Full Text
Date of Reserve : 7th January, 2008
Date of Decision: 24th January, 2008 WP(C) No.233/1999
NB SUB. JANAK SINGH .... Petitioner
JUDGMENT
1. UNION OF INDIA
2. THE CHIEF OF ARMY STAFF
3. OFFICER INCHARGE RECORDS... Respondents Advocates who appeared in this case: For the petitioner: Mr.V.K.Sawhney, Advocate For the respondents: Ms.Jyoti Singh with Mr.Ankur Chhibber, Advocates CORAM: HON'BLE MR.
JUSTICE A.K. SIKRI HON'BLE MR.
JUSTICE J.M. MALIK
1. Whether the Reporters of local papers No may be allowed to see the judgment?
2. To be referred to Reporter or not? Yes
3. Whether the judgment should be Yes reported in the Digest? WP(C) No.233/1999 2008:DHC:245-DB J.M. MALIK, J. *
1. The controversy in this case pivots around the question whether the promotion of Janak Raj, Naib Subedar, the petitioner in this case to the rank of PA Subedar took effect from the date of notional promotion or from the date of actual promotion. The indisputable facts of this case are these. The petitioner, Naib Subedar Janak Singh joined the Indian Army on 18th July, 1974. He was promoted to the rank of Naib Subedar on 1st January,
1991. Thereafter, vide letter dated 3rd September, 1996, he was promoted to the rank of PA Subedar with effect from 16th June,
1996. Para No. 3 of the promotion letter reads:-
3. Please ensure that the above NCOs at the time of physical assumption of higher rank meets all the eligibility criteria (ACRs, Med and Discp) for promotion laid down in Army Headquarters letter No. B/33513/AG/FS 2(c) dated 18 Jan 93.” [Emphasis supplied]
2. On 19th August, 1996 the petitioner while going out of the Living in Barracks to attend games, parade, etc. at Unit location fell down from the stairs and sustained injuries. He was placed in Lower Medical Category. The petitioner was admitted in hospital on 19th August, 1996 and was granted 56 days sick leave with effect from 29th September, 2006. On expiry of sick leave he was again admitted in the hospital and was discharged on 6th December, 1996. The petitioner was down graded to medical category CEE (Temporary) for six months with effect from 5th December, 1996. The petitioner suffered severe head injury with compound fracture phalanx and certain other injuries. Subsequently, he was granted 20% medical disability as he had sustained injuries while on duty. His promotion order was cancelled on 14.01.1997. Fresh proposal was asked vide letter dated 23.04.1997. On 04.05.1997, signal was sent to headquarters with a request to withhold posting of Naib Subedar Janak Singh. 05.05.1997, a letter was received from Command Hospital, Lucknow for recategory of Naib Subedar Janak Singh. On 10.05.1997, a letter was received that the petitioner did not report for recategorisation. On 06.05.1997 a letter was sent by headquarters that no category medical board in respect of Naib Subedar Janak Singh had been held in Command Hospital, Lucknow. On 07.06.1997 relinquishment of paid acting rank was cancelled consequent to down gradation of the petitioner from medical category Permanent to CEE Temporary. He was struck off from strength on 01.08.1998 on completion of tenure as Naib Subedar. The representation made by the petitioner did not ring the bell. Consequently, he filed the instant writ petition for issuance of writ in the nature of mandamus directing the respondents to promote the petitioner with effect from 16th June, 1996 and grant consequential benefits from that date.
3. It is not out of place to mention here that in the original writ petition filed by the petitioner he had omitted the word “Medical” occurring in para No.3 above. This Court vide its order dated 29th November, 2005 came to the conclusion that the petitioner had not approached the Court with clean hands. Consequently, the writ petition filed by him was dismissed. The petitioner filed a review petition dated 3rd January, 2006, which was accepted by the order passed by this Court vide order dated 30th March, 2007 and it was ordered that the writ be heard on merits.
4. The respondent has contested the present writ petition.
5. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties. The logic trotted out by the learned counsel for the petitioner was that the petitioner stood promoted with effect from 16th June, 1996. He also pointed out that he had assumed the charge and had been working in place of his predecessor, who had retired. He, however, could not produce the evidence to support this contention.
6. We are of the view that all his assumptions are wet. The above-said order dated 3rd September, 1996 is of utmost importance. It elucidates that the elevation of the petitioner to the above-said office was subject to certain conditions laid down in the above-said order itself. It must be borne in mind that the petitioner was to be promoted to next rank only if he met the medical criteria at the time of promotion. Assumption of charge means to undertake an office or duty ceremoniously in prescribed or customary form. Anybody can see with half an eye that the order dated 3rd September, 1996 unambiguously lays down that charge would be given after the completion of the above said conditions including the medical one. This factor cannot be skimmed over and in order to give full effect to the above said order all the conditions must be fulfilled. After getting the medical fitness certificate, he was yet to take formally the insignia of the above-said office. Since he could not satisfy all the conditions, therefore, the promotion was rightly not granted in his favour.
7. Again, the petitioner was to be put on probation for a period of three months on assumption of charge. Within the said period the petitioner could be reverted back to the regimental duty and until requisite period of probation expired it was not to be considered as a permanent posting.
8. It is well settled that the petitioner can claim the benefits of promotion from the date of his actual promotion and not from the date of his notional promotion. This view neatly dovetails with the observations made by the Apex Court in A.K.Soumini Vs. State Bank of Travancore and Another, (2003) 7 SCC 238.
9. The writ petition is without merit and the same is therefore dismissed. There shall be no orders as to costs. J.M. MALIK, J. A.K. SIKRI, J. January 24, 2008 dc