Full Text
CM No. 2458/2006 in WP (C) No. 5586/1998
JUDGMENT
1. Whether Reporters of Local papers may be allowed to see the Judgment?
2. To be referred to the Reporter or not?
3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest? A.K. SIKRI, J.
1. When this petition came up for hearing on 4.1.2008, orders were reserved and permission was given to learned counsel for the petitioner to file written submissions, if any, within one week. However, we waited for over two weeks, but the same were not filed. Since we heard the matter on merits, we are now proceeding to decide the issue involved vide this judgment.
2. The petitioner had filed the aforesaid writ petition claiming pensionary benefits from the date of his discharge from service. After hearing the counsel for the parties, this petition was dismissed vide orders dated 7.9.2001. Almost one and a half years thereafter, i.e. in February 2003, the present application 2008:DHC:268-DB 7.9.2001. Before we advert to the contents of the application and the nature of modification which the petitioner is seeking, it would be appropriate to restate the nature of order passed on 7.9.2001.
3. The petitioner had joined the Border Security Force (BSF) on 21.9.1965. However, after some years of service he submitted his resignation and his request for voluntary retirement was accepted. He, thus, ceased to be in the service of BSF with effect from 26.6.1976. In this way, the petitioner rendered 10 years and 9 months of service.
4. It is not in dispute that a person has to have a minimum of 20 years of service, as provided in Rule 48-A of the CCS (Pension) Rules. The petitioner admittedly had not completed the qualifying service on the basis of which he could earn pension and, therefore, this benefit was not accorded to him. However, 22 years after his discharge, the petitioner preferred the aforesaid writ petition stating that even if service rendered by him was less than 20 years, he should be given pro-rata pension on the basis of service rendered by him. It is this relief which was denied to the petitioner by this Court in its order dated 7.9.2001 holding that the petitioner cannot be given any such pro-rata pension. The Court referred to the judgment of the Apex Court in the case of Union of India & Ors. v. Rakesh Kumar, (2001) 4 SCC 309 and on the basis of this judgment it was held that the petitioner, who had resigned from service not entitled to get any pension.
5. In the application for modification it is alleged that the case of the petitioner is wrongly decided. It is further alleged that this Court had took up the case on its own motion on 3.9.2001 and passed an ex-parte judgment relying upon the judgment in the case of Rakesh Kumar (supra), which is not applicable in the instant case.
6. We find from the order dated 7.9.2001 that no doubt the petition was listed on 3.9.2001 and nobody had appeared on behalf of the parties on that date. However, thereafter the petition was directed to be listed on 7.9.2001 and on that date counsel for both the parties appeared. Ms. Santosh Singh, who was the counsel for the petitioner, duly appeared and represented the petitioner and argued the case on his behalf. It is only after hearing both the counsel that the order was passed on 7.9.2001. It is, therefore, totally wrong on the part of the petitioner to alleged that an ex-parte order was passed.
7. Insofar as contention of the petitioner that judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Rakesh Kumar (supra) is not applicable is concerned, that would not be a ground for seeking modification of the order. In essence, the petitioner is seeking review of the said judgment. Such a contention is not available even for the purpose of seeking review inasmuch as if the petitioner feels that the case is wrongly decided, his remedy was to challenge the order. Even otherwise, review application can be filed within 10 days whereas the present application was filed and is, thus, clearly time barred.
8. Learned counsel for the petitioner has sought to argue the case afresh and wanted liberal interpretation to be given to Rule 48-A of the CCS (Pension) Rules. He referred to the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Madan Singh Shekhawat v. Union of India & Ors., (1999) 6 SCC 459. That was a case where the Court was concerned with the grant of disability pension which was denied to the appellant therein on the ground that he was not on duty because the journey being performed by him on leave was not 'at public expense'. The Court held that the appellant could not be denied disability pension by giving a liberal interpretation to the expression 'at public expense' and the appellant should be treated on duty and, therefore, was held that the appellant was entitled to disability pension.
9. We fail to understand how such a judgment is applicable to the fact situation insofar as the present case is concerned. Rule 48- A, in no uncertain terms, lays down the eligibility condition for earning pension, namely, minimum service of 20 years. By no stretch of imagination it can be said that a person who has rendered less service and is not even eligible for pension should be given pro-rata pension.
10. The case was then argued referring to Rule 19 of the BSF Rules, 1969 which deals with 'Resignation'. The petitioner cannot seek shelter under this Rule to get pro-rata pension only because he was allowed to resign from the Force having regard to the special circumstances. This provision only permits the Central resign from the Force having regard to the special circumstances. If there are no such special circumstances, an officer is not even entitled to resign. Thus, one cannot take advantage of this Rule for interpreting Rule 48-A of the CCS (Pension) Rules and advance an argument that simply because he was allowed to resign before he put in minimum 20 years of service, to earn pension he should now be given pro-rata pension.
11. Therefore, even on merits we do not find any force in this application and, accordingly, dismiss the same.
(A.K. SIKRI) JUDGE (SUDERSHAN KUMAR MISRA) JUDGE January 28, 2008 nsk