Jagdeep Singh v. Union of India and Others

Delhi High Court · 24 Jan 2008 · 2008:DHC:246-DB
A.K. Sikri; J.M. Malik
WP(C) No.2042/1998
2008:DHC:246-DB
administrative appeal_dismissed Significant

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court dismissed the writ petition challenging termination from BSF service for prolonged unauthorized absence and desertion, emphasizing the fatality of delay and lack of medical justification.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
Date of Reserve : 11.01.2008
Date of Decision: 24.01.2008 WP(C) No.2042/1998
Jagdeep Singh .... Petitioner
VERSUS
Union of India and Others. ... Respondents Advocates who appeared in this case :
For the petitioner : Mr.Arun Bhardwaj, Advocate
For the respondents : Mr.A.K.Bhardwaj, Advocate
CORAM :
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE A.K. SIKRI
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE J.M. MALIK 1.Whether the Reporters of local papers No may be allowed to see the
JUDGMENT
?
2.To be referred to Reporter or not? Yes 3.Whether the judgment should be Yes reported in the Digest?
J.M. MALIK, J.

1. The petitioner, Jagdeep Singh, joined as Temporary Constable in BSF on 27th MaY, 1988. He received a grievous injury on his right eye, while unloading the bamboos from a WP(C) No.2042/1998 2008:DHC:246-DB Government vehicle, that is, during the course of discharging the Government duty. The injury was diagnosed as “covnea opacity. On 14th October, 1988 Mr.N.S.Dayal, Commandant, after receiving a letter from the father of the petitioner, requested Dr.L.C. Gupta, Additional Chief Medical Officer, HQ DG BSF, R.K.Puram, New Delhi, to help the petitioner in getting treatment in one of the Government hospitals in Delhi. On 4th September, 1989 the case of the petitioner was referred to I/D (MD) Frontier Hospital, TCM for further investigation and treatment by the Medical Officer. The report dated 7th September, 1989 reveals, “There is no possible treatment in Agartala, Tripura Hospital. Keratoplasty facilities are not available at Tripura Hospital.”

2. The petitioner tendered resignation vide his application dated 23rd November, 1989 which was accepted with immediate effect from 6th March, 1990. His period of absence from 24th October, 1989 to 6th March, 1990 was regularised as EOL without pay.

3. Thereafter, the petitioner submitted an application for revocation of discharge order and he was permitted to join duty within fifteen days from the date of the above-said letter dated 2nd August, 1990. However, he actually joined the duty on 17th October, 1990. The medical report dated 3rd December, 1990 reveals that BSF Hospital had made the following recommendations, “As per the advice of RMC and condition of patient he requires kertoplasty which is possible at Delhi or any other hospital. These facilities are not available in Tripura.”

4. On 4th July, 1991 the father of the petitioner made a request to the respondent to post the petitioner near Delhi for petitioner's treatment. On 15th July, 1991 the request made for transfer to Delhi was turned down by the respondents. On 5th October, 1991 a show cause notice was issued to the petitioner by respondent No. 3. On 18th October, 1991 the petitioner's leave was sanctioned but in the same order he was removed from service on the ground that he had deserted the Army.

5. The petitioner has filed the present writ petition with the prayers that the order of termination dated 18th October, 1991 be set aside, petitioner be reinstated with full back wages, and continuity of service with effect from the date of his termination, the respondent be directed to reimburse the cost of treatment of ailment and award a lump sum compensation in the sum of Rs.50,000/- and to issue directions to the respondents to adjust the petitioner on a light duty job at BSF Head Quarter at Delhi or at a nearby BSF station and get the petitioner treated at a specialised hospital with advanced technology and equipments.

6. The respondent has defended the termination order dated 18th October, 1991 and listed the following grounds. The petitioner was discharged in the year 1991 but the writ petition was filed in the year 1998. It was prayed that the writ petition be dismissed on the ground of delays and laches. The petitioner himself preferred to take treatment from a famous Doctor in Rohtak Medical College. He was accordingly granted leave during which period he got himself admitted in Krishna Lal Jaloan Eye Hospital, Haryana of his own accord. In that hospital he underwent optical Tridoctomy operation in right eye. Thereafter, he did not report for duty on expiry of leave and from his home town he submitted a letter dated 23rd November, 1989 requesting therein for discharge from service. Subsequently, he was taken back to the above-said service with effect from 17th October,

1990. After rejoining, he again applied for leave and he was sanctioned 30 days Earned Leave and 6 days JP (joining period) from 20th May, 1991 to 24th June, 1991. At that time, only 31 days leave were at his credit. The petitioner reported from leave in time but again deserted from Unit line on 1st July, 1991. Two call letters were issued to him to report for duty but the needful was not done. A show cause notice was also issued but it did not produce the desired result. Ultimately, the petitioner was removed from service with effect from 18th October, 1991 in accordance with Section 11(3) of the BSF Act read with BSF Rules 22 and 177.

7. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties. The learned counsel for the petitioner vehemently argued that the respondent committed an egregious mistake in not transferring the petitioner to Delhi. It was argued that the hospital's Unit MI Room did not have the facility to treat the petitioner as is apparent from the detailed medical advice referred above. The petitioner had to tender resignation under present circumstances for medical treatment. It was argued that under these circumstances no fault can be attributed to the petitioner. Counsel for the petitioner argued that the petitioner will not pray for back wages.

8. We are of the considered view that there is an inordinate delay in filing the present writ petition. It must be borne in mind that the petitioner did not send response to the above-said two call letters and show cause notice. It is also pertinent to note that the petitioner himself preferred to take treatment from a famous Doctor in Rohtak, Medical College. His leave application was granted as prayed. He was treated in Krishna Lal Jaloan Eye Hospital, Haryana as per his own desire. He applied for earned leave again but no earned leave was found at his credit, yet he was granted 30 days H.P.L. Again, he remained absent from 25th October, 1989 to 17th October, 1990 and that period was treated as 'Dies Non'.

9. Moreover, no explanation was given as to why did he desert the BSF for more than seven years. He could have asked for further leave. He could have asked for leave without payment of salary. He could have requested the respondents to post him at Delhi as treatment in Imphal and Rohtak did not ring the bell. There is no evidence, worth name, to show that from 18th October, 1991 till the date of filing of the writ petition before this Court, he was suffering from an eye disease or was treated anywhere else. The delay in approaching the Court is fatal. In a recent authority reported in Shiv Dass Vs. Union of India and Ors., AIR 2007 SC 1330, it was held,

5. Normally, in the case of belated approach writ petition has to be dismissed. Delay or laches is one of the factors to be borne in mind by the High Courts when they exercise their discretionary powers under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, 1950 (in short the 'Constitution'). In an appropriate case the High Court may refuse to invoke its extraordinary powers if there is such negligence or omission on the part of the applicant to assert his right as taken in conjunction with the lapse of time and other circumstances, causes prejudice to the opposite party. Even where fundamental right is involved the matter is still within the discretion of the Court as pointed out in Durga Prasad v. Chief Controller of Imports and Exports and Ors., AIR 1970 SC 769. Of course, the discretion has to be exercised judicially and reasonably.

7. It was stated in State of M.P. v. Nandlal Jaiswal and Ors., AIR 1987 SC 251, that the High Court in exercise of its discretion does not ordinarily assist the tardy and the indolent or the acquiescent and the lethargic. If there is inordinate delay on the part of the petitioner and such delay is not satisfactorily explained, the High Court may decline to intervene and grant relief in exercise of its writ jurisdiction. It was stated that this rule is premised on a number of factors. The High Court does not ordinarily permit a belated resort to the extraordinary remedy because it is likely to cause confusion and public inconvenience and bring in its train new injustices, and if writ jurisdiction is exercised after unreasonable delay, it may have the effect of inflicting not only hardship and inconvenience but also injustice on third parties. It was pointed out that when writ jurisdiction is invoked, unexplained delay coupled with the creation of third party rights in the meantime is an important factor which also weighs with the High Court in deciding whether or not to exercise such jurisdiction.

10. Now let us turn to the merits of this case. A Division Bench of this Court in WP(C) No.1714/2006 titled as Ex-Naik Charan Singh Vs. Union of India and Others decided on 13th July, 2006, was pleased to hold,

“6. From the service record of the petitioner, it is apparent that an opportunity to reply to the charge-sheet of unauthorised absence for the period from 23.6.89 to 14.2.90 was not availed of and the authorites having left with no alternative had passed the order of dismissal from service under Rule 177. Unauthorised absence is a serious misconduct and in fact where no reasonable cause is shown and a member of the Force remains unauthorisedly absent without leave or sanction of the competent authority, it would be termed as a misconduct of a grave nature. This was held to be even true in the cases of State Police and in the case of Ex. Constable Satnam Singh v. State of Punjab 1997 (3) RSJ 353 where the court referred to various judgments of the Supreme Court including the judgment in the case of The State of Punjab and Others v. Ram Singh Ex. Constable JT 1992 (4) SC 253. Thus, it cannot be said that absence of the petitioner could not be the foundation for dismissing him from service. Even before the court, no explanation whatsoever has been rendered by the petitioner for his prolonged unauthorised absence except that he was having a back problem which again is not supported by any definite medical record. The petitioner has also failed to explain why couldn't he appear or get in touch with any of the units in and around his own State. In the order itself, the absence for the relevant period has been treated
as extraordinary leave without pay which will not amount to condoning the offence as it has been done primarily for the purposes of regularisation of record and dues payable to the petitioner in accordance with rules. Reference can also be made in this behalf to the judgment of the Punjab & Haryana High Court in the case of Ex.H.C. Gagan Bhaskar v. State of Punjab CWP 10245/2001 decided on 2.8.2001. Thus, in our considered view, the petitioner is not entitled to the relief on this account. Though the petitioner has not even filed the copy of the order of dismissal but having gone through the record, we do not think that the proceedings dated 25th May, 1990 call for any judicial intervention.”
12,295 characters total

11. The learned counsel for the respondent also drew our attention to a judgment of a Division Bench of this Court in WP(C) No. 6577/2002 titled as Ex.Constable Akhilesh Kumar Vs. The Director General, BSF and Ors. decided on 21st March, 2006, wherein the Division Bench has observed, “In a recent decision of the Supreme Court in State of Rajasthan & Anr. v. Mohammed Ayub Naz reported in 2006 I AD (SC) 308 the Supreme Court after referring to many other precedencfes has held that absenteeism from office for prolong period of time without prior permission by the Government servant has become a principal cause of indiscipline which have greatly affected various Government services. It is also held that in order to mitigate the rampant absenteeism and willful absence from service without intimation to the Government the Government has promulgated a rule that if the government servant remains willfully absent for a period exceeding one month and if the charge of willful absence from duty is proved against him, he may be removed from service. The Supreme Court held that the order of removal from service passed in the said case was the only proper punishment to be awarded in view of the fact that Government servant was absent from duty for long period without intimation to the Government.”

12. The whole gamut of fact and circumstances detailed above leans on the side of the respondents. The writ petition is therefore dismissed, but the parties are left to bear their own costs. J.M. MALIK, J. A.K. SIKRI, J. January 24, 2008 dc