.2008. After 7.1.2008, there is no further extension and the DTC does not want to give another extension. The petitioners, however, point out that on 3.1.2008, they had given cheques representing the licence fee as well as separate cheques for repairs and maintenance for these six zones for a period from 8.1.2008 to 7.2.2008. Though the cheques towards licence fee have not been encashed as these were the postdated cheques, cheques for repair and maintenance have been encashed, which are for a total sum of Rs.1,57,343/-. These cheques were given along with covering letter dated 3.1.2008 mentioning that they are for the period from beyond 8.1.2008 and the petitioners are directed to remove their hoardings, it may taken about two weeks from today. This process would take us to the end of January 2008. It would, therefore, be more appropriate and even in the interest of DTC to extend the contract till 7.2.2008 in respect of these six zones as well, more particularly, when the cheques representing the amount towards repairs and maintenance for this period have been encashed by the DTC. This is more so when contract in respect of various other zones is expiring on 7.2.2008;

(iii) the petitioners shall not be entitled to any further extension in respect of these six zones beyond 7.2.2008. Even in respect of other zones, on the expiry of the term of the contract, it would be open for the DTC to treat those contracts as over and there would not be any right with the petitioners to seek any extension;

(iv) in case the Sales-Tax authorities impose service tax, it is considered that that shall be the liability of the petitioner, as per the agreement;

(v) the other contracts shall, however, be not terminated prematurely. This would be subject to the condition that the petitioners continue to pay the licence fee, as per the contract, in time. Learned counsel for the DTC had informed that the security deposit in respect of certain contracts is to be replenished as the earlier security has been appropriated towards the monthly licence fee which was due from the petitioners. The petitioners shall informing the amount; and

(vi) insofar as the disputes are concerned, Mr. Tripathi, learned senior counsel appearing for the DTC, fairly agreed that those would be settled as per the mechanism provided in the contract. It was agreed that the petitioners shall enlist those disputes and forward the same to the Chairman, DTC. Likewise, the DTC also shall make its claims, if any, against the petitioners by writing a letter within one week to the Chairman, DTC and within two weeks thereafter, as per the arbitration clause/mechanism provided in the contract, steps would be taken by the Chairman.

14. The petitions are disposed of in the aforesaid terms.

(A.K. SIKRI) JUDGE January 18, 2008 IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI OMP No. 466 of 2005 Pronounced on: January, 2008 # M/s. Shivaai Industries (P) Ltd......Petitioners

VERSUS

Advocate CORAM:- *THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE A.K.SIKRI

1. Whether Reporters of Local papers may be allowed to see the Judgment?

2. To be referred to the Reporter or not?

3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest? A.K. SIKRI, J. For orders, see OMP No. 465/2005.

(A.K. SIKRI) JUDGE January 18, 2008 nsk