Full Text
Writ Petition (C) No.5208/2007
Date of Decision: 22nd January, 2008 S.M. ENTERPRISES ... Petitioner through Ms. Anusuya Salwan, Advocate
Mr. Digit Saikia, Adv.
1.Whether reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the
JUDGMENT
2.To be referred to the Reporter or not? 3.Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest?
GITA MITTAL, J (Oral)
1. By way of this writ petition, the petitioner has assailed an order dated 19th July, 2006 passed by the respondent whereby the request of the petitioner for revalidation of its enlistment as Class 1 Contractor (Electrical) was rejected on the ground that the petitioner has failed to secure any work of appropriate nature and amount as required by the Enlistment Rules, 2001. WP (C) No.5208/2007 Page No.1 2008:DHC:217 The petitioner points out that by an order passed on 15th October, 1999 upon being satisfied with the petitioner's eligibility, he was enlisted as contractor (Electrical) in the Class I category of the respondent who was eligible to tender for CPWD works in such category of contracts in the entire Indian union. Such appointment was for a period of five years in terms of Rule 7 of the Enlistment Rules, 2001 which is employed by the respondent for such enlistment. It has been contended that the petitioner has given the tenders for special contracts and has been successful for award of the contracts during his period of enlistment. The petitioner's enlistment was revalidated by an order dated 27th February, 2003 and extended upto the 14th October, 2003. The petitioner had made an application dated 13th October, 2003 for revalidation of the enlistment which application was pending with the respondent. However, pending consideration of the application, the respondent granted provisional extension of the enlistment by an order on 6th June, 2005. The respondent had required the petitioner to furnish additional documents in support of its pending application by a communication dated 16th November, 2005 for WP (C) No.5208/2007 Page No.2 revalidation of the enlistment.
2. In support of the contention that the petitioner fulfills the requirement for revalidation of the enlistment, the petitioner places reliance on the requirement which has been notified by the respondent in para 19 of the Enlistment Rules, 2001 which reads thus:- “19.0 Revalidation of Enlistment The validity of initial enlistment of the contractor shall be as given in para 7.0. It shall, however, be revalidated on merits if desired by the contractor. Only the contractor who has secured at least one work of appropriate magnitude in CPWD, PWD (NCTD) or CCU of Ministry of Environment A& Forest during the period of enlistment. A work completed/secured as an associate contractor of the main contractor, to whom a composite contract was, has been awarded, shall also qualify for consideration of revalidation.”
3. From a reading of the above, it is apparent that the a person seeking revalidation of the enlistment is required to secure at least one work of the appropriate magnitude of the CPWD, PWD (NCTD) or CCU of the Ministry of Environment & Forest during the prior period of enlistment or last period of revalidation, to be eligible for consideration. The magnitude of WP (C) No.5208/2007 Page No.3 such contract has been specified in the back of appendix as a work which is valued at over Rs.10,00,000/-.
4. It is noteworthy that there is no categorisation prescribed with regard to the nature of the contract which such contractor is required to complete. The petitioner is aggrieved by the fact that it was awarded work at a tender cost of Rs.13,677,84/which was awarded to the petitioner by an order dated 17th October, 2003 or thereabout. The records in respect thereof is available with the respondent. However, there is no dispute that the value of this work meets the requirement as envisaged under Rule 19 of the Enlistment Rules, 2001. It is also not in dispute that such work fell within the period within which the petitioner was required to have secured such work for the purposes of consideration of his application for revalidation of the enlistment. However, by the impugned order dated 19th July, 2006, the respondent appears to have arrived at a conclusion that the petitioner has failed to secure the work of appropriate nature and amount as required under the rules.
5. My attention has also been drawn to a judgment dated 23rd February, 2007 passed in W.P.(C) No.13002/2006 entitled WP (C) No.5208/2007 Page No.4 M/s Alcon Builders & Engineers Private Limited Vs. Union of India wherein in similar circumstances, a similar office memorandum denying enlistment to the petitioner was allowed.
6. Learned counsel for the respondent has vehemently objected to the grant of any relief to the writ petitioner on the ground that the petitioner was required to have secured not only a work of financial limit prescribed under Rule 19 of the Enlistment Rules but was required to complete a work which entailed internal electrification. In my view, this submission is not supported by the very rule which has been prescribed by the respondent to govern the enlistment. The petitioner was only required to undertake such work of the magnitude which is prescribed in the rules. No nature of work has been prescribed and consequently such objection in my view is wholly misconceived.
7. In view of the above, it has to be observed that the respondent fell in error in considering that the petitioner was disentitled to revalidation of the enlistment on the ground that he had not secured work of appropriate nature and amount. This writ petition is, therefore, allowed. WP (C) No.5208/2007 Page No.5 The order dated 19th July, 2006 is hereby set aside and quashed. The respondent shall make appropriate order on the application of the petitioner seeking revalidation of the enlistment and communicate the orders thereon to the petitioner within a period of four weeks from today. Copy of this order be given dasti to counsel for the parties.
(GITA MITTAL) JUDGE January 21, 2008 aa