Samsung India Electronics Ltd. v. Asha Marketing and Ors.

Delhi High Court · 28 Jan 2008 · 2008:DHC:279
S. Ravindra Bhat
CS(OS) 842/2005
2008:DHC:279
civil appeal_allowed

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court decreed an ex-parte recovery suit in favor of Samsung India Electronics Ltd. for unpaid dues under a distributorship agreement, awarding principal and moderated interest against the defendants.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
CS(OS) 842/2005
Reserved on : January 21 2008 Pronounced on :January 28, 2008
SAMSUNG INDIA ELECTRONICS LTD. … Plaintiff
Through : Mr. J.R.Midha & Mr. Niraj Singh Advocates
Vs.
ASHA MARKETING AND ORS … Defendants
Through : Defendants are Ex-parte
CORAM
Mr. Justice S. Ravindra Bhat
JUDGMENT

1. Whether reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment.? YES

2. To be referred to the Reporter or not? YES

3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest? YES MR.

JUSTICE S. RAVINDRA BHAT:

1. This is a suit for recovery of Rs.88,23,511.00/- (Eighty Eight Lakhs Twenty Three Thousand, Five Hundred, eleven only).

2. The plaintiff is a company incorporated under the Companies Act; it has its office at 7th - 8th Floor, IFCI Tower, 61, Nehru Place, New Delhi.

3. The plaintiff manufactures and sells consumer electronic goods and home appliances; its brand name is “SAMSUNG”. On 29th July, 2002, the plaintiff appointed the first defendant as its distributor. The second defendant executed the dealership CS(OS) 842/2005 1 2008:DHC:279 agreement on behalf of the first defendant; the second defendant is a partner in the first defendant concern. The second defendant executed the agreement on behalf of the first defendant as its Proprietor. It is averred that subsequently defendant No.3 took over the charge as proprietor of the first defendant and accepted the liability of both the defendants; however, the plaintiff did not discharge the second defendant to conduct the first defendant’s business. It is further averred that both defendants i.e. Nos. 2 & 3 are conducting business of the first defendant and are incharge and responsible for its affairs.

4. According to the plaintiff, pursuant to the distributorship agreement dated 29.7.2002, the defendants placed orders for supply of plaintiff’s products; the goods were accordingly shifted/supplied to them during the period 29th July, 2002 to 2nd June, 2004. The defendants placed orders for supply of consumer electronics and home appliances products worth Rs.17,26,62,880/- (Seventeen Crore, Twenty Six Lakhs, Sixty Two Thousand, Eight Hundred Eighty only). The plaintiff supplied the materials asked for; the defendants released payments to the extent of Rs.16,88,45,900/- (Sixteen CRores, Eighty Eight Lakhs, Forty Five Thousand, Nine Hundred). It is averred that adjusting the payment made and after taking into account the credit notes of Rs.1,26,22,825/- and debit notes for Rs.1,65,62,778/-, sum of Rs.77,56,993/- is claimed outstanding and payable by the defendants. The plaintiffs have produced statement of accounts, extracted from their books for the relevant period. It is filed as Annexure P-2 to the plaint. The relevant invoices and delivery challans for the said period i.e. 29.7.2002 to 2.6.2004 have been produced in form of 841 documents; and are annexed as Annexure P- 3 collectively to the plaint. CS(OS) 842/2005 2

5. The defendant issued a written confirmation on 23rd March, 2004 that the balance sum of Rs.79,74,725.52 as on 29th February, 2004 was payable to the plaintiff. That document has been produced as Annexure 4 to the plaint.

6. The plaintiffs avers that for the full satisfaction of its liabilities, the defendant had issued a blank cheque enabling the plaintiffs to recover the amounts due to them by filling the appropriate amount. According to the plaintiff, the defendants agreed and undertook to ensure that the cheques would be honoured when presented. However, cheque bearing No. 331516, dated 26.5.2004 drawn on Oriental Bank of Commerce, Bhopal for Rs.77,56,933.50 when presented was returned unpaid. The plaintiff has produced the said cheque as Annexure P-5 to the plaint; it has also produced the memo of the Oriental Bank of Commerce, Bhopal issued to the IDBI Bank, the clearing Bank dated 31.5.2004 indicating that the amount was not paid since the account was closed. The plaintiff claims to have issued a legal notice dated 1.7.2004 upon the defendants calling upon them to pay the sum of Rs.77,56,933.50. It is further averred that the defendants in their reply raised frivolous pleas and falsely alleged that Rs.35,00,000/was payable to them.

7. In view of the above averments, the plaintiff claims a decree for the sum of Rs.77,56,933.50 and interest at 22% per annum which according to it is the agreed rate of interest; between the parties for the period from 29.7.2002 to[2].6.2004. On that score, a sum of Rs.10,66,578/- is claimed as interest till filing of the suit. CS(OS) 842/2005 3

8. The plaintiff, therefore, seeks a decree for the sum of Rs.88,23,511/- against the defendants with the pendente lite and future interest at 22% per annum till realization.

9. Repeated attempts to serve the defendants were unsuccessful. This court, therefore, allowed substituted served through publication of summons in the newspaper upon the defendants by order dated 5.9.2006. This court recorded that the summons were duly published in the “Navbharat” addition of the Madhya Pradesh on 28.11.2006 and were therefore deemed to have been served by the order dated 23.1.2007. Vide the said order, this court set down the defendants ex-parte. The plaintiff was permitted to lead ex parte evidence through affidavit. The affidavit evidence of Sh./ Sidhartha Pandit, PW 1 dated 30.4.2007 was tendered on the record on 8.5.2007. That day his statement recording affirmation of the contents of the affidavit and also identifying the exhibits i.e. Ex. PW 1/1 to PW 1 /4 collectively and Ex. PW 1/5 to Ex. PW 1/8 (Collectively) to Ex. PW 1/8 was recorded.

10. PW 1 has produced the copy of the power of attorney in its favour by the plaintiff as PW 1/1. He has identified the original dealership agreement dated 29.7.2002 entered into between the parties as Ex. PW 1 /2 He has further deposed that pursuant to the agreement the plaintiff supplied its products for the period between 29.7.2002 and 2.6.2004 and that after adjusting the amounts paid by the defendants, their outstanding liabilities worked out to Rs.77,56,933/-. He produced and affirmed to the correctness of Ex. PW 1/3, the statement of account. He also identified and spoke about the delivery challans, credit notes and debit notes issued by the plaintiff to the defendants and marked CS(OS) 842/2005 4 as Ex. PW 1 /4 (collectively). PW 1 deposed that on 13.3.2004 the defendants issued a balance confirmation acknowledging that Rs.79,74,725.52 was due and payable by them and they had supplied a blank cheque being No.331516 drawn on Oriental Bank of Commerce which was filled up with the amount of Rs.77,56,933 dated 26.5.2004 and duly presented to the banker. The cheque and the returned memo have been produced and marked as Ex. PW 1/6 and PW 7. The witness has also marked the copy of the legal notice issued to the defendants on instructions of the plaintiff together with postal receipts and acknowledgment card which are all marked as Ex. PW 1/8 ( collectively).

11. The dealership agreement indicates the year of establishment of the defendant No.1 as 2001; it has been executed by the second defendant. Details of the first defendant i.e. shop and warehouse as well as their value have been disclosed in the agreement. The agreement was signed by the parties which included the second defendant for the first defendant and also the Branch Manager, the Senior Manager and the Vice President (Sales) of the plaintiff. According to the terms and conditions of the dealership agreement Ex. PW 1 /2, the first defendant could not assign the benefit of the agreement without prior consent of the plaintiff; the defendant No.1 was bound to, during the subsistence of the contract, sell the products of the plaintiff according to its general instructions. The dealership was conferred on non-exclusive basis and the plaintiff reserved the right to sell the products directly within the same territory. Clause 12 of the agreement stated that disputes between the parties could be referred for arbitration and the courts in Delhi alone would have jurisdiction in such cases. CS(OS) 842/2005 5

12,182 characters total

12. The terms also indicated that the defendant No.1 dealer was obliged to place the orders of the plaintiff’s products at its office in New Delhi or other places which might be notified from time to time. The Ex. PW 1/3 is an extract of the customers ledger, pertaining to the defendants’ account for the period 6.1.2004 to as on 5.1.2005. It discloses a balance payable liability as Rs.77,56,933.50. Ex. PW 1 /4 (collectively) is the series containing 840 documents. These documents are the invoices issued by the defendant No.1 placing orders for supply of the plaintiff’s goods; each invoice is accompanied with a delivery challan issued by the transporter and is acknowledged on behalf of the first defendant by the second defendant.

13. This court has examined the documents and pleadings on the record, in addition to the dealership agreement and the documents discussed above. The plaintiff has relied on Ex. PW 1/5 which is the balance confirmation executed by the second defendant on behalf of the first defendant, acknowledging that the sum of Rs.79,74,725.52 was payable to it. The plaintiff has also produced the cheque bearing No. 331516 drawn on Oriental Bank of Commerce, Habib Ganj Branch, Bhopal in its favour by the first defendant. That was the cheque which was signed by the third defendant and is dated 26.5.2004. A copy of the return memo by the Oriental Bank of Commerce dated 31.5.2004, has been marked as Ex. PW 1/7 and it discloses that the reason for its dishonour was “Account Closed”. The legal notice issued on 1.7.2004 along with postal receipts and AD Cards indicates that the third defendant received the notice, and the same have also been produced and marked as Ex. PW 1/8 collectively. CS(OS) 842/2005 6

14. From an examination of the pleadings and evidence, i.e. both oral and documentary, the plaintiff has been able to establish that it entered into a dealership agreement with the defendant No.1, a sole proprietorship concern of the second defendant. In terms of the said agreement Ex. PW 1/2, the defendants 1 and 2 agreed to place orders of the plaintiff’s products and comply with the other terms. The orders were to be placed upon the plaintiff’s office in New Delhi or such other office as designated by it. The plaintiff has also established that for the period claimed in the pleadings, a sum of Rs.77,56,933/- was shown as outstanding and payable to the defendants’ account; this is supported by Ex. PW 1/3, the invoices as well as the delivery challans Ex. PW 1 /4. The latter documents show that the orders were placed on the plaintiff; the goods were actually dispatched by it and received by defendant Nos. 1 and 2. The plaintiff has also proved that the defendant No.2 acting on behalf of the first defendant has acknowledged the liability for the sum of Rs.79,74,725.52 in exhibited Ex. PW 1/5. In discharge of the defendants’ liability, a cheque for Rs.77,56,933.50 Ex. PW 1/6 issued by the third defendant and drawn on Oriental Bank of Commerce was furnished; it was returned with the remark “Account Closed”. The plaintiff has further proved issuance of legal notice Ex. PW 1/8 along with postal receipts and AD cards. In these circumstances, this court is of the opinion that the plaintiff has proved its case for entitlement to a decree in the sum of Rs77,56,933/-.

15. As far as the interest of Rs.10,66,578/- @ 22% per annum is concerned, the dealership agreement does not reflect any such condition. However, the copies of invoices produced as annexure Ex.. PW 1/ 4 (collectively), on the reverse incorporate such a printed term. In the over all conspectus of the facts of this case, this court is of CS(OS) 842/2005 7 the opinion that the said rate of interest is too high. Therefore, the plaintiff is held entitled to interest at 12% per annum for the period from 29.7.2002 to 2.6.2004 till the filing of the suit. As far as future interest is concerned, the plaintiff is entitled to 10% upon the aforesaid amount and interest. The plaintiff is entitled to judgment in the following terms:a ) Rs.77,56,933/-; b ) Interest @ 12% per annum for the period 29.7.2002 to 2.6.2004 up to the filing of the suit; b) Interest @ 10% on the amounts 1 and 2 above pendente lite, and till realization of the above amounts. The suit is decreed with costs in the above terms. Dated: January 28, 2008 (S. RAVINDRA BHAT) JUDGE