Full Text
Date of Reserve: January 04, 2008
Date of Order: January 24, 2008
• IA Nos. 11881/06, 262/07 & CS(OS)No.1455A/06
# MMTC Limited ...Plaintiff/Petitioner ! Through: Mr.Rohit Puri, Advocate
^ Through: Mr.Moazzam Khann with Mr.Mudit Sharma and Ms.Bhavna Kohli, Advocates
JUSTICE SHIV NARAYAN DHINGRA
JUDGMENT
1. Whether reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
2. To be referred to the reporter or not ?
3. Whether judgment should be reported in Digest ? JUDGMENT:
1. The award dated 30th September, 2004 was filed by the Arbitrator before the Court and a notice of filing of the award and arbitral proceedings was sent to the parties. Claimant/MMTC filed objections to this award under Section 30 of the Arbitration Act on the ground that award was erroneous in law and contrary to the facts. It is stated that the award given by the Arbitrator suffers from errors which are apparent on the face of it. The counter claim entertained by the Arbitrator was never raised prior to commencement of the arbitration and therefore was not a pre-existing dispute. The learned Arbitrator though agreed that the counter claim was raised only during the arbitration proceedings and was not a pre-existing dispute, but rejected the objections of the claimant/MMTC and adjudicated the counter claim. The Arbitrator thus went beyond the scope of his authority. The Arbitrator wrongly determined that non-applicant, i.e., J.K. Synthetics Ltd. had suffered damages. It is further stated that only one party could be at fault. Both the parties cannot be held at fault. The Arbitrator has determined the 2008:DHC:249 contract. There cannot be a breach of contract by both the sides. Once Arbitrator has considered that there was breach of contract on part of the J.K. Synthetics Ltd. due to which MMTC Ltd. had to purchase material from third party incurring more cost and Arbitrator quantified the losses suffered by MMTC, the Arbitrator could not have held that J.K. Synthetics Ltd. had suffered loss of profit due to breach of contract by MMTC and quantify the loss of profit.
2. The objections to the award have also been filed by the J.K. Synthetics Ltd. on the ground that the quantification of damages by the Arbitrator in favour of MMTC Ltd. was wrong and could not have been done since MMTC Ltd. was the party that violated the contract and this issue has already become final and cannot be re-opened.
3. In order to appreciate the arguments of both the sides, a brief history of the facts is necessary. MMTC Ltd. had invited offers from various parties for supply of 10,000/- M.T. 'Soyabean' on behalf of their buyers at Jordan. The offer of the respondent to supply 10,000/- M.T. 'Soyabean' meal at a price of US$ 205 per M.T. was accepted. However, the contract could not be carried out due to several reasons and a dispute arose which was referred to the Arbitrator. The Arbitrator gave an award dated 5th January, 1994 deciding following issues: i. Whether claimants furnished legally valid LC as per terms of agreement ? ii. Whether respondents were liable to furnish performance guarantee even in the absence of proper LC ? iii. Whether the damages claimed by the parties are legally justified and tenable and to what extent ? iv. Relief.
4. The Arbitrator decided issue nos. 1 & 2 against the MMTC Ltd. and while deciding issue no.iii observed as under:- Issue No.iii In view of my findings on issue no.i & ii, it is clear certain steps which were required to be taken by both the parties before this agreement could be given effect to. The buyers (claimants) were required to open the LC (clause 11) and sellers (respondents) were required to submit performance guarantee. Though the buyers opened the LC but it was not considered to be commercially acceptable and valid by the sellers and as much they did not give the performance guarantee and disputed to fulfill their part of the agreement. In such type of agreements, where performance is conditional, both the parties are free to get out of the agreement due to failure of the either party to perform/fulfill their part of the agreement and there is no question of claiming damages from the other party. The clause 13 of the agreement is regarding execution of contract and provides that sellers shall perform the contract satisfactorily and the buyer has right to purchase at the risk and expenses of the seller for the quantity defaulted by the seller. But in this case, there is no question of default in quantity as the supply never started. The seller raised objections about the validity of the LC and did not even furnish performance guarantee which implies that the stage of performance never arrived. There is no doubt that claimants and respondents suffered some losses or did not earn the profit which they would have earned on satisfactorily completion of the contract. The claimants incurred expenses on opening of LC and had to purchase material at higher cost and therefore, had to forgo a part of the profit. On the other hand, respondents also suffered as they had already placed orders for the material vide purchase order dated 21.9.91 on M/s. Next Pvt. Ltd. Jabalpur and on Kalyan Solvent Extraction, Indore vide purchase order dated 25.9.91 (photocopies of which are in the file) and they would have certainly earned some profits also on satisfactorily completion of the contract. Since both the parties suffered losses due to default of each other, the damages claimed by each are not legally justified and in my opinion, each has to bear their own losses. This issue is decided accordingly.”
5. Objections were filed against this award by MMTC Ltd. vide suit no. 336A/1994. The suit was disposed of by the Court vide order dated 19th February, 2003. During arguments in suit no. 336A/1994, the counsel for MMTC had argued that the award of Arbitrator, so far it related to issue no.iii, was required to be remitted back to the Arbitrator since the Arbitrator had not quantified the damages suffered by the claimants and respondents. Considering this argument, this Court observed that there quantified the damages suffered by the claimants and remitted the award to the Arbitrator on the limited question of quantifying the damages as spoken of under issue no.iii of the award. Thus, the objections of the MMTC Ltd. were only partly allowed vide order dated 19th February, 2003 and the award so far as it related to issue no.iii was remitted back to the Sole Arbitrator for quantifying the damages spoken under issue no. iii.
6. It is apparent that this Court had rejected the objections of MMTC Ltd. against the award on all issues, i.e., issue nos. i, ii & iii. But since there was no quantification of the damages suffered by the parties as stated in issue no.iii, the award was sent back for quantification. The subsequent award dated 30.9.2004, the subject matter of challenge in this petition by the MMTC, is the result of order of this Court and it is an award limited to quantification of the damages. Thus, this award is a part of the earlier award dated 5th January, 1994 and cannot be looked upon as a separate award.
7. The award dated 5th January, 1994 coupled with the award dated 30th September, 2004 formed one award. The objections to the award dated 30th September, 2004, in fact, would not lie at all since the objections to the main award have already been dismissed and only quantification was to be done by the Arbitrator, which the Arbitrator has done. The Arbitrator while deciding the issue no.iii, categorically, held that there were certain steps which were required to be taken by both the parties before the performance of the agreement. The agreement was conditional and each of the party was free to get out of the agreement due to failure of other party to perform or fulfill its part of the agreement and there was no question of claiming damages from other party. The Arbitrator has further observed that in this case there was no question of default in quantity as supply never started and the seller raised objections about the validity of LC and did not even furnish the performance guarantee which implies that the stage of performance never arrived. each party had to bear its own losses.
8. The Arbitrator had not quantified the losses suffered by each party because he did not consider it necessary to quantify. He had not come to the conclusion that MMTC Ltd. was entitled for any claim. However, this Court considered that quantification of the losses suffered by the parties should be there. The Arbitrator has quantified the losses but the fact remains that Arbitrator had come to conclusion that MMTC Ltd. was not entitled for claiming any losses since MMTC Ltd. had failed to fulfill its part of agreement of providing legally valid LC.
9. I, therefore, consider that no challenge lies to the award dated 30th September, 2004. The objections of both the parties are not tenable and are hereby dismissed. January 24, 2008 SHIV NARAYAN DHINGRA, J. ak