Goyal MG Gases P Ltd v. Atash Industries (India) Ltd.

Delhi High Court · 09 Jan 2008 · 2008:DHC:51
S. Ravindra Bhat
EX.P. 166/2001
2008:DHC:51
civil appeal_dismissed Significant

AI Summary

Execution proceedings against a company in liquidation require prior leave of the Companies Court under Section 446 of the Companies Act, and courts lack jurisdiction to execute decrees concerning properties outside their territorial limits.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
EX.P. 166/2001
GOYAL MG GASES P LTD ..... Decree Holder
Through Mr. Vibhu Bakhru with Ms. Pooja
VERSUS
ATASH INDUSTRIES (INDIA) LTD. F+ .....
Judgement Debtor
Through Mr. Kumar Dushyant Singh, Advocate with Ms. M .F. Humayunisa, Advocate for JD2.
Mr. Ravindra Kumar, Advocate for OL, Bombay High Court.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S. RAVINDRA BHAT
JUDGMENT

1. Whether reports of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?

2. To be referred to the Reporter or not?

3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest? O R D E R % 09.01.2008

1 In this execution proceeding the decree holder seeks enforcement of an award, which was subsequently made the rule of the Court to the extent of Rs.4,64,81,699/- with interest at 24% per annum.

2 The mode of execution is inter alia a declaratory order that two plots located in 14B & 14C, Sector 15-A, NOIDA alleged to be kept in the possession of the decree holder and presently occupied EX.P. 166/2001 1 of 10 2008:DHC:51 by its tenants have effectively appropriated the consideration paid by it to the company in liquidation i.e. Judgment Debtor No.1.

3 The brief facts of this case are that the decree holder claimed rights under an Inter Corporate Deposit Agreement dated 23.4.1997 on the failure of the judgment debtor to comply with the terms and make good the claim for the same of Rs.1.[5] crores with interest as agreed Recourse to arbitration proceedings was sought by the decree holder which culminated in the award dated 23rd May,

2000. The Arbitrator Mr. Justice J.K. Mehra found in favour of the decree holder and held that it was entitled to the sum of Rs.1.[5] crores by way of principal and further sum of Rs.1,89,67,260/- as outstanding interest at contractual rate.

4 In the meanwhile apparently proceedings for the winding up the company commenced; an application U/s 433 of the Companies Act was presented before the Bombay High Court on 11.4.1997. This resulted in the winding up order 15.2.2000. Alleging that the winding up order was not correct some tenants of the decree holder approached the Bombay High Court, for recall of the order. It is claimed that on 21.5.1997, during the pendency of the winding up proceedings, the two flats (which are the subject matter of this execution proceeding) were allegedly handed over by the judgment debtor to the decree holder pursuant to an agreement to sell and EX.P. 166/2001 2 of 10 other documents such as power of attorney etc.

5. The decree holder approached the Bombay High Court in February, 2003 under Section 446 Companies Act, for leave to pursue execution proceedings in this court. Soon thereafter on 20.8.2003 the winding up order made by court on 15.2.2000 was recalled. The petitioner had been also granted leave to pursue the present execution proceedings.

6. The Bombay High Court then proceeded to consider the winding up proceedings afresh. It is urged that another winding up proceeding, was filed during the pendency of the first winding up proceeding another winding on 28.12.1988. The High Court directed the winding up of the judgment debtor company on 1.7.2004 on the same day apparently the award made in favour of the decree holder was made rule of the court by this Court.

7. The initial leave granted by the Bombay High Court under Section 446 was recalled by an order dated 11.3.2004. Being aggrieved the decree holder preferred an appeal to the Division Bench. The Division Bench in that appeal dismissed the appeal and affirmed the order declining the leave to prefer execution proceedings. The Division Bench inter alia held as follows:- “Heard. Mr. Mudnaney for the appellant. The learned Single Judge has reviewed the order that he had passed earlier in as much as the obvious error in the earlier order was pointed out EX.P. 166/2001 3 of 10 to him and he was right in correcting the mistake that had occurred. It was pointed out to the Court that the order passed required to be reviewed and, therefore, he recalled it and passed a correct order. Mr. Mudnaney submits that the observations in para 39 of the impugned order by clarified. As such, no clarification is required. However, by way of abundant caution we clarify that the execution proceedings mentioned in that para are concerned, the properties of the company. Appeal dismissed. “

8. In the order recalling the leave granted under Section 446, the learned single judge had reasoned that by reason of Section 533 (2) of the Companies Act no leave could have been granted from 11.4.1997 and all transactions thereafter would be ex facie void. The order of the Division Bench confirming the view of the single judge declining the leave under Section 446 was carried in appeal to the Supreme Court which dismissed the Petition by its order dated 4.4.2005.

9. Mr. Vibhu Bakhru, learned counsel for the decree holder made two-fold contentions; first it was submitted that having regard to the contextual background of the dispute and the text of Section 446 it was not necessary for the decree holder to seek leave of the court once the winding up proceedings ceased to exist. It was submitted that the winding up order was made only on 1.7.2004 and the previous winding order since recalled on 20.8.2003. It was submitted that all transactions between the date of proceeding i.e. EX.P. 166/2001 4 of 10 11.4.1997 and the date of winding up 15.2.2003 (which subsequently was recalled) could not have been automatically invalidated, as held by the Bombay High Court.

10. Learned counsel submitted that the transaction was a bona fide one, by which the decree holder legally appropriated the dues payable to the extent possible, by adjusting the value of the flats towards the liabilities of the judgment debtor under the award. To that extent the decree holder is entitled to a declaration in these proceedings that the property of the judgment decree company presently in winding up proceedings stood adjusted.

11. It was contended independently that no leave for entertaining the present proceedings is necessary. It is open to the decree holder to seek the declaration sought, in the present execution as far as judgment debtor company is concerned.

12,623 characters total

12. The counsel for the Official Liquidator resisted the contentions and submitted that the present execution is not maintainable without express leave of the company court in view of the subsequent winding up order dated 1.7.2004. Learned counsel relied upon the judgment of the Bombay High Court dated 11.3.2004 particularly paras 35 to 37 and submitted that the reasoning was favoured by the Division Bench which declined to interfere with the discretion not to grant leave. In such circumstances, it is open to the EX.P. 166/2001 5 of 10 decree holder to contend that no leave is necessary. Learned counsel urged that whatever be the merits of the contention that there was no need to apply for leave, such a contention is now not available since the decree holder elected for the remedy and was unsuccessful. Learned counsel relied upon the text of Section 446 and submitted that in any event with passing order of dated 1.7.2004, no proceeding which would deal with the properties or estates of the company in liquidation can continue and the official liquidator would have full control and is subject to the supervision of the Companies Court.

13. From the above discussion it is apparent that the question which requires resolution is whether the execution proceeding is maintainable and whether independently the decree holder can obtain a declaration it validly adjusted amounts payable to it. Section 446 of the Companies Act reads as follows:- “Suits stayed on winding up order. -- (1 ) When a winding up order has been made or the Official Liquidator has been appointed as provisional liquidator, no suit or other legal proceeding shall be commenced, or if pending at the date of the winding up order, shall be proceeded with, against the company, except by leave of the [Tribunal] and subject to such terms as the [Tribunal] may impose. ( 2 ) [Tribunal] shall, notwithstanding anything contained in any other law for the time being in force, have jurisdiction to entertain, or dispose of -- ( a ) any suit or proceeding by or against the company; ( b ) any claim made by or against the company EX.P. 166/2001 6 of 10 (including claims by or against any of its branches in India); ( c ) any question of priorities or any other question whatsoever, whether of law or fact, which may relate to or rise in course of the winding up of the company, whether such suit or proceeding has been instituted or is instituted or such claim or question has arisen or arises or such application has been made or is made before or after the order for the winding up of the company, or before or after the commencement of the Companies (Amendment) Act, 1960 (65 of 1960).]

14. It is not in dispute that the proceeding for winding up of the Company was presented on 11.4.1997; the winding up order on this was made on 15.2.2000. It is no doubt true that the order was later recalled.

15. The invalidity sought to be set up could have been examined if the Decree Holder had not originally applied only in this court. However, the application for leave sought for under Section 446 (2) by the petitioner before the Bombay High Court, which was seized of winding up petition, however, lends a different colour to the whole issue. Initially the court had granted leave to pursue the execution proceedings; subsequently that leave was withdrawn on 11.3.2004. That order was tested in appeal before the Division Bench where it was confirmed and ultimately before the Supreme Court which declined to interfere under Article 136. Therefore, contention of the official liquidator that the decree holder EX.P. 166/2001 7 of 10 is not en titled to maintain the present execution without express leave by the Bombay High court, is of considerable merit.

16. Even otherwise, the further detail i.e. the issuance of a winding up of 1.7.2004 as mentioned by the petitioner's counsel, to my mind concludes the locus of the decree holder to maintain the present proceedings without recourse of Section 446. That provision enacts inter alia that no proceeding, suit or civil proceeding can be instituted without leave of the Companies Court. Now even if the first contention of the decree holder were to be in the affirmative in respect of the period prior to 20.8.2003, in view of issuance of the second winding up order, the bar under Section 446 applied and divests this court of jurisdiction to deal with the properties of the company. In this finding, in the opinion of the Court, concludes the second issue sought to be raised i.e. a declaration independent of the proceedings in liquidation. Now once a winding up order is issued, without any leave, it is not open to party to seek enforcement of its right or other remedies without approaching the Companies Court and seeking leave, for the purpose. Therefore if the second contention were to be accepted and declaration given to the fact that the decree holder has appropriated the properties which are stated to be occupying towards satisfaction of its dues under the award it would in a direct manner, impinge on the integrity and scope of EX.P. 166/2001 8 of 10 Section 446. I, therefore, see no merit in the contention.

17 Apart from the above one cannot ignore that the properties of the judgment debtor over which the decree holder seeks to exercise its rights are not within the territorial limits of jurisdiction of this court, being located in NOIDA. Therefore, on this ground too the execution has to fail.

18. In view of the above findings EA No. 804/2003 and 29/2004 are rejected as far as Judgment Debtor No.1 is concerned. However, it is open to the decree holder to approach this court again after obtaining leave in this regard from the Bombay High Court. EX. P. 166/01

19. This execution pertains to the award adverted to above in the proceeding part of the order; this court has ruled that the execution cannot be mtaintained so far as the judgment debtor No.1 is concerned without obtaining specific leave from the Bombay High Court. However, as far as Judgment Debtor No.2 is concerned the execution is maintainable because till date there is no material on record showing that the award has been satisfied by the said judgment debtor.

20. Judgment Debtor No.2 has filed affidavits on 20.9.2001 and 27.11.2002. In view of the pendency of these proceedings since long, details are necessary. Accordingly, the JD No.2 is directed to EX.P. 166/2001 9 of 10 make a fresh declaration of his liabilities. He shall produce the copies of the necessary supporting documents including the title deeds, agreements etc. The same shall be filed within four weeks. List on 22.2.2008.

21. In view of the order of this court the further presence of the official liquidator is hereby discharged for the time being.

S. RAVINDRA BHAT,J

January 9, 2008