Full Text
Date of Reserve: 10.01.2008
Date of Order: January 24, 2008 CS(OS) No.1815A/1997
# Vipul Kumar Jain ... Plaintiff/Petitioner ! Through: Mr. Shiv Khorana, Advocate
JUSTICE SHIV NARAYAN DHINGRA
JUDGMENT
1. Whether reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
2. To be referred to the reporter or not ?
3. Whether judgment should be reported in Digest ? JUDGMENT:
1. By this Petition, the Plaintiff/Petitioner has challenged the award dated 28th July, 1997 on various grounds. A perusal of award would show that the learned Arbitrator passed the award on the basis of compromise between the parties. The operative part of the award reads as under: In response to the notices issued by me both the parties have appeared before me. On 12th of July, 1997 S/Shri Vipul Kumar Jain, claimant, Vivek Kumar Jain, respondent no. 1 and his father Devendra Jain, respondent no. 2 (that is firm's name) made a statement before me as follows: “ The partnership between the partner is admitted. A sum of Rs.46,06,251/- was paid by the partnership firm Devendra & Sons to DGS&D, Govt. of India as 25% of the sale price of the contract awarded to the said firm. Out of the said amount a sum of Rs.18,70,000/- (Rs. Eighteen lakhs and Seventy Thousand) is payable to Sh. Vipul Jain, claimant and the balance amount of Rs.27,36,251/- is payable to the respondents. The arbitrator has not given his award as yet against DGS&D. The above amount along with interest if any shall be distributed between the parties in the above ratio whenever it is received from DGS&D. We have no objection if the amount is received by the arbitrator and districted by the arbitrator as stated above. From 2008:DHC:250 25% and 75% respectively. The award may be made accordingly.” I find that the aforesaid compromise is perfectly in order and covers all the disputes and differences between the parties except, however, the alleged claim of the claimant regarding the amount of Rs.5,40,000/- approximately which was allegedly arranged by him from M/s Kwality Traders. It may be mentioned that M/s Kwality Traders are not party to this arbitration and obviously the claimant has not referred to the said claim in the compromise. Hence I need not give any finding about it.
2. It is apparent that the objections to the award filed by the Plaintiff/Petitioner are absolutely misconceived. The award was in the nature of a compromise decree passed by the Arbitrator at the behest of both the parties after the parties had made a statement of compromise before the Arbitrator. The Arbitrator has not discussed the merits or demerits of the claim or any other issues since the parties entered into a compromise. An award passed on the basis of compromise is governed by the same principles as a compromise decree. The award is binding on the parties and no objections can be filed against such an award.
3. There is no dispute to the fact that there was an Arbitration Agreement between the parties and there was a dispute which was referred to the Arbitrator. In view of the fact that the award has been passed on the basis of compromise between the parties, I consider that Plaintiff/Petitioner has no locus standi or ground to challenge the award. The petition is hereby dismissed. January 24, 2008.
SHIV NARAYAN DHINGRA, J. vn