Gurvinder Pal Singh & Anr. v. Union of India & Others

Delhi High Court · 21 Jan 2008 · 2008:DHC:180-DB
T.S. Thakur; Aruna Suresh
W.P.(C) 7517/2000
2008:DHC:180-DB
administrative petition_dismissed Significant

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court dismissed a writ petition challenging land use conversion and allotments, holding that prior withdrawal of litigation bars re-agitation and that only eligible persons have locus standi to challenge allotments.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
W.P.(C) 7517/2000
Date of Decision: 21st January, 2008 GURVINDER PAL SINGH & ANR. ..... Petitioner
Through Mr. P. Chakraborty, adv.
VERSUS
UNION OF INDIA & OTHERS ..... Respondent
Through Mr. Ramesh Ray, adv. for LAC
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE T.S. THAKUR
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE ARUNA SURESH
JUDGMENT

1. Whether reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Not Necessary

2. To be referred to the Reporter or not? Not Necessary

3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest? Not Necessary Per Thakur, J (oral): W.P.(C)4954/1994 was filed by Mansarovar Residential Welfare Association. The petition pointed out that a park located in the said residential locality was being converted by the DDA for carving out house sites for allotment to different individuals. The petitioners opposed the said conversion and allotment by invoking the extraordinary writ jurisdiction of this Court in public interest seeking a mandamus to the respondents to maintain the area as a public park and to forebear from changing the land use fixed for the same.

2. The respondents, in the said writ petition, appeared to oppose the petition and inter alia pointed out that a sufficiently large number of 2008:DHC:180-DB around the colony which fact was reflected even in the zonal development plans for the said area. It was alleged that a fully developed park was located at a distance of barely 60ft. on the south of the land in question whereas on the northern side there are open vacant sites including one for a primary school measuring 2.[6] acres. The respondents denied that area in question was ever shown as a green area in the Master Plan or the Zonal plan then in force. They further pointed out that as per the modified Master Plan MPD-2001 the site in question has been earmarked for use for residential purposes.

3. In the affidavit filed on behalf of the MCD it was inter alia explained that the technical committee of DDA had on March 2, 1990 recorded a decision recommending that the site in question be used for purposes of allocation of house sites to 21 individuals affected on account of correction of the wrong alignment of Rama Road. The affidavit stated that the defect in the alignment had been detected at the time of the construction of the Rama Road and that while finalizing the allotment.

4. A Division Bench of this Court by an order dated 17th May, 1995 dismissed the aforementioned writ petition holding that the explanation offered by the MCD and DDA in their affidavits was satisfactory and that there was neither any arbitrariness nor any illegality in the conversion of the land use for allotment among eligible persons affected on account of construction of Rama Road mentioned above.

5. The Association felt dissatisfied with the above view and filed a Special Leave Petition before the Supreme Court which was eventually dismissed as withdrawn by an order dated 25th October, 1996. The order passed by their lordships runs as under: “Delay condoned. view of the further material placed on record by the respondents and the express statement made on behalf of DDA that there are several parks and more than 92 trees in that area, the petitioner does not want to pursue the writ petition as originally framed. He submits that in view of these further facts disclosed by the respondents including the DDA and MCD, the petitioner seeks leave to withdraw this Special Leave Petition as well as the Writ Petition as originally filed with liberty to resort to the appropriate remedy available in accordance with law for the surviving grievance of the petitioner. This statement is placed on record and the petitioner is permitted to withdraw the Special Leave Petition as well as the Original Writ Petition filed in the High Court with liberty as above. Consequently, the Special Leave Petition filed in this Court and the original Writ Petition filed in this High Court stand dismissed as withdrawn”

6. The present writ petition was thereafter filed by the petitioners who happen to be two of the members of the Association who had filed the previous writ petition. The present writ petition, in substance, claims the very same relief as was claimed in the previous petition with the exception of an additional prayer by way of a writ, direction or order striking down Section 11 A of the Delhi Development Act, 1957 insofar as the same permits the change of land use from educational to residential has also been added. The challenge proceeds on the ground that the power vested in the competent authority to permit change of land use is ultra vires the provisions of Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution. For the sake of ready reference we may gainfully extract the prayer contained in the present writ petition: “(i) To issue an appropriate writ or direction holding that Section 11A of the D.D. Act, 1957 in so far as it relates to change of land use from educational to residential is ultravires of Article 14 and 21 of the Constitution. proposing to change land use of primary school site No. 10 Mansarovar Garden Residential colony to residential.

(iii) A writ of mandamus quashing the allotment of alternative residential plots in primary school site No.10 on the basis of report dated 7.5.93 and the decision of the MCD dated 5-8-98 and 13-7-98 refusing to approve the building activities in site No. 10.

(iv) To issue any other appropriate writ or direction this Hon'ble Court may deem fit and proper in the above facts and circumstances of the case.”

7. The respondents have, in response to a notice issued by this Court, appeared and filed their counter affidavits inter alia alleging that the writ petition was not maintainable and that the issue regarding validity of the conversion of the land use had attained finality.

8. Appearing for the petitioner, Mr. Chakraborty strenuously argued that while the question of conversion of the land use in terms of the impugned notification may have attained finality on account of the judgment of this Court and the subsequent withdrawal of the writ petition before the Supreme Court yet the petitioners were entitled to question the validity of the allotments made in favour of those who had allegedly lost their land in the course of the construction of Rama Road on its changed alignment. Mr. Chakraborty was at pains to urge that the allottees of the sites in question had not actually lost any land in connection with the construction of Rama Road on the changed alignment and that the authorities had not followed any transparent procedure while making the allotments. He submitted that at least 10 out of 21 total allotments had been canceled by the authorities upon verification of the true facts and that if a proper procedure had been followed for making the allotments even the remaining allotments would allotment orders issued in favour of the allottees who had been impleaded as party respondents to this petition.

9. We have given our careful consideration to the submissions made at the bar and perused the record. The issue that fell for consideration before this Court in the earlier round of litigation was whether the proposed conversion of the land use which, according to the petitionerassociation in the said petition, was at the relevant time being used as a park/green patch was justified. The respondents, DDA and the MCD, had, however, pointed out on affidavit that the area in question was not reserved for use as a park or a green patch at any stage in the Master Plan or the Zonal Development Plans. The affidavits further pointed out that the land use for the land in question was residential and that the site may have been at some stage earmarked even for Municipal School. The question of conversion of the land use, however, was considered by the authorities and land use permitted to be changed having regard to the fact that there were adequate number of Municipal Schools in the area. Suffice it to say that the reasons underlying the conversion of the land use were examined by the Division Bench of this Court and upheld. The Court felt that there was nothing arbitrary, unfair or irrational about the conversion of the land use and accordingly dismissed the writ petition. When the matter reached the Apex Court in appeal, the petitioner withdrew the writ petition implying thereby that the grievance made by the petitioner against the conversion of land use was also withdrawn. A reading of the order passed by their lordships would make it clear that the petitioner/association was given liberty only to the extent of seeking redress for the remainder of any grievance. That did not, in our opinion, imply that the petitioner/association or any of its members could file a fresh round of writ petition in this Court challenging the validity of the writ petition have done. The petitioners have assailed the conversion and not only is the notification permitting the same challenged but even the provision under which such conversion has taken place has been attacked. We, however, fail to appreciate how the petitioners can do so. If the source of power available to the competent authority was itself liable to be struck down as ultra vires, there was no reason why the petitioner could not have attacked it in the previous round of litigation. All such grounds of attack as were available to the petitioners in the said petition could and indeed ought to have been urged in the said petition alone. Neither the petitioner/association nor its members could, for that purpose, maintain a separate round of litigation as is sought to be done by them by filing the present writ petition. The result of the dismissal of the writ petition by this Court and the withdrawal of the SLP from the Supreme Court as also the writ petition is that the challenge to the validity of the proposed conversion was itself withdrawn which could not then be revived or re-agitated by filing a fresh petition on behalf of some of the members of the Association.

10. That leaves us with the only other aspect that Mr. Chakraborty argued with considerable vehemence. He submitted that while this Court may not go into the validity of conversion of the land use, the question of validity of the allotments made by the authorities could well be gone into. We regret our inability to accept even that argument. We say so because the petitioners do not claim to be themselves eligible for an allotment out of the sites carved out by the respondents in the disputed area. These sites are meant, according to the respondents, to be alloted only to such of the land owners as had lost their land in connection with the construction of the Rama Road on its changed alignment. The petitioners did not, however, qualify for any such land in the position, they have no locus standi to question the validity of the allotment made by the authorities. If a person eligible for an allotment in the area on account of his/her having lost any land in connection with the construction of Rama Road was excluded from consideration or given an unfair or discriminatory treatment in the matter of making of allotment, he or she could approach the authorities or seek redress in this Court. Any one not otherwise eligible for allotment, however, could not do so simply because at one point of time the land in question was a green patch which the authorities have converted against the wishes of the residents of the area. The petitioner's grievance, we may in fairness to Mr. Chakraborty state, is not so much against the allotment of the sites to different owners as it is to the conversion of the site from what, according to the petitioners, was a green patch in a residential colony. That aspect, however, stands concluded by the earlier round of litigation. Even if one were to examine in detail the grievance against the individual allotment made by the authorities in favour of different individuals, all that it would lead to is that in stead of one allottee another one may step in to his shoes. From the stand point of the petitioners, the area would in any case remain a housing residential colony and not a green patch. The petitioners attempt to relegate it back to be used as a green patch does not appear to us to be realistic.

11. There is no merit in this petition which fails and is hereby dismissed with costs assessed at Rs.5000/- T.S. THAKUR,J ARUNA SURESH, J JANUARY 21, 2008